- 1 - !"# $"% "" "& '( ')*+(,' ** - ! ! "#$%& ! '(& )'# "%' * $'%+%' ! +)%$( Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $)%+%) %$%%' ! &$$% ! , ! - !* . & . /0 1023234506 7899: 35 ;<0:2345 2/0 =<>?@052 4A 745B372345 85> 46>06 4A :0520570 >820> $'%+%' 18::0>CD2/0908650>>>32345893B39<>?0E! <@58C8>354+)%$(8:745A36@0>CD2/0 >>3234589 3:26372 E 0::345: <>?0 3>86 :32235? 82 8:8B8F89D85 35 63@3589 11089 4%$%%' A46 2/04AA0570:1<53:/8C90<5>06 072345:&(85>'%)" 4A2/085> 072345$#&4A2/042460/3790:72 $(## /0 6389 4<62 :0520570> 2/0 1023234506 24 <5>06?4 :3@190 3@163:45@052 A46 :3G @452/: 85> 24 - 3 - 18D 8 A350 4A :$%%%%" A46 2/0 4AA0570 1<53:/8C90 <5>06 072345 '%)" H32/ >0A8<92 A46 2/600 @452/: A350 4A :$%%%" A46 2/0 4AA0570 <5>06 072345 &( H32/ >0A8<92 A46 $ >8D: 85> A3504A :%%"A462/04AA0570<5>06 072345$#& 72H32/>0A8<92 A46$>8D: /0110998204<62 8AA36@0>2/0745B37234585>:0520570 64:07<2345 78:0 35 C630A 3: 2/82 45 $+%&%$( 82 8C4<2 '% 1@ 5086 2/0 663?82345 <39>35? 45 <@58C8>I898C<68?3 48> 82 8993F/0> B3998?0 2/0 1023234506 >64B0 @42467D790 C08635? 0? 4 "'" "$(%( 8990?0>9D 35 8 68:/ 85> 50?93?052 @85506 85> >8:/0> 8?835:2 450 8B35>68 4 <:2858118 460 H/4 H8: 764::35? 2/0 648> 60:<9235? 35 /3: 35:28528504<: >082/ 45 8774<52 4A ?630B4<: 35=<630: /0 63>06 8990?0>9D 90A2 2/0 :142 H32/4<2 0G205>35? @0>3789 8::3:28570 63@0 - 4 - 4&'%$( H8: 60?3:2060> 85> <145 74@1902345 4A 35B0:23?823457/86?0":/002H8:A390>/0164:07<2345 0G8@350>*$24*$$85>@86F0>G:$24# ' 08650> 74<5:09 A46 2/0 1023234506 :<C@32: 3 0:2 >0523A3782345 868>0 H8: 542 745><720> 2/4<?/*)85>*+860164=0720>8:0D0H3250::0:J 33 2/060 860 745268>372345: 85> 4@3::345: 35 2/036 20:23@4530:J85>333 8:2/0B0/3790:/4H0>54B3:3C90 >8@8?0 32: 35B49B0@052 3: >4<C2A<9 5 :0520570 609385703:19870>452/0446>35820057/>073:34535 69 4%%$%%' H/37/ A4994H35? 6014620> 35 ! 244F 8 9053052B30H<5>06 072345'%)"4A5423735?2/0 8?04A2/0877<:0>85>82205>8527367<@:28570:85> - 5 - 60><70> 2/0 :<C:28523B0 3@163:45@052 24 2/600 @452/: ./01)2/1.34)50./ ! "# $% & ' ( ') * ( + + &) ) 2 3: 26320 2/82 2/3: 4<62 35 60B3:345 >40: 542 60"8116073820 0B3>0570 8: 8 :0745> 811099820 A46<@ <590:: 2/0 A35>35?: 860 @853A0:29D 106B06:0 C8:0> 45 @3:608>35? 4A 0B3>0570 46 2/060 3: @3:786638?0 4A =<:2370 0:20> 45 2/3: 85B39 2/0 745B372345 H866852: 54 35206A060570 *3250::0: 160:052822/0:142H/4/8B03>0523A30>2/01023234506 - 6 - 8: 2/0 63>06 85> /8B0 20:23A30> 68:/ 85> 50?93?052 >63B35?7<9@358235?352/0A82893@1872/011099820 4<62 /8: 7457<660> /0 545"/49>35? 