Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92345 (KAR)

KISHAN LAL v. U.KRISHNA REDDY AND ANR

MFA/202395/2018 · 2025-09-11

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# # $%$&#! # '#"( $$)$) $"$&&" *)+ $"$&&" $"$&&" $"$&&" # !" ##$ % & '!(!)* ) +) ,- .*)."*" ".*( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '!*$** ,)/ , , "# , , - *)*( )*))*0 - - , - % # +$ ) ! # + + ! - )! , (! % - 3 - +) ,- *)"*" ".*( '!*$** ) ,)/ +*$)*) , , "# , , - *)*( - - , )*#)*0 ,- % # !" ##$ % & +) ,- .*)."*" ".*( '!*$** ) - 4 - '!(!)*) ,/ ,) , , "# , , - - - )*))*0 *)*( ,- % # +$ ) ! # + + ! - )! , - 5 - , (! % '!(!)* 0 +) ,- .*)."*" ".*( '!*$** ,!/ )! / 0 , , "# , , - *)*( )*#)*0 - - , - % , 1 , - 2 - "( , 3)*)+#))*( 45 64789 :; <=8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; A>9 , 3)*)#$!)*( 45 64789 :; B7A4CA><5 B=A778>E4>E <=8 -?9EC8>< A>9 AFA@9 DA5589 4> 3)*))*0 9A<89 *)*( :; 8>43@ 4G47 -?9E8 A>9 -A9E4@463@5=3@<H<=8<@4:?>A71 - 6 - ) , 3)*)#"))*( 45 64789 :; B7A4CA><5 A>9 , 3)*)+##)*( 45 64789 :; >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; B=A778>E4>E <=8 -?9EC8>< A>9 AFA@9 DA5589 4> 3)*#)*0 9A<89 *)*( :; 8>43@ 4G47 -?9E8 A>9 -A9E4@463@5=3@<H<=8<@4:?>A71 # ,AB<5 78A94>E <3 6474>E 36 3)*))*0 A@8 <=A< 3> )*+)*0 A< A:3?< ** AC 3> A9E4@ ' A@A;A>D8< CA4> @3A9 >8A@ A4@ACI3>9A 477AE8 B7A4CA>< FA5 D@3B8894>E 4> A?<3 @4BI5=AF :8A@4>E 3 .#0."! A73>E F4<= 3<=8@5 < <=A< <4C8 9@4G8@ 36 -88D :8A@4>E 3 .*)."*" 9@3G8 =45 -88D 4> @A5= A>9 >8E74E8>< CA>>8@=4E=5D889BAC86@3C3DD354<894@8B<43>3>F@3>E 5498 A>9 9A5=89 <3 A?<3 @4BI5=AF A5 A @85?7< 36 F=4B= B7A4CA><5?5<A4>89E@48G3?54>J?@485=8B7A4CA><=A564789 B7A4CD8<4<43>=8<@4:?>A7=A5AFA@989B3CD8>5A<43>=8 B7A4CA><5 =AG8 D@868@@89 ADD8A7 588I4>E 8>=A>B8C8>< 36 B3CD8>5A<43> =8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; =A5 D@868@@89 ADD8A7K?85<43>4>E4<574A:474<; + ,AB<5 78A94>E <3 6474>E 36 3)*#)*0 A@8 <=A< 3> )*+)*0 A< A:3?< ** AC 3> A9E4@ ' - 7 - A@A;A>D8< CA4> @3A9 >8A@ A4@ACI3>9A 477AE8 <=8 98B8A589'A:A>>A FA5 D@3B8894>E 4> A> A?<3 @4BI5=AF :8A@4>E 3 .#0."! A73>E F4<= 3<=8@5 < <=A< <4C8 9@4G8@ 36 <=8-88D :8A@4>E 3 .*)."*"9@3G8=45 -88D 4> @A5= A>9 >8E74E8>< CA>>8@ =4E= 5D889 BAC8 6@3C 3DD354<8 94@8B<43> 4> F@3>E 5498 A>9 9A5=89 <3 A?