- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( ! " ## #$ %&'("$" ) % & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & %&($$& * )+ "% )$$#)$)# ! ** ",# "!* * "($')$)) * -. ""')$" * * / # / ! " 012345012678094:;<=;45:>30: ) 5>:1??01@>:<>@03=A450B@1>8194161>9:4450 C7368094 193 1D123 31403 "($')$)) ?1::03=A 450 33>4>;91@ 09>;2 >E>@ 7360 193 08=02 %. >C1A1?721 F<;2 :5;24 G2>=791@HI >9 ;""')$" :00J>9609519B08094;<B;8?09:14>;9 - 3 - # 50 B@1>8194 1603 ( A012: 804 D>45 19 1BB>3094 ;9 $)$&)$" 193 :7:41>903 62>0E;7: >9C72>0: 09B050<>@031B@1>8?04>4>;9=0<;204502>=791@:00J>96 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :)$$$$$$% <2;8 450 20:?;93094: 50 2>=791@ 1<402 B;9:>302>96 450 094>20 0E>309B0 ;9 20B;23 1D12303 450 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :)#)$$% D>45 >94020:4 14 (K ?02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< ?04>4>;9 4>@@ 201@>L14>;9 193 3>20B403 20:?;93094 ;"% ;D902 ;< 450 E05>B@0 4; ?1A 450 B;8?09:14>;9 193 0M;9021403 20:?;93094;)%9:7219B0;8?19A<2;8>4:@>1=>@>4A 662>0E03 =A 450 :1>3 1D123 450 1??0@@194% B@1>819451:?20<0220345>:1??01@81>9@AB;94093>964514 450B;8?09:14>;91D12303=A4502>=791@793021@@5013: >: ;9 450 @;D02 :>30 4 >: B;9409303 4514 45;765 450 B@1>8194D1:0129>96 :#$$$$%?028;9454502>=791@ 02203>941J>96450>9B;80;9@A14 :"#)&$%?028;945 4 >:1@:; B;94093034514 ) - ;B4;2 51: 1::0::03 450 3>:1=>@>4A14)&4;#$K>920:?0B4;<2>6547??02@>8==74 450 2>=791@ 51: B;9:>30203 450 :180 14 &K D5>B5 >: - 4 - 20N7>2034;201::0::03=A45>:;724193457:?21A03<;2 1@@;D>964501??01@ & 38>4403@A >4 >: 450 B1:0 ;< 450 3>:1=>@>4A :7<<0203 =A 450 B@1>8194 5;765 B@1>8194 B@1>8: 5>: >9B;80 1: :#$$$$% ?02 8;945 50 <1>@03 4;?2;E0 450 :180 9 450 1=:09B0 ;< 0E>309B0 1: 450 1BB>3094 >: ;< 450A012 )$" 1: ?02 450B5124>::703=A450129141J1 4140 061@ 02E>B0: 745;2>4A 450 2>=791@ 51: 2>654@A 1::0::03 5>: >9B;80 14 :"#)&$% ?02 8;945 D5>B5 9003:9;>9402<0209B0=A45>:;724 ( : ?02 M( - ;793 024><>B140 450 B@1>8194 :7:41>903 <21B4720 ;< 2>654 B@1E>B@0 D5>B5 >: :5;D9 1: 62>0E;7: >9 914720 0 D1: 138>4403 1: >9?14>094 <;2 31A: 793026;90 :72602>0: 193 1@:; 793026;90 <;@@;D 7? 420148094 ) >: 450 245;?103>B7260;9D5; >::703 >:1=>@>4A024><>B1401:?02M "#1::0::>964503>:1=>@>4A 14)&4;#$K>920:?0B4;<2>6547??02@>8=051:1@:; :41403 4514 450 >8?@194: D020 208;E03 <21B4720: 120 794>03 193 >9C72>0: 120 9;D 501@03 7? 