Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92370 (KAR)
AWAJI AND OTHERS v. KHOOBAPPA AND OTHERS
RSA/200070/2021 · 2025-12-18
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92370 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92370 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! %%
&%' (
! "
#
$
!%
&#
'
(#) *
)
#
$
&#
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
#
&#
)
#
&#
+ # )
$
)
)
#) ! $%#)
! $ )#
)
) ,-.#)
#
!* #
!"
/
##
))
!#)
!#*
#) +%
/
## //
- 3 -
!*
)
/
)
!*
)) ! /
## ) )
!*
))
!#)
'
(#
/
0 +0 !( **
/
%% /
# #
"$ %
%%%
/
$%
#
#
+ %%
#/
%! /
1
/ 2
/
- 4 -
3#)
)$! 456 6789:; <==7<> 56 ?@ A47 =><5:A5BB6 <CCD57E7; ?@ A47 FG;CH7:A <:; ;78D77 ;<A7; %%%% =<667; 5:
9"$ % 9: A47 B5>7 9B ;;5A59:<> 56AD58A G;C7 5F<@<=GD (47D75:<BA7D D7B7DD7; A9 <6 A47 1/5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA2* ?@ I4584 A47/5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA I45>7 <>>9I5:C A476<5;<==7<>B5>7;?@A47;7B7:;<:A64<667A<65;7A47 FG;CH7:A <:; ;78D77 ;<A7; %% =<667; 5:
9+ %% 9: A47 B5>7 9B A47 7:59D 5E5> G;C7 G;;7?54<><:;89:67JG7:A>@;56H5667;A476G5A
47<?9E76G5A5:
9+ %%56B5>7;?@A47 =><5:A5BB6B9DA47D7>57B9B=<DA5A59:<:;67=<D<A7=96676659:
9B ><:; ?7<D5:C @9$% H7<6GD5:C %!
<8D76 CG:A<6 65AG<A7; <A G>>GD E5>><C7 G;;7?54<> <>GK 5F<@<=GD<56AD58A(6G5A6847;G>7=D9=7DA@* - 5 - <67 9B A47 =><5:A5BB 56 A4<A 9:7 G=<><==< A47 =D9=965AG6 4<; B5E7 69:6 :<H7>@ I<F5 45E<D<@< L =><5:A5BB 9 )499?<==< ;7B7:;<:A 9 9A45><> =><5:A5BB9<:;5A4<>=><5:A5BB9+4<AA47D7I<6< =<DA5A59:?7AI77:G=<><==<<:;45669:69:%%""" 5: A7DH6 9B < H7H9D<:;GH I4584 I<6 7:A7D7; 5:A9 ?7AI77: A47 =<DA576 47 6<5; G=<><==< 4<; ?77: <>>9AA7; 6G5A =D9=7DA@ <6 456 64<D7 E7: <BA7D A47 =<DA5A59: ;7B7:;<:A 9 I<6 =58K5:C G= JG<DD7> I5A4 G=<><==< 89:87D:5:C A47 6G5A 6847;G>7 =D9=7DA@ =D766GD5M5:C45HA9AD<:6B7DA476<H75:A47:<H79B456 69:6:<H7>@A47;7B7:;<:A69<:;AI<6D7656A7; ?@ 6<5; G=<><==< 47 6<5; G=<><==< ;57; 9: % %% <A G>>GD 4<:;< >7<E5:C ?745:; =><5:A5BB6 ;7B7:;<:A 9 <6 ><66 475D6 7<84 ?75:C 7:A5A>7; B9D !A4 64<D7 5: A47 6G5A 6847;G>7 =D9=7DA@ 47 =><5:A5BB6 D7875E7; 5:B9DH<A59: BD9H A47 5>><C7 889G:A<:A A4<A ;7B7:;<:A 9 4<; B5>7; < <D<;5 <>>7C5:C A4<A A47 - 6 - G=<><==< 4<; 7N78GA7; < 5>> 9: %+%$%% ?7JG7<A45:C 6G5A =D9=7DA@ 5: B<E9GD 9B ;7B7:;<:A6 9 <:; :>7<D:5:C<?9GAA476<H7A47=><5:A5BB6B5>7;A47 9?F78A59:?7B9D7 A47 89:87D:7; <GA49D5A576 ;56=GA5:C A47 7N78GA59: 9B <>>7C7; 5>> ?@ G=<><==< 5: B<E9GD 9B ;7B7:;<:A6 9 <:; <6 A47 6<H7 I<6 B9DC7; <:; B<?D58<A7; I5A49GA A47 K:9I>7;C7 9B G=<><==< 4<A =><5:A5BB6 A47D7<BA7D <==D9<847; A47 ;7B7:;<:A 9 A9 7BB78A =<DA5A59: I4584 I<6 ;7:57; 4<A A47 <>>7C7; 5>> I<68D7<A7;?@;7B7:;<:A9476<5;G=<><==<;57; 9:% %%I47D7<6A47<D<;59:A47?<6569B<>>7C7; 5>> I<6 B5>7; 5: A47 @7<D %% 47 <>>7C7; 5>> I<6 < 89:898A7; ;98GH7:A 6GDD9G:;7; ?@ 6G6=5859G6 85D8GH6A<:876 4<A A47 =><5:A5BB6 <D7 5: F95:A =96676659: <:;7:F9@H7:A9BA476G5A=D9=7DA@7:87B5>7;6G5AB9D =<DA5A59:<:;67=<D<A7=96676659: + 7B7:;<:A69<:;<==7<D7;A4D9GC4A475D 89G:67>47;7B7:;<:A9?75:CH5:9DD7=D767:A7;?