Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92372 (KAR)
SMT. SUNANDA W/O ALTE KASILING SULTANPUR AND ORS v. SRI. RAMACHANDRA S/O SHIVALINGAPPA AND ANR
RSA/7366/2013 · 2025-12-12
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92372 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92372 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! %% &'$( )
! "#"
! "#"
$
! "#"
%
% % %
&
"#" '
(% %
)
* %
%
)
+
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
(,+
-
% . (/+
"- % . (0+
"
% . (1+ %
" % . (2+
% . ! % % (+ . '
( %
* %
+
)
) ! "
)
) % ! ! )! $
$
)
) % ! (! %
+ !)
- 3 -
)
)
! %
3! $!
42 0,5678921 ,552,: 7; <7:21 /= 642 5:,7967<<; >?2;678979@ 642 A?1@B296 ,91 120C22 C2912C21 /= 642 552::,62 8?C6 79 8" D42C2 642 ,552,: 7; ,::8D21,91642120C228<642C7,:8?C67;C2E2C;21,91 089;2>?296:=;?767;17;B7;;2189:=89642@C8?9164,6642 /8?91,C72; 8< 642 ;?76 :,91 /2,C79@ =8 $ ,C2 986 <?C97;421/=6425:,7967<<;42;,71A?1@B296,91120C22 8< 642 552::,62 8?C6 7; 98D ?912C 04,::29@2 ,6 642 79;6,9028<6425:,7967<<; )8C 642 ;,F2 8< 089E2972902 642 5,C672; ,C2 C2<2CC2168,;52C6427CC,9F/2<8C2642C7,:8?C6 48?@4642<,B7:=6C22D,;9865C81?021/2<8C2 642 C7,: 8?C6 647; 8?C6 4,E79@ 2G629;7E2:= 42,C1 642 B,662C0,::21?589642:2,C92108?9;2:<8C6425:,7967<<;68 <?C97;4 <,B7:= 6C22 ,; 76 D8?:1 /2 E2C= 0C?07,: 68 - 4 - ?912C;6,91 642 08C2 17;5?62 /26D229 642 5,C672; 42 <,B7:= 6C22 <?C97;421 ,:89@ D764 642 B2B8 7; 642C2<8C2 E2C= 0C?07,: ,91 C2:2E,96 642 ;,B2 7; 2G6C,0621 D4704 C2,1;,;?912C C858;76?;(,B2;986F98D9+ 47E,:79@,55,(1721+,9B,964C,=,(1721+4,91C,;4,(1721+ ,B04,91C, (1721+ H?C?/,7(,+ 47E,;4,C9,55,,GB,9(1721+ !,@,12E7D7<2 47E,9,91?C?;4,96:79@4,91C,F,:,,;7:79@(1721+ ?9,91,D7<2 4476C,:2F4,2@4, ,A,;42F4,C 711?(/+?;:,/,7(0+47E,9,91(1+?B,9@,:,(2+ - 5 - 42 5:,7967<<; ,C2 642 D718D ,91 6D8 B798C 1,?@462C; 8< :,62 ,;7:79@ C25C2;29679@ 642 /C,904 8< ,9B,964C,=, 42 12<291,96; C25C2;296 642 /C,904 8< 47E,:79@,55, :648?@4 642 9,B2 8< 642 8C7@79,: 5C858;76?; 7; 986 6C,02,/:2 <C8B 642 C208C1; 642 <,B7:= 6C22 ?92>?7E80,::= ;48D; 64,6 47E,:79@,55, ,9B,964C,=, ,91 4,91C,;4, D2C2 <?:: /C8642C; :,7B79@ 64C8?