4A 8 0:2 >0523A3782345 868>0 3: 542 A8289 H/060 H3250::0:/8>8>0;<820411462<532D24:002/07<91632 85> /8B0 3>0523A30> 2/0 877<:0> 35 4<62 85> :<7/ 47<98620:23@45D3:74?05285>745:3:2052/04<62: C094H/8B0H32/608:45:A4<5>2/822/0>014:32345: 4A *) 85> *+ H32/:285> 764::"0G8@3582345 45 @8206389 186237<986: /3: 4<62 :00: 54 106B06:32D 35 2/82811607382345 /0>3:760185730:143520>4<2860@354685> 10631/06896098235?242/0:0;<05703@@0>38209D8A206 2/08773>05285>>3:28570:542?435?242/07460A872 4A 68:/50?93?052 63>35? CD 2/0 1023234506 85> 2/0 3>05232D 4A 2/0 63>06 /0 6389 4<62 /8: 0G160::9D 4C:06B0> 2/82 H/390 2/060 860 K:4@0 >3:760185730:L - 7 - 2/0 0B3>0570 785542 C0 C685>0> KH/499D A89:0L /0 11099820 4<62 /8: 05>46:0> 2/3: B30H 4 @8206389 745268>372345 /8: C005 >0@45:26820> 24 >3:760>32 2/0 :<C:2682<@ + /086?<@0522/822/0@42467D790H8:K542 >8@8?0>L85>/057054235B49B0>3:<52058C90!36:2 35B49B0@052 A94H: A64@ 2/0 47<986 8774<52 85> :<664<5>35? 7367<@:28570: 542 @0609D A64@ 2/0 0G2052 4A B3:3C90 >8@8?0 0745> 35 74993:345: 35B49B35? 8 10>0:26385 82 @4>06820 :100> B0/3790: @8D 0G/3C32 @353@89 0G206346 >8@8?0 H/390 :2399 35A937235?A8289C4>39D35=<6D/0A35>35?4A35B49B0@052 3:2/060A460:4<5> / 420./, "&20 & /0 A35>35? 2/82 2/0 63>06 90A2 2/0 :7050 H32/4<2605>0635?8::3:285704660146235?3:C46504<2 CD2/00B3>057085>2/07367<@:28570:60746>0>/0 - 8 - 745B372345 <5>06 072345 $#& 72 745:0;<0529D :285>:45A36@A44235? # 5 B30H4A2/08C4B0 4352 3 3: 85:H060> 8?835:22/01023234506/0745B372345:<5>06 072345: &(E'%)"85> 072345$#&72860/060CD 8AA36@0> / 4/04/24 ( 4@35? 24 4352 33 /0 ;<0:2345 3: H/02/062/0;<852<@4A3@163:45@052<5>06 072345 '%)" 4A 60;<360: @4>0682345 /0 @8G3@<@ :0520570<5>06 072345'%)"4A3:2H4D086:85> :05205735? @<:2 C0 1641462345820 24 2/0 >0?600 4A 68:/50::50?93?057085>2/02428932D4A7367<@:28570: $% /0 A4994H35? 7367<@:28570: 35 2/3: 4<62-: B30H H866852 60><72345 4A 2/0 :<C:28523B0 3@163:45@052A64@:3G@452/:242/600@452/: - 9 - $$ /078:060:2:4568:/85>50?93?05263>35? H32/4<2 8??68B8235? A87246: :<7/ 8: 3524G3782345 74@102323B0 :100>35?68735? 46 >093C06820 607F90::50:: /0 60746> >40: 542 35>37820 ?64:: 50?93?05704A8>0?6008116487/35?7<918C90/4@373>0 $ !64@ 2/0 8>@3220> A872: 85> 2/0 0B3>0570 C64<?/24560746>3289:40@06?0:2/822/0745><724A 2/0 >0708:0> 785542 C0 74@190209D 4B06944F0> /0 20:23@4530: 4A * 85> *' 35>37820 2/82 2/0 8773>052477<660>458C<:D:26027/4A2/0<@58C8>I 898C<68?3 48> 5086 2/0 663?82345 <39>35? H/060 B0/37<986 @4B0@052 3: 745235<4<: /0 @8206389 45 60746> A<62/06 :<??0:2: 2/82 2/0 >0708:0> 8220@120> 24764::2/0648>8C6<129DH32/4<205:<635?2/822/0 786638?0H8D H8: 79086 46 2/82 8116487/35? B0/3790: /8> :<AA373052 23@0 24 60872 10>0:26385 2/4<?