@ - 7 - 456 CG<D;5<: ;7B7:;<:A 9 47 ;7B7:;<:A 9 5: 456 ID5AA7: 6A<A7H7:A I45>7 ;7:@5:C A47 =><5:A <>>7C<A59: 89:A7:;7; A4<A A47 C7:7<>9C@ BGD:5647; I5A4 A47 =><5:A I<6 5:89H=>7A7 5:<6HG84 <6 ;<GC4A7D 9B G=<><==< :<H7>@ 4<DH5:5?<5 I<6 :9A H<;7 =<DA 9B A47 6G5A 47D7B9D7 A47 6G5A I<6 :9A H<5:A<5:<?>7 B9D :9:F95:;7D 9B :78766<D@ =<DA576 4<A 7<D>57D =<DA5A59: 4<; A<K7: =><879:%%"""5:I45846G5A=D9=7DA@4<;B<>>7:A9 64<D7 9B G=<><==< 4<A A47 6<5; G=<><==< ;GD5:C 456 >5B7A5H776=785<>>@<BA7DA47=<DA5A59:I<6D765;5:CI5A4A47 ;7B7:;<:A94<A;7B7:;<:A9=D9E5;7;<>>8<D7A9 G=<><==< 6 6G84 G=<><==< 9GA 9B 456 9I: I5>> <:; E9>5A59: 7N78GA7;A47 5>>;<A7; %+%$%% ?7JG7<A45:C A47 6G5A =D9=7DA@5: B<E9GD9B 456 CD<:;69:6;7B7:;<:A6 9 <:; 47 6<5; 5>> I<6 ID5AA7: ?@ 9:7 D5 <A5> <;E98<A7 <AA76A7; ?@ I5A:76676 :<H7>@ 5;;<==< GA<==<<EGD<:;9;;54<>>;E98<A7475>>I<6 D7C56A7D7; ?7B9D7 A47 G?7C56AD<D G;;7?54<> 47 - 8 - H<AA7D I<6 6G?67JG7:A>@ 5:B9DH7; A9 A47 7E7:G7 GA49D5A576A97:A7DA47:<H769B;7B7:;<:A69<:; 5: A47 D789D;6 9B D5C4A6 9I7E7D 5>><C7 889G:A<:A 9?>5C5:C A47 =><5:A5BB6 ;5; :9A 7:A7D A47 :<H76 9B ;7B7:;<:A6 9 <:; 5: A47 D7E7:G7 D789D;6 47 ;7B7:;<:A9565:7N8>G65E7=96676659:9B7:F9@H7:A9B 456 6G5A =D9=7DA@ : %!%% ;7B7:;<:A 9 B5>7; <==>58<A59:A9A47D7E7:G7<GA49D5A576677K5:CHGA<A59:9B :<H7 9B 45H67>B <:; ;7B7:;<:A 9 ?F78A59:6 I7D7 B5>7;?@A47=><5:A5BB36A9A476<5;<==>58<A59:D76G>A5:C5:
7:JG5D@ ?75:C 89:;G8A7; I47D75: <465>;<D G;;7?54<> =<667;9D;7D6A97:A7DA47:<H769B;7B7:;<:A69<:; 5: A47 6G5A =D9=7DA@ E5;7 9D;7D ;<A7; %%% 889D;5:C>@A47:<H769B;7B7:;<:A69<:;7:A7D7; 5:A9E5;79! %%% 66G84A47D756:98<G67 9B<8A59:7:8769GC4AB9D;56H566<>6G5A
! <5; 4<DH5:?<5 ;<GC4A7D 9B G=<><==< I<6 5H=>7<;7;<6;7B7:;<:A9+
- 9 -
$ #<67;9:A47=>7<;5:C6A47D5<>9GDABD<H7; B9>>9I5:C566G76
! " #$%& ' ( )* &+ , - *. /+01 23 4 567
-
8
9 "6&+
) :)*;. 23 4 567
-
8 < - =
- = <
- >
)'& ? @1 AB))CD16
EFG 23 4
567
-
8 H '<- I@J
)*&
- 3 7 HK< < >
)'&
C ( ? 23 4 567
-
8 L - HML:)
N
- >O3
8 KP
5QR"
B8
47 =><5:A5BB 9 7N<H5:7; 45H67>B <6 <:; 7N45?5A7; ;98GH7:A6 <6 N6
A9 47 ;7B7:;<:A 9 7N<H5:7; <6 47 ;7B7:;<:A 9+ 7N<H5:7; <6 + 47 AI9 9A47D I5A:76676 4<E7 ?77:
7N<H5:7;<6<:;<:;7N45?5A7;% ;98GH7:A6 <6 N6 A9 : <==D785<A59: 9B A47 7E5;7:87 <:; H<A7D5<>9:D789D;A47D5<>9GDA<:6I7D7;566G769
- 10 -
<:;!=<DA>@5:A47<BB5DH<A5E7566G769<:;5:A47 <BB5DH<A5E7566G79+5:A47:7C<A5E7<:;89:67JG7:A>@ ;78D77;A476G5A5:=<DA;78><D5:CA4<AA47=><5:A5BB6?75:C 7:A5A>7; B9D =<DA5A59: <:; 67=<D<A7 =96676659: 9B $A4 64<D75:A47=D9=7DA@
#75:C <CCD57E7; A47 ;7B7:;<:A6 9 A9 + =D7B7DD7; <==7<> 5: 9"$ % 47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDABD<H7;A47B9>>9I5:C=95:AB9D5A689:65;7D<A59:
"
:D7<==D785<A59:9BA477E5;7:87<:;H<A7D5<> 9: D789D; A47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA <>>9I7; A47 <==7<> 67AA5:C<65;7A47FG;CH7:A<:;;78D77=<667;?@A47D5<> 9GDA #75:C <CCD57E7; A47 =><5:A5BB6 <D7 ?7B9D7 A456 9GDA
% 456 9GDA ?@ 9D;7D ;<A7; +%% BD<H7; A47B9>>9I5:C6G?6A<:A5<>JG76A59:69B><I
- 11 -
!
