- 1 - ! "# $"%" " && '&( ) ! " # $%&' ( !% " # $%&' ! # ! " # )$%&' Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! " # )$%&' (% " # )$%&' $ " # )$%&' '' * # '!'('! (' ('' # # # %('' (+('', # # # ' (('($ - #. * / # - 3 - *% " / # 01 234567819 :12789 34413; 6: <= 501 91>189385 3::36;68?501@A9?B185389912C117>501441;;3517AC5 C1891C1968 7(' ('' ( 7C 501 :3D1 7> 278E1861821 501 43C561: 3C1 C1>1CC19573:41C5016CC38D<1>7C1501C63;7AC5 ! 01 4;36856>>: 68:565A519 501 :A65 >7C :4126>62 41C>7CB382178501<3:6:7>327851B47C3817A:972AB185 3;;1?19;= 1F12A519 <= 501 91>189385 78 501 E1C= 93= 78 G0620 501 C1?6:51C19 :3;1 9119 B3CD19 3: F G3: 1F12A519227C968?575014;36856>>:501=G1C168AC?185 8119 7> >6838263; 3::6:53821 389 A478 5016C C1HA1:5 501 91>1893853?C119571F518930389;7387> :%$''')5 6:5016C23:150353>51C39E38268?501:3690389;738501 91>189385 68:6:519 5035 3 :3;1 9119 <1 1F12A519 3: :12AC65= >7C 501 3B7A85 78:1HA185;= 501 4;36856>>: 1F12A5193972AB185:5=;193:3:3;1911978&'&(''! - 4 - 68C1:41257>(32C1:7A57>5015753;1F51857>!32C1:( ?A853:507A?0501:3B1G3:6851891978;=3:3:12AC65= 5C38:325678 01 4;36856>>: >AC501C 2785189 5035 :6BA;53817A:;= 501 91>189385 1F12A519 68 5016C >3E7AC 3 :143C3513?C11B185B3CD193:FA891C53D68?57C1) 278E1= 501 E1C= :3B1 4C741C5= A478 C143=B185 7> 501 ;7383B7A8501=3::1C55035501:A65;389G3:3E3;A3<;1 4C741C5= E3;A19 35 3C7A89 :(''''') 41C 32C1 68 501 =13C (''! 1:4651 501 1F12A5678 7> 501 C1)278E1=3821 3?C11B18550191>18938553D68?A89A139E3853?17>501 C1?6:51C19 :3;1 9119 389 501 4;36856>>:. 6B47E1C6:019 278965678C1>A:19570787AC501A891C53D68?1B<7961968 F 5 6: 3;;1?19 5035 501 91>189385 C1413519;= 47:547819501B3551C27B41;;68?5014;36856>>:57>6;1501 4C1:185 :A65 :11D68? :4126>62 41C>7CB3821 1F4C1::68? C139681:: 389 G6;;68?81:: 57 C143= 501 3B7A85 7> :%$''') - 5 - $ 01C63;7AC596:B6::19501:A6507;968?6851C 3;63 5035 501 27851B47C3817A: 3?C11B185 B3CD19 3: FG3:8754C7E19<=5014;36856>>:017AC5>AC501C 01;95035FG3:A818>7C213<;1>7CG3857>C1?6:5C35678 & 8 34413; 501 6C:5 441;;351 7AC5 C1E1C:19 501C63;7AC5.:@A9?B185389912C119501:A65>7C:4126>62 41C>7CB3821013441;;3517AC501;95035F969875 C1HA6C1 C1?6:5C35678 389 278:565A519 3 E3;69 389 18>7C213<;13?C11B18557C1)278E1=53;:7C1;619013E6;= 7850139B6::678:1;6265199AC68?5012C7::)1F3B68356787> *G01C1680132D87G;19?1906::6?835AC1:78F , 01:196E1C?185>68968?:03E1?6E18C6:157501 4C1:185:1278934413; % *06;1 39B65568? 