@4 6427C ,902;68C ,9B,964C,=, 642 5:,7967<<;79;676?621 8 $ ;22F79@,120:,C,6789 ,9179A?90678979C2;52068<642;?765C852C6= " 42 5:,7967<<;I 0,;2 7; 64,6 47E,;4,C,9,55, 6427C<,642C79:,D2<<20621,5,C6767898<642A8796<,B7:= 5C852C672; ,91 17;6C7/?621 642 :,91; ,B89@ 76; B2B/2C; 42 4?;/,91 8< 5:,7967<< 8 D48 7; ,:;8 642 <,642C 8< 5:,7967<<8;,914,117215C78C68642;,715,C676789 912C642C2@7;62C21,C676789 221642JI;0421?:2:,91; D2C2,::86621686425:,7967<<;A8796:=,91642=D2C25?679 58;;2;;789 5?C;?,96 68 ;?04 ,::86B296 42 5:,7967<<; 0896291 64,6 642 12<291,96; 4,E2 98 B,992C 8< C7@46 - 6 - 676:2 8C 7962C2;6 8E2C 642 ;?76 :,91 /2,C79@ =8 $ B2,;?C79@ " ,0C2; $ @?96,; 008C179@ 68 642B 12<291,9687;6428D92C8<=8 $B2,;?C79@$ ,0C2;"@?96,;D47047;17;67906<C8B642;?76:,91 - 42 5C2;296 ;?76 0,B2 68 /2 <7:21 ,::2@79@ 64,6 642 12<291,96; 7::2@,::= 7962C<2C21 D764 642 5:,7967<<;I 58;;2;;789,91<,:;2:=,;;2C621676:28E2C642;?765C852C6= 589 ;2CE702 8< ;?BB89; 642 12<291,96; 2962C21,552,C,902,91<7:21,DC76629;6,62B296129=79@ 642 5:,7967<<;I ,;;2C6789; 42= ;5207<70,::= 17;5?621 642 5:,7967<<;I0:,7B64,6=8 $8D921/=64212<291,96; :72; 68 642 ;8?64 8< 642 ;?76 :,91 42 12<291,96; ,:;8 129721 ,9= 7962C<2C2902 8C 64C2,6 8< 17;58;;2;;789 089629179@79;62,164,66427C:,91:72;6864298C648<642 5:,7967<<;I 5C852C6= 42= ,::2@21 64,6 642 ;?76 7; , B,:, <712,662B56/=6425:,7967<<;68290C8,04?589<2C67:2:,91 /2:89@79@68 64212<291,96; 42=<?C642C ;?/B7662164,6 980,?;28<,067892G7;621<8C<7:79@642;?76 - 7 - # 9 642 /,;7; 8< 642 C7E,: 5:2,179@; 642 C7,: 8?C6<C,B216429202;;,C=7;;?2;,9117C206216425,C672; 68,11?022E712902 $ 589 089;712C79@ 642 8C,: ,91 180?B296,C= 2E712902642C7,:8?C6,9;D2C217;;?28;6879642 ,<<7CB,67E2 9 7;;?2 8 76 42:1 64,6 642 5:,7967<<; 4,1 2;6,/:7;421 6427C 676:2 68 642 ;?76 ;0421?:2 5C852C6= 9 7;;?2 8 76 42:1 64,6 642 5:,7967<<; 4,1 5C8E21 7962C<2C2902/=64212<291,96;89;2>?296:=642;?76D,; 120C221120:,C79@6425:,7967<<;68/2642,/;8:?628D92C; 8<642;?76:,91 @@C72E2112<291,968;,915C2<2CC21,9 ,552,:/2<8C2642)7C;6 552::,628?C6 42 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6 ,::8D21 642 ,552,: 48:179@64,66425:,7967<<;<,7:21682;6,/:7;4642/8?91,C72; 8<=8 $ :648?@46425:,79612;0C7/21642;?76:,91 ,;B2,;?C79@",0C2;$@?96,;D764;5207<70/8?91,C72; 642 552::,62 8?C6 98621 64,6 642 C2@7;62C21
