Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92401 (KAR)

THE BRANCH MANAGER v. MARGU AND ORS

MFA/202181/2022 · 2025-07-16

Ravi V Hosmani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$# %$!&&! !!'' (& ) * !" ! # !! $ % & $ # $'!('! % $ !) &# *& # *&!!!' ' + ",!(# Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # - $ ./01.23342567567849:/;/;94;7<68.=/>74>8/:542;>49 =/0>745:/;32;8647686782?4>03:/;:6>259673/725 ! .2554>16>1@091A4>82>92<2;992849*&!!! 327749BC'99686/>254>6/; 6D6509142>9 /8/;==694>8 526A7 ;6B0>25'+ 6@2C230;2 :/; 7./;8 E8;6B0>25F 6> >/",!(8.6723342567:6549 & ;6 2>D4>9;2 499C 542;>49 =/0>745 70BA68849 233425 <27 BC 6>70;4; /> G02>80A /> 1;/0>9 8.28 <.654 2774776>1 =/A34>7286/> 6> =274 /: 9428. /: A6>/; 2149 & C42;7 6> A/8/; D4.6=54 2==694>8 8;6B0>25 .29 29/3849 A05863564;=/;;473/>96>18/214/:C/0>14;32;4>8;28.4;8.2> 8.28/:94=42749.4;4:/;42<2;9</059;4G06;4;490=86/>8 <2770BA688494D4><.4>8;6B0>25>/8498.289;6D4;/:6>70;49 D4.6=54 <27 >/8 ./596>1 D2569 2>9 4::4=86D4 9;6D6>1 56=4>=4 96;4=86/> 8/ 6>70;4; 8/ 32C =/A34>7286/> 8/ 8.6;9 32;8C - 3 - =526A2>87 2>9 8.4;42:84; ;4=/D4; 72A4 :;/A 6>70;49 <27 >/8 @0786:6492>97/01.86>84;:4;4>=4 , ;6 $/0@25216 542;>49 =/0>745 :/; ;473/>94>87=526A2>87/33/749233425 " 42;9542;>49=/0>7454;07496A301>49@091A4>8 2>92<2;9 > D64< /: 2B/D4 =/>84>86/>7 3/6>87 8.28 </059 2;674:/;=/>7694;286/>2;4 * ;/A2<2;96867744>8.28=526A348686/><27:6549 0>94; 4=86/> /: /8/; 4.6=547 =8 78286>1 8.28 28 * & 2A/>!H*!"<.4>4D4>9;2/ 2;102AB42149 & C42;7 <27 782>96>1 6> :;/>8 /: .67 ./074 28 $.652;.2886 9;6D4; /: 8;2=8/;'8;2654; B42;6>1 >/$'!('! 2>9 ' '&**! 5/2949 <68. A09 9;/D4 68 6> ;27. 2>9 >415614>8 A2>>4;2>968;2>/D4;=.659?6556>168/>73/8>=526A348686/> - 4 - :6549 BC 32;4>87 2149 !" C42;7 2>9 !! C42;7 ;4734=86D45C ;4:4;;6>1 8/ 94=676/> /: />FB54 03;4A4 /0;8 6> ;43/;8496> 68=/>7694;49>/86/>256>=/A4/:A6>/;287&'2335649 A05863564; =/;;473/>96>1 8/ 214 /: C/0>14; 32;4>8 64 ( 2;;6D4928>482A/0>8/:5/77/:9434>94>=C287",' / 7269 2A/0>8 :65625 =/>7/;860A /: 7,' 42=. 