Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92338 (KAR)
SHIVAKUMAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/202023/2025 · 2025-12-17
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92338 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92338 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%""
"
&&'() &(( *
! ! "
#
! $ %"&
'
"
'
" " (# %
!& $ %")" &
' ! '
" '
"
" '
%&(
!(! ' ' ) )'
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' *
+")
,-./01234-50-12123426728-59:1,-/..;6-536 /45 ! ;45-< -.1234 ! 37 ",/</12:/ /=/<2> ;</>6,/ /4,21/ !(! 6-->24= /412.20/13<: 9/28 24 <2?- 3(
!(!<-=261-<-59:245,/4;<;</8382.-1/1234 /2.,;< 261<2.1 0-4524= 34 1,- 728- 37 5521234/8 2@28 );5=- /45 )' 245,/4;< 73< 1,- 377-4.-6 0;426,/98- ;45-< -.12346 %!& %& (A%& ! %!&%&37",/</12:/:/://4,21/!(!%73<6,3<1 B"!(!C& ! ,- =261 37 1,- 0<36-.;1234 ./6- 26 1,/1 1,-<- -D2616 / 834=61/4524= 5260;1- 9-1E--4 1,- 0-121234-<6C 7/?28: /45 1,- .3?08/24/41C6 7/?28: E21, <-=/<5 13 /4.-61</8/=<2.;81;</88/45126/88-=-51,/134!(#!(! /1/93;1A(/?E,-41,-.3?08/24/41/45,267/1,-< ,/5 =34- 13 1,- 5260;1-5 8/45 1,- 0<-6-41 /..;6-5 0-<63461<-60/66-534131,-8/45/4502.>-5;0/F;/<<-8
- 3 -
126/88-=-51,/11,-/..;6-5E-<-/<?-5E21,/>427-/45 /4 2<34 <35 /45 1,/1 0-121234-< 3 G ,2@/>;?/< /66/;81-5 1,- .3?08/24/41 E21, /4 2<34 <35 1 26 7;<1,-< /88-=-5 1,/1 24 1,- 6/?- 24.25-41 1,- .3?08/24/41 /863 /66/;81-51,-/..;6-50-<6346346-F;-418:/./6-/45 .3;41-<./6- ./?- 13 9- <-=261-<-5 /=/2461 931, 1,- 7/?282-6*,28-1,-0<-6-410-121234-<6/<-.,/<=-6,--1-5 24 <2?- 3(
!(! 1,- .3?08/24/41 /45 ,26 7/?28:
?-?9-<6/<-/863.,/<=-6,--1-524<2?-3
!(! -/<4-5 .3;46-8 73< 1,- 0-121234-<6 5</E24= /11-41234131,-7/.11,/1/412.20/13<:9/28,/6/8<-/5:9--4 =</41-5 13 1,- .3?08/24/41C6 7/?28: 24 1,- .3;41-<./6- E3;85 6;9?211,/1 21 E/6 24 7/.1 1,-.3?08/24/41C67/?28:
E,3 E-<- 1,- /==<-663<6 /45 1,/1 0-121234-< 3 G ,2@/>;?/<,/66;61/24-561/924H;<2-6/11,-,/456371,- .3?08/24/41 - E3;85 7;<1,-< 6;9?21 1,/1 1,- E3;45 .-<1272./1- 0<35;.-5 /834= E21, 1,- 0-121234 2452./1-6 1,/1 1,- .3?08/24/41C6 7/1,-< ,/6 6;77-<-5 348: / 8/.-</1-5 E3;45341,-?-52/883E-<-:-825341,-8-71625-E,2.,26
- 4 -
3024-5 13 9- 62?08- 24 4/1;<- -/<4-5 .3;46-8 .341-456 1,/1 1,- 5260;1- 26 -66-412/88: 34- /<2624= 3;1 37 /=<2.;81;</8 8/45 /45 1,/1 43 =<2-@3;6 24H;<2-6 /<- ?/5- 3;1 - E3;85 7;<1,-< 6;9?21 1,/1 ?-<- 24@3./1234 37 -.1234(A371,-",/</12:/:/://4,21/!(!./4431 9:216-879-/=<3;45135-4:/412.20/13<:9/28/451,/134 1,- 0<24.208- 37 0/<21: 1,- 0-121234-<6 ,/@- ?/5- 3;1 / ./6-73<=</4137/412.20/13<:9/28
8-/<4-5 2=, 3;<1 3@-<4?-41 8-/5-<61<34=8:30036-51,-0-121234.341-4524=1,/11,- 4/1;<- 37 1,- /88-=/12346 526.836-6 /4 377-4.- 37 =</@- 4/1;<-?3<-0/<12.;8/<8:/4/11-?0113?;<5-</451,/1 1,-.<2?-,/69--4<-=261-<-524@3>24=-.1234(A371,-
",/</12:/:/://4,21/!(!