"#$ "#% & ' () ' ' (* + D55:<@<K=A7>7<D:7;89G:67><==7<D5:CB9D A47 =><5:A5BB6 <==7>><:A6 A<K5:C A456 9GDA A4D9GC4 D789D;6 6G?H5AA7; A4<A A47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA CD966>@ 7DD7; 5: ;56H5665:C A47 6G5A <887=A5:C A47 8<67 9B ;7B7:;<:A6 9B A47@ 4<E5:C =D9E7; A47 5>> A49GC4 A47@ 4<E7:9A89H=>57;I5A4A47D7JG5D7H7:A9B78A59:$9B :;5<: G8876659: 8A <:; 78A59: $ 9B A47 :;5<: E5;7:87 8A ?@ >7<;5:C 89C7:A7E5;7:874<A65:87 A47 5>>I<6=D9=9G:;7;?@A47;7B7:;<:A6A47?GD;7:I<6 9: A47 ;7B7:;<:A6 A9 =D9E7 A47 7N78GA59: 9B A47 5>> - 12 - DG>5:C 9GA <>> 6G6=5859G6 85D8GH6A<:876 6GDD9G:;5:C A47 7N78GA59: 9B A47 5>> I4584 A47 ;7B7:;<:A6 5: A456 8<67 4<E7B<5>7;A9;5684<DC7A476<5;9:G64<AA477E5;7:87 9B<:;!<D7HGAG<>>@89:AD<;58A9D@47 5:4568D9667N<H5:<A59:4<6;7=967;A4<A47I<6I9DK5:C 5:<:C<><)<D@<><@<<AG;;7?54<><:;47;5;:9A4<E7 <:@ K:9I>7;C7 <?9GA A47 =7D69:<> <BB<5D6 9B G=<><==< 7 ;5; :9A 7E7: 4<E7 K:9I>7;C7 <?9GA A47 B<H5>@ 9B G=<><==< 7 ;5; :9A 6A<A7 A47 <8AG<> ;<A7 9B A47 7N78GA59:9BA475>>4<AE7D@;7=965A59:9B6<5;I5A:766 9B 47 <BB5N5:C 456 65C:<AGD7 <6 < I5A:766 A9 A47 5>> 56 89:AD<;58A9D@5:A4<AI45>75:A477N<H5:<A59:8457B474<6 6A<A7; A4<A 47 <BB5N7; 456 65C:<AGD7 9: A47 5>> 5: A47 =D767:87 9B ;E98<A7 )<E<;5H<A4 49I7E7D ;GD5:C A47 8D9667N<H5:<A59: 47 4<6 6A<A7; A4<A 47 <BB5N7; 456 65C:<AGD79:A475>>5:A479BB5879BG?7C56AD<D4<A ?@ A47 A5H7 47 I7:A A9 A47 6=9A A4<A 56 9GA65;7 9B A47 9GDAA475>>I<6<>D7<;@A@=7;<:;A47;7B7:;<:A9 - 13 - <:; )<E<;5H<A4 <;E98<A7 <:; A47 6<5; I5A:76676 4<; C9:7A9G?7C56AD<D BB587 6<C<5:6AA47;7=965A59:9B5:456 7E5;7:87 4<6 6A<A7; A4<A 47 8<H7 A9 K:9I <?9GA A47 7N78GA59:9B5>>H<:@;<@66G?67JG7:AA9A47;7H5679B G=<><==<A4<A474<6677:A475>>9:>@<BA7DA47;7<A4 9B G=<><==< 7 C9A A47 6<H7 D7<; A4D9GC4 456 69:6 47 ;7B7:;<:A 9 4<6 =>7<;7; 89H=>7A7 5C:9D<:87 <?9GA A47 5>> 5: 456 ID5AA7: 6A<A7H7:A <:; 4<6 8><5H7; A4<A47 8<H7A9K:9I<?9GAA47 6<5;5>>9:>@<BA7D A47 ;7H5679B G=<><==< 4G6 A47 7E5;7:87 9B <:;!<D789:AD<D@<:;HGAG<>>@;76ADG8A5E7 7B7DD5:C A9 A47 9D;7D 6477A 9B A47 D5<> 9GDA ;<A7;%!%>7<D:7;89G:67>6G?H5AA7;A4<A9:7 9;;54<>I<6<=GD=9DA7;I5A:766A9A475>>4<A9:7 5>5= 4<; <==7<D7; ?7B9D7 A47 9GDA 8><5H5:C A9 ?7 A47 69: 9B 6<5; 9;;54<> 7 4<; D7BG67; A9 <BB5N 456 - 14 - 65C:<AGD7 9: A47 <BB5;<E5A 5: >57G 9B 456 7N<H5:<A59: 5: 8457BI5A49GA>99K5:C5:A9A47;98GH7:A#GA9:=7DG65:C A475>>=D9;G87;<AN 47;7:57;A4765C:<AGD79B456 B<A47D9;;54<>47D5<>9GDA<889D;5:C>@D7F78A7; A47=D<@7D9B;7B7:;<:A69A9A989H=7>6<5;5>5=A9 C5E7 7E5;7:87 47 6<5; 9D;7D I<6 <66<5>7; 5: 9%%%"$ % ?7B9D7 A47 5C4 9GDA I4584 D76G>A7;5:;56H566<>9BA47ID5A=7A5A59:4G65A56=D9E7; A4<A N ;5; :9A 89:A<5: A47 65C:<AGD7 9B 9;;54<> 47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA I5A49GA <;E7DA5:C A9 A4767<6=78A69BA47H<AA7D4<67DD9:79G6>@;78D77;A47 6G5A 47 5>> <A N 56 < D7C56A7D7; ;77; I4584 5:;58<A76 A4<A A47 6<H7 4<6 ?77: ;D<BA7; ?@ 9:7 <A5> 9I7E7D 5A 56 <AA76A7; ?@ AI9 I5A:76676 :<H7>@ 5;;<==<<EGD<:;9;;54<> + 7B7DD5:C A9 ;98GH7:A N A47 >7<D:7; 89G:67> =95:A6 9GA A4<A A47D7 <D7 9E7DID5A5:C6 <:; 5:A7D=9><A59: 5: A47 ;98GH7:A : A4<A =<C7 9 9B - 15 - N ;976 :9A ?7<D A47 65C:<AGD7 9B A47 A76A<A9D 47 =<C799BA476<5;N ;5BB7D6BD9H <C796<:; 47 65C:<AGD7 9B A47 A76A<A9D 6<5; A9 4<E7