5020<;20 450 - 5 - 2>=791@ 51: B;9:>30203 3>:1=>@>4A 14 &K 4; 450 D5;@0 =;3A;;J>964;450>9C72>0::7<<0203193450420148094 793026;90 45>: ;724 <>93: >4 201:;91=@0 4; 41J0 D5;@0 =;3A 3>:1=>@>4A 14 "$K BB;23>96@A 450 B@1>8194 >: 094>4@03<;2@;::;<<747200129>96B1?1B>4A1:79302 :"#)&$%M")M"#M"$KO :)$(,$$% , 50B@1>8194D1:138>4403>94505;:?>41@<;2 31A:193793026;90<;@@;D7?420148094<;2:0E021@31A: 193>4>::41403451450B;7@39;414409319AD;2J14@01:4 <;2 1 ?02>;3 ;< ( 8;945: 5020<;20 45>: ;724 <>93: >4 201:;91=@0 4; 09519B0 450 18;794 ;< B;8?09:14>;9 4; :&$$$$%<;2>9C72A?1>9193:7<<02>96+ :)&$$$%<;2 @;:: ;< 1809>4>0:+ :#$$$$% <;2 4219:?;2414>;9 0M421 9;72>:58094 193 144093194 B51260:+ 193 :#,&$% <;2 @;:: ;< >9B;80 372>96 @1>3 7? ?02>;3 <;2 # 8;945: 50 2>=791@51:2>654@A1D123031:78;< :&,#"%4;D123: 803>B1@0M?09:0:D5>B59003:9;>9402<0209B0 - 6 - ' 50 B;8?09:14>;9 1D12303 =A 450 2>=791@ >: 8;3><>031:79302 @ ; 013: D123=A450 2>=791@ D123=A45>: ;724 " 9C72A ?1>9 193 :7<<02>96 :#$$$$% :&$$$$% ) 03>B1@ M?09:0: :&,#"% :&,#"% # ;:: ;< <74720 0129>96B1?1B>4A :"$#),)% :)$(,$$% 219:?;2414>;9 0M421 9;72>:58094 193 144093194 B51260: :,$$$% :#$$$$% & ;:: ;< 1809>4>0: :"$$$$% :)&$$$% ( ;:: ;< >9B;80 372>96 @1>3 7? ?02>;3 :)(&$$% :#,&$% ;41@ :)#""#% :$',"% 5020D>@@=009519B08094;< :",(,'% ;3;7=44502>=791@51:2>654@A;=:02E034514 45020 D1: 9; E1@>3 2>E>96 >B09:0 4; 450 32>E02 ;< 450 - 7 - >9:7203 E05>B@0 193 45020 >: E>;@14>;9 ;< 450 4028: 193 B;93>4>;9: ;< 450 ;@>BA 193 509B0 50@3 4514 20:?;93094 ;" - ;D902 ;< 450 >9:7203 E05>B@0 >: @>1=@0 4; ?1A 450 B;8?09:14>;94;450B@1>8194 "$ ;D0E02 20@A>96;9 450C7368094;< 450?0M ;724 >9 450 B1:0 ;< $)**+ &, &-./ +0)1 )02) 45>: ;724 3>20B4: 20:?;93094 ;) - 9:7219B0 ;8?19A 4; ?1A 450 B;8?09:14>;9 4; 450 B@1>8194 14 450 <>2:4 >9:419B0 193 >4 >: 14 @>=024A 4; 20B;E02 450 :180 <2;8 20:?;93094;" "" 945020:7@4450<;@@;D>96;2302>:?1::03 >! ??01@>: >>! 50 B@1>8194 >: 094>4@03 <;2 450 09519B03 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :",(,'% D>45 >94020:4 14 (K ?02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< ?04>4>;94>@@4503140;<201@>L14>;9 1 )$"'!#)$' - 8 - >>>! 0:?;93094 ;) - 9:7219B0 ;8?19A >: 3>20B403 4; 30?;:>4 450 1<;20:1>3 B;8?09:14>;918;7941@;96D>45>94020:4D>45>9 ;90 8;945 <2;8 450 3140 ;< 45>: ;2302 14 450 <>2:4>9:419B0193>4>:14@>=024A4;20B;E02450 18;794 <2;8 20:?;93094 ;" - ;D902 ;< 450 E05>B@0 >E! 9 :7B5 30?;:>4 450 B@1>8194 >: ?028>44034;D>45321D450094>2018;7941@;96 D>45>94020:41BB2703;9>4 ,/3 %$' # >:4;"@;&