Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92339 (KAR)
DODDA DHULAYYA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203476/2025 · 2025-11-17
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92339 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92339 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"#!$%&
' &("&"&
)"*
! " ##
$
!
%"
" #
%
" !
!
& ## '
( ##
!#
") "$
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
%
&& &&+ %
% *
%## (
!!#&&&, %
#
%
# *#
# -! #)
#"#
! -! #)
#"# $
./0/012.3045.613./704183/4..902:61;;1<02:3.;0.6 =448. > <30/ 02 /7. 2>/83. 16 ?>2@>?84 @03.A/02: /7. (3@ 3.4B12@.2/ /1 A12A;8@. .2C803D 020/0>/.@02A>4.5.>302:1!711?0&&&>4 B.322.E83.%F
& / 04 12. 16 /7. .E/3.?.;D @04/83502: /3.2@ 3.6;.A/02:/7.:3144@.3.;0A/01216@8/D>2@>B>/7D12/7.
B>3/ 16 /7. 3.4B12@.2/ >8/7130/0.4 02 @04A7>3:02: /7.03 4/>/8/13D15;0:>/012 (
7. B3.4.2/ B./0/012 04 60;.@ 5D /7. B./0/012.3 4..902: @03.A/012 /1 /7. 3.4B12@.2/ /1 A12A;8@. /7.
B31A..@02:4 020/0>/.@ 82@.3 8;. 16 /7. >2@ 3>2/ 8;.4<70A7>3.B.2@02:402A./7.D.>3&
- 3 -
>4.16/7.B./0/012.304/7>/7.<>4>;>2@;.44 B.3412 1<.G.3 <>4 A8;/0G>/02: /7. ;>2@ 5.>302: D1 5.;12:02: /1 /7. 3.4B12@.2/1G.32?.2/ 82>8/71304.@;D 613 ?13. /7>2 > @.A>@.
7.3.>6/.3 7. ?>@.>2>BB;0A>/0124..902:3.:8;>304>/0121682>8/71304.@ A8;/0G>/0125D60;02:>BB;0A>/01202%13?123.4B124. /7.3.16 >2@3>2/ 1??0//..7.;@ .2C803D >2@:3>2/.@ /7. ;>2@ 5D 13@.3 @>/.@ HHH .4B12@.2/ 1 /7.3.>6/.3 7>@ 0448.@ > 21/0A. @>/.@ &HHHH+ A>;;02:
8B12 /7. B./0/012.3 /1 @.B140/ /7. B3.?08? >?182/ AA13@02:;D B./0/012.3 7>4 B>0@ /7. 4>0@ >?182/ 12 &HHHH+ 2.
>D>??> *1 !70?>DD> <>4 >;41 82>8/71304.@ 1AA8B>/012 >2@ A8;/0G>/012 16 ;>2@ 5.>302: D14>2@7>@>;41485?0//.@>2>BB;0A>/012613 3.:8;>304>/0127.<>4>;41:3>2/.@/7.;>2@5D/7.G.3D 4>?.1??0//..1<.G.3/>902:>@G>2/>:.16/7.:3>2/ /7./703@B>3/D7>@4/>3/.@/102/.36.3.<0/7/7.B144.44012 16/7.B./0/012.3
- 4 -
./0/012.3 02 /7. D.>3 & >BB31>A7.@ 3.4B12@.2/ 1( <0/7 > 3.C8.4/ /1 3.A/06D /7. 3.A13@4 16 30:7/45>4.@12/7.:3>2/02A;8@02:A12@8A/02:/7.483G.D 16 /7. :3>2/ ;>2@ .4B12@.2/ 1( @03.A/.@ 3.4B12@.2/ 1 /1 A12@8A/ 2.A.44>3D .2C803D 02/1 /7. :3>2/ ?>@. >2@/1485?0/>@./>0;.@3.B13/.4B12@.2/1@.B8/.@ 0/448513@02>/./1B3.B>3./7.3.B13/>2@485?0//7.@./>0;
3.B13/
7. 3.G.28. 024B.A/13 7>@ >AA13@02:;D A12@8A/.@ /7. 4B1/ 024B.A/012 B3.B>3.@ /7. @./>0;.@ 3.B13/ >2@ 485?0//.@ 4>?. /1 3.4B12@.2/ 1 ./ >:>02 3.4B12@.2/ 1( 5D 1660A. A1??820A>/012 @>/.@ +&(@03.A/.@3.4B12@.2/ 1 485?0/ /7.@./>0;.@ 3.B13/ >;12: <0/7 /7. ;>2@ :3>2/ 13@.3 3.4B12@.2/ 1( 3.A.0G02: /7. 3.B13/4 631? /7. 48513@02>/. 3.G.28. 1660A.344/>3/.@A12@8A/02:.2C803D02/1/7.:3>2/?>@.02 0/4 B31A..@02:4 5.>302: 28?5.3 1!711?0&& ./0/012.3 02A;8@02: /7. /703@ B>3/0.4 >4 B>3/0.4 02 /7.
.2C803D
718:7 /7.D 7>G. 5..2 >//.2@02: 613 >;; /7.4.
- 5 -
D.>34 3.4B12@.2/ 1( 7>4 21/ B31A..@.@ 683/7.3 A124/3>0202:/7.?/1>BB.>35.613./704183/
.A13@4 3.G.>; /7>/ /7. .2C803D <70A7 <>4 020/0>/.@<0/73.4B12@.2/1(>518/&D.>34>:17>421/ ?>@.>2DB31:3.44<70A704>;?14/>C8>3/.316>A.2/83D 7.@.;>D04@.6020/.;D02.EB;0A>5;. + AA13@02:;D B./0/012 04 .4B12@.2/ 1(04@03.A/.@/1B31A..@<0/7/7..2C803D>2@A12A;8@. /7.4>?.<0/702/73..?12/74631?/7.@>/.163.A.0B/16 A.3/060.@A1BD16/70413@.3
.4B12@.2/ 1( 7>4 4>/ 1G.3 /7. ?>//.3 613 1G.3&D.>34
7.3.613.0/04?>@.A;.>34718;@/7.3.5.
>2D 683/7.3 @.;>D 3.4B12@.2/ 1( 47>;; B.3412>;;D B>D A14/164&B.3@>D631?704B.3412>;>AA182/8/ 16/7.A14/164&447>;;5.B>0@/1/7. B./0/012.3>2@4/1/7. .:>;.3G0A.48/7130/0.4
"+, )&"&* (!
04/1;1
"