Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92388 (KAR)

SRI A VENKANNA v. THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

WP/201024/2025 · 2025-07-21

M I Arun

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $%" % & ' ! " #$ % & % % ' ' ((( $)% ! %% '% ( * ' ' %% * %% +,,( " #$ - % . - %!& Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' % !!/ !!, % % %' ' & ' % ' ! % (/(!(! *+% % % - $+% $& ' % ' ! % ' (/ !!(! *+ & '% ' $ ! $ + /, + - !(!+ ! ! (!!(! % ,+ *+ % 0$) ' - 3 - 1$- # 1$- & 23456789:23;3:<:<863=25>?3365@AB<=3798=:23 ;B=;8>3> 89 5:<8654 <C2D5E 3>;86736: 8! D28 <> :23@8F;3:36:5B:28=<:EB673=:23 5:<8654<C2D5E>@: G/ #98= >28=: 0 )& 25> ;5>>37 56 5D5=7 75:37 / !!(!#663HB=3+ :8:23D=<:;3:<:<86&<6=3>;3@:89 :23 4567 89 :23 ;3:<:<863= D2<@2 25> ?336 5@AB<=37 23=359:3==3>;86736: 8! 25>;5>>37568:23= 5D5=775:37! (!!(!#663HB=3+:8:23D=<:;3:<:<86& <6 =3>;3@: 89 :23 >5F3 4567 D2<@2 ?3486C> :8 :23 ;3:<:<863=:25>=3>B4:37<6=37B@:<8689:23@8F;36>5:<86 5F8B6:CC=<3I37?E:23>5F3:23;=3>36:D=<:;3:<:<86 <>9<437 ! 23 @5>3 89 :23 ;3:<:<863= <> :25: 86@3 56 5D5=7<>;5>>37?E=3>;86736: 8!23?3@8F3> 56723@5668:;5>>568:23=5D5=7<6=3>;3@:89:23 - 4 - >5F3 4567 6 :23 >5<7 C=8B67 <: <> ;=5E37 :25: :23 >3@867 5D5=7 75:37 ! (!!(! #663HB=3+ :8 :23 D=<: ;3:<:<86& ?3 >3: 5><73 567 54>8 ;=5E37 98= ;5EF36: 89 @8F;36>5:<865>;3=:2335=4<3=5D5=7 3= @86:=5 435=637 3;B:E 84<@<:8= 363=5489 67<5 5;;35=<6C 98= =3>;86736: 8> 567 JB>:<9<3> :23 8=73=;5>>37?E=3>;86736: 8!567;=5E>98=7<>F<>>54 89:23D=<:;3:<:<86 23 5:<8654 <C2D5E> @: G/ ;=8I<73 98= 5@AB<><:<8689456798=:23;B=;8>3>89 5:<8654<C2D5E> 3@:<86 #5& 89 :23 @: 739<63> 0@8F;3:36: 5B:28=<:E) 5> 98448D> ! " # ! - 5 - $ 6 :23 <6>:56: @5>3 <: <> 68: <6 7<>;B:3 :25: =3>;86736: 8!<>:23@8F;3:36:5B:28=<:E / 3@:<8689:23@:>;35K>5?8B::23;=8@3>> 89 73:3=F<65:<86 89 5F8B6: ;5E5?43 5> @8F;36>5:<86 98= :234567>5@AB<=3723>5F3=357>5>B673= % & $ '& ( ( ( ) " $ % $ - 6 - * + ( % ' ( " "(( " ( $ , - ( ( ' * " $ . % ' ! " $ /-) " " %00/ '/ %00/ " $ - 7 - 12 ( % . 3 3 " *4 ( 3 ( " ( 4 ( 3 ( ) ( " (4 ( ($ - 8 - , 2B>?EI<=:B3893@:<86# &89:23@::23 @8F;3:36: 5B:28=<:E 25> :23 ;8D3= :8 73:3=F<63 :23 @8F;36>5:<86;5E5?4398=:2345675@AB<=37B673=:23@: 8D3I3= :23=3 <> 68 ;=8I<><86 <6 :23 5:<8654 <C2D5E> @: G/ D2<@2 3F;8D3=> :23 @8F;3:36: 5B:28=<:E :8 =3I<3D 2<> 8D6 73@<><86 6 :23 5?>36@3 89 :23 >;3@<9<@ ;8D3= 89 =3I<3D @8693==37 86 :23 @8F;3:36: 5B:28=<:E 86@323;5>>3>565D5=723?3@8F3> >;3=3@:<86#&89:23@:<93<:23=89:23 ;5=:<3> 5=3 5CC=<3I37 ?E :23 @8F;36>5:<86 5F8B6: 5D5=737:23E5=35:4<?3=:E:85;;=85@2:235=?<:=5:8=<6 5@@8=756@3 D<:2 45D 6 :2<> @5>3 <: D<44 ?3 :23 JB=<>7<@:<8654 3;B:E 8FF<>><863= $8:2 :23 4567 48>3= 567 :23 2<C2D5E 5B:28=<:<3> 25I3 :23 5B:28=<:E :8 5;;=85@2 :23 >5<7 5=?<:=5:8= ?B: <: <> 68: 8;36 98= =3>;86736: 8! :8 =3I<3D 2<> 8D6 8=73= 6 :23 <6>:56: @5>3 :28BC2 =3>;86736: 8! 25> 68: >:E437 :23 <F;BC6378=73=5>5=3I<3D89:2335=4<3=5D5=7<:25>:8 ?3@86>:=B375@@8=7<6C4E3@5668:;5>>565D5=798=:23 - 9 - >3@867:<F32B>:23<F;BC6375D5=775:37! (!!(! #663HB=3+ :8 :23 D=<: ;3:<:<86& <> =3AB<=37 :8 ?3 >3: 5><73 G 36@3:2398448D<6C < '=<:;3:<:<86<>5448D37 << 23<F;BC6375D5=775:37! (!!(!?35=<6C 8 + /, 5C5=<+ -575@23=45+ !(!+! #663HB=3+ :8 :23 D=<: ;3:<:<86& ;5>>37?E=3>;86736: 8!<>23=3?E>3:5><73 <<< 3>;86736: 8!>2544:5K3>:3;>:8<F;43F36: :23 35=4<3= 5D5=7 75:37 / !!(! ?35=<6C 8 + /, 5C5=< + -575@23=45 + !(!+!,#663HB=3+ :8:23D=<:;3:<:<86& D<:2<6 5 ;3=<87 89 :2=33 F86:2> 9=8F :23 75:3 89=3@3<;:89@3=:<9<37@8;E89:2<>8=73=B643>> :23 5:<8654 <C2D5E B:28=<:<3> 5;;=85@2 :23 - 10 - 5=?<:=5:8= <6 5@@8=756@3 D<:2 45D 567 5=3 5?43 :88?:5<656E8=73=>5C5<6>:<F;43F36:5:<8689 :235D5=7;5>>37 () &%' " <>: 8 4 8,