- 1 - ! "!#!! $$ %#& ' ! "## $ ##% & " # $ ' # (% ' ' # # ) *! +# * ! &'' ) ' ) ,! # !, ! &''))' ## ' ## ' ## Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ##'' ) - ) #! $#- ) % ./0122314/0567.3241/87/9953/8:1::;/3<3=567.3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 =173= *! + 21003= /8 B* ! & B8 7.3 9/43 B9 7.3 ==/7/B814 38/B; /</4 )?=:3 18= )' 1/A.?;$9B; 0.B;7 C7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7D%56E./A. 7.3'/;07 22344173 B?;7 E./43 144BE/8: 7.3 122314 9/43= 56 7.3 241/87/99 ;302B8=387 .3;3/8 037 10/=3 7.3>?=:@387 18==3A;33=173= ,! 21003= /8 B!, ! &B87.39/43B97.3==/7/B814/</4)?=:3 $);8%18=)'1/A.?;$9B;0.B;7C7.3;/14B?;7D% ! .3 15B<3 0?/7 /8 B!, ! & /0 9/43= 56 7.3241/87/99 122344187.3;3/8033F/8:9B44BE/8:;34/39D0G - 3 - !"!#$ %$&'# () * + !, * B8738=/8: $ 7.17 .3 /0 7.3 150B4?73 BE83;/83HA4?0/<32B00300/B818=38>B6@387B92;B23;76 531;/8: B24B, 0/7?173= 17 717/B8 ;31 1/A.?; $.3;3/81973; ;393;;3= 7B 10 I7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76J% .3241/87/992;3038746;30/=/8:171=<177//441:39B;7.3 2?;2B03B9./04/<34/.BB=.17=3938=187/0./0;31434=3; 5;B7.3;E.B/0EB;F/8:101BBF17;1<144B;D0 ?8:14BE 1/A.?; 3938=187 /0 8B7 .1</8: ;/:.7 7/743 18= /873;307 B<3; 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76 3938=187 E10 7;6/8: 7B 9B;A/546 7;3002100/87B7.3.B?03B97.3241/87/991773@27/8:7B4BAF 7.3 .B?03 18= 7.;317383= 7.3 241/87/99 18= ./0 738187 7B 2167.3;3877B./@B;34037.36EB?4=53B?073=9;B@7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76 3938=187 /0 /873;93;/8: E/7. 7.3 231A39?4 2B00300/B8 18= BE83;0./2 B9 7.3 241/87/99 B<3; 7.3 0?/7 - 4 - 2;B23;76 .?0 7.17 :1<3 ;/03 7B A1?03 B9 1A7/B8 9B; 7.3 241/87/997B9/437.30?/79B;/8>?8A7/B8 3938=187 /8 ./0 E;/7738 07173@387 AB8738=3= 7.17241/87/99/08B7.1</8:1862;B23;76B;.B?03531;/8: B, 0/7?173= 17 0717/B8 1;31 1/A.?; 10 A41/@3= .177.3=3938=187D0.B?03531;/8:B!!+ *$B4=% B!! *!$83E%AB80/070B97.;332B;7/B80:/<387B 7381870B8;387.3=3938=187/0/81A7?142B00300/B818= 38>B6@387B97.301/=2;B23;763938=1872?;A.103=7.3 01/=2;B23;769;B@B83 63=/61K?==/818=AB807;?A73=1 .B?03 B8 /7 /8 7.3 631; ,+ 56 B571/8/8: 23;@/00/B8 38A30B?:.79B;=/0@/0014B97.30?/7 .3;/14B?;79;1@3=9B44BE/8:7.3/00?309B; /70AB80/=3;17/B8G #!- . /!- . 0!- . 1!-., - 5 - & #41/87/993H1@/83=./@034910#18=18B7.3; E/78300 10 #! 18= 3H./5/73= + =BA?@3870 @1;F3= 10 H#7B#+3938=1873H1@/83=./@03491018=7EB B7.3; E/7830030 10 0! 18= * 18= 3H./5/73= * =BA?@3870@1;F3=10 H0 7B* 8 122;3A/17/B8B9 7.33</=38A37.3;/14B?;7180E3;3=/00?3B07B*/8 7.3 199/;@17/<3 18= AB803L?38746 =3A;33= 7.3 0?