Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92346 (KAR)

ANILKUMAR v. M SHIVAKUMAR AND ANR

MFA/204365/2023 · 2025-12-03

P Sree Sudha

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! ! " #$!! % & ' #% ! &( ! !& &!&) * + * " * & !) &!& " & &! % Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "* , , - " # ./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 9.3 :41/;1<9 1=1/<09 9.3 ">6=;3<9 1<6 1?1@6 61936 & !) &!& 210036 /< A & &! % 78 9.3 66/9/A<14 3</A@ /B/4 ">6=3 1<6 1417>@1=/ 5A@ 0.A@9 C9.3 9@/7><14D 033E/<= 3<.1<:3;3<9A59.3:A;23<019/A< & .3 :41/;1<9 1=36 ! 831@0 ?A@E/<= 10 7>/46/<= 21/<93@ ;39 ?/9. 1::/63<9 A< ) !) &! + 1<6 0>553@36 =@/3BA>0 /<F>@/30 3 5/436 :41/; 239/9/A< 735A@3 9.3 9@/7><14 033E/<=:A;23<019/A<A5 0 )!&!!!!#14A<=?/9./<93@309 .39@/7><141593@:A<0/63@/<=9.33<9/@33B/63<:3A<@3:A@6 1?1@636 1 0>; A5 0 +)!!# 14A<= ?/9. /<93@309 19 9.3 @193A5$G23@1<<>; ==@/3B36789.301/6">6=;3<91<6 1?1@6 9.3 :41/;1<9 .10 2@353@@36 9.3 2@303<9 122314 1<6 ;1/<48:A<93<6369.19.3?101=36)831@01<631@</<=1 0>; A5 0 &&!!!# 23@ ;A<9. 10 A< 9.3 6193 A5 1::/63<9 .3:41/;1<93H1;/<369.3A:9A@ .3A:9A@100300369.3 - 3 - 6/017/4/98A59.3:41/;1<919))G7>99.39@/7><14.1091E3< A<48 &G .3:41/;1<9.102@A6>:36;36/:147/4409A10>; A5 0 )$!+$#7>99.39@/7><14.10A<481?1@63610>;A5 0 &+)+!!# >@9.3@ <A 1;A><90 1@3 =@1<936 5A@ 9@1<02A@919/A<3H9@1<A>@/0.;3<91<61993<61<9:.1@=301<6 9.3 A9.3@ .3160 1@3 A< 4A?3@ 0/63 1<6 9.3@35A@3 @3I>30936 5A@3<.1<:3;3<9A59.3:A;23<019/A< 31@69.31@=>;3<905@A;7A9.0/630 ) 31@<36 :A><034 5A@ 9.3 @302A<63<9 :A<93<636 9.19 9.3 ;36/:14 7/440 2@A6>:36 78 9.3 :41/;1<90 1@3 <A9 155/H36 ?/9. 0314 0 23@ 9.3 H ! ;36/:14 7/440 9.3 9@/7><14 .10 @/=.948 1?1@636 1 0>; A5 0 &+)+!!# .3 :41/;1<9 .10 <A9 5/436 1<8 /<:A;3 2@AA5 3 ;39 ?/9. 1::/63<9 A< ) !) &! + 0 23@ 9.3 =>/634/<30 A5 9.3 1@<191E1 9193 3=14 3@B/:30 >9.A@/98 9.3 <A9/A<14 /<:A;3 A5 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 9A 73 91E3< 19 0 !&!# 23@ ;A<9. .3 :41/;1<9 ?10 1=36 ) 831@0 10 23@ H 6.1@ 1@6 1<6 9.3 ;>49/24/3@ ?10 91E3< 19 C $D 0 23@ H 9.3?A><6:3@9/5/:1939.3:41/;1<90>091/<365@1:9>@3 - 4 - A55A>@@/7019@/=.9:.3091<6=A903B3@341:3@1936/<F>@/309A 4/B3@ 4><=0 :.309 1<6 176A;/<14 @3=/A< 5@1:9>@3 A5 @/=.9 ?@/09FA/<91<6:>91<641:3@1936?A>461943593837@A?1<6 5A@3.316 .3 :41/;1<9 3H1;/<36 9.3 A:9A@ J * & 3 100300369.36/017/4/98><63@H K/<?./:./9/00919369.19 9.3:41/;1<90>091/<369@1>;19/::.3091<6176A;/<14/<F>@8 5@1:9>@3 A5 <1014 7A<3 ?./:. /0 =@/3BA>0 /< <19>@3 .3 0:1< A5 :.309 @3B31436 7A9. 