,C676789 - 8 - 221171986B296789/8?91,C72;27642C68642;?76:,918C 68 ,98642C 5C852C6= =8 B2,;?C79@ - ,0C2; $ @?96,;,:;8,::86621686425:,7967<<;I/C,9048:2:=89647; @C8?91K64,6 642 /8?91,C72; D2C2 986 ;5207<721 79 642 ,C676789 221K642 552::,62 8?C6 C2E2C;21 642 C7,: 8?C6I;A?1@B296,9117;B7;;21642;?76 42;2089<:70679@<79179@;4,E2/229,;;,7:2179 6425C2;296,552,:=8C12C1,621 - 647;8?C6 ,1B76621642,552,:89642<8::8D79@;?/;6,967,:>?2;6789; 8<:,D ! " # $ %&
*+,*+-. 2<8C2 2G,B7979@ 642 C7E,: 0896296789; 76 7; 9202;;,C=<8C647;8?C668089;712C02C6,790C?07,:,;5206;
- 9 -
68 1262CB792 D42642C 642 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6 D47:2 <?90678979@ ,; 642 <79,: <,06<79179@ ,?648C76= 4,; B7;,55C207,6216428C,:,91180?B296,C=2E712902:21/= 6425:,7967<<;6,:;8/208B2;2;;2967,:68,;;2;;D42642C 642 <79179@; C208C121 /= 642 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6 ,C2 79 089<8CB76= D764 642 C2>?7C2B296;?912C?:2; ,91 8<
C12C & 8< 642 812 8< 7E7: C8021?C2 9 647; 08962G6C2<2C2902B?;6/2B,1268G"9,B2:=)8CB 8 7;;?21 /= 642 ?CE2= ?648C7672; )8CB 8 7; , B,62C7,: 180?B296 2E7129079@ 64,6 642 :,91; 42:1 /= 642 5:,7967<<;I ,902;68C ,91 648;2 42:1 /= 642 12<291,96;I ,902;68C D2C2 ;?/A20621 68 ;?/17E7;789 ,91 64,6 642 58177;;,5C8022179@;4,E2,66,7921<79,:76=48?@4642 12<291,96; ;8?@46 68 >?2;6789 642;2 5C8022179@; /= C2:=79@89G; ,91 D470479170,6264,66427;;, 5C8022179@;D2C204,::29@2198<?C642CC2/?66,:2E712902 4,;/2295C81?02168;48D64,6642;,715C8022179@;D2C2 2E2C ;26 ,;712 8C 7962C<2C21 D764 79 ,008C1,902 D764 :,D
- 10 -
)8CB 8 642C2<8C2 ,;;?B2; ;7@97<70,902 ,91 D,CC,96; 2G6C,06789D47047;C25C81?021/2:8D
G"
!" ! #$%$&'
(2B54,;7;;?55:721+
47;8?C6,:;8122B;76<76680?::8?6642817 755,97 B,5 8< =8 $ B,CF21 ,; G D4704 ! ( )*
+ ( ,*-. + / )01 23
456*7(-8! 9 +6-:;/: <-=: >: 9 +6-:;/: >? : *7(-8! 9 +6-:;/: ,*-. + 3=: $< 23 + @
&
ABCD&E
ABCD&E
FG
AHIDDE
+8
D
A&CBE
A&JBE
AKI'BE
L1<M
K$
A&CDE
A&CDE
AKI'BE
N O- P
K
AKQCDBE
AKQCDBE
AKI'DE
- 11 -
79170,62; 64,6 =8 $ 7; 17E7121 7968 64C22 5,C6; 42 ;,B27;2G6C,0621D47047;,;?912C
<-RS<M8TG5
"
U! !