/7 3/8: 1::;/3<3= =3938=187 2;393;;3= 7.3 15B<3 122314 /8 B* ! &B80/=3;/8:7.3:;B?8=0?;:3=7.3'/;07 22344173 B?;7 9;1@3= 7.3 9B44BE/8: 2B/870 9B; /70 AB80/=3;17/B8G #)- . /)- . 0)- . 1)-. + 8 ;3122;3A/17/B8 B9 7.3 @1773; 7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 180E3;3= 2B/87 B0 18= ! /8 7.3 - 6 - 83:17/<3 2B/87 B* /8 7.3 199/;@17/<3 18= AB803L?38746 144BE3= 7.3 122314 56 0377/8: 10/=3 7.3 >?=:@387 18= =3A;33 21003= 56 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 10 8B73= 15B<3 3/8: 1::;/3<3=567.301@37.32;30387122314/09/43= 31;83= AB?8034 9B; 7.3 241/87/99 122344187 ;3/73;17/8: 7.3 :;B?8=0 ?;:3= /8 7.3 @3@B;18=?@ B9 122314 0?5@/773= 7.17 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 B8 122;3A/17/B8 B9 2431=/8:018=3</=38A3@B;321;7/A?41;467.31=@/00/B8B9 7.3 =3938=187 B9 .3 .1</8: 8B AB8A3;8 E/7. 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76 A41/@3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 .1= ;/:.746 :;1873= 7.3 ;34/39 B9 23;@18387 /8>?8A7/B8 E./A. B?:.7 8B7 7B .1<3 5338 ;3<3;03= 56 7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 3 0?5@/70 7.17 7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 3;;3= /8 AB@/8: 7B 7.3 AB8A4?0/B8 B9 241/87/99 8B7 53/8: 2B00300/B8 B9 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76 @3;346 53A1?03 7.3 7381870 E.B E3;3 /8 BAA?217/B8 B9 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76 .1= <1A173= /810@?A. 10 7.32B00300/B8 B9 7.3 241/87/99 B<3; 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76 E10 AB807;?A7/<3 06@5B4/A7.;B?:.7.37381870./01023A7B9 7.3@1773;.1053384B070/:.7567.3'/;0722344173B?;7 - 7 - .177.3'/;0722344173B?;73;;3=/8.B4=/8:7.177.3;3/0 1=/02?73B97.37/743B<3;7.30?/72;B23;7618=.1=B2/83= 7.3241/87/997B033F1AB@2;3.380/<3;34/39/87.315038A3 B9 186 =/02?73 7B 7.3 7/743 .3;310 7.3 =3938=187 /8 ./0 A;B003H1@/817/B8 .1= 1=@/773= 7.17 .3 E10 8B7 7.3 BE83;B97.30?/72;B23;7687.174/:.7B97.3@1773;7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 3;;3= /8 =/0@/00/8: 7.3 0?/7 9B; /8>?8A7/B8:/</8:;/037B0?507187/14L?307/B8B941E , 8;302B803431;83=AB?803412231;/8:9B;7.3 =3938=187 ;302B8=3870?5@/707.177.30?/72;B23;7653/8: A41/@3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 /0 =/993;387 18= =/07/8A7 9;B@ 7.3 2;B23;76/82B00300/B8B97.3=3938=18730?5@/707.17 7.3;/14B?;718=7.3'/;0722344173B?;7.1<3AB@37B 7.3 AB8A?;;387 9/8=/8: B8 7./0 1023A7 B9 7.3 @1773; .3;39B;3 7.3 241/87/99 B?:.7 7B .1<3 2;B<3= 7.3 91A7 B9 /873;93;38A3/9186567.3=3938=187/8./02;B23;76E./A. 7.3241/87/99.1091/43=.3L?307/B87.3;39B;3B9:;187/8: 23;@18387 /8>?8A7/B8 /8 7.3 15038A3 B9 2;BB9 B9 /873;93;38A3E103;;B83B?0E./A.E1003717;/:.7567.3 - 8 - '/;0722344173B?;718=01@3A188B7539B?8=91?47E/7. 