Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92390 (KAR)
BASAWARAJ v. GANAPATI AND ANR
MFA/202314/2024 · 2025-12-03
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92390 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92390 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $
$$
%&' (
!!" # $
" %
!"
" ! &''!'
" !! ''!&&
" "& ()!)*
&')
"
" ! *'''! " &! +!'!! !&!'''''
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
""! "'" ' ! !!"'" ' * # $
"
!%
"!)&$!%
*"' " '
"+*+ '
"!!')'' "!''''
! "
"
,
"
-
# $ - %
./01. 2.34 562278 .64 9/57 0: ;/8 6<53443/= >32. 9/=47=2 /; ?768=7< 9/0=47? ;/8 :682374 32 34 26@7= 0: ;/8 .7683=1"
" .34 6::76? 34 ;3?7< 6163=422.7 A0<157=2 6=< 6>68< <627< *"' " ' :6447<BC2.77=3/83D3?0<176=< .3226:083=/"+*+/; ' "
&" .7 3=A087< 9?6356=2 617< * C7684 </3=1 618390?2087 572 >32. 6= 6993<7=2 /= '!"' " ' 6=< ;3?7<
- 3 -
9?635 6::?39623/= 9?6353=1 9/5:7=4623/= /; 4"&+''''" .7 83B0=6? 9/=43<783=1 2.7 7=2387 7D3<7=97 /= 879/8< 186=27< 2.7 9/5:7=4623/= /; 4"!!')'' >32. 3=278742 62 2.78627/;*:7897=2:786==05;8/52.7<627/;:72323/=23?? <7:/432 6=< 2.7 83B0=6? 7E/=78627< 874:/=<7=2 /" 3=4086=97 9/5:6=C ;8/5 :6C3=1 9/5:7=4623/= 6=< <387927< 874:/=<7=2 /"!/>=78 /; 2.7 D7.39?7 2/ <7:/432 2.7 9/5:7=4623/=65/0=2"
"11837D7<BC2.7463</8<782.346::76?34:87;7887< BC2.76::7??6=29?6356=23=>.39.3234563=?C9/=27=<7<2.62 2.7 5/=2.?C 3=9/57 /; 2.7 9?6356=2 >64 >8/=1?C 26@7= 64 4"!'' 6=< 3=278742 34 2/ B7 7=.6=97<" .7 874:/=<7=2 /"!/>=78/;2.7D7.39?7>64<387927<2/:6C9/5:7=4623/=64 2.7<83D78>64=/2.6D3=12.7D6?3<<83D3=1?397=97".787;/8732 349/=27=<7<2.62874:/=<7=2/" 3=4086=979/5:6=C56CB7 <387927<2/:6C6=<879/D78".0487F07427<;/85/<3;39623/= /;2.7/8<78"
" 768=7< 9/0=47? ;/8 2.7 874:/=<7=23=4086=97 9/5:6=C9/=27=<7<2.622.7?36B3?32C>64/=2.7/>=78/;2.7 D7.39?76=<.7.64.6D7=/2;3?7<6=C6::76?"42.79?6356=234
- 4 -
=/> 64@3=1 ;/8 :6C 6=< 879/D78C 2.7 ?768=7< 9/0=47? 34 40B53227<2.622.765/0=24186=27<0=<782.7/2.78.76<4687 7E97443D76=<32342/B75/<3;37<64:782.7?6>"
*" 768<2.7681057=24/;B/2.43<74"
)" .7 3=A087< 9?6356=2 42627< 2.62 .7 >64 768=3=1 Rs. '''':785/=2.B02.7.64=/2;3?7<6=C3=9/57:8//;"
7572>32.6=6993<7=2/='!"' " ' "4:782.7103<7?3=74 /; 68=626@6 2627 716? 78D3974 02./832C .34 =/23/=6? 3=9/57 34 2/ B7 26@7= 64 4"!)' :78 5/=2. 6=< .7 >64 617<*C76846=<2.750?23:?378342/B726@7=64!&"
" .7 :72323/=78 7E653=7< 2.7 </92/8 64 "" " .7 </92/8 .64 42627< 2.62 2.62 :72323/=78 >64 40;;783=1 ;8/5 ;8692087 /; (C1/56239 89. B3?62786? 56E3??68C 43=04 6=< ;8692087/; 8B32.75/88.61399/=2043/=3=G 6=<;8/=26? ?/B74"=2.7>/0=<97823;3962762E.3B32&323442627<2.62 2.7:72323/=78.6440;;787<2.7;/??/>3=13=A08374 !" 76<=A08C"
"68B?77<3=1" &"/;:683726?8713/=H&954 H!954"
"/D78831.2;8/=26?275:/86?&H 954"
- 5 -
"B8643/=/D78/47" *"0?23:?76B8643/=/D78?7;2?71"
+" .7 </92/8 34407< <346B3?32C 97823;3962764 :78 E.3B32 6=<6447447<2.7<346B3?32C64I2/2.7>./?7B/<C".7 83B0=6? .64 26@7= /=7 2.38< /; I >.39. 9/574 2/ !I" .787;/872.7<346B3?32C=77<4=/3=278;787=97".042.7?/44 /; ;02087 768=3=1 96:6932C 9/574 2/ 4"&!' $!)'E! E!&E!I%" .7 :72323/=78 >64 ./4:326?3J7< ;/8 6 :783/< /; &* <6C4" 7 >64 6<53227<" = '!"' " ' 6=< <349.6817</='"'&" ' 64:78E.3B32)"/=43<783=12.7 =62087 /; 3=A08374 :783/< /; ./4:326?34623/= 6=< 2.7 /2.78 87?7D6=2 ;692/84 2.7 65/0=24 186=27< 0=<78 2.7 /2.78 .76<4 3=9?0<3=1 57<396? 7E:7=474 62 4" & !
