Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92416 (KAR)
SHANTAYYA S/O GURULINGAYYA CHIKKAMATH v. STATE
CRL.RP/200066/2020 · 2025-07-24
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92416 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92416 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!%
$% &
'()'*+&
,'++
-
!"#"$%
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&'(
)
$#%&%$(
$*"'%%'
)
%$( + )
%*$%%%
,
)
,
)
$ -./0 /1 .2.3.4156 .21 4-./5-0 78952-4 :8/ ;<- /-312185 =-;1;185-/.7792-0 .50 /1 --/.5.6890. .41=.;14 4-./5-0 16< 89/; 83-/5>-5; 4-.0-/ :8/ ;<- /-2=850-5;!;.;-
<- /-312185 =-;1;185-/ 12 ;<- .7792-0 ?<8 29::-/-0 . @906>-5; 8: 785317;185 .50 .5 8/0-/ 8: 2-5;-57- 15 8$*"'%%' .50 785317;-0 :8/ ;<- 8::-57- =9512<.A4- 950-/ -7;185 %' 501.5 -5.4 80- .502-5;-57-0;8950-/68;?8B-./221>=4-1>=/1285>-5; .50;8=.B:15-8:2"%%%!?1;<0-:.94;2-5;-57-8:;?8
- 3 -
>85;<2 21>=4- 1>=/1285>-5; .50 :8/ ;<- 8::-57- 950-/ -7;185 % 8: 501.5 -5.4 80- 85- B-./ 21>=4- 1>=/1285>-5; .50 :15- 8: 2"%%%! ?1;< . 0-:.94; 2-5;-57-8:;?8>85;<21>=/1285>-5; & .4101;B8:;<-@906>-5;8:785317;185.508/0-/ 8: 2-5;-57- ?.2 C9-2;185-0 A-:8/- ;<- 1/2; ==-44.;- 89/;15/1>15.4==-.48%$(
<- 4-./5-0 )906- 15 ;<- 1/2; ==-44.;- 89/; .:;-/ 2-79/156 ;<- /-78/02 <-./0 ;<- ./69>-5;2 8: ;<- =./;1-2 /-!.==/-71.;-0 ;<- >.;-/1.4 -310-57- .50 AB 785210-/-0 @906>-5; 0.;-0 *;< 7;8A-/ %% 012>122-0 ;<-.==-.48:;<-.7792-0.50785:1/>-0;<-@906>-5;8: 785317;185.508/0-/2-5;-57-=.22-0AB;<-/1.4)906-
" -156:9/;<-/.66/1-3-0AB;<-2.>-.7792-012 A-:8/-;<1289/;15;<12/-312185 * /1 .2.3.4156 .21 4-./5-0 78952-4 :8/ ;<- /-312185 =-;1;185-/ 785;-50-0 ;<.; <.3156 /-6./0 ;8 ;<- 41>1;-0 278=- 8: ;<- /-312185.4 @9/12017;185 <- ?8940 58;
- 4 -
<.3- >97< ;8 29A>1; ?1;< /-6./0 ;8 ;<- :150156 8: 6914;
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
- 5 -
' - :9/;<-/ 785;-50-0 ;<.; >12.==/8=/1.;-0 .>895; 12 ;8 ;<- ;95- 8: 2&#'%%! .50 ;<- 2.10 .>895; 12 09- -./41-/ ;8 %%# .50;<-/-:8/- C9-2;185 8: 2<8?156.5B4-51-57-;8;<-/-312185=-;1;185-/?894058; ./12- .50 2896<; :8/ 012>122.4 8: ;<- /-312185 =-;1;185 15 ;8;8 $% .3156<-./0;<-./69>-5;28:A8;<210-2;<12 89/;=-/92-0;<->.;-/1.485/-78/0>-;17948924B $$ 5297<=-/92.48:;<->.;-/1.485/-78/01;12 2--5;<.;;<-/-1258012=9;-;<.;.7792-0?.2;<-=B6>B 7844-7;8/8:/12<5. /.>--5..5D.2.3-2<?./8485B /.57< $ <-.>895;8:>12.==/8=/1.;185120-;.14-089; .2950-/ 4 8 7 8 .>- 8: -=821;8/ .4.57-.2=-/ .5D88D .4.57-.2=-/ .22A88D >895; 8: 1//-694./1;B
$ ('% .311/.5 2(#%%%! 2$%%%! 2$*&%%%! ('$ 5.50 2(#%%%! 2"*%%%! 2$(#%%%! & #$* <./.5.==. 2**%%%! 2('"%%! 2$&"%%! #& 9/6-==. 2*%%! 2&("%%! 2&'%%! 8;.4 2*%%! 2*$%%%! 2&#'%%!