3 9?;7.3; 0?5@/70 7.17 7.3 241/87/99 .1= 9/43= 18 1224/A17/B8 /8 B ?8=3; ;=3; ?43 + 033F/8: 1@38=@387 7B 7.3 241/87 7B 7.3 3993A7 7.17 7.3 0?/7 2;B23;76E./A.E10/87.32B00300/B8B97381870.1=5338 .18=3=B<3;18=7.301/=1224/A17/B8A1@37B53;3>3A73= 18= 7.3 B;=3; B9 ;3>3A7/B8 .10 1771/83= 9/814/76 8 7.17 </3EB97.3@1773;7.31443:3=2B00300/B8B97.3241/87/99 .10 8B7 5338 2;B<3= .3;39B;3 .3 0?5@/70 7.17 7.3 =3938=187 E10 >?07/9/3= /8 AB8738=/8: 7.17 8B 0?A. 2;B23;76 10 A41/@3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 3<3; 3H/073= 38A3 8B 0?507187/14 L?307/B8 B9 41E 7.3;39B;3 EB?4= 1;/03 9B; AB80/=3;17/B8/87.3@1773; 7 7./0 >?8A7?;3 431;83= AB?8034 9B; 7.3 1223441875;/8:/8:7B7.38B7/A3B97./0B?;77.1710?/7/8 B!! ! *9/43=567.3=3938=187.3;3/81:1/8077.3 <3;6241/87/99/8;3023A7B92;B23;76531;/8:B!!+ * $B4=% !! *! ! *9/43=567.3=3938=187.3;3/81:1/8077.3 <3;6241/87/99/8;3023A7B92;B23;76531;/8:B!!+ * $B4=% !! *! $83E% 0?5@/70 7.17 0BB8 1973; =3A;33/8: B9 7.3 0?/7 7.3 =3938=187 .10 9/43= 7.3 15B<3 - 9 - 0?/7 E./A. /8=/A173 7.17 7.3 =3938=187 AB?4= 8B7 .1<3 AB873873= 7.3 2;B23;76 53/8: A41/@3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 534B8:07B./@ 8;302B803431;83=AB?80349B;7.3=3938=187 0?5@/70 7.17 7.3 2;B23;76 0?5>3A7 @1773; B9 7.3 0?503L?3870?/7/8 B!! ! */07.301@3E./A.7.3 =3938=187 .10 A41/@3= 18= AB8738=3= /8 7.3 E;/7738 07173@387E./A./0=/993;38718=0321;17318=7.17.10:B7 8B7./8: 7B =B E/7. 7.3 2;B23;76 53/8: A41/@3= 56 7.3 241/87/99 38A3 .3 0?5@/70 7.17 9/4/8: B9 7.3 0?503L?387 0?/7EB?4=8B7.1<3186/@21A7B87.32;303870?/7 ! 31;=23;?03=7.3;3AB;=0 * .3;/14B?;718=7.3'/;0722344173B?;7B8 122;3A/17/B8B97.33</=38A3.1<3AB@37B7.3AB8A?;;387 9/8=/8:18=AB8A4?0/B87.172;B23;7653/8:A41/@3=567.3 241/87/99 531;/8: B#B, 18= 7.3 2;B23;76 53/8: A41/@3= 56 7.3 =3938=187 531;/8: # B - 10 - !! *!$83E% 1;3 =/993;387 18= 1;3 0/7?173= 17 =/993;387 4BA17/B80 .3;39B;3 7.3 B846 L?307/B8 7.17 EB?4= 1;/03 9B; AB80/=3;17/B8 /0 E.37.3; 7.3 =3938=187 .1= /8=33= /873;93;3=E/7.7.32B00300/B8B97.32;B23;76A41/@3=56 7.3241/87/99 .3;3 /0 140B 8B =/02?73 B9 7.3 91A7 7.17 7.3 241/87/99E.B.1=B;/:/814469/43=7.30?