/ 0523290>24764::81<C937648>3:0;<899D<5>06890?89 - 10 - 4C93?82345 24 0G0673:0 608:458C90 7860 85> 78<2345 /0 A839<60 4A 2/0 >0708:0> 24 /00>2/3: C8:37 :8A02D 546@ 745:232<20: 745263C<246D 50?93?0570 H/37/ C608F: 2/0 7/835 4A 0G79<:3B0 C98@0 45 2/0 63>06 /<:452/08>@3220>A872:32785542C0:83>2/822/0 052360 7<918C3932D 60:2: <145 2/0 1023234506 89450 8: 2/0 >0708:0> 89:4 745263C<20> 24 2/0 477<660570 CD 7/44:35?24764::2/0648>828535411462<50@4@052 85> H32/4<2 8>0;<820 B3?398570 /060 3: 54 @8206389 45 60746> 4A 16346 763@3589 852070>052: !36:2"4AA0570 :282<: 3: 8 H099"6074?53M0> @323?8235? A87246 /0 477<6605703:4A$+%&%$(/01023234506/8:A870> 2/0 46>089 4A 26389 811089 85> 60B3:345 4B06 @460 2/85 :3G D086: H/37/ 3: 6090B852 24 7893C682345 4A 1<53:/@052186237<9869DH/060>020660570/8:89608>D C005:06B0>CD2/016470:: - 11 - $' 52/078:04A:<168 A4994H35? 2/0 68234 4A :<168 8 9053052 B30H H8: 28F05 35 :3@3986 7367<@:28570: CD 60><735? 2/0 7<:24>389 :0520570 24 2/600 @452/: 2 2/0 :8@0 23@02/04<62785542C04C93B34<:242/094::4A93A0 85> 2/0 63>06-: A839<60 24 605>06 3@@0>3820 83> /060A460 H/390 2/0 :<C:28523B0 3@163:45@052 3: 60><70>2/0745B372345:85>A350:86090A235287285> 2/0 >0A8<92 :0520570: A46 545"18D@052 4A A350: :/899 89:460@835!<62/062405:<602/0603:54><193782345 35 1<53:/@052 A46 2/0 :8@0 872 4A 68:/ >63B35? 32 3: 79863A30> 745:3:20529D H32/ 2/0 =<63:16<>0570 2/82 072345 &( 4A 8 @3546 4AA0570 @06?0: 3524 072345'%)"4A2/0?68B064AA0570 A461<614:0: 4A:<C:28523B07<:24>3891<53:/@0522/8285D7<:24>389 :052057060A068C9024 072345&(4A3A3@14:0> :/8996<57457<660529D85>3:3585D78:0:<C:<@0>CD 2/0 :0520570 <5>06 072345 '%)" 4A /0 - 12 - :0186820 A350 <5>06 072345 &( 4A 3: /4H0B06 @83528350> $) <C:2852389 A350 /8: C005 3@14:0> <5>06 072345 '%)" 4A C0:3>0: A350: <5>06 072345: &(4A85>$#&4A72835283535?2/0:0A350: 8945?:3>0 8 :/46206 7<:24>389 206@ 8>0;<8209D :06B0: 2/0 83@: 4A >020660570 >05<57382345 85> 8774<528C3932D $ 5 2/0 60:<92 2/3: 4<62 164700>: 24 18:: 2/0A4994H35? /0 63@3589 0B3:345 0232345 3: 8994H0> 35 1862 8:<5>06 3 /0 745B372345: 4A 2/0 1023234506 A46 4AA0570:<5>06 072345:&(85>'%)"4A2/0 - 13 - 85> 072345$#&4A2/042460/3790:72 8608AA36@0> 33 /0:0520570<5>06 072345'%)"4A 3: @4>3A30> 2/0 1023234506 :/899 <5>06?4 63?464<: 3@163:45@052 A46 2/600 ' @452/: 85> 18D 8 A350 4A :%%%"J 35 >0A8<92 4A 18D@052 4A A350 /0 :/899 <5>06?4 :3@190 3@163:45@052A462/600@452/: 333 /0 A350 4A :$%%%" A46 2/0 4AA0570 <5>06 072345&(4AH32/>0A8<92:3@190 3@163:45@052 A46 $ >8D: 85> 2/0 A350 4A :%%"A462/04AA0570<5>06 072345$#&4A 72H32/>0A8<92:3@1903@163:45@052A46 $>8D: 860@83528350> 3B 99 :<C:28523B0 :0520570: 3A 85D :01868209D:231<9820>:/8996<57457<660529D - 14 - B /010232345063:0523290>24:02"4AA<5>06 072345 )# 4A 6 A46 85D 10634> 4A >02052345 89608>D <5>06?450 35 7455072345 H32/2/3:78:0 0?3:26D242685:@322/060746>:242/063894<62 A462/H32/8945?H32/8741D4A2/3:46>06A465070::86D 74@1938570 /0 1023234506 :/899:<6605>06 C0A460 2/0 63894<62H32/35A4<6H00F:A64@24>8D24:06B02/0 @4>3A30> :0520570 A83935? H/37/ 2/0 6389 4<62 :/899 :07<60 /3: 160:0570 85> 74@@32 /3@ 24 163:45 35 87746>8570H32/98H 3+ ' ""* % 3:24 94