<3 @4BI5=AF A5 A @85?7< 36 F=4B= A:A>>A 5?5<A4>89 E@48G3?5 4>J?@485A>994894><=8=35D4<A7F=478<AI4>E<@8A<C8>< 8EA7 =84@536<=898B8A589'A:A>>A=AG864789B7A4CD8<4<43>=8 <@4:?>A7=A5AFA@989B3CD8>5A<43>=8B7A4CA><54878EA7 @8D@858><A<4G85 36 <=8 98B8A589 =AG8 D@868@@89 ADD8A7 588I4>E 8>=A>B8C8>< 36 B3CD8>5A<43> =8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>;=A564789ADD8A7K?85<43>4>E4<574A:474<; ! 8A@978A@>89B3?>58763@ADD877A><5A>978A@>89 B3?>58763@@85D3>98><5 0 8A@>89 B3?>587 63@ <=8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; F3?79B3><8>9<=A<C3<3@G8=4B784>5D8B<3@=A54>5D8B<89<=8 -88D 4>G37G89 4> <=8 ABB498>< A>9 =A5 E4G8> =45 @8D3@< A< L A>9 4> <=A< <=8 >?C:8@ 36 G8=4B78 8LAC4>89 45 C8><43>89 A5 .*)."*!" =8 B3><8>95 <=A< G8=4B78 - 8 - 4>G37G894><=8BA5845 .*)."*"A>9<=A<G8=4B7845>3< 4>5D8B<89 :; C3<3@ G8=4B78 4>5D8B<3@ =8@863@8 <=8@8 45 93?:< A@4585 F=4B= G8=4B78 45 4>G37G89 4> <=8 ABB498>< A>9 F=4B= >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; 45 74A:78 <3 DA; B3CD8>5A<43> =86?@<=8@5?:C4<5<=A<<=85A49C3<3@G8=4B784>5D8B<3@=A5 :88> 8LAC4>89 A5 > <=858 E@3?>95 5=8 D@A;5 <3 8L3>8@A<8 <=8 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; 6@3C 74A:474<; <3 DA; B3CD8>5A<43>AC3?>< " 8A@>89 B3?>587 63@ ADD877A><5 4> :3<= ADD8A75 F3?79 B3><8>9 <=A< C3<3@ G8=4B78 4>5D8B<3@ =A5 :88> 8LAC4>89 A5 A>9 4> =45 B=486.8LAC4>A<43> =8 =A5 5D8B464BA77; 5<A<89 <=A< =8 =A5 8LAC4>89 -88D :8A@4>E . *)."*" > @8K?454<43>'L) <=8 -88D >?C:8@ 45 C8><43>89 A5 .*)."*!" A>9 4> =45 @8D3@< 'L A753 <=8@8 45 C8><43> 36 G8=4B78 8LAC4>89 45 .*"."*!" 3>5498@4>E <=8 5AC8 <=8 >5?@8@ 36 -88D :8A@4>E 3 . *)."*"4574A:78<3DA;B3CD8>5A<43>AC3?><86?@<=8@ 5?:C4<5 <=A< B3>5498@4>E <=8 5A49 A5D8B< <=8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 @4E=<7; 64L89 74A:474<; 3> <=8 >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; <3 DA; - 9 - B3CD8>5A<43> 48 >5?@A>B8 3CDA>; 36 G8=4B78 3 . *)."*" ( 8A@>89 B3?>587 63@ ADD877A><5 4> , 3)*)#"))*( 5?:C4<5 <=A< <=8 98B8A589 FA5 AE89 !* ;8A@5A53><=89A<836ABB498><48)*+)*0A>9=8786< :8=4>9B7A4CA><5'78EA7=84@5F=3A@864G84>>?C:8@5=8 @4:?>A7=A58@@894><AI4>E4>B3C8365"***.4>5<8A936 5("!*.A5D8@B=A@<86?@<=8@5?:C4<5<=A<<=8<@4:?>A7 =A5 >3< <AI8> 6?<?@8 D@35D8B<5 8 6?