?77: <==7<D5:C <A =<C7 96 <:; <D7 :9A 65H5><D 9 <>69 A47 65C:<AGD76 9B 9;;54<> <D7 <>69 :9A 65H5><D 47D756:9H7:A59:5:A47;98GH7:A<AN D7C<D;5:C A47 A76A<A9D 4<E5:C 65C:7; A47 6<5; ;98GH7:A 5: A47 =D767:87 9B A47 <AA76A5:C I5A:76676 47 I5A:76676 4<E7 65C:7;A476<H7<BA7DA4765C:<AGD79BA47A76A<A9D47D7 56:9H<A7D5<><6A9A4789:A7:A69B5>>4<E5:C?77:D7<; 9E7D <:; 7N=><5:7; A9 A47 A76A<A9D 47 =49A9CD<=46 9B A47 A76A<A9D <==7<D5:C 9: A47 ;98GH7:A <A N ;976 :9A ?7<D 456 65C:<AGD7 9D 67<> <8D966 ?@ A47 7C56A7D5:C GA49D5A@<6D7JG5D7;G:;7DG>7(*9BA47)<D:<A<K< 7C56AD<A59:G>76"$!4789>9GD9B=<C796<:; 9B N ;5BB7D6 BD9H =<C7 9 <C7 96 A9 9B N ?7<D6 ;5BB7D7:A 6A<H=6 9B A47 7C56A7D5:C GA49D5A576 E7: A47 65C:<AGD7 9B A47 7C56A7D5:C - 16 - GA49D5A576 <>69 ;5BB7D 4<A A47D7 <D7 H<:@ 6G84 9A47D ;568D7=<:8576I45848D7<A76G6=5859:D7C<D;5:C7N78GA59: 9B A47 5>> <:; A47 6<H7 56 :9A ;56=7>>7; ?@ A47 =D9=9G:;7D ?@ =D9;G85:C 89C7:A 9D<> ;98GH7:A<D@ 7E5;7:87 47D7B9D7 47 6G?H5A6 A4<A A47 <==7<> ?7 <>>9I7;<:;9D;7D9BA47/5D6A==7>><A79GDA9D;7D?767A <65;7 !
:D76=9:67A47>7<D:7;89G:67><==7<D5:CB9D A47 ;7B7:;<:A6 <A A47 9GA67A 6G?H5A6 A4<A A456 9GDA G:;7D 78A59: %% 9B 8<::9A C7A 5:A9 A47 ;56=GA7; B<8A69BA47H<AA7D5:<6HG84<6A47/5D6A==7>><A79GDA ?75:CA47B5:<>9GDA9BB<8A64<689H7A9A4789:8>G659: 4<AH7D7>@?78<G67<:9A47D9=5:59:56=9665?>7A475C4 9GDA 64<>> 7N8567 A47 D76AD<5:A 7 BGDA47D 6G?H5A6 A4<A <;H5AA7;>@ 5>> 56 < D7C56A7D7; ;98GH7:A 56 A47 H96A:<AGD<> <:;ADGA4BG> I5A:766 I4584 56 7E5;7:ABD9H A47B<8A9B47:9A?75:C<?>7A9A7>>A477N<8A;<A79BA47 5>> I4584 56 < :<AGD<> =47:9H7:9: 4<A A47 6AD<@ - 17 - <;H56659:5:A477E5;7:879BD7C<D;5:C<?67:879B ;7B7:;<:A98<::9A?7A<K7:A9;568D7;5AA475>>47 5>> ?75:C A47 A76A<H7:A<D@ ;98GH7:A 9B A47 ;787<67; 4<6 A9 ?7 C5E7: 5A6 BG>>76A H7<:5:C <:; 7BB78A 4<A A47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA A<K5:C 5:A9 89:65;7D<A59: A47 <AA7:;5:C85D8GH6A<:8769BA47H<AA7D4<6D5C4A>@89H7A9 A4789:8>G659:9B;56H5665:CA476G5A<:;6<H78<::9A?7 B9G:;B<G>AI5A47:87677K6B9D;56H566<>9BA47<==7<> $ 7<D; 7DG67;A47D789D;6 #7B9D7 <;E7DA5:C A9 A47 H7D5A6 9B A47 8<67 <==D9=D5<A7 A9 <;E7DA A9 9:7 9B A47 89:A7:A59:6 E747H7:A>@GDC7;?