&;$D$K
A
" 9 ,1176789 68 )8CB 8 642 817L755,97 B,5 5:,021 89 C208C1 <?C642C 0:,C7<72; 642 6858@C,5470,: 12:792,6789 8< 642 :,91; 42:1 /= 642 5:,7967<<; ,91 642 12<291,96; 429 642;2 180?B296; ,C2 ,55C207,621 79 089A?906789D764642,1B7;;789;2:7076211?C79@6420C8;;
2G,B79,6789 8< 642 <,06?,: 58;76789 08902C979@ 642 C2:,67E2 :80,6789 8< 642 C2;52067E2 5C852C672; /208B2;
- 12 -
7917;5?6,/:2 42 0C8;;2G,B79,6789 8< 0896,79; B,62C7,:,1B7;;789;64,6@868642C8868<6420896C8E2C;= ,91;7@97<70,96:=;?558C66425:,7967<<;I0,;2
-
4,; 0,62@8C70,::= ,1B76621 64,6 8?6 8< =8 $ 642 12<291,96;I@C,91<,642C D,; ,::86621 :,91 B2,;?C79@ $ ,0C2;
" @?96,; D4704 7; ,;;7@921 =8 $ 8C2 7B58C6,96:=
K642 ;20891 12<291,96K4,; ,1B76621 79 ?92>?7E80,: 62CB; 64,6 =8 $8D921/=64212<291,96;7;;76?,62189642 ;8?642C9;7128<6425:,7967<<;I:,9147;,1B7;;7897;986 B2C2:= 79071296,: /?6 7; 1262CB79,67E2 79 2;6,/:7;479@ 642 08CC206 8C7296,6789 ,91 /8?91,C72; 8< 642 :,91; 79 >?2;6789
42;2;6,62B296;D429C2,1D764)8CB8 ,91 642 817L755,97 B,5 0890:?;7E2:= 12B89;6C,6264,6 642 5:,7967<<;I :,91 /2,C79@ =8 $ B2,;?C79@ " ,0C2;$@?96,;7;:80,6216864298C648<64212<291,96;I 5C852C6=42;,71,1B7;;78917;B,96:2;642E2C=12<2902
- 13 -
;26 ?5 /= 642 12<291,96; /2<8C2 642 C7,: 8?C6 ,91 642 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6 64,6 6427C :,91 :72; 89 642 98C642C9 ;7128<642;?765C852C6=
# 7E29 642 1207;7E2 9,6?C2 8< 647; 62;67B89= 76 /208B2; 9202;;,C= <8C 647; 8?C6 68 2G6C,06 642 C2:2E,96 58C6789 8< 642 0C8;;2G,B79,6789 D4704 7; 0:2,C ?92>?7E80,: ,91 17C206:= 08CC8/8C,62; 642 5:,7967<<;I E2C;7894252C6792962G6C,067;C25C81?02142C2?912C
V $ $ $ +? 1W +-X Y +-X 7(-$ Y P < 8 <Z Y + - +-X 7(-$ [ 1 - ! $& ( ' <-R
$ 9 \ $ ] #^ + \ ! <-R
*@ Z(_#$\ `7(1-a [ 1- b )_#$ # `7( ?c8 #?G[,*-)$9\$#B$D$D( [ # ,*-.
P d `\ R0- 9 \ $ ] P # d ef .-R0 + # Q$$D ( [ + ) P d S60- 9 \ $ ] g # [ *0 *-8 <1-: hi 1 Y 170 \ $ ( [ - # +8j 8,*-Y+dkl0-O#X - 14 - .