@<=8@ 5?:C4<5 <=A< A5 B7A4CA><5 A@8 64G8 4> >?C:8@5 <=8; A@8 8><4<789 63@ B3>53@<4?CA<<=8@A<8365+****.D8@=8A94<=<=858 =8D@A;5<38>=A>B8C8><36B3CD8>5A<43> $ 8A@>89 B3?>587 63@ ADD877A>< 4> , 3)*)#$!)*(F3?79B3><8>9<=A<<=8B7A4CA><FA5AE89 0* ;8A@5 A5 3> <=8 9A<8 36 ABB498>< A>9 <=8 @4:?>A7 =A5 8@@894><AI4>E4>B3C8365"***.4>5<8A9365("!*.A5 D8@ <=8 B=A@< D@8DA@89 63@ 58<<74>E <=8 945D?<85 4> <=8 3I 9A7A<= 8 6?@<=8@ 5?:C4<5 <=A< 945A:474<; A< !M 45 3> 73F8@ 5498 8 5?:C4<5 <=A< AFA@9 36 B3CD8>5A<43> ?>98@ =8A95 36 DA4> A>9 5?668@4>E 7355 36 4>B3C8 9?@4>E 7A49 ?D - 10 - D8@439A>9735536AC8>4<485A@83>73F8@54984<=<=858 =8D@A;563@8>=A>B8C8><36B3CD8>5A<43> * AG4>E =8A@9 78A@>89 B3?>5875 <=45 3?@< =A5 D8@?5894CD?E>89J?9EC8><5A>9<@4A7 3?@<@8B3@95 5 D8@ <=8 B=A@E8.5=88< A>9 3<=8@ @8B3@95 <=8 G8=4B78 4>G37G89 4> <=8 ABB498>< 45 -88D :8A@4>E @8E45<@A<43> 3 .*)."*" =8 ADD877A><5 4> :3<= <=8 ADD8A75 64789 :; <=8 >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; A@8 >5?@8@ 36 -88D :8A@4>E @8E45<@A<43> 3 .*)."* ' 3<3@ 8=4B78 >5D8B<3@=A5@8B84G89A@8K?454<43>.L)63@4>5D8B<4>E<=8 G8=4B78 4>G37G89 4> <=8 ABB498>< A6<8@ 8LAC4>4>E <=8 G8=4B78 =A5 E4G8> =45 @8D3@<.L > L A>9 L) <=8 >?C:8@ 36 G8=4B78 <3 :88LAC4>89 45 C8><43>89 A5 . *)."*!">L8G8><=3?E=A<B37?C>3$.B@4C8 G8=4B78 DA@<4B?7A@5 <=8 >?C:8@ 36 G8=4B78 45 C8><43>89 A5 .*)."*!" > <=8 @8D3@< <=8 G8=4B78 8LAC4>89 45 C8><43>89 A5 -88D :8A@4>E @8E45<@A<43> 3 .*)."*" .3<3@ 8=4B78 >5D8B<3@ 4> =45 B=486.8LAC4>A<43> =A5 5<A<89<=A<=8=A58LAC4>89<=8G8=4B78:8A@4>E@8E45<@A<43> 3 .*)."*" 3>5498@4>E <=8 5A49 8G498>B8 3>@8B3@9 - 11 - <=8<@4:?>A7=A5@4E=<7;=879<=A<<=8G8=4B784>G37G894><=8 ABB498>< 45 .*)."*" A>9 4< =A5 :88> 8LAC4>89 :; F=3=A5455?89@8D3@<A5D8@LA>9<=8>5?@8@ 36<=85A49G8=4B784574A:78<3DA;<=8B3CD8>5A<43>AC3?>< *) ,+ ) =8AE836<=898B8A589<=89A<836ABB498><A>9 <=8B7A4CA><5F=3A@864G84>>?C:8@54898D8>98><536<=8 98B8A589 A@8 >3< 4> 945D?<8 =8 ABB498>< =A5 <AI8> D7AB8 3> )*+)*0 < <=8 <4C8 36 ABB498>< <=8 AE8 36 <=8 98B8A589FA5!*;8A@5A>9B7A4CA><5A@8=45F468A>963?@ B=479@8>=8<@4:?>A7=A5<AI8><=84>B3C836<=898B8A589 A< 5"***. D8@ C3><= 5 D8@ <=8 B=A@< D@8DA@89 63@ 58<<78C8>< 36 945D?<85 4> <=8 3I 9A7A<= <=8 >3<43>A7 4>B3C8 64L89 63@ <=8 ;8A@ )*0 45 5("!*. =8 <@4:?>A7 3?E=<<3=AG8<AI8><=85A49>3<43>A74>B3C8365("!*. D8@C3><==8<@4:?>A7=A5>3<AFA@9896?<?@8D@35D8B<5A5 <=898B8A589FA5AE89!*;8A@5=8B7A4CA><5A@88><4<78<3 6?