501 34413; 506: 7AC5 >C3B19 501>7;;7G68?:A<:538563;HA1:5678:7>;3G - 6 - ! " # # $ %&' $ ( "! + 13C819 1867C 7A8:1; >7C 501 3441;;385 39E1C568?57501:A<:538563;HA1:5678:7>;3G>C3B1935501 56B17>39B6::678G7A;9:A<B655035501:A653:4;13919 4C72119:785014;36856>>:.7G8E1C:6785035501:3;19119 G3: 78;= 3 :12AC65= >7C 3 0389 ;738 C3G68? :4126>62 3551856785743C3?C340:$389&7>5014;3685012785189: - 7 - 5035 501 5C38:325678 68 4650 389 :A<:53821 38:G1C: 501 91:2C6456787>3IB7C5?3?1<=2789656783;:3;1JG65068501 B13868?7>125678$% 27>501C38:>1C7>C741C5=25 %%(K 278:1HA185;= 501 27CC125 C1B19= ;3= 68 3 :A65 >7C C191B45678389875683:A65>7C:4126>6241C>7CB382156: 501C1>7C1 AC?19 5035 501 E1C= >C3B1 7> 501 :A65 6: B6:278216E19389501C1;61>2;36B196:;1?3;;=A85183<;1 ' 3CC=68? 501 3C?AB185 >AC501C 01 3::36;: 501 ?18A68181::38918>7C213<6;65=7>F227C968?5706B 501 4;36856>>: 03E1 >36;19 57 96:203C?1 501 <AC918 7> 4C7E68? 5035 3 27851B47C3817A: 3?C11B185 G3: 68 >325 1F12A519 <= 501 91>189385 78 501 :3B1 93= 3: 501 C1?6:51C19 :3;1 9119 1 47685: 7A5 5035 87 3221453<;1 1E691821 16501C 4C6B3C= 7C C1;63<;1 :127893C= 03: <118 399A219571:53<;6:05011F12A567827851B47C38165=389 <68968?203C3251C7>FK87C03E15014;36856>>:4C7E19 9A1 3551:535678 7C 26C2AB:53821: ;18968? 2C196<6;65= 57 65: 7C6?6885013<:18217>27?1854C77>F01:A<B65: - 8 - 238875<14C1::196857:1CE621573;51C7C96;A51501;1?3; 1>>1257>39A;=C1?6:51C19278E1=3821 F 1 3;:7 4;321: 278:691C3<;1 1B403:6: 78 125678 & 2 7> 501 4126>62 1;61> 25 +&! 389 501 27CC1:478968? F4;3835678 57 2785189 5035 501 4;36856>>: 03E1816501C4;13919G650C1HA6:651:4126>6265=87C4C7E19 278568A7A: C139681:: 389 G6;;68?81:: 57 41C>7CB 5016C C1264C723; 7<;6?35678: 01 4;13968?: 01 :A<B65: 3C1 :D1;153;K 501 1E691821 35 <1:5 6: 41C>A8257C=K 389 501 6C:5 441;;351 7AC5 03: >36;19 57 A891C53D1 501 B389357C= :2CA568= 7> 501 4;36856>>:. C139681:: 389 G6;;68?81:: >C7B 501 9351 7> 501 2785C325 56;; 501 >6;68? 7> 501 :A65 389 501C13>51C 8 506: 27A85 3;781 01 :A<B65: 501912C11>7C:4126>6241C>7CB38216:E6563519 ( 1C 2785C3 ;13C819 27A8:1; >7C 501 4;36856>>: :A447C5: 501 @A9?B185 389 912C11 7> 501 6C:5 441;;351 7AC5 1 :A<B65: 5035 78 501 39B65519 >325: 78;= 3 47C56787>50107;968?(32C1:7A57>!32C1:( ?A853:G3: - 9 - 278E1=19A891CF389:6BA;53817A:;=50191>189385 1F12A519 F 3?C1168? 57 C1)278E1= 501 E1C= 4C741C5= A478 C143=B185 7> 501 0389 ;738 7> :%$''') 227C968?5706BF6:327851B47C3817A:3?C11B185 7> C1)278E1=3821 C127C968? 