- 1 - !! ""#$"%&'! ! (! ')#'#' * +#, + * +#, $ * +#, ! !"#$% & '( ) Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $ !"#$$ !"#$ * !"#$ # ( ( "# ( !"#$ & ' ( +$*, +#) + - + + ) + $!$$!# $$* $ . ! + #$$* . ! ) + + + + + - 3 - + ! !"#$% & '( ) " $ !"#$$ !"#$ * !"#$ # ( "- !"#$ & ' ( +$*, +#) - 4 - + - + + ) + $$$# $$** $ . ! + #$$** . ! ) + + + + + $+ ! !"#$% & '( ) " - 5 - $ !"#$$ !"#$ * !"#$ # "" !"#$ & ' ( +$*, +#) + -+ + ) + $$$# $$$* $ . ! + #$$$* . !)+ + + + + + - 6 - / ( " ' / () 0121343456174891:57130485;739146<=<<741>1?9@ 301 A5BB56 C;?<B163 =6? 57?17 2=881? 46 1>48456 134345658$$$$*=6?$$$*56301:4D15:12;3@ 5BB48845617=4A0;79@E04A030112;3@5BB48845617 E04D1 =DD5E46< 301 1>48456 13434568 :4D1? 9@ 301 274>=31 718256?163 5# 017146 0=? 813!=84?1 301 57?17 ?=31? $$*2=881?9@30188483=635BB4884561746 221=D 58*# ** =6? $"* 71821A34>1D@ =6? 0=? A5681F;163D@ ?471A31? 301 B;3=3456 1637@ 35 91 1::1A31? 353011G31635:<;63=846@5$$#H463016=B1 5:274>=31718256?16388;9C1A335:46=D718;D346A4>4D8;4346 5$#$216?46<A5684?17=345656301:4D15:4>4D ;?<1'76)5;7346?0=6;7 - 7 - 01A=815:30121343456174830=3574<46=DD@D=6? 91=746<@5$$#HD?5$$#B1=8;746<$=A718 *<;63=8843;=31?=346?0=6;746?0=6;7=D;I=4A0;7 48374A3 E171 2;7A0=81? 9@ 301 B53017 5: 301 2134345617 6=B1D@ =GB4 E4:1 5: =<=7=C :75B 301 1783E04D1 5E617 6=B1D@ =83<478=9 46 317B8 5: ?11? 5: 8=D1 5: 301 @1=7 $%%%! 01 8=4? 2752173@ 305;<0 2;7A0=81? 46 301 6=B15:301B530175:3012134345617E=8:75B=6?5;35: 301C5463:=B4D@:;6?80=3301274>=31718256?1638017146 AD=4B350=>12;7A0=81?=61G31635:<;63=85;35:301 8=4?$=A718*<;63=85:D=6?:75B301=:5718=4?B53017 5: 301 2134345617 ;6?17 ?11?8 5: 8=D1 ?=31? "$$ 0=3 301 8=4? 1G1A;3456 5: ?11? 5: 8=D1 E=8 E4305;3 A568163 =6? A56A;7716A1 5: 301 2134345617 6 D1=7646< =95;3 301 8=B1 2134345617 0=? :4D1? 59C1A34568 91:571 718256?163 5* 71F;18346< 653 35 B;3=31 301 6=B18 5: 301 274>=31 718256?1638 256 :4D46< 5: 8=4? =22D4A=3456 718256?163 5* 9@ 57?17 ?=31? ** 71C1A31? 301 AD=4B5:301274>=31718256?1638=6?6=B15:301B53017 5:3012134345617E171?471A31?3591A56346;1? - 8 - * <<741>1?9@3018=B1301274>=31718256?1638 271:1771? 71<;D=7 =221=D ;6?17 1A3456 $* ') 5: 301 (=76=3=I==6?1>16;1A391:571301718256?1635 E04A0 71<483171? 301 =221=D8 46 221=D 58 *# ** =6? $"* 71821A34>1D@ 01 718256?163 5 9@ 57?17?=31?%$$*?48B4881?3018=4?=221=D856301 271B481 5: 216?46< D434<=3456 =6? ?471A31? 301 2=73418 35 =2275=A0 301 4>4D 5;73 811I46< 71?71881D 5: 30147 <741>=6A18 # 146< =<<741>1? 9@ 301 8=B1 301 274>=31 718256?1638 017146 :4D1? 301 =95>1 71>48456 213434568 91:571 301 718256?163 5$ ! 