@A47>7<D:7;B9DA47D76=9:;7:AA4<A 56A4569GDAG:;7D78A59:%%9B 64<>>:9AE7:AGD7 A9 D7<==D785<A7 A47 7E5;7:87 <:; A47 B<8A6 <:; 64<>> H<5:A<5: D76AD<5: 5: A4<A D7C<D; ==D9=D5<A7 A9 D7B7D A9 FG;CH7:A 9B A47 =7N 9GDA 5: A47 8<67 9B - 18 - I47D75:<A =<D< A47=7N9GDA4<647>;A4<A , # - , : A47 >5C4A 9B A47 <?9E7 =D5:85=>7 9B ><I A47 89:A7:A59:6 GDC7; D7C<D;5:C FGD56;58A59: 9B A456 9GDA A9 <==D785<A77E5;7:875:A476789:;<==7<>G:;7DA47B<8A6 <:; 85D8GH6A<:87 9B A47 =D767:A 8<67 <6 ;7<>A I5A4 47D7G:;7D8<::9A?789G:A7:<:87; " 47 D7><A59:645= ?7AI77: A47 =<DA576 56 :9A 5: ;56=GA7476G5A=D9=7DA@?7>9:C5:CA9G=<><==<56<>69 :9A5:;56=GA7 % 475:4568D9667N<H5:<A59:4<6;7=967; A4<A47>7<D:A<?9GAA475>><?9GA75C4AH9:A46<BA7DA47 - 19 - ;7H5679B456B<A47D4<A47;9:9AK:9I5B474<;677: A475>><BA7DA47;7H5679B456B<A47D4<A4756:9A<?>7 A96A<A7<A9I47:474<;C9A45669:6A9D7<;A475>> 4<A 456 ?D9A47D6 4<; <AA7:;7; A47 BG:7D<> D5A76 <:; D5AG<>69B456B<A47DAA4<AA5H747I<6:9A<I<D79BA47 5>>7N78GA7;?@456B<A47D47D7B9D747;5;:9A5:B9DH 456?D9A47D6<?9GA7N78GA59:9BA475>>756:9A<I<D7 9BA47;<A79BA475>>756<>69:9A<I<D7<6A9I47D7 A475>>I<67N78GA7; 4G6 BD9H A47 <?9E7 ;7=965A59: 9B 5A 56 8>7<DA4<A47I<6:9A<I<D79BA477N78GA59:9BA475>> ?@456B<A47D<:;47>7<D:A<?9GAA476<H7>9:C<BA7D456 ;7H567 9:AD<D@ A9 A47 <?9E7 ;7=965A59: 9B I49 56 9:7 9B A47 <AA76A5:C I5A:76676 9B A47 6<5; 5>> 5: 456 7N<H5:<A59: 5: 8457B 4<6 ;7=967; A4<A 47 C9A <8JG<5:A7;I5A4G=<><==<I47:474<;89H7A9<AA7:;< - 20 - I7;;5:C 7 4<6 BGDA47D ;7=967; A4<A A47 5>> I<6 =D7=<D7; ?@ )<E<;5H<A4 <;E98<A7 <A A47 5:6ADG8A59: 9B G=<><==< A4<A 47 <>9:C I5A4 G=<><==< <:; AI9 ;E98<A76:<H7>@)<E<;5H<A4<:;9;;54<>I7:AA9A47 9BB587 9B G?7C56AD<D I47D7 G=<><==< I<6 D7<;9E7D A47 89:A7:A6 9B A47 5>> <:; G=9: 456 6<A56B<8A59: A47 D7C56AD<A59: I<6 ;9:7 4<A 47 4<6 <BB5N7; 456 65C:<AGD7 <6<I5A:766<>9:CI5A49;;54<><;E98<A7<A<?9GA% <H : A47 8D9667N<H5:<A59: A47 6<5; I5A:766 4<6 <;H5AA7; A4<A 47 56 I9DK5:C <6 <E<: 5: <A G;;7?54<> <:C<><?4<E<: 4<A 47 56 I9DK5:C =7DH<:7:A>@ BD9H H9D:5:CA97E7:5:C<:;474<6:949>5;<@67;976:9A D7H7H?7D6A47;<A76<:;7E7:A69BH<DD5<C76A4<AA<K76 =><8778<::9A7E7:6<@49IH<:@=79=>74<;89H7A9 A476<5;4<>>4<AG=<><==<<H<:54<;89H7A99:79B A47I7;;5:C6 :>@A47:47C9A<8JG<5:A7;9A47DI56747 4<; :9 <8JG<5:A<:87 4<A 47 56 :9A <I<D7 9B <:@ =7D69:<>;7A<5>69B6<5;G=<><==<7<>69;976:9AK:9I - 21 - I47D7<:;I47:6<5;G=<><==<=<667;<I<@756:9A <I<D7 9B G=<><==< I<6 :9A <?>7 A9 I<>K I5A49GA <:@ <6656A<:87 4<A 47 4<6 :9A E7D5B57; A47 ;98GH7:A6 BGD:5647; ?7B9D7 A47 9GDA 4<A 47 56 :9A <I<D7 9B A47 ;7A<5>69BA478<67756<8JG<5:A7;I5A4;7B7:;<:A9 B9D % @7<D6 4<A G=<><==< 7N78GA7; A47 5>> 9: %$%% <:; 47 <BB5N7; 456 65C:<AGD7 5: A47 9BB587
9B G?7C56AD<D 4<A ?7B9D7 47 <BB5N5:C 456 65C:<AGD7 G=<><==< )<E<;5H<A4 <;E98<A7 <:; 9;;54<> <;E98<A7 4<; <BB5N7; A475D 65C:<AGD76 4<A )<E<;5H<A4 <;E98<A7 4<;=D7=<D7;A475>>9GA65;7A479GDA=D7H5676<:;47 I7:A <BA7D A47 6<H7 4<E5:C ?77: =D7=<D7; 7 56 :9A <I<D7 9B <:@ =<=7D 4<E5:C ?77: ?D9GC4A ?