/@24=,-/<51,-8-/<4-5.3;46-834<-.3<5/45 ;034 /4D23;6 .34625-</1234 37 1,- .,/<=-6,--1 ?/1-<2/8 1,-73883E24=03241/<26-673<.34625-</1234
- 5 -
4-D/?2424=1,- .,/<=-6,--1?/1-<2/8 ?3<- 0/<12.;8/<8: 1,- E3;45 .-<1272./1- 21 26 -@25-41 1,/1 1,- .3?08/24/41 ,/6 6;61/24-5 / 8/.-</1-5 E3;45 34 1,- ?-52/883E-<-:-825341,-8-71625-E,2.,26.-<1272-5139- / 62?08- 24H;<: ,- <-.3<56 7;<1,-< 526.836- 1,/1 1,- 24.25-41,/6<-6;81-524<-=261</123437/./6-/45.3;41-< ./6- /<2624= 3;1 37 / 5260;1- 9-1E--4 1E3 7/?282-6 3@-< /=<2.;81;</8 8/45 1 26 /863 431 24 5260;1- 1,/1 1,- .3?08/24/41C67/?28:E,3/<-7/.24=62?28/</88-=/1234624 1,- .3;41-<./6- ,/@- /8<-/5:9--4 =</41-5 /412.20/13<: 9/2841,-6-.2<.;?61/4.-61,263;<126371,-@2-E1,/1 1,- 0-121234-<6 /<- -41218-5 13 1,- 9-4-721 37 0/<21: 3E 1,/1 1,- .,/<=-6,--1 ,/6 9--4 728-5 /45 1,- 24H;<2-6 2452./1-5/<-62?08-244/1;<-?-<-24@3./123437-.1234 (A 37 1,- ",/</12:/ :/:/ /4,21/ !(! ./4431 9- / 638- =<3;45 13 5-4: /412.20/13<: 9/28 ,- 5260;1- /00-/<6 13 9- 0<-53?24/418: .2@28 24 4/1;<- E21,
- 6 -
.<2?24/8 3@-<134-6 ..3<524=8: 1,26 3;<1 26 24.824-5 13 =</41/412.20/13<:9/28247/@3;<371,-0-121234-<6 # '3< 1,- 73<-=324= <-/6346 1,26 3;<1 0<3.--56 130/661,-73883E24=
,-<2?24/8-12123426/883E-5 ,- <-60345-41G382.- /<- 52<-.1-5 13 <-8-/6- 1,- 0-121234-<6349/28241,--@-41371,-2</<<-6124.344-.1234 E21, <2?- 3(
!(! <-=261-<-5 9: 245/433< ;</8 382.-1/1234/2.,;<261<2.173<1,-377-4.-60;426,/98- ;45-< -.12346 %!& %& (A%& ! %!& /45 %&371,-",/</12:/:/://4,21/!(!6;9H-.1131,- 73883E24=.345212346 2& ,- 0-121234-<6 6,/88 /00-/< 9-73<- 1,- 4@-612=/124= 772.-< E21,24 7271--4 %& 5/:6 7<3?1,-5/1-37<-.-20137/.-<1272-5.30:371,26 3<5-< /45 6,/88 -D-.;1- / 0-<634/8 9345 73< / 6;? 37 6(((((
%;0--6 4- />, 348:&
- 7 -
-/., E21, 1E3 6;<-12-6 73<1,- 82>- 6;? 13 1,- 6/1267/.1234371,-4@-612=/124=772.-< 22& ,- 0-121234-<6 6,/88 .330-</1- E21, 1,- 24@-612=/1234 /45 6,/88 /00-/< 9-73<- 1,- 4@-612=/124=772.-</6/45E,-4<-F;2<-5 222& ,- 0-121234-<6 6,/88 431 24 /4: ?/44-< 1/?0-< E21, 1,- 0<36-.;1234 E214-66-6 3< -@25-4.--21,-<52<-.18:3<2452<-.18: 2@& ,- 0-121234-<6 6,/88 <-=;8/<8: /00-/< 9-73<- 1,-<2/83;<15;<24=1,-.3;<6-370<3.--524=6 ;48-66 -D-?01-5 73< @/825 <-/6346 9: 1,- <2/8 3;<1 @&,-0-121234-<66,/8843124@38@-1,-?6-8@-624 /4:62?28/<3<31,-<.<2?24/8/.12@21:247;1;<- +) &""( %
"
<1 261383