-R0-9\ $[P 1 ?c+-($ YP*Ni< 8< 1 #*@ Xk.R9\ $m $ 429 642 0C?07,: 180?B296,C= 2E712902 ,11?021/=6425:,7967<<;9,B2:=G"()8CB8 +,91 G (817755,97 B,5+ 7; ,55C207,621 ,:89@;712 642 0,62@8C70,: ,1B7;;789; B,12 /= 642 ;20891 12<291,96 2G,B7921,; 64208C217;5?62C2@,C179@642C2:,67E2 :80,67898<6425:,7967<<;I,9112<291,96;I5C852C672;;6,91; 0890:?;7E2:= C2;8:E21 42;2 B,62C7,:; D429 C2,1 68@2642C :2,E2 98 ;0852 <8C ,B/7@?76=* C,642C 642= 2;6,/:7;4D764,/;8:?620:,C76=642;5,67,:58;7678979@8<642 C2;52067E2:,91; 947;0C8;;2G,B79,6789642;2089112<291,96 4,; ?92>?7E80,::= ,1B76621 64,6 642 :,91 42:1 /= 642 5:,7967<<;I ,902;68C 9,B2:= =8 $ B2,;?C79@ " ,0C2; $ @?96,; (642 ;?76 5C852C6=+ :72; 89 642 98C642C9 ;712 8< 642 :,91 42:1 /= 642 12<291,96; /2,C79@ - 15 - =8 $ 47; ,1B7;;789 986 89:= 08CC8/8C,62; 642 5:,7967<<;I 180?B296,C= 2E712902 /?6 ,:;8 ?912CB792; 642 5C7B,C= 12<2902 ;26 ?5 /= 642 12<291,96; C2@,C179@ /8?91,C=8C7296,6789 902 642 @28@C,5470,: 58;76789 8< /864 5C852C672; 7; <7CB:= 2;6,/:7;421 64C8?@4 ?97B52,04,/:2 180?B296,C= 2E712902 ,91 0:2,C ,1B7;;789; 642 92G6 7;;?2 64,6 ,C7;2; <8C 089;712C,6789 7; D42642C 642 12<291,96; 4,E2 C,7;21 ,9= ;?/;6,967,: 8C 0C217/:2 04,::29@2686425:,7967<<;I676:28,11C2;;647;76/208B2; 9202;;,C= <8C 647; 8?C6 68 6?C9 68 642 5:2,179@; 5,C670?:,C:=642DC76629;6,62B296<7:21/=64212<291,96; ,C,@C,54 8< 642 DC76629 ;6,62B296 7; 8< ;7@97<70,96 C2:2E,902 ,; 76 ;26; 8?6 642 12<291,96;I 08C2 12<2902 C2@,C179@676:242;,715,C,@C,547;642C2<8C22G6C,0621 42C279/2:8D '( ) ( ) ) - 16 - *+%&,-% %" ., ) % + ) *+%&,-./ *0 + / / % .1 0,C2<?:C2,179@8<5,C,@C,548<642DC76629 ;6,62B296C2E2,:;64,664212<291,96;4,E2986;2C78?;:= 17;5?621 642 676:2 8< 642 5:,7967<<; 8E2C 642 ;?76 ;0421?:2 5C852C6=427C;8:2089629678952C6,79;68642:80,67898< 642 :,91 /2,C79@ =8 $ B2,;?C79@ " ,0C2; $ @?96,; D4704 642= ,;;2C6 :72; 68 642 ;8?64 8< 6427C 5C852C6= 89E2C;2:= 642 12<291,96; 0896291 64,6 12<291,96 8I; :,917; ;76?,621 68 64298C648< 642 ;?76 5C852C6= 47; 5:2,179@ 76;2:< 5C2;?558;2; ,9 7B5:7076 ,1B7;;789 8< 642 5:,7967<<;I 676:2 8E2C =8 $ 9 642 <,02 8< ;?04 5:2,179@; 642 C2E29?2 C208C1; 5C81?021 /= - 17 - 642 5:,7967<<;KG; ,91 K,;;?B2 C2:2E,902 42;2 ; 0:2,C:= 12B89;6C,62 64,6 642 :,91; 42:1 /= 642 5:,7967<<;I ,902;68C; /2,C , ;25,C,62 ,91 17;67906 ;?CE2= 9?B/2C =8 $ G 52C6,79; 68 642 5:,7967<<;I :,91D42C2,;GC2:,62;68=8 $B2,;?C79@$ ,0C2; " @?96,; ;6,9179@ 79 642 9,B2 8< 642 <7C;6 12<291,96 4?; 642 5:,7967<<;I 8D92C;475 8< =8 $ 7; 986 79 17;5?62* 642 89:= 0896C8E2C;= 52C6,79; 68 76; C2:,67E2:80,6789E7;ME7;64212<291,96;I:,91 4292G6>?2;678964,6,C7;2;<8C1262CB79,6789 7; D42642C 642 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6 4,; B7;C2,1 642 2E712902 89 C208C1 47; 8?C6I;