12;3@ 5BB48845617 18256?1635$!12;3@5BB488456179@3014B2;<61? A5BB56 C;?<B163 =6? 57?17 71:1771? 35 =95>1 =DD5E1? 3018=4?71>48456213434568=86531?=95>1 " 146<=<<741>1?E4303018=B1301213434561748 91:5713048A5;73 - 9 - 1=761?A5;681D:5730121343456178;9B43830=3 3018=D1B=?19@301B530175:301213434561746:=>5;75: 274>=31718256?1638A56>1@46<<;63=85:D=6?1=A048 653946?46<5604B46A13018;43:4D1?9@3012134345617 017146 46 5$#$ 48 216?46< A5684?17=3456 ;634D ?1317B46=34565:30174<0385:30121343456173016=B15: 301B530175:3012134345617E4DD91A56346;1?18;9B438 30=3 301 12;3@ 5BB48845617 E4305;3 3=I46< 4635 3048 =821A3 5: 301 B=3317 0=8 =DD5E1? 301 1>48456 13434568 ?471A346< 301 6=B1 5: 301 274>=31 718256?1638 35 91 163171? 4635 46 301 2D=A1 5: 6=B1 5: 301 B53017 5: 301 213434561716A1301213434568 - 1=761? A5;681D :57 301 274>=31 718256?1638 5# 56 301 53017 0=6? 8;9B438 30=3 =?B4331?D@ 301 274>=31 718256?1638 0=>1 2;7A0=81? <;63=8 5: 1=A0 :75B 301 B53017 5: 301 2134345617 46 317B8 5: 71<483171? ?11?85:8=D10=DD16<1B5;631?9@301213434561735301 8=4??11?85:8=D148216?46<A5684?17=3456465$# 5: $ 01 ?11? 5: 8=D1 1G1A;31? 9@ B53017 5: 301 - 10 - 2134345617 48 834DD >=D4? =6? 8;9848346< 4DD 71>178=D 5: 301 8=B146301B=6617I65E635D=E3012134345617A=6653 =8 = B=3317 5: 74<03 AD=4B =6@ 74<03 5>17 301 2752173@ 16A1 01 8;9B438 30=3 301 57?17 2=881? 9@ 301 12;3@ 5BB48845617A=665391:5;6?:=;D3E430 1=7?17;81?30171A57?8 % +=A38 83=31? =95>1 ?5 653 71F;471 714317=3456 ?B4331?D@ B53017 5: 301 2134345617 0=? A56>1@1? <;63=85:D=6?1=A046:=>5;75:301274>=31718256?163846 317B8 5: ?11?8 5: 8=D1 ?=31? "$$ 01 2134345617 017146 0=8 46434=31? 8;43 46 5$# 5: $ 811I46< 2=7343456=6?812=7=31258818845646A4?163=DD@F;18345646< 301 1G1A;3456 5: ?11?8 5: 8=D1 9@ 048 B53017 8 74<03D@ 3=I16 6531 5: 9@ 301 718256?163 ! 12;3@ 5BB48845617 34DD ?1317B46=3456 5: 301 74<038 5: 301 2=73418 46 301 8=4? 8;43 1637@ 5: 6=B1 5: B53017 5: 301 2134345617 E05 01781D: 0=8 85D? 301 2752173@ 46 :=>5;7 5: 274>=31 718256?163 A=6653 91 A56346;1? 01 57?17 4B2;<61? - 11 - 4381D: 27531A38 301 46317183 5: 301 2134345617 E04A0 48 301 1637@ 5: 301 6=B18 5: 301 274>=31 718256?1638 46 301 71>16;1 71A57?8 E5;D? 91 8;9C1A3 35 301 5;3A5B1 5: 301 8;43:4D1?9@3012134345617630=3>41E5:301B=331765 <75;6?8=71B=?15;3:5746317:1716A14630157?17 $ AA57?46<D@ 30181 213434568 =71 A56:47B46<30157?172=881?9@30112;3@5BB48845617 $$ 53E43083=6?46< 301 ?48B488=D 5: 301 213434568 2134345617 48 =3 D49173@ 35 811I 8;A0 71B1?@ 91:571 301 5;7391:571E05B8;43465$#5:$48216?46< A5684?17=3456 #-+ *'#' , )" ( ( 4835$D5# (