501 5CA1 835AC1 7> 501 3CC38?1B185K65969875C1HA6C1C1?6:5C3567838903:<118 9A;= 4C7E19 50C7A?0 39B6::678: 1;626519 >C7B *) 68 2C7::)1F3B6835678 1 >AC501C 2785189: 5035 5014;36856>>: 03E1 278:6:5185;= 3::1C519 389 91B78:5C3519 5016C C139681::57C143=5013B7A8538938=;34:1:355C6<A519 57501B3C1816501C<7C817A5<=501C127C987C:A>>626185 57918=381HA653<;1912C1168501>325:7>50123:1 +,-+,. , /01/23,2+34 506/2+, 437 /'+( 2 '+++( ! 1>7C1 4C7211968? 57 1E3;A351 501 C6E3; :A<B6::678: 389 501 >68968?: C127C919 <= 501 7AC5: <1;7G 506: 7AC5 911B: 65 344C74C6351 57 C14C79A21 501 C1;1E385741C356E147C56787>F3:501278:5CA256787> 506: 972AB185 <13C: 96C125;= 78 6 501 203C3251C 7> 501 - 10 - A891C;=68? 5C38:325678K 66 501 8121::65= 7C 7501CG6:1 7> C1?6:5C35678K389 6665014;36856>>:.18565;1B185573912C11 >7C :4126>62 41C>7CB3821 01 B351C63; 47C5678 7> F C139:50A: !"# $ %& '( )*+ ,%-. /0 $ %& %0 1 & 23 & '& 4$ %& , 5+ , %6 78 '9 -: ' : %& ),% ;< =% ' 4$ 5+ )9 ;0 ;% ! =% ' '>? @ 5+ %0A , 7(@ B&? ( /C %8 )D E '?F %6 . GH, 5+ , BBC < % B0 ( -: 7(@ $%0? ' I - 11 - BBC < % B0C@J, K %LH M '& NO @% 01?7E1C868?4C68264;1:C1?3C968?B7C5?3?1<= 2789656783; :3;1 E6:)L)E6: :3;1 G650 3 278965678 57 C1) 4AC203:1501>7;;7G68?@A9?B185:G7A;9<1C1;1E385 6 7C5?3?1 <= 2789656783; :3;1 E: :3;1 G650327896567857C1)4AC203:1 01 78.<;1 A4C1B1 7AC5 03: C1413519;= :15 7A5 501 51:5: 57 96:568?A6:0 3 B7C5?3?1<=2789656783;:3;1>C7B3:3;1G6503 27896567857C1)4AC203:1 3 G018 501 278965678 >7C C15C38:>1C 6: 1B<79619 68 501 E1C= 68:5CAB185 5035 1>>125: 7C 4AC47C5: 57 1>>125 501 :3;1 501 5C38:325678 >3;;: G65068125678$% 2K<A56>501C13C1 5G7 :143C351 972AB185: 501 4C1:AB45678 ;138: 3?368:5 3 B7C5?3?1 - 12 - 389 68 >3E7AC 7> 38 7A5C6?05 :3;1 G650 3 B1C1 27E18385 57 C1)4AC203:1 :A<@125 3;G3=: 57 501 43C561:. 5CA1 685185678 ?3501C19 >C7B 501 972AB185 : 389 35518938526C2AB:53821: < !"#$ % & '( )* +,,- . / C1651C3519 5035 501 >7CB 6: 875 9126:6E1K 501 7AC5 BA:5 ?3501C 501 685185678 7> 501 43C561:MG01501C 501C1 G3: 3 :A<:6:568? 91<57C)2C19657C C1;35678:064 3895015C38:>1CG3:685189193::12AC65= B7C5?3?1 7C G01501C 65 G3: 3 :3;1 G650 38 68914189185 27E18385 57 C1) 4AC203:1 2 0$( $ 1( +2) - ' $ 3)" +- . 501 7AC5 1B403:6:19 501 2185C3;65= 7> 685185678 389 :ACC7A8968? 26C2AB:53821: 68 344;=68?125678$% 2 9 0" *4*" +.55,-/ .. 2;13C;=96:568?A6:01: 501 5G7 2351?7C61:M683B7C5?3?1<=2789656783; - 13 - :3;150191<5:A<:6:5:3895015C38:>1C6: <= G3= 7> :12AC65=K 68 3 :3;1 G650 3 278965678 57 C1)4AC203:1 565;1 43::1: 3<:7;A51;= ;13E68? 