Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92354 (KAR)
MR SANTOSH v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/202269/2025 · 2025-12-09
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92354 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92354 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$!! %!&
!"#
$
%! & !%#
! !'$(#
(
$
!'$(#
! #
!%#(
%
$
& !%
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
! !%
"
!"
'
! &
!"#
)
*
+
, ,
!%###
$
,
* , , + !%###
,
!'##%
(
,
!%#
- 3 -
! ,
&
& !%$#
%
&
& !%$
"
* +
!%$#
!%$#
'
!%$#
#
!%$#
!%$#
$
!%$#
,,
!%$#
- 4 -
( ,
&
!%#
! ( ,
! !%###
)
*
,
% (-
,
"-
,
$-
, !+
& ,
$$% $$" ,
,
& ,
%
"
$
& ,
%
" $ , &
,
! ,,
,
"$#$! & ,, & ,
%
, ,
& ,
,###### *
+ &
,
&
- 5 -
. /0 10232345067 860 90:460 2/37 4;62 700<35= :4>>4?35=60>30:@7- A+
77;08?632352/0582;604:B85C8B;7C360D235= 2/0 607145C052 4 24 % 24 28<0 81164163820 >0=8> 85C C37D31>3586E 8D2345 8=83572 2/0 607145C052 4" 24$ +
77;08?632352/0582;604:B85C8B;7C360D235= 2/0607145C052424%24C37B3772/0607145C052 4"24$:64B2/0706F3D0 +
77;08?632352/0582;604:B85C8B;7C360D235= 2/0607145C052424!24D/85=02/0
5F0723=8235=
::3D06785C24D45C;D22/035F0723=823454:4>/86 63B0 4"$#$! 2/64;=/ 85E 42/06 >8? 893C35= 4::3D06 +
77;08?632352/0582;604:B85C8B;7C360D235= 2/0607145C052424%243532382035G;36E3560710D2 4: :8<0 B0C3D8> 60D46C 377;0C 9E 2/0 607145C052 4 +
77;08?632352/0582;604:B85C8B;7C360D235= 2/0607145C05242418E87;B4:7###### *;1007 05 8</ 5>E+ 24?86C7 D4B105782345 24 08D/10232345067 ,+5E42/0660>30:@72/3745@9>04;62C00B7:32B8E 1>0870 90 =68520C 35 :8F4;6 4: 2/0 1607052 10232345067H
- 6 -
$ /0D8704:2/010232345067372/822/0E8602/0 6073C05274:2/08CC6077077/4?5352/0D8;70232>0/83>35= :64B 8 B4C072 :8B3>307 :64B 8 B86=358>3I0C D4BB;532E >08C35=2/036>3:0D866E35=458=63D;>2;68>85C42/06163F820 J497 >3F35= 2/036 >3:0 108D0:;>>E ?32/ C3=532E 8>45= ?32/ 2/036 :8B3>307 /82 45 '#"$#$! 607145C052 4" 85C /37 7;946C358207 ?32/4;2 85E D8;70 46 608745 46 J;723:3D82345 3>>0=8>>E 244< 2/0 10232345067 :64B 2/036 60710D23F0 6073C05D0 85C <012 2/0B 35 3>>0=8> C02052345 ?32/4;2:4>>4?35=C;0164D0774:>8? /0E?060<012358 9;3>C35= 732;820C 8CJ8D052 24 2/0 14>3D0 7282345 4: 4>/86 0232345067 ?060 8>74 7;9J0D20C 24 1/E73D8> 85C B0528> 2462;60 07145C052 4" /8C 1/E73D8>>E 8778;>20C 2/0 10232345067242/00K20522/0E8>747;::060C70F0603520658> 85C 0K20658> 35J;6307 /0E ?060 0F05 C0530C 2/0 9873D B0C3D8> 83C /4;=/ 607145C052 4" /8C 28<05 2/0 10232345067 3524 3>>0=8> D;724CE 45 '#"$#$!