6> 299686/> 8/ 7"' 8/<2;97 :0>4;25 4I34>747 2>9 7"' 8/<2;97 5/77 /: 478284 <27 29949 2>9 8/825 =/A34>7286/>/:7"'<272<2;949 ( >7/:2; 27 562B6568C 8;6B0>25 ;4:4;;49 8/ 3/56=4 6>D47861286/> ;4=/;97 4734=6255C I*'=.2;14 7.448 <.4;46> 9;6D4; /: 6>70;49 D4.6=54 <27 =.2;147.44849 :/; 9;6D6>1 A/8/; D4.6=54 <68./08 3/774776>1 D2569 2>9 4::4=86D4 9;6D6>1 56=4>=4 2>9=2076>12==694>89048/;27.2>9>415614>89;6D6>18/./59 8.286>70;4;</059>/8B4:055C562B540882?6>1>/84/::2=8 8.28D6=86A/:2==694>8<278.6;932;8C8/=/>8;2=8/:6>70;2>=4 2>9 ;286/ 5269 9/<> BC />FB54 03;4A4 /0;8 6> !"# $ %& ';43/;8496>()6896;4=849 - 5 - 6>70;4;8/32C=/A34>7286/><68.56B4;8C8/;4=/D4;72A4:;/A 6>70;492A4676>G04786/> H 9A688495C94=42749<278.6;932;8C8/=/>8;2=8/: 6>70;2>=4734;;286/6>*=274703;227<45527 + %$ , %- ;43/;849 6> ( . 96;4=86/> 677049 BC 8;6B0>25 </059 B4 @0786:649 .4;4:/;4 6>70;4;F7 =.2554>14 </059 >/8 B4 70B782>862849/6>8>/672>7<4;496>>41286D4 > G02>80A 8;6B0>25 .27 2335649 A05863564; =/;;473/>96>18/214/:C/0>14;32;4>8>D64</: />7868086/> 4>=. 94=676/> /: />FB54 03;4A4 /0;8 6> / %& ' +' $ ;43/;849 6> 214 /: 94=42749 .27 8/ B4 =/>7694;49 :/; 30;3/747 /: 23356=286/> /: A05863564; <.6=. </059 B4 " : =/A34>7286/> 67 ;4'</;?49 BC 2335C6>1 =/;;473/>96>1 A05863564; /: " =/A34>7286/> 8/<2;97 5/77 /: 9434>94>=C</059B47,"'7&'I" 32;8 :;/A 2B/D4 =526A2>87 </059 B4 4>868549 :/; 7,' 42=. 8/<2;97 :65625 =/>7/;860A 7"' - 6 - 8/<2;97 :0>4;25 4I34>747 2>9 7"' 8/<2;97 5/77 /: 478284734;94=676/>6>+'*&703;28.4C </059 B4 4>868549 :/; J 47=25286/> :/; 4D4;C 8.;44 C42;7 6>=4A/;48.2>76IC42;7.2D45237492:84;94=676/>6>+' *&703;28.4C</059B44>8685498/!J47=25286/> 647!!'7'I!J.07=526A2>87</059 B44>8685498/8/825=/A34>7286/>/:7"(!'2774774927 :/55/<7 +,-./01+2.,342 0523 /77/:9434>94>=C 7",' />D4>86/>25.4297 7' 7=25286/>!J 7!!' 3,6 . 7 ! /6>8 >/! 67 2>7<4;49 6> 2::6;A286D4 2==/;96>15C />74G04>85C:/55/<6>1 6 3342567255/<496>32;8@091A4>82>92<2;9 92849 *&!!! 327749 BC '99686/>25 4>6/; 6D65 0914 2>9 /8/; ==694>8 526A7 ;6B0>25'+6@2C230;26> >/",!(67 A/96:649 =526A2>87 2;4 .459 4>868549 :/; 8/825 =/A34>7286/> /: 7"(!' 27 2126>78 7"' 2<2;949 BC ;6B0>25 <68. - 7 - 6>84;478 28 J 34; 2>>0A :;/A 9284 /: =526A 348686/>865532CA4>8 66 6;4=86/> BC 8;6B0>25 6>7/:2; 27 562B6568C /: 6>70;4; 8/ 32C =/A34>7286/> 8/ =526A2>87 6> :6;78 6>782>=4 <68. 56B4;8C 8/ ;4=/D4; 68 :;/A 6>70;4;8.4;42:84;782>97=/>:6;A49 666 >70;4; 67 96;4=849 8/ 943/768 =/A34>7286/> 2A/0>8B4:/;4;6B0>25<68.6>76I<44?7 6D A/0>8 6> 943/768 6: 2>C B4 8;2>7A68849 8/ 8;6B0>25:/;967B0;74A4>8 !-7 (&&!) $ 678/ 5/ & 8 ?