=77<4 =/ 3=278;787=97" />7D782.7?/44/;3=9/57<083=1?63<0::783/< 34 2/ B7 5/<3;37< 64 4" ' $!)' E &% 3=4276< /; 4"*''" />7D78 2.7 83B0=6? 186=27< Rs.'''' 2/>68<4 ;02087 57<396? 7E:7=474 >32./02 6=C B6434 6=< 2.787;/872.79?6356=234=/27=232?7<;/82.7463<65/0=26=<32 34 2/ B7 <7?727<" .787;/87 2.7 2/26? 9/5:7=4623/= 9/574 2/ 4"!'&)*!" .04 2.7 9/5:7=4623/= 34 87<097< ;8/5
- 6 -
4"!!')'' 2/4"!'&)*! >32. 3=278742 62 *I :78 6==05"
!'".76>68</;9/5:7=4623/=:6447<BC2.783B0=6? 345/<3;37<640=<78
76<4 5/0=23=4" !"/44/;;020873=9/57
&!'
"7<396?7E:7=474
& ! &"63=6=<0;;783=1 ''''
"/44/;657=32374 ''''
"86=4:/82623/=7E286 =/0834.57=26=<6227=<6=29.68174 '''
*"/44/;768=3=1<083=12.7?63<0: :783/<
'
/26? )*+
!!".783B0=6?/B478D7<2.62323469647/;=/<83D3=1 ?397=97 6=< ;3E7< 2.7 ?36B3?32C /= 2.7 />=78 /; 2.7 D7.39?7" 768=7< 9/0=47? ;/8 :72323/=789?6356=2 87F07427< ;/8 :6C 6=< 879/D78CBC2.7874:/=<7=23=4086=979/5:6=C".787;/873= 2.7?31.2/;2.7A0<157=2/;2.7 /=-B?70:8757/0823=2.7
- 7 -
9647 /;
87:/827< 3= >.7873= 2.7
/=-B?70:8757/082.64.7?<2.62>.7=2.78734=/<83D3=1 ?397=97 2.7 3=4086=97 9/5:6=C .64 2/ :6C 9/5:7=4623/= 6=< 2.7= 879/D78 2.7 4657 ;8/5 2.7 />=78 /; 2.7 D7.39?7 2.7 874:/=<7=23=4086=979/5:6=C34<387927<2/:6C9/5:7=4623/= 6=<879/D782.74657;8/52.7/>=78/;2.7D7.39?7"
! "=2.78740?22.7;/??/>3=1/8<7834:6447< $3% ::76?346??/>7<3=:682" $33% .7 :72323/=789?6356=2 34 7=232?7< ;/8 2.7 2/26? 9/5:7=4623/=/;4"!'&)*!+>32.3=27874262*:7897=2:78 6==05;8/52.7<627/;:72323/=23??2.7<627/;876?3J623/=" $333% 74:/=<7=2 /" =4086=97 9/5:6=C 34 <387927< 2/ <7:/4322.76;/87463<9/5:7=4623/=>32.3=/=75/=2.;8/52.7 <627/;2.34/8<78" $3D% = 409. <7:/432 2.7 9?6356=2 34 :7853227< 2/ >32.<86>2.77=238765/0=26?/=1>32.2.73=278742699807</= 32"
- 8 -
$D% .7 874:/=<7=23=4086=97 9/5:6=C 34 62 ?3B782C 2/ 879/D782.7463<65/0=2/=2.7/>=78/;2.7D7.39?7BC <07:8/9744/;?6>"
,-+ %$ ' #
342/"!?/"*'