/0 /8C 542 60=372060C 2/0 D63B0 5;B906 8=83572 2/0B 9608D/35= 8>> 7282;246E85CD457232;23458>B85C820 /0E?0605420F05
- 7 -
164C;D0C 90:460 2/0 J;637C3D23458> 8=3726820 ?32/35 2/0 B85C8246E 10634C 4: $( /4;67 07145C052 4" /8C 542 0F05 35:46B0C 2/0 =64;5C7 4: 866072 032/06 24 2/0 1023234506746242/036:8B3>EB0B9067
/35=7 9035= 2/;7 CF4D8207 9E 58B0 63/3F68J 858C3 85C 638=85582/ 368C86 823> 811648D/0C 607145C052 4" 45 90/8>: 4: 2/0 10232345067 700<35= 35:46B82345 894;2 2/0 98737 45 ?/3D/ 2/0 10232345067 ?060 <012 35 3>>0=8> C02052345 /0 783C 8CF4D8207 /8C 811648D/0C 2/0 607145C052 4" 902?005 #!# 1B 24 #%## 1B 45 $#"$#$! 2 37 8>>0=0C 0F05 2/0 783C 8CF4D8207 /8C 7005 2/0 10232345067 9035= 8778;>20C4?0F06607145C0524"85C/377;946C358207 =8F00F873F0601>E35858220B1224/3C02/0B82206 /0 783C 8CF4D8207 4: 2/0 10232345067 /8C 377;0C 8 5423D0 45 $#"$#$ 82 864;5C ### 1B 60G;07235= ;145 2/0 607145C052 4" 24 377;0 85 05C4670B052 45 2/0 4::3D0 D41E4:2/0783C5423D007145C0524"3BB0C3820>E>0:2 2/014>3D07282345C3C5420F05377;005C4670B052/8F35=
- 8 -
60D03F0C 2/0 783C 5423D0 85C C3C 542 0F05 602;65 24 2/0 14>3D072823452/4;=/2/08CF4D8207?060<012?83235=;1 24 #$ 1B /0 783C 8CF4D8207 8CC60770C 8542/06 5423D024607145C0524%9635=35=24/375423D02/03>>0=8> C02052345 D86630C 4;2 9E 607145C052 4" 41E 4: 2/0 78B0 ?87 8>74 =3F05 24 2/0 7;946C35820 4: 607145C052 4"?/4?8745C;2E4?0F062/0783C7;946C35820C3C 542 60D03F0 2/0 5423D0 0 /8C 7052 2/0 D41E 4: 2/0 783C 5423D0 24 607145C052 47% 85C " 2/64;=/ 2/0 B493>0 5;B906 45 2/0 78B0 C8E 30 45 $#"$#$! 50 8/85207/ 82/81823 ?/4 /8C 8DD4B18530C 2/0 8CF4D8207 85C ?/4 8>74 /811050C 24 90 8 :6305C 4:
1023234506 4'/8C 60D46C0C 2/0700F0527 45/37B493>0 &/05 2/0 783C 8CF4D8207 ?060 ?83235= :46 8663F8> 4:
607145C052 4" 2/036 7;946C35820 /8C 8CF370C 2/0 8CF4D8207 4: 10232345067 24 /8F0 C35506 85C D4B0 DD46C35=>E ?/05 2/0 8CF4D8207 4: 10232345067 602;65 24 2/0 14>3D0 7282345 8:206 2/0 C35506 2/0E :4;5C 2/0 10232345067/8C900528<054;22485;5C37D>470C>4D82345
- 9 -
2 37 8>>0=0C 2/82 8>> 2/070 8D23F32307 /8F0 9005 60D46C0C 85C D812;60C 35 2/0 D8B068 35728>>0C 35 2/0 14>3D0 7282345 1160/05C35= C0726;D2345 4: 2/0 78B0 2/0 783C 8CF4D82074:2/010232345067/8C0F05=3F0560G;373234524 2/0607145C0524"24:;6537/2/0B2/0 :4428=045 $(#"$#$!82 $(%8B /0 7;946C358204:607145C052 4" ?/4 ?87 45 2/0 C;2E B8C0 05C4670B052 45 2/0 783C >02206 82 #$!