@ G=<><==< 476<5;5>>I<67N78GA7;9:%$%%47;7B7:;<:A 9 4<; ?D9GC4A G=<><==< A9 A47 G?7C56AD<D BB587 <:;47I<6<6656A5:C45H4<A47;976:9AK:9IA9D7<; 9DID5A7?GA474<6:9AD7<;A477E5;7:87<BB5;<E5A4<A 9: %$%% 7N87=A ;7B7:;<:A6 :9 9A47D =7D69:6 4<; - 22 - 89H7B9DA47=GD=9679BD7C56AD<A59:4<A4756;7=965:C ?7B9D7 A47 9GDA <6 5:6ADG8A7; ?@ ;7B7:;<:A 9 7 <;H5A6A4<A;7B7:;<:A94<E5:C?D9GC4A45HB9D87BG>>@ A9A479GDA 47 :<H7>@ 9:7 <H<><==< 5: 456 7E5;7:874<6;7=967;A4<AA47D7I<6<=<DA5A59:?7AI77: G=<><==<<:;456%!845>;D7:;GD5:C456>5B7A5H75:I4584 %!<8D769B><:;I<6D7A<5:7;?@G=<><==<4D779B456 845>;D7:I7D7I9DK5:C9GA65;7<:;47I<6D765;5:C5:A47 49G67 9B ;7B7:;<:A 9 I49 I<6 A<K5:C 8<D7 9B 456 I7>B<D7 : A47 8D9667N<H5:<A59: 6<5; I5A:766 4<6 =>7<;7; 5C:9D<:87 <?9GA A47 7NA7:A 9B ><:; I4584 I<6 =9667667; ?@ G=<><==< 7 4<6 <>69 =>7<;7; 456 5C:9D<:87 <?9GA A47D7 ?75:C <:@ =<DA5A59: ?7AI77: G=<><==< <:; 456 845>;D7: 7 4<6 <>69 ;7=967; A4<A A47D7 I<6 :9 H56G:;7D6A<:;5:C ?7AI77: G=<><==< <:; 456 845>;D7: 9 A47D7 I<6 :9 5:85;7:A B9D G=<><==< A9 ;7E7>9= <:@ <:5H965A@ <C<5:6A A47 =><5:A5BB6 7 4<6 - 23 - <;H5AA7; A4<A G=<><==< I<6 D765;5:C I5A4 <>> 456 845>;D7: 4<A 47 4<6 :9A 677: A47 5>> 7N78GA7; ?@ G=<><==<4<A4756:9A7E7:<I<D7A4<AG=<><==<4<; 7N78GA7;<5>><AG;;7?54<> + 47 7B7:;<:A 9 I49 56 69: 9B ;7B7:;<:A 9 4<6 ?77: 7N<H5:7; <6 !
: 456 8457B 7N<H5:<A59: A47 6<5; I5A:76676 4<E7 6A<A7; A4<A G=<><==<4<;?D9GC4A9:75;;<::<GAA<==<<E9D<:; 9:79;;54<><;E98<A7?@D7JG76A5:CA47HA9?7A47 I5A:76676A9A476<5;5>>;77;47
<A5><;E98<A7 4<; ;D<BA7; A47 5>> <:; 47 C9A 5A A@=7; <6 =7D A47 5:6ADG8A59:9BG=<><==<74<6<>69;7=967;<?9GAA47 H<::7D 5: I4584 A47 G=<><==< 4<; D7JG76A7; A47 <AA76A5:C I5A:76676 A9 H<K7 A475D 65C:<AGD7 9: A47 5>> 476<5;I5A:7664<6=>7<;7;5C:9D<:87<?9GAA47;<A79B ;7<A4 9B G=<><==< 7 4<6 <>69 ;7=967; <?9GA A47 H<::7D 5: I4584 A47 G=<><==< 4<; D7JG76A7; A47 <AA76A5:CI5A:76676A9<BB5NA4765C:<AGD769:A475>>:
- 24 -
A478D9667N<H5:<A59:A476<5;I5A:766=>7<;7;5C:9D<:87 <?9GA A47 ;<A7 9B ;7<A4 9B G=<><==< 7 <>69 ;7=967;
A4<A 47 4<6 :9A <I<D7 A4<A <6 9: I4584 ;<A7 A47 6<5;
G=<><==< 4<; 7N78GA7; A47 5>> 4<A A49GC4 A47 <A5>4<;;D<BA7;A475>>4756:9A<I<D79BA47;<A7 H9:A4<:;@7<D9B456;7<A4756<>69;7=967;A4<A47 56<>69:9A<I<D7<6A9A47;<A7H9:A4<:;@7<D9B;7<A4 9B <:9A47D I5A:766 9;;54<> ;E98<A7 7 4<6 <;H5AA7;
A4<A474<;:9AC9:7I5A4456CD<:;B<A47D<:;
<A5> B9DA47=GD=9679B;D<BA5:CA475>>476<5;I5A:7664<6 <>69 <;H5AA7; A4<A 47 56 :9A <I<D7 <6 A9 I47D7 <:;
A4D9GC4 I49H <:; <A I4<A A5H7 9: %+%$%% 456 CD<:;B<A47D;D<BA7;<:;D7C56A7D7;A475>>4<A47>7<D:A A4<A 456 B<A47D 5:B9DH7; 45H <?9GA A47 5>> <BA7D A47 ;7H5679B456CD<:;B<A47D4<A47H<;7<67=<D<A76G5A 5: A47 @7<D %% 677K5:C ;78><D<A59: 9B 456 9I:7D645= 9E7D A47 =D9=7DA@ 7 E9>G:A77D7; A4<A 47 4<6 :9A B5>7; <:@67=<D<A76G5A
- 25 -