,9;D2C 7; ,9 2B54,670 =2;67;791221?9<8C6?9,6264,6642)7C;6 552::,628?C6 12;5762 /279@ 642 <79,: <,06<79179@ ,?648C76= 17E2C621 76; ,662967896852C7542C,:,;5206;C2:,679@68989B29678979@ 8< /8?91,C72; 79 642 C2@7;62C21,C676789 22179;62,18< ,55C207,679@64208@296,91C2:7,/:22E7129022;6,/:7;479@ 642 5:,7967<<;I 676:2 ,91 642 :80,6789 8< 642 ;?76 :,91 42 2G7;629028<08B5:26218175C8022179@;C2<:2062179G - 18 - ",91G0:2,C:=2;6,/:7;42;64,6642:,91;42:1/=642 5:,7967<<; ,91 642 12<291,96; ,C2 17;67906 ,91 2G0:?;7E2:= 12B,C0,621 42 5:,7967<<; ,C2 79 2G0:?;7E2 58;;2;;789 8< =8 $,9112<291,9687;6422G0:?;7E28D92C8< =8 $ 9 ;?04 07C0?B;6,902; 642 ,/;2902 8< /8?91,C=C2076,:;796427962C;2,C676789 221D,;D48::= 7BB,62C7,: 42180?B296,C=2E712902 C279<8C021/= 642 ,1B7;;789; 2:707621 <C8B 0890:?;7E2:= 5C8E2; 986 89:= 642 5:,7967<<;I 676:2 8E2C =8 $ /?6 ,:;8 76; :80,67898964298C642C9;7128<64212<291,96;I5C852C6= 47; <,06?,: 58;76789 2B2C@2; 986 B2C2:= <C8B 642 180?B296,C= 2E712902 /?6 7; <?C642C <8C67<721 /= 642 ?92>?7E80,: ,1B7;;789; B,12 /= 1?C79@ 0C8;; 2G,B79,6789 642 ;20891 12<291,96 4,; ,1B76621 D7648?6,B/7@?76=64,6642:,918D921/=64212<291,96; :72; 68 642 ;8?64 8< 642 5:,7967<<;I :,91 47; ,1B7;;789 ;6C7F2; ,6 642 E2C= <8?91,6789 8< 642 12<2902 5:2,121 79 642 DC76629 ;6,62B296 42 5:,7967<<; 4,E2 642C2/= ;?0022121 79 12B8:7;479@ 642 12<291,96;I E2C;789 - 19 - C2@,C179@ 642 :80,6789 8< 642 C2;52067E2 :,91; 42;2 0C?07,: ,;5206; 4,E2 /229 08B5:262:= 8E2C:88F21 /= 642 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6 D4704 79;62,1 <80?;21 89 B,662C; D48::=2G6C,928?;68642C2,:7;;?26;C2,;8979@C2<:206; , B7;17C206789 ,91 , <,7:?C2 68 ,55C207,62 B,62C7,: 2E7129025,C670?:,C:=8964208C2>?2;67898<D42642C642 5:,7967<<;I :,91 7; ;76?,621 68 642 98C64 8< 642 12<291,96;I 5C852C6= " 7902 642 12<291,96; 4,E2 986 ;2C78?;:= 17;5?621 642 5:,7967<<;I 676:2 8E2C 642 ;?76 :,91 642 )7C;6 552::,62 8?C6I; 79;7;62902 89 /8?91,C= 12;0C756789; 79 642C2@7;62C21,C676789 221D,;D48::=?9D,CC,9621,91 7CC2:2E,96 68 642 ,1A?170,6789 8< 642 5C2;296 17;5?62 42 7B5?@921 C2,;8979@ 986 89:= ;?