501 E1897C 78;= 3 2785C325A3;C6?0557:11DC1)278E1=3821 01 4C7E6:7 57 125678 $% 2 B3D1: 65 1F4;6265 5035 A8;1:: 501 278965678 6: 1B<79619 68 501 :3B1 :3;1 9119 501 5C38:325678 G6;; 875 <1 5C13519 3: 3 B7C5?3?1<=2789656783;:3;1 $ 8501;6?057>5014C68264;1:8756219:A4C3501 >7;;7G68? 278:7;693519 4C747:65678: 1B1C?1 >C7B 501 @AC6:4CA918217>50178.<;1A4C1B17AC57850196E691 <15G118 3 IB7C5?3?1 <= 2789656783; :3;1J A891C 125678 $% 27>501C38:>1C7>C741C5=25%%(389387A5C6?05 :3;127A4;19G650327E1838557C1)4AC203:1 & 01 5CA1 203C3251C 7> 501 5C38:325678 5AC8: 78 50143C561:. 685185678 57 <1 ?3501C19>C7B 501 :A<:53821 7>5013CC38?1B185501;38?A3?17>50168:5CAB185:389 501 355189385 26C2AB:53821:K 87B182;35AC1 6: 875 9151CB68356E1 - 14 - , *01C1501278965678>7CC15C38:>1C6:1B<79619 68 501 :3B1 68:5CAB185 5035 7:518:6<;= 278E1=: 565;1 501 5C38:3256784C6B3>3261355C325:125678$% 278E1C:1;= G01C1501C13C15G7:143C35168:5CAB185:3:3;19119389 38 68914189185 3?C11B185 >7C C1)4AC203:1 1E18 6> 1F12A51927851B47C3817A:;=5014C1:AB456786::5C78?;= 3?368:53B7C5?3?138968>3E7AC7>387A5C6?05:3;1G6503 41C:783; C6?05 7> C14AC203:1 A8;1:: 278E68268? 1E691821 :07G: 501 278E1=3821 G3: 68518919 3: :12AC65= >7C 3 :A<:6:568?91<5 % 014C7E6:7B389351:503535C38:325678238875 <1 5C13519 3: 3 B7C5?3?1 <= 2789656783; :3;1 A8;1:: 501 278965678 >7C C1278E1=3821 6: 6827C47C3519 68 501 E1C= 972AB18550354AC47C5:571>>125501:3;1011F6:518217> 5G7:143C351GC6568?::A<:538563;;=81?356E1:5015017C=7> B7C5?3?1 + 012C65623;51:56:G01501C47:5)278E1=38213 91<5 :A<:6:5: 389 501 :3;1 6: 68 5CA50 3 :12AC65=K 6> :7 - 15 - C191B45678 6: 501 :535A57C= 68269185 > 501 5C38:>1C 6: 3<:7;A51389501E1897CC15368:78;=3;6B65192785C325A3; 745678 57 C1)4AC203:1 G65068 56B1 65 6: 3 :3;1 G650 3 27896567857C1)4AC203:1:01;9<=50178/<;1A4C1B1 7AC5 68 !"#$6" ") & ' 389 0"6" ") & ' (' 3257C::A203:;7G278:691C35678:6BA;53817A: <7CC7G68?7C501E1897C.:>6838263;96>>62A;5=G6507A5B7C1 97 875 278E1C5 38 7A5C6?05 :3;1 6857 3 B7C5?3?1 68 501 3<:18217>91B78:5C3<;1685185575C135501278E1=38213: :12AC65= : 01;9 <= 501 78/<;1 A4C1B1 7AC5 68 0$($1(6"")& ' ( 01 78.<;1 A4C1B1 7AC5 68 7 !! 78&4"$ +.5.5- 5 03: 278:6:5185;= 344;619 501 3<7E1 51:5: 1B403:6N68? 5035 03C9:0642388757E1CC691685185678 (( AC868? 