8B 45 $(#"$#$! 4?0F06 54 :4428=0/8F09005:;6537/0C032/06242/010232345067 46 24 2/036 8CF4D8207 23>> C820 ,08635= C0726;D2345 4: 2/0 783C 0F3C05D0 2/0 8CF4D8207 4: 2/0 10232345067 /8C 8>74 74;=/2:468220720CD413074:*+F373246.760=372682345944< *$+7282345/4;70C386E*+ :4428=0:64B#"$#$! 24 $(#"$#$! *(+ :4428=0 :64B $(#"$#$! 24 $!#"$#$!;5C063=/224
5:46B82345D2 ( /35=77244C2/;7607145C0524"3546C0624 D4F06;1/373>>0=8>C00C7/8CD60820C863B00=3720635 63B0 4"$#$! :46 2/0 4::05D07 1;537/89>0 ;5C06 0D2345 #*(+*!+ 4: /86823E8 E8E8 85/328 $#$! - 10 -
7/4?35=/3B70>:872/0D4B1>835852 /0783C8D2/879005 C450 9E 607145C052 4" 35 D4>>;7345 ?32/ 607145C052 47 24 $ /;7 8 :8<0 D4B1>8352 ,
85C 2/0 42/06 C4D;B0527 /8F0 9005 D60820C 24 4F06D4B0 2/0 60G;37323457 B8C0 9E 2/0 8CF4D8207 4: 2/0 10232345067 ,;62/06 607145C052 4" =42 8 :8>70 B0C3D8> :325077 D0623:3D820 1601860C 9E 607145C052 4 45 $(#"$#$! /4D<35=>E 2/4;=/ 607145C052 4" /8C 35:>3D20C 70F068> 3520658> 85C 0K20658> 35J;6307 45 2/0 10232345067 607145C05242;6535=9>35C0E0242/0783C35J;6307/8C 377;0C8:8>70D0623:3D8204:2/0609035=5435J;6307452/0 94C307 4: 2/0 10232345067 /0608:206 607145C052 4" 89;735= 2/0 10232345067 ?32/ :3>2/E >85=;8=0 85C 2/60820535=2/0B4:2/0C360D4570G;05D071435235=2/0B 2/0 ?08145 1;2235= 2/036 >3:0 85C 2/0 >3:0 4: 2/036 :8B3>E B0B9067 82 637< 35726;D20C 2/0 10232345067 542 24 7108< 26;2/ 90:460 2/0 8=3726820 /;7 ?/05 2/0 10232345067 ?060164C;D0C90:4602/0CC323458>3F3>;C=085C, 878F85898=0?8C39035=;5C060K260B0:086C3C5424105
- 11 -
2/036 B4;2/ /;7 2/0 607145C052 4" 9E D608235= 8 :8>70 85C :8<0 C4D;B052 /87 0F05 B37>0C 2/0 ;C3D38> 8=3726820 /0 10232345067 /8C 811>30C :46 2/0 983> 85C 2/0E/8F09005=68520C983> ! 08650C D4;570> :46 2/0 10232345067 28<35= 2/37 4;622/64;=/2/060D46C785C60>E35=;1452/0J;C=B052 4:2/010K4;62352/0D8704:
6014620C35 F0/0B052>E D45205C 2/82 607145C052 4" 37 =;3>2E 4: B37;70 4: /37 4::3D38>14?0685C/87D45C;D20C/3B70>:35=6477F34>82345 4::;5C8B0528>85C7282;246E63=/274:2/010232345067 % /37 4;62 /8C C360D20C :46 :;6537/35= 4: 2/0 B0C3D8> 0K8B3582345 601462 4: 2/0 10232345067 82 4F065B052471328>3J8E81;68
5607145702/0>08650C 4F065B052 CF4D820 85C 2/0 8CF4D820 :46 2/0 607145C052 2820/8C:3>0C8B0B4C820C(#$#$! /0 783CB0B4378DD4B18530C9E 944<4:2/010232345067 /0 783C C4D;B0527 60F08> D452;73457 85C 74:2 205C457
- 12 -
7;::060C 9E 2/0 10232345067 45 2/0 ;1106 1862 4: 2/036 9;224D<785C >0=7 85C2/0E D4B1>83535= 1835 8>>4F06 2/0 94CE/85C785C:002@7452;73457/8F08>7490051607052 4F062/063=/22/3=/
" 5 2/0 72820B052 4: 49J0D2345 :3>0C 9E 2/0 607145C0524"2/08>>0=823457B8C0352/010232345860 710D3:3D8>>E C0530C B460 18623D;>86>E 4: 86607235= 85C 3>>0=8>>E C0283535= 2/0 10232345067 902?005 '#"$#$! 24 $(#"$#$! /08>>0=8234574:8CF4D82074:2/010232345067 811648D/35= 2/0 607145C052 4" 82 2/0 14>3D0 7282345 37 8>74 C0530C
520607235=>E 82 1868 # 4: 2/0 49J0D2345 72820B052 8CF06235= 24 2/0 60G;3732345 4: 2/0 8CF4D8207 :462/010232345067:467;11>E4: :4428=0:4>>4?35=37 72820C- A>>0=82345 2/82 2/0 282345 4;70
::3D06 607145C052 4" /8C 60D03F0C 8 60G;3732345 45 $(#"$#$! 37 542 ?32/35 2/0 <54?>0C=0 4:
607145C052 4" 4604F06 D8B0687 ?060 54235410682345:64B$#"$#$!24$%#"$#$! 52/3760=86C8D4B1>8352?878>74>4C=0C9E2/0 607145C052 4" 45 $$#"$#$!