<<2C; <C8B 52CE2C;76= /?6 ,:;8 C2<:206; , 0:2,C E78:,6789 8< 642 B,91,68C= C2>?7C2B296; ?912C?:2; ,91 8< C12C & 8< 642 D4704 8/:7@,62 642 ,552::,62 08?C6 68 79125291296:= ,;;2;; ,91 ,;;7@9 C2,;89; /,;21 89 642 2E712902 42 <79179@;C208C121/=642)7C;6 552::,628?C6,C27917C206 - 20 - 089<:706D764642,1B7;;789;2:707621<C8B64212<291,96;79 0C8;;2G,B79,6789 ,; D2:: ,; D764 642 0,62@8C70,: ,1B7;;7898<6425:,7967<<;I676:20896,7921795,C,@C,548< 642DC76629;6,62B296C25C81?021;?5C, - 48?@4 :2,C921 08?9;2: <8C 12<291,96 8 ;?/B7662164,6642,552,:0,9986/2,1A?170,62189B2C76; ?967: 986702 7; ;2CE21 ?589 C2;5891296 8(2+ L ?B,9@,:, 647; 8?C6 <791; 98 B2C76 79 642 ;,71 0896296789 42 :767@,6789 79767,621 /= 642 12<291,96; ,@,79;6
642 5:,7967<<; D,; 76;2:< ?9D,CC,9621 ,91 6427C 0891?06 64C8?@48?6 4,; /229 @C8;;:= ?9<,7C 2<291,96 8 4,; ,067E2:= 5,C67075,621 79 642 6C7,: 2962C21 642 D7692;; /8G ,91 ,11?021 C2/?66,: 2E712902 2 7; 642C2<8C2,9202;;,C=,91;?<<7072965,C6=686425C2;296 ,552,:8C28E2C,::8642C;7/:79@;8<12<291,968,; D2::,;642047:1C298<12<291,968,B,04,91C,4,E2 /229 1?:= ;2CE21 ,91 4,E2 048;29 986 68 08962;6 642 5C8022179@; 42 B2C2 <,06 64,6 C2;5891296 8(2+ 4,; 986 /229 ;2CE21 0,9986 /2 , @C8?91 68 7912<79762:= - 21 - 58;65892 642 ,1A?170,6789 2;5207,::= D429 2<<2067E2 C25C2;296,6789 8< 642 12<291,96; 7; ,:C2,1= 89 C208C1 008C179@:=642,552,:7;B,796,79,/:2,910,9/21207121 89B2C76; 9E72D8<642<8C2@879@17;0?;;789;?/;6,967,: >?2;67898<:,D87;,9;D2C217964248:179@ 64,6642)7C;6 552::,628?C62CC2179C2E2C;79@642D2:: C2,;8921 A?1@B296 ,91 120C22 8< 642 C7,: 8?C6 ?/;6,967,: >?2;6789 8< :,D 8 7; ,:;8 ,9;D2C21 79 642 ,;642)7C;6 552::,628?C64,;0:2,C:=B7;C2,1 ,91 B7;,55C207,621 642 2E712902 89 C208C1 5,C670?:,C:= G" ()8CB 8 + ,91 G (7;;, 817 ,5+ 89;2>?296:= ;?/;6,967,: >?2;6789 8< :,D 8 7; ,9;D2C2179642 48:179@64,66427962C<2C2902 /=642)7C;6 552::,628?C6D764642A?1@B2968<642C7,: 8?C6D,;D48::=?9D,CC,9621 # )8C 642 <8C2@879@ C2,;89; 647; 8?C6 5C80221; 685,;;642<8::8D79@ - 22 - 7 422@?:,C20891 552,:7; 77 42 A?1@B296 ,91 120C22 1,621 5,;;21/=C79075,:2978C7E7: !?1@2 ,91 ! ?:/,C@, 79 8" 7; 42C2/= C2E2C;21 89;2>?296:= 642 A?1@B296 ,91 120C22 1,621 $ 5,;;21 /= 642 C79075,: 7E7:!?1@2(!C 9+,91!),6?:/,C@, 79
8 $ ;6,91;C2;68C21 777
C,D120C22,008C179@:=
,' &!!( $
7;68:8"