/7033F/8:;34/3910 3H7;1A73= 15B<3 .1= 140B 9/43= 18 1224/A17/B8 /8 B 033F/8: 1@38=@387 7B 7.3 241/87 AB8738=/8: 7.17 7.3 7381870 E.B E3;3 2?;2B;73= 7B .1<3 5338 /8 2B00300/B8 B9 7.3 2;B23;76 .1= <1A173= 18= .18=3= B<3; 7.3 2B00300/B87B./@.301/=1224/A17/B81=@/773=46A1@37B 53 ;3>3A73= 18= 7.3;3 .10 5338 8B A.14438:3 7B 7.3 01/= B;=3;.3;3/0140B8B=/02?73B97.391A77.177.3241/87/99 .10 8B7 2;B=?A3= 186 @173;/14 B8 ;3AB;= 7B 0.BE 7.3 2;B23;76A41/@3=56./@E10/82B00300/B8B91867381870 7/0?8=3;7.303A/;A?@0718A307.3'/;0722344173B?;7 - 11 - E./43180E3;/8:2B/87B.10B2/83=7.17/87.315038A3 B9 241/87/99 2;B=?A/8: 186 3</=38A3 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 AB?4= 8B7.1<3AB@37B7.3AB8A4?0/B8B9241/87/99.1</8:2;B<3= 7.32B00300/B8 & '?;7.3;18146K/8:7.3;34/39D00B?:.79B;567.3 241/87/99103H7;1A73=15B<37.3'/;0722344173B?;7.10 AB@3 7B 7.3 AB8A4?0/B8 7.17 7.3 241/87/99 300387/1446 E10 033F/8:;34/391:1/8077.3=3938=187;307;1/8/8:./@9;B@ /873;93;/8: E/7. 18= =/07?;5/8: 7.3 2B00300/B8 B9 7.3 7381870 .17 /8 7.3 15038A3 B9 241/87/99 2;B</8: 7.3 2;B23;76 53/8: /8 2B00300/B8 B9 7.3 738187 10 ;/:.746 71F38 8B73 56 7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 7.3;3 E10 8B A1?03B91A7/B8>?07/96/8:=3938=1877B53;307;1/83=9;B@ 0BA1443= /873;93;38A3 /8 7.3 2B00300/B8 B9 7.3 7381870 B9 7.3241/87/99 + .3;/14B?;7@3;34653A1?037.3=3938=187 .1=1=@/773=7.177.30?/72;B23;76=/=8B7534B8:7B./@ - 12 - .10 AB8A4?=3= 7.17 =3938=187 =/= 8B7 .1<3 186 ;/:.7 7B /873;93;3>?07/96/8::;187/8:B923;@18387/8>?8A7/B8 <38 /9 7.3 241/87/99 .1= 307154/0.3= ./0 41E9?4 2B00300/B8 B<3; 7.3 2;B23;76 E/7.B?7 .3 2;B</8: 18= 307154/0./8:7.3/873;93;38A37.3;3E108B>?07/9/A17/B89B; 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 7B .1<3 :;1873= /8>?8A7/B8 1:1/807 7.3 =3938=187.3;39B;37.3;3<3;014B97.301/=9/8=/8:18= AB8A4?0/B8 B9 7.3 ;/14 B?;7 56 7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 A188B7539B?8=91?47E/7. , 0 ;3:1;=0 7.3 B503;<17/B8 B9 7.3 '/;07 22344173 B?;7 B9 =3938=187 =/02?7/8: 7.3 7/743 B9 7.3 241/87/99 18= 7.3 B503;<17/B8 @1=3 E/7. ;393;38A3 7B 7.3 >?=:@387 B9 7.3 23H B?;7 /8 7.3 A103 B9 ;32B;73= /8 1721;1:;12.B!&B9/70>?=:@387140BA188B753 9B?8=91?47E/7./810@?A.10E./437.3241/87/99/0A41/@/8: ;/:.7 7/743 18= /873;307 B<3; 2;B23;76 531;/8: B, 7.33H/0738A3B9E./A.7.3=3938=187.10=38/3=E./437.3 - 13 - =3938=187/0A41/@/8:3H/0738A3B92;B23;76531;/8:B !! *!.3;3/0AB8A?;;3879/8=/8:B991A70E/7.;3:1;= 7B 3H/0738A3 B9 7EB =/993;387 2;B23;76 7 /0 ?27B 7.3 241/87/99 /9 0B 1=</03= 7B 033F 122;B2;/173 ;3@3=6 /8 7.3 4/:.7B9=38/14B97.3<3;63H/0738A32;B23;76@1=3567.3 =3938=187 ! /7. 7.3 15B<3 B503;<17/B80 7./0 B?;7 7.3@1773;108B0?507187/14L?307/B8B941E EB?4=1;/039B;AB80/=3;17/B8 () %!!& # * #