57 501 >325: 35 0389 501 B351C63; >135AC1: 3C1 ;3C?1;= A82785C7E1C519 01 91>189385 03: - 16 - 4C79A219 501 7C6?683; C1?6:51C19 :3;1 9119 93519 &'&(''! F 278E1=68? ( 32C1: 7A5 7> 3 5753; 07;968? 7> ! 32C1: ( ?A853: 01 4;36856>>: C1;= 78 3 :143C351 27851B47C3817A: GC6568? F:53519 5703E1 <118 1F12A519 78 501 :3B1 93= G01C1<= 501 91>189385 3?C119 57 C1)278E1= 501 E1C= ;389 A478 C143=B185 7> :%$''') 01 C63; 7AC5 A891C577D 38 1;3<7C351 3::1::B185 7> 7C3; 1E691821 389 87568? 5035 501 :A447C568? G6581::1: 969 875 3>>6CB 1F12A5678 <= 501 91>189385 2782;A919 5035 F G3: 875 4C7E19 389 68 38=1E185G3:A818>7C213<;1>7CG3857>C1?6:5C35678 (! 7G1E1C5011E691821<13C:32CA263;>135AC1 68 2C7::)1F3B6835678 G018 278>C78519 G650 F 501 91>189385 *) 39B65519 06: :6?835AC1 78 501 972AB185 A20 38 39B6::678 ?71: 57 501 C775 7> 3A507C:0641F12A5678 389 23CC61: :A<:538563; 4C7<356E1 E3;A1K 35 501 E1C= ;13:5 65 :06>5: 501 1E6918563C= <AC918 7857 501 1F12A5385 57 1F4;368 501 26C2AB:53821: 7C 57 6B41320501972AB185.:;1?3;1>>125 - 17 - ( 6E185012185C3;65=7>506:3:412557 64C77>7> 1F12A5678389 665014C741C;1?3;203C3251C6N356787>501 5C38:325678 A891C 501 :155;19 4C68264;1: 65 6: 3447:651 57 C14C79A21 501 4C126:1 47C5678 7> *).: 39B6::678 3: C127C919<=501C63;7AC501C1;1E3851F5C325C139:3: >7;;7G: = @ =P, QH '9 &9 R (>? 7(@ , N ' ( N 5&S , '9 $T >* NB 5&S ; K >JA K (> R (>? ' 7JB, N ' ( 7J 5S '9 $T >* NB RJ 5S; K >JE 5S U CL, B& N BB K 8 =@8, 5S,B :VB BB >?8, 5S, / = UW > X )0 J N B&*%&9 B* Y@9 X )0 J BB% N B&*%Z>?@9( K N B&*%0( %8,[ & ' - 18 - ($ 478 3 23C1>A; C13968? 7> 501 39B6::678: 1;626519685012C7::)1F3B68356787>*)506:7AC56:7> 501 278:691C19 E61G 5035 501 C63; 7AC5 03: 2;13C;= B6:96C12519 65:1;> 68 344C1263568? 501 1E691821 C1;3568? 57 501 4C77> 7> F 01 51:56B78= 7> *) 2785368: 2351?7C623;389A81HA6E723;39B6::678:32D87G;19?68?06: :6?835AC17850127851B47C3817A:972AB185F01:1 39B6::678: ?7 57 501 E1C= C775 7> 1F12A5678 389 3A501856265= 7> 501 972AB185 01 6C:5 441;;351 7AC5 03: C6?05;= >72A:19 78 501:1 2CA263; 39B6::678: 389 65: >68968?: 78 501 4C77> 7> F :5389 >6CB;= :A447C519 <= 5011E6918563C=C127C901C63;7AC5785017501C0389 34413C: 57 03E1 7E1C;77D19 501 4C7<356E1 E3;A1 7> 501:1 :5351B185:38903:278:1HA185;=B6:C1395011E69182178 506:B351C63;3:4125 (& 821 501 1F12A5678 7> F :5389: :A<:538563519 50C7A?0 501 91>189385.: 7G8 39B6::678: 501 ;1?3; 278:1HA1821: BA:5 <1 3::1::19 68 501 ;6?05 7> 501 :155;19 4C68264;1: ;369 97G8 <= 501 78.