- 6 -
$& 0>1;;-04B ;<82- .>895;2 ./- 7844-7;-0 :/8> ;<-6-5-/.4=9A417.50/-312185=-;1;185-/:.14-0;80-=821;
;<- 2.>- ;8 ;<- .5D /-294;156 15 ?/856:94 4822 ;8 ;<- 78>=4.15.5;.50?/856:946.15;8;<-.7792-0 $ .5D <.0 ;8 15 ;9/5 2.;12:B ;<- 792;8>-/2 A-7.92-;<-792;8>-/2<.078>=4.15-0;<-.5D2<8?156 ;<- =/88: 8: <.3156 0-=821;-0 >85-B ;</896< =B6>B 7844-7;8//-312185 =-;1;185-/ A9; ;<- 2.>- ?.2 58; 0-=821;-015;8;<-.5D $" :;-/78>156;8D58?.A89;;<-.77895;2 8: ?<17< ;<- =-;1;185-/ ?.2 ;<- =B6>B 7844-7;8/ .7792-0 ?.2 C9-2;185-0 .50 <- 010 58; /-=.B ;<- >85-B .50 ;<-/-:8/-78>=4.15;7.>-;8A-4806-0AB;<-.5.6-/8: /12<5. /.>--5. .5D .50 A.2-0 85 297< 78>=4.15; . 7.2- 7.>- ;8 /-612;-/-0 15 /1>- 8"#%%# AB .6./8417-.4.A9/.61 $* :;-/ ;<8/896< 153-2;16.;185 7<./6-!2<--;
7.>- ;8 A- :14-0 :8/ ;<- 8::-57-2 =9512<.A4- 950-/
- 7 -
-7;1852 %* %# %' $( .50 % 8: 501.5 -5.4 80- $(
-./5-0 /.14 .612;/.;- ;88D 78651E.57- .50 .:;-/ 09- ;/1.4 .7792-0 ?.2 785317;-0 :8/ ;<- 8::-57-2 =9512<.A4- 950-/ -7;1852 %' .50 % 8: 501.5 -5.4 80-.502-5;-57-0.2/-:-//-0;829=/. $# -156 .66/1-3-0 AB ;<- 2.10 @906>-5; 8:
785317;185 .50 2-5;-57- .7792-0 :14-0 .5 .==-.4 A-:8/- ;<-12;/17;89/;15/1>15.4==-.488:%$(?<17< .4287.>-;8A-012>122-0AB;<-12;/17;89/;85>-/1;2 .:;-/<-./156;<-./69>-5;28:A8;<210-2 $' 5 ;<- 416<;8: ;<- /-3121856/89502;<12 89/; /-785210-/-0;<->.;-/1.4-310-57-85/-78/0 % 5297</-785210-/.;185;<-/-1258012=9;-;<.; .7792-0?.2;<-=B6>B7844-7;8/.50;<-/-:8/-;<-/-?.2 .9;8>.;17 -5;/92;>-5; 8: ;<- >85-B 8: ;<- /12<5. /.>--5 .5D ;</896< ;<- 0-=821;8/2 ;8 A- 0-=821;-0 A.7D15;8;<-.5D
- 8 -
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
- 9 -
.7792-0 15 ;<12 7.2- .2 ;<- .7792-0 ?.2 .==815;-0.2;<-=B6>B7844-7;8/AB;<-/12<5.
/.>--5 .5D1;2-4:
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
- 10 -
B-./2.50=/-=./-0;8/-=.B;<-.>895;>12.==/8=/1.;-0 ;8 ;<- .5D 15 . ;1>- A8950>.55-/ -5<.57156 ;<- :15- .>895;15.29>8:2"%%%!1:;<-;1>-12-F;-50-0;8 =.B ;<- A.4.57- .>895; 8: 2#'%%! ;8 /12<5. /.>--5. .5D AB 2-;;156 .210- ;<- A.4.57- =-/180 8: 1>=/1285>-5;-5028:@92;17-?8940A->-;15;<-=-7941./ :.7;2.5071/79>2;.57-8:;<-7.2- ' 778/01564B;<-:8448?156
1 <-/-312185=-;1;18512.448?-015=./; 11 <14- >.15;.15156 ;<- 785317;185 8: ;<- .7792-0 :8/ ;<- 8::-57-2 =9512<.A4- 950-/ -7;1852%'.50%8:501.5-5.480- 111 92;80B =-/180 .4/-.0B 950-/685- AB ;<- /-312185 =-;1;185-/ A- ;/-.;-0 .2 =-/180 8: 1>=/1285>-5; AB 01/-7;156 <1> ;8 =.B -5<.57-0 :15- .>895; 15 . 29> 2"%%%! .50 A.4.57- >12.==/8=/1.;-0 .>895; 8:
2#'%%! 85 8/ A-:8/- &$2; 8: 9692; %"
- 11 -
13 .149/-;8=.B;<--5<.57-0:15-.>895;.50 A.4.57- >12.==/8=/1.;-0 .>895; .7792-0 /-312185 =-;1;185-/ 2<.44 950-/68 1>=/1285>-5; .2 8/0-/-0 AB ;<- /1.4 .612;/.;- 785:1/>-0 AB ;<- 1/2; ==-44.;- 89/;
::17-1201/-7;-0/-;9/5;<-/1.489/;/-78/02?1;< 78=B 8: ;<12 8/0-/ :8/;<?1;< :8/ 1229- 8: >801:1-0 785317;185?.//.5; .& '%+ ! 12;8$48*"