! /GDA47D =7DG6<> 9B A47 5>> <A N 5:;58<A76 A4<A A47 B5D6A =<C7 9B A47 6<5; 5>> 56 :9A 65C:7; ?@ A47 A76A<A9D I45>7 A47 6789:; =<C7 ?7<D6 456 65C:<AGD7 <H76 9B AI9 I5A:76676 <D7 H7:A59:7; 57 5;;<==< GA4<==<<EGD<:;9;;54<>47A45D;=<C79BA47 ;98GH7:A ?7<D6 A47 67<> <:; 65C:<AGD76 9B A47 G? 7C56AD<D <:; <>69 A47 A4GH? 5H=D76659: 47 67<> <:; 65C:<AGD7B9G:;9:A476789:;=<C7<D7;5BB7D7:ABD9HA47 67<> <:; 65C:<AGD7 B9G:; 9: A47 A45D; =<C7 9B A47 6<5; 5>> 47D7 56 89:65;7D<?>7 ;56=<D5A@ ?7AI77: A47 65C:<AGD76B9G:;5:A476789:;=<C79BA475>>I5A4A4<A 9: A47 65C:<AGD76 B9G:; 9: A47 A45D; =<C7 9B A47 5>> 49A9CD<=49BG=<><==<;976:9A?7<D<:@65C:<AGD79D 67<>
$ <D<CD<=4 96$ <:; $ 9B A47 FG;CH7:A 9B A47 D5<> 9GDA 5:;58<A7 A4<A ?7B9D7 7N<H5:5:C ;7B7:;<:A64<; B5>7; <: <==>58<A59:B9D <==95:AH7:A9B < 9GDA 9HH56659:7D A9 7N<H5:7 D5 9;;54<> I49 I<6
- 26 -
9:7 9B A47 <AA76A5:C I5A:76676 A9 A47 5>> 4<A 9: %%!%%<H7H9I<6B5>7;?@A47;7B7:;<:A66A<A5:C A4<A 47 56 :9 >9:C7D 5:A7D76A7; A9 7N<H5:7 A47 6<5; I5A:766889D;5:C>@69GC4AB9D;D9==5:CD789D;5:C9BA47 6<5; I5A:766 G?67JG7:A>@ A47 6<5; 9;;54<> =<667; <I<@ 69 <>69 <;E98<A7 )<E<;5H<A4 47 ;7B7:;<:A6 9 A9 A47D7<BA7D H<;7 <: <AA7H=A A9 7N<H5:7 69: 9B 9;;54<> ?@ :<H7 5>5= I49 I<6 6GHH9:7;G=9:A47<==>58<A59:B5>7;?@;7B7:;<:A69 A9476<5;5>5=69:9B9;;54<><==7<D7;?7B9D7 A47 9GDA <:; 47 D7BG67; A9 <BB5N 456 65C:<AGD7 9: A47 <BB5;<E5A =D9=967; A9 ?7 B5>7; 5: >57G 9B 456 8457B 7N<H5:<A59:I5A49GA>99K5:C5:A9A47;98GH7:A47:A47 6<5;5>5==7DG67;A47;98GH7:AN 5>>47;7:57;
A4<A A47 6<5; ;98GH7:A 89:A<5:7; A47 65C:<AGD7 9B 456 B<A47D9;;54<>A<==7<D6A4<A;7B7:;<:A96A9 4<;89H=7>>7;5>5=9:?74<>B9B9;;54<>A9C5E7 7E5;7:87 I4584 I<6 D7F78A7; ?@ A47 9GDA <C<5:6A I4584
- 27 -
A47;7B7:;<:A96A94<;=D7B7DD7;<ID5A=7A5A59:5:
9%%%"$ % I4584I<6;56H5667;G=49>;5:CA47 9D;7D9BA47D5<>9GDA
47D5<>9GDA9:<==D785<A59:9BA47<B9D76<5; <6=78A9BA47H<AA7D<A=<D<CD<=4$!9BA47FG;CH7:A4<6 7:8<=6G><A7;A47;568D7=<:8@<6G:;7D (%.
&
-
-/ 012+
"#$
/ 02
#& 02
-"#$
02#&
'
(* +
'
() ' 0 2
#&
-3
"#$
4 #&
"#$
' #3! "#$
3
02
51)
''6 -
# &
&
"#$-
7
012
#&
189(9$:11
0
"#$
2"#$
89(9$::)
#&
- 28 -
1(($:11-
18($:11
0
#& '
"#$ ;
#&
02"#$
51) 0$2 " 51
5$ )
; 02 ! 5 1 -
"#$
51
;
5$ )
0)2 +&
51
02 "#$ #&
&
51 082! / 02
:8#:(#$::)-
51)
5$ )
$)#:%#$::<
02
02=
51-
;
3
"#$
-
51
; 0 2 5 &
5 1 ) -
;
$)%$::< 02
"#$-
51
; 119(9$::) 89(9$::)-
51
& $)9%9$::< ! &
- 29 -
3 0%2 ! +&
"*9
0263 9&
+&"*
023 <10<27
;3
3 1>(% &
-
2 - 3 *17
;3
3 1>(%-
&
- 3 *10%2&
-
0 2
& +&"*
3 <1 *1 -
3 02 ! 51 $
+&"*
5)
+&"* 012 51 $ ' #3 ? @- AB ” 02
5) +&"*Bដជ B 02 + 51 $ 5)+&"* 02 ! & +&"*
02 ! 3 5)
;
CC
! 5) ; 65$ 0;25$ )+&"*
-
3 &
- 30 -
A56?<67;9:A47<B9D76<5;H<A7D5<>7E5;7:87 A47 D5<> 9GDA 4<6 89H7 A9 A47 89:8>G659: A4<A A47 ;7B7:;<:A64<;B<5>7;A9=D9E7A47C7:G5:7:7669BA475>> <:;<889D;5:C>@4<;;78D77;A476G5ACD<:A5:C $A464<D7
" 9:AD<D@A9A47<?9E7A47/5D6A==7>><A79GDA 4<6 <==D9<847; A47 89:AD9E7D6@ 5: < ;5BB7D7:A 89:A7NA I458456677:5:5A6D7<69:5:C<A=<D<CD<=4+I458456 7NAD<8A7;47D7G:;7D 118! *8
D
1>>$
D
; B
- B E D ;
@ '3E8
$:#:># 1>><
3D
F
F D #
E
D+&"#% D
; D@
G ,
?