85C 2/0
- 13 -
D8B0687 D8B0 24 90 6072460C 35 410682345 45 $%#"$#$!9E450 63532E 0D/54>4=307H
/0 B0C3D8> 60D46C7 :;6537/0C 8>45= ?32/ 2/0 B0B4 85C 2/37 10D;>386 7285C 4: 8>>0=0C 545 ?46<35= 4: 2/0
163B8 :8D30 >05C7 2/0 D60C05D0 24 2/0 8>>0=823457 4: 3>>0=8> C02052345 7;9J0D235= 4: 2/0 10232345067902?005'#"$#$!24$(#"$#$!7;9J0D235= 2/0B 24 3>>0=8> C02052345 ?32/4;2 60=3720635= 2/0 ,
85C 542 164C;D35= 90:460 2/0 >08650C 8=3726820 7;9J0D235= 2/0B 24 1/E73D8> 85C B0528> 2462;60 /0 J;723:3D82345 4: :4428=0542:;5D234535=822/8260>0F85223B0:;62/06 >05C7D60C05D0242/08>>0=82345B8C09E2/0102323450674:
85 8220B12 9035= B8C0 9E 607145C052 4" 85C /37 7;946C358207 4: /;7/35= ;1 85C B37>08C35= 2/0 052360 164D077J;723:307=685235=4:2/0168E0674;=/2:469E2/0 10232345067:46 ' 5F30?4:2/0894F02/0:4>>4?35=-
- 14 -
*8+ /010232345378>>4?0C351862 *9+ /0 607145C052 47 24 7/8>> 1>8D0 8>> 2/0 B820638> 106283535= 2/0 D870 82 /85C 90:460 2/0 /836B85 2820 ;B85 3=/27 4BB377345 ?/4 7/8>>B8<050D07786E05G;36E35242/0B822068:206 8::46C35=411462;532E242/01023234506787?0>>87 607145C05247"24$35242/08>>0=823457B8C0 9E2/010232345067875420C/06035894F0 *D+ 5 8CC32345 2/0 607145C052 4 9035= 2/0 C37D31>3586E 8;2/4632E 4: 607145C052 47" 24 $ 7/8>>8>74/4>C8535C0105C052C37D31>3586E05G;36E 3524 2/0 8>>0=82345 B8C0 8=83572 2/0 607145C052 4" ?/4 37 2/0 4>3D0 ;9
5710D246 4>/86 4>3D02823454>/86 *C+ /0 607145C052 4 7/8>> 8>74 057;60 2/82 50D07786E 05G;36E 37 8>74 D45C;D20C 8=83572 607145C052 4 0C3D8>
::3D06 3524 2/0 8>>0=823454:/0377;35=:8<0B0C3D8>D0623:3D8207 *0+ 0232345067 860 106B3220C 24 811086 90:460 2/0 2820;B853=/274BB37734587?0>>8790:460 607145C052 4 ;145 16346 5423D0 35 J;723:3D82345 4:2/0368>>0=823457B8C0352/010232345
- 15 -
*:+ 07145C05247"24$8608>7482>39062E24:3>0 2/036 601>E 49J0D23457 35 2/036 C0:05D0 35 2/0 8:460783C206B7 *=+ /07005G;363077/8>>90D45C;D20C85CD45D>;C0C 87 0K10C3234;7>E 87 147739>0 85C 81164163820 46C0679018770C358DD46C85D0?32/>8??32/3585 4;206>3B324:'#C8E7:64B2/0C8204:60D03124: 2/0D0623:30CD41E4:2/3746C06
'( %!!& $
3724>4$