<?@8 D@35D8B<5 A< *M 4> G48F 36 <=8 98B4543> 36 <=8 3>1:78 D8L 3?@< 4> <=8 BA58 36 @8D3@<89 4> - 12 - !! =8<@4:?>A7=A5@4E=<7;<AI8>C?7<4D748@A< H#1A>9@4E=<7;989?B<89+<=<3FA@95D8@53>A78LD8>58536 <=898B8A589>G48F36<=8A:3G8<=8B7A4CA><5A@88><4<78 <373553698D8>98>B;A5?>98@ -!./0-!, -!, 1 1 120-! ,! # =8 B7A4CA><5 :84>E F468 A>9 63?@ B=479@8> A@8 8><4<78 <3 B3>53@<4?C 4> A 5?C 36 5+****. 8AB= 48 5)*****. A5 AEA4>5< 5*****. <3FA@95 B3>53@<4?C A>9 5!****. <3FA@95 73G8 A>9 A668B<43> A5 AFA@989 :; <=8<@4:?>A7=8B7A4CA><5A@88><4<78<36?>8@A78LD8>58536 5!***.A>95!***.<3FA@95<@A>5D3@<A<43>3698A9 :39;<3<A74>E<35#****.A5AEA4>5<5)!***.<3FA@95 6?>8@A78LD8>585A>95****.<3FA@95<@A>5D3@<A<43>36 98A9:39;A5AFA@989:;<=8<@4:?>A7 + =8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 @4E=<7; AFA@989 C894BA7 8LD8>585365#+"$. ! >G48F36<=8A:3G8<=8B7A4CA><5A@88><4<78<3 <3<A7B3CD8>5A<43>A563773F5 - 13 - $3 456-7894:-5;<: 894:-5;<: 5=5>646 ?@ ;A<-B>; 3553698D8>98>B; 5)0)!. ) 35536B3>53@<4?C5+****.! 5)*****. # @A>5D3@<A<43> 36 98A9 :39; A>9 6?>8@A78LD8>585 5#****. + 894BA78LD8>585 5#+"$. ;53 -!!, 0 =8B7A4CA><5A@88><4<78<3<3<A7B3CD8>5A<43>36 5+("0*+.A5AEA4>5<5#!***.A5AFA@989:;<=8 <@4:?>A7A73>EF4<=4><8@85<A<<=8@A<8360MD8@A>>?C *) ,+ " =8>J?@89FA5AE890*;8A@5A53><=89A<836 ABB498>< 48 3> )*+)*0 =8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 <AI8> <=8 4>B3C836<=898B8A589A<5"***.D8@C3><= 5D8@<=8 B=A@<D@8DA@8963@58<<78C8><36945D?<854><=8 3I 9A7A<= <=8 >3<43>A7 4>B3C8 64L89 63@ <=8 ;8A@ )*0 45 5("!*. =8<@4:?>A73?E=<<3=AG8<AI8><=85A49>3<43>A74>B3C836 5("!*. D8@ C3><= =8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 @4E=<7; <AI8> <=8 C?7<4D748@H$1=83B<3@F=3A5585589<=8945A:474<;A<#0M =A5:88>8LAC4>89A5)A>9=845>3<A<@8A<893B<3@ 3>5498@4>E <=8 5A49 A5D8B< <=8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 @4E=<7; <AI8> <=8945A:474<;A<!M=8B7A4CA><=A55?5<A4>89=8A94>J?@; - 14 - A>9=8FA5A9C4<<894><=835D4<A763@54L9A;5 3>5498@4>E <=85A49A5D8B<<=8B3CD8>5A<43>AFA@989<3FA@95DA4>A>9 5?668@4>E @8K?4@85 <3 :8 8>=A>B89 6@3C 5(***. <3 5)!***. 7355 36 AC8>4<485 6@3C 5****. <3 5)****. 6339 >3?@45=C8>< A>9 B3>G8;A>B8 B=A@E85 6@3C 5****. <3 5)****. =8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 >3< AFA@9897355364>B3C89?@4>E7A49?DD8@439=8B7A4CA><45 8><4<78<37355364>B3C89?