D
D
;
- 31 -
D & E
D D +
&D
&D
;
'
:8#:(#$::) ;
E 8 DF
;
- ' 3
&
#
% 49GC4 9:7 9B A47 <AA76A5:C I5A:76676 A9 A47 5>>4<6?77:7N<H5:7;<6D7JG5D7;G:;7D78A59:$9B :;5<:G8876659:8A<:;78A59:$ 9B:;5<:E5;7:87 8AI4584<889D;5:CA9/5D6A==7>><A79GDA6<A56B576A47 D7JG5D7H7:A9B><I47;568D7=<:8576:9A7;?@A47D5<> 9GDA 4<E7 ?77: ?DG647; <65;7 ?@ A47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA <6 A47@ <D7 H7D7 <:9H<>576 <:; 6AD<@ <;H56659:6 ?@ A47 I5A:76676 ?@ 9=5:5:C A4<A
- 32 -
DG7 5A 56 A4<A 56 9:>@ 9: <==D785<A5:C A47 7E5;7:87 <6 < I49>7 < 8>7<D =58AGD7 I9G>; 7H<:<A7 6 :9A7;<?9E7A47E7D@9D5C5:9B5>><:;K:9I>7;C79B5A6 7N56A7:87 56 :9A H<;7 8>7<D ?@ A47 ;7B7:;<:A6 #9A4 ;7B7:;<:A6 9 <:; I49 4<E7 ?77: 7N<H5:7; <6 <:;!D76=78A5E7>@4<E7=>7<;7;A475D5C:9D<:87 <?9GA G=<><==< 7N78GA5:C A47 5>> <:; A47@ 4<E7 8<A7C9D58<>>@;7=967;A4<AA47@I7D7:75A47D<889H=<:57;
:9D I7D7 =D767:A <A <:@ =95:A 9B A5H7 5: A47 =D98766 9B 7N78GA59:9BA475>><:;A47@>7<D:A<?9GAA47G=<><==< 7N78GA5:CA475>>>9:C<BA7D456;7H5675A56:9A8>7<D<6 A949I<:;BD9HI47D7;5;A47@C7AA475>>5:A475D4<:;
A47 <AA76A5:C I5A:766 9: A47 9A47D 4<:; 8<A7C9D@ ;7=967;A4<A;7B7:;<:A9I<6=D767:AA4D9GC49GAA47 <8JG<5:A<:879BA476<5;I5A:766I5A4G=<><==<5A67>B56 JG76A59:<?>7
/D9HA477E5;7:879B5A<==7<D6A4<A47 4<; H7A G=<><==< 9:>@ 9:87 5: 456 >5B7A5H7 47 6<5;
- 33 -
I5A:766I<6I9DK5:C<6<8>7<:7D5:A47<:C<><#4<E<:
47 69: 9B 9A47D <AA76A5:C I5A:766 4<6 ;7:57; A47 65C:<AGD7 9B 9A47D I5A:766 :<H7>@ 9;;54<> 4<6 ;7:57;A4765C:<AGD79B456B<A47D<:;4<67E7:D7BG67;A9 7:A7D A47 I5A:766 ?9N A9 ;7=967 5: A456 D7C<D; I4584 56 7H<:<A5:C BD9H =<D<CD<=4 96$ <:; $ 9B A47 G;CH7:A5:A47D5<>9GDA
47D7>5<:87=><87;?@A47D5<>9GDA9:A9A47 FG;CH7:A6 9B A47 =7N 9GDA 5: A47 8<67 9B
! "## $## D7=9DA7; 5: % & '# () '#D D7=9DA7; 5: % ! ( ! $' ) D7=9DA7;5:* *% <:; ! # +, - )
D7=9DA7; 5: ./ % ** : A47 B<8A6 <:; 85D8GH6A<:8769BA478<675A56FG6A<:;<==D9=D5<A7
- 34 -
+ 47/5D6A==7>><A79GDA9:A479A47D4<:;4<6 <;E7DA7; A9 A47 8<67 ?@ A<K5:C < 89H=>7A7>@ ;5BB7D7:A <==D9<84 I4584 5: A47 B<8A6 <:; 85D8GH6A<:87 9B A47 8<67 5: A47 89:65;7D<A59: 9B A47 9GDA 56 5:<==D9=D5<A7 /9D A47 <B9D76<5; D7<69:6 <:; <:<>@656 A47 6G?6A<:A5<> JG76A59:69B><I<D7<:6I7D7;<889D;5:C>@
!
: A4<A E57I 9B A47 H<AA7D A47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA I<6 :9A FG6A5B57; 5: D7E7D65:C A47 FG;CH7:A <:;
;78D77 =<667; ?@ A47 D5<> 9GDA D7><@5:C G=9: A47 7E5;7:879B<:;!889D;5:C>@A47B9>>9I5:C0
(5* 47<==7<>56)0 (55* 47 FG;CH7:A <:; ;78D77 ;<A7; %%%% =<667; ?@ A47 /5D6A ==7>><A7 9GDA 5:
9"$ % 5667A<65;7
- 35 -
(555* 47 FG;CH7:A <:; ;78D77 ;<A7; %% =<667;?@A47D5<>9GDA5: 9+ %%56 89:B5DH7;
*+ &!!' $
))
+ )