0/63 .3;A2<3>;A9.A@1H 1<6 :A441203A5710144><=4A730 023@9.3A703@B19/A<0;163/< 9.3 /<B309/=19/A<0 /< 9.3 6/017/4/98 :3@9/5/:193 9.3 :41/;1<9 @3B31436 5@1:9>@3 A5 <1014 7A<3 1<6 41:3@19/A< A5 4/B3@ 1<6 7/4193@14 .3;A2<3>;A9.A@1H A46 5@1:9>@3 A5 @6 $9. 9A K9. @/70 A< @/=.9 0/63 1<6 04>6=3 1<6 09A<30 /< =144 74163@ 1<6 5/<14489.36/017/4/98?101003003610))G9A9.33<9/@37A68 3<:3 @6 A5 ))G :A;30 9A G >9 9.3 9@/7><14 .10 ?@A<=4891E3<9.36/017/4/9810 &G3@@A<3A>0481<6/9/09A 73@3:9/5/36 3<:39.34A00A55>9>@331@</<=:121:/98/010 ><63@, 0 !&!#' &' $' GL 0 &K&!!# - 5 - .3 9@/7><14 :A<0/63@/<= 9.3 ;36/:14 7/440 1?1@636 1 0>; A5 0 &+)+!!# 9A?1@60 ;36/:14 3H23<030 1<6/9<3360<A/<93@53@3<:3 .3:41/;1<9?10.A02/914/M36 5A@ ) 6180 A<0/63@/<= 9.3 <19>@3 A5 /<F>@/30 1=3 1<6 A::>219/A< A5 9.3 :41/;1<9 1<6 A9.3@ @343B1<9 51:9A@0 9./0 A>@9 5/<60 /9 @310A<1743 9A 1?1@6 1 0>; A5 0 $!!!!# 9A?1@60 21/< 1<6 0>553@/<= 0 !!!!# 9A?1@60 4A00 A5 1;3</9/30 1<6 0 !!!!# 9A?1@60 9@1<02A@919/A< 3H9@1 <A>@/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1@=30 .3 :41/;1<9 ;/=.9 .1B3<A91993<6361<8A9.3@?A@E5A@19431095A>@;A<9.0 3<:3 1 0>; A5 0 ) !!!# 0 !&!# ' ) ;A<9.0 /0 1?1@636 9A?1@60 4A00 A5 /<:A;3 6>@/<= 41/6 >2 23@/A6 3<:39.39A914:A;23<019/A</010><63@, ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 A00A55>9>@331@</<=:121:/98 0 &K&!!# & 36/:143H23<030 0 &+)+!!# 1/<1<60>553@/<=0 0 $!!!!# ) A00A51;3</9/30 0 !!!!# @1<02A@919/A< 3H9@1 <A>@/0.;3<9 1<61993<61<9:.1@=30 0 !!!!# $ A00 A5 /<:A;3 6>@/<= 41/6 >2 23@/A6 0 ) !!!# 2+) - 56 - 6 - $ 31@<36 :A><034 5A@ 9.3 <0>@1<:3 :A;21<8 0>7;/90 9.19 9.3 :A;23<019/A< 1;A><9 1?1@636 78 9.3 9@/7><14.10733<632A0/936735A@39.39@/7><14 + ::A@6/<=489.35A44A?/<=A@63@, / .3122314/0144A?36/<21@9( // .3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 9A 9A914 :A;23<019/A<A5 0 +!K!!#14A<=?/9./<93@309 19 9.3 @193 A5 $G 23@ 1<<>; 5@A; 9.3 6193 A5 239/9/A< 9/44 9.3 6193 A5 @314/M19/A< 10 1=1/<09 0 +)!!#1?1@636789.39@/7><14( /// <0>@1<:3 :A;21<8 /0 6/@3:936 9A 632A0/9 9.3 3<.1<:36 :A;23<019/A< A5 0 +!!#14A<=?/9./<93@309?/9./<A<3;A<9. 5@A;9.36193A59./0A@63@( /B < 0>:. 632A0/9 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 23@;/9936 9A ?/9.6@1? 9.3 3<9/@3 1;A><9 14A<= ?/9./<93@3091::@>36A</9( - 7 - B /63 A@63@ 61936 ! !& &!&) 9.3 :41/;1<9/0<A93<9/94365A@/<93@3095A@9.323@/A6A5 &%6180/<5/4/<=9.3122314 -,6 %$ ' # /09A , 4A ,)+ , "