<;1 A4C1B1 - 19 - 7AC5 68 & ' 389 501 1F4C1:: B389351 7> 501 4C7E6:7 57 125678 $% 2 7> 501 C38:>1C7>C741C5=2585014C1:18523:1501278965678 C1;3568? 57C1)5C38:>1C 7>501 4C741C5= 6: 8756827C47C3519 68 501 C1?6:51C19 :3;1 9119 F <A5 6: :15 7A5 68 38 1856C1;= :143C351 68:5CAB185 83B1;= F 8 :A20 26C2AB:53821: 501 :535A57C= 4C1:AB45678 6: 9126:6E1;= 3?368:5 501 5C38:325678 <168? 5C13519 3: 3 B7C5?3?1 <= 2789656783; :3;1 8;1:: 501 91>189385 6: 3<;1 57 91B78:5C351 16501C >C7B 501 ;38?A3?1 7> 501 972AB185: 7C 501 :ACC7A8968? 26C2AB:53821: 5035 501 C13; 685185678 7>50143C561:G3:575C135501278E1=38213:3:12AC65=>7C C143=B1857>391<55015C38:325678BA:5<1278:5CA193: 387A5C6?05:3;13227B438619<=32785C325A3;27E1838557 C1)278E1= 7 :A20 27B41;;68? 1E691821 03: <118 4;3219 78C127C9<=50191>189385 (, 01 C63; 7AC5 34413C: 57 03E1 <118 278:691C3<;=68>;A18219<=5014;36856>>:.3::1C56785035501 1F12A56787>FG3:B756E3519<=5018119>7C30389 - 20 - ;738 389 <= 501 27851B47C38165= 7> F 7G1E1C 65 >36;19 57 A891C53D1 501 2C65623; 18HA6C= B3893519 <= 501 78.<;1 A4C1B1 7AC5 83B1;= 38 1F3B6835678 7> 501 685185678 7> 501 43C561: 96:21C819 >C7B 501 :A<:53821 7> 501 972AB185: 501 :535A57C= >C3B1G7CD 389 501 835AC1 7> 501 C6?05: 2C13519 01 6C:5 441;;351 7AC5 68 2785C3:5 03: 27CC125;= 344C1263519 5035 G01C1 5G7 :143C351 972AB185: 3C1 1F12A519 78 501 :3B1 93= 781 1>>12568? 3 278E1=3821 389 501 7501C 278536868? 3 27E18385 >7C C1)278E1=3821 501 87CB3; 68>1C1821 6: 5035 50143C561:685189193:3;1G6503C6?0557C14AC203:1389 8753B7C5?3?1<=2789656783; :3;1 06: 344C7320 7> 501 441;;351 7AC5 6: 68 27B4;151 03CB78= G650 501 <68968? 4C1219185: (% 01 C63; 7AC5 03: 27BB65519 =15 387501C :1C67A: 1CC7C 68 07;968? 5035 F C1HA6C19 27B4A;:7C= C1?6:5C35678F971:8754AC47C5572C13511F568?A6:0 3::6?8 7C ;6B65 38= C6?05 565;1 7C 6851C1:5 68 6BB7E3<;1 4C741C5=684C31:18565B1C1;=6827C47C351:34C7B6:178 - 21 - 50143C57>50191>18938557C1)278E1=5014C741C5=A478 C1216457>501:564A;3519278:691C35678A203972AB1856: 3B1C13?C11B18557C1278E1=389971:875>3;;G65068501 3B<65 7> 125678 , < 7> 501 1?6:5C35678 25 78:1HA185;= 125678 + 7> 501 1?6:5C35678 25 G0620 C1:5C625: 501 A:1 7> A8C1?6:51C19 972AB185: 3>>12568? 