@4>E7A49?DD8@43963@AD8@43936 <=@88 C3><=5 4> A 5?C 36 5("!*. # C3><=5 N 5)0)!*. =8 <@4:?>A7 =A5 @4E=<7; AFA@989 C894BA7 8LD8>585 36 5+*"#). =8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<78 <3 7355 36 6?<?@84>B3C8A5?>98@ -!1 11/0-!! ( > G48F 36 <=8 A:3G8 <=8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<78 <3 <3<A7B3CD8>5A<43>A5?>98@ $3 456-7894:-5;<: 894:-5;<: 5=5>646 ?@ ;A<-B>; 355366?<?@84>B3C8 5+"!*. ) 3FA@95DA4>A>95?668@4>E 5)!***. # 894BA78LD8>585 5+*"#). + 355364>B3C89?@4>E7A49?DD8@439 5)0)!*. ! ,339 >3?@45=C8>< A>9 A<<8>9A>< B=A@E85 5)****. 0 35536AC8>4<485 5)****. ;53 - ! ! - 15 - $ =8 B7A4CA>< 45 8><4<78 <3 <3<A7 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5)"#"#). A5 AEA4>5< 5)*#***. AFA@989 :; <=8 <@4:?>A7F4<=4><8@85<A<<=8@A<8360MD8@A>>?C )* >G48F36<=8A:3G8<=863773F4>E 4 , 3)*)+#))*( A>9 , 3)*)+##)*(64789:;<=8>5?@A>B8B3CDA>; A@8945C45589/ 44 , 3)*)#"))*( A>9 , 3)*)#$!)*( 64789 :; <=8 B7A4CA><5 A@8 A773F894>.DA@</ 444 =8 B7A4CA><5 4> , 3)*)#"))*( 3)*#)*0 A@8 8><4<78 <3 <3<A7 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5+("0*+. A5 AEA4>5< 5#!***. A5 AFA@989 :; <=8 <@4:?>A7A73>EF4<=4><8@85<A<<=8@A<8360MD8@ A>>?C6@3C<=89A<836D8<4<43><477@8A74OA<43>/ - 16 - 4G =8 >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; 5=A77 98D354< <=8 5A49 AFA@9 AC3?>< F4<= 4><8@85< F4<=4> A D8@4393684E=<F88I56@3C<=459A;6A474>EF=4B= 4<4574A:78<3DA;4><8@85<A<<=8@A<836$MD8@ A>>?C/ G =8 B7A4CA><5 4> , 3)*)#$!)*( 3)*))*0 A@8 8><4<78 <3 <3<A7 B3CD8>5A<43> 36 5)"#"#). A5 AEA4>5<5)*#***.A5AFA@989:;<=8<@4:?>A7 F4<=4><8@85<A<<=8@A<8360MD8@A>>?C6@3C <=89A<836D8<4<43><477@8A74OA<43>/ G4 =8 >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; 5=A77 98D354< <=8 5A49 AFA@9 AC3?>< F4<= 4><8@85< F4<=4> A D8@4393684E=<F88I56@3C<=459A;6A474>EF=4B= 4<4574A:78<3DA;<=84><8@85<A<<=8@A<836$M D8@A>>?C/ G44 =8 3@98@ 36 98D354< A>9 @878A58 DA5589:;<=8<@4:?>A74>:3<=<=8B7A4CD8<4<43>5 @8CA4>?>.945<?@:89/ - 17 - G444 =8 ADD3@<43>C8>< 36 B3CD8>5A<43> DA5589:;<=8<@4:?>A74> 3)*#)*0A753 @8CA4>5?>.945<?@:89/ 4L =8 AC3?>< 4> 98D354< :; <=8 >5?@A>B8 B3CDA>; 4> :3<= <=8 ADD8A75 45 3@98@89<3:8<@A>5C4<<89<3<=8<@4:?>A7/ L 8E45<@;4594@8B<89<3@8<?@><=8<@4A7 3?@< @8B3@95 A73>E F4<= A B3D; 36 <=45 -?9EC8>< $6 *$)$)+ ( 45<3 73 )!