6BB7E3<;1 4C741C5= 03: 87 344;6235678 57 3 972AB185 :A20 3: F 01 C63; 7AC5.: E61G 5035 F 6: 681>>1256E1 >7C G385 7> C1?6:5C35678 6: 501C1>7C1 A8:A:53683<;168;3G (+ 8 501 ;6?05 7> 501 :A<:538563; HA1:5678: 7> ;3G >C3B19<=506:7AC5501;1?3;47:65678B3=<1:A226825;= :ABB3C6N19 50A: 3 27851B47C3817A: 3?C11B185 57 C1) 278E1= G018 1F12A519 :143C351;= >C7B 501 :3;1 9119 278:565A51: 3 2785C325 5035 6: :4126>623;;= 18>7C213<;1 :A<@12557501A:A3;C1HA6C1B185:A891C5014126>62 1;61> 25 F <168? :A20 3 2785C325 971: 875 C1HA6C1 C1?6:5C35678 389 6: 39B6::6<;1 68 1E6918218 E61G 7> 501 2;13C 389 A83B<6?A7A: 39B6::678: 7> *) - 22 - 32D87G;19?68? 06: :6?835AC1 78 F 501 1F12A5678 7> F :5389: 9A;= 4C7E19 821 1F12A5678 6: 1:53<;6:019 501<AC918:06>5:5750191>18938557C1<A55012785185:7C 57 1:53<;6:0 5035 501 972AB185 971: 875 C1>;125 501 5CA1 685185678 7> 501 43C561: 7 :A20 C1<A553; 03: <118 >7C5027B68? : 501 4;36856>>: 03E1 >7A8919 5016C 2;36B :HA3C1;= 78 F 389 03E1 4C7E19 501 :3B1 501 5C38:32567823887568;3G<1278:5CA193:3B7C5?3?1<= 2789656783;:3;1014;36856>>:.C1B19=6:501C1>7C1C6?05;= 781 7> :4126>62 41C>7CB3821 7> 501 C1)278E1=3821 27E18385016C:5441;;3517AC503:27CC125;=912C119 501:A6538965:@A9?B185G3CC385:3>>6CB35678 !' 227C968?;= :A<:538563; HA1:5678: 7> ;3G 6 57 6663C138:G1C196850199*$ ) +,-+,.,/01/23,2+34506/2+,437'+8( ! 01 ;13C819 27A8:1; >7C 501 4;36856>>: >AC501C :A<B65: 5035 501 20C787;7?= 7> 1E185: A8B6:53D3<;= 91B78:5C351: 501 4;36856>>:. <783 >691 C139681:: 389 - 23 - G6;;68?81::5741C>7CB5016C43C57>5012785C32501;1?3; 875621G3:6::A1978(,' (''&389501:A65>7C:4126>62 41C>7CB3821G3: 4C7B45;=68:565A51978$'&(''&G1;; G65068 3 C13:783<;1 56B1 8 5C38:325678: 7> 506: 835AC1 G01C1 3 :3;1 9119 6: 27A4;19 G650 3 27851B47C3817A: 3?C11B185 57 C1)278E1= 501 :5C625 C6?7AC: 7> 278568A7A: C139681::389G6;;68?81::3:27851B4;3519A891C125678 & 2 7> 501 4126>62 1;61> 25 238875 <1 B12038623;;= 344;6190191>18938503:3;;3;78?<1186847::1::6787> 501 :A65;38938903: <11818@7=68? 501A:A>CA25 G6507A5 3227A8568? >7C 501 :3B1 389 501C1>7C1 87 4C1@A9621 G035:71E1C 6: 23A:19 57 06B <= 501 4;36856>>:. 3551B45 57 18>7C21 501 5CA1 <3C?368 821 501 4;36856>>: 32568? 78 F 6::A19 3 875621 1F4C1::68? 5016C A81HA6E723; G6;;68?81:: 57 C143= 501 3B7A85 389 :7A?05 C1) 278E1=3821501C1HA6C1B1857>C139681::389G6;;68?81:: :5779 :A<:538563;;= :356:>619 68 501 >325: 7> 501 23:1 78:1HA185;= 501 >68968? 7> 501 C63; 7AC5 5035 501 4;36856>>: >36;19 57 4C7E1 C139681:: 389 G6;;68?81:: 6: - 24 - 41CE1C:1 <168? 2785C3C= 57 501 B351C63; 78 C127C9 389 6?87C68? 501 E1C= 835AC1 7> 501 A891C;=68? 5C38:325678 A<:538563; HA1:5678 7> ;3G 7 6E 6: 38:G1C19 68 99*$ ) 227C968?;=50134413;6:96:B6::19 -9 '" "( % 6:57!;7