- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " # $ $ % &' ( ) $ ) $ & $ * $ * ! "$ $* + # $** (&"# *$ $ $ * ,- $ * $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) * $ $ &( $ * * $) . $. /$ $ 0,1 233-24 ,1 5,4-6 78 90- :42,;2<9 2=2,<19 90- >6=;-<9 2<6 2?2@6 629-6 3211-6 ,< $ A&( 7890-@,<:,324-<,A@,B,4>6=-2<6$ ,C2823>@2"5A@10A@9D90-9@,7><24E#1--F,<=-<02<:-;-<9A5 90-:A;3-<129,A< 0- :42,;2<9 ;-9 ?,90 2::,6-<9 A< 2<6 1>55-@-6 =@,-BA>1 ,<C>@,-1 0- :42,;2<9 ?21 2=-6 & 8-2@121A<90-629-A52::,6-<92<6?216A,<=2=@,:>49>@24 ?A@F2<6-2@<,<=21>;A5 1 3-@;A<90-5,4-6 :42,; 3-9,9,A< 7-5A@- 90- 9@,7><24 :42,;,<= 2 1>; A5 1 24A<= ?,90 ,<9-@-19 0- 9@,7><24 259-@ :A<1,6-@,<=90--<9,@--B,6-<:-A<@-:A@62?2@6-621>;A5 1% 24A<= ?,90 ,<9-@-19 29 90- @29- A5 G 3-@ 2<<>; 5@A; 90- 629- A5 3-9,9,A< 9,4490- 629- A5 @-24,H29,A< - 3 - ,<:-90-6@,B,<=4,:-<:-?21<A9@-<-?-690-9@,7><240-46 90- @-13A<6-<9 A 9A 6-3A1,9 90- :A;3-<129,A< 2;A><9 ?,90,<& 62815@A;90-629-A590-A@6-@ & <90-3@-1-<9233-24,9,1:A<9-<6-69029213-@ I 90- :42,;2<9 1>192,<-6 =@,-BA>1 ,<C>@,-1 2<6 021 13-<9 0>=- ;-6,:24 -I3-<1-1 1 3-@ 90- -B,6-<:- A5 90- A:9A@ 90- 3-@;2<-<9 3081,:24 6,127,4,98 ,1 27A>9 G 9A 90-@,=094A?-@4,;7>990-9@,7><24021:A<1,6-@-6A<48(G 6,127,4,98 9A 90- ?0A4- 7A68 0- 9@,7><24 -IA<-@29-6 90- <1>@2<:-:A;32<8A<90-=@A><6902990-@-,1B,A429,A<A5 90-3A4,:8:A<6,9,A<5A@<A902B,<=B24,62<6-55-:9,B-6@,B,<= 4,:-<:-2<690>1@-J>-19-65A@3282<6@-:AB-@8 % -2@690-2@=>;-<915@A;7A901,6-1 0-:42,;2<91>192,<-65,B-,<C>@,-1213-@I% K?A><6:-@9,5,:29-2<6,9?21A71-@B-6902990-,<C>@,-12@- 1,;34-,<<29>@-7>990-,<9-@<24,<C>@,-16-9-:9-67890- 1:2< 2@-=@,-BA>1,< <29>@- 1 3-@ 90- 6,127,4,98:-@9,5,:29- 90- :42,;2<9 ,1 1>55-@,<= 5@A; @,=09 2:9A7>42@ 5@2:9>@- ?,90 @,=09329-4425@2:9>@-@,=099,7,25@2:9>@-+:4A1-@-6>:9,A<?,90 - 4 - ,<9-@<245,I29,A<?,90$<2,4,<=5A@9,7,2 *?,903429,<=5A@ 2:-927>42;?,@,<=5A@329-442 9,1241A1929-69029213-@90-L@28@,=093-4B,1 ?,907A900,32<6@,=094-=629-6 ( 0-24-65@2:9>@- A5 2:-92742; 2<6 9,7,2 ?,90 ,;342<9 ,< 1,9> 2<6 90- A:9A@ A3,<-6 9029 90- 9A924 3-@;2<-<9 ,;32,@;-<9 ,< @-429,A< 9A @,=094A?-@4,;7,1G ( -2@<-6:A><1-45A@90-:42,;2<91>7;,91902921 3-@90--B,6-<:-A590-A:9A@90-@-2@-,;342<912<690>1 @-J>-19-65A@=@2<9,<=A51A;-2;A><99A?2@61@-;AB24A5 90- ,;342<9 -@ :A<9@2 4-2@<-6 :A><1-4 5A@ 90- <1>@2<:- :A;32<8 1>7;,91 9029 <A90,<= ,1 ;-<9,A<-6 @-=2@6,<= 90- ,;342<91 78 90- A:9A@ 2<8?0-@- ,< 90- -B,6-<:- A@ ,< 90- 6,127,4,98 :-@9,5,:29- < B,-? A5 90- 6,127,4,98 :-@9,5,:29-90- A:9A@ 021 A71-@B-6 9029 5@2:9>@- A5 90- ;,6 10259 A5 90- 9,7,2 2<6 5,7>42 ?,90 ,<9-@<24 5,I29,A< 2<6 21 3-@ 90- L@28 5@2:9>@-A590-@,=092:-927>4>;?,90,<9-@<245,I29,A< 0- :42,;2<9 021 52,4-6 9A 3@AB- 0,1 ,<:A;- -<:-90-9@,7><24021@,=094892F-<0,1<A9,A<24,<:A;-29 - 5 - 1& 3-@ ;A<90 ,< B,-? A5 90- =>,6-4,<-1 A5 90- 2@<292F2929--=24-@B,:-1>90A@,980-:42,;2<9?21 2=-6 & 8-2@1 2<6 90- ;>49,34,-@ 2334,:274- ,1 DE 0- A:9A@ 211-11-6 90- 6,127,4,98 21 G 2<6 90- 9@,7><24 021 @,=0948 92F-< 90- 6,127,4,98 29 (G A<1,6-@,<= 90- ,<C>@,-1 1>192,<-6 78 90- :42,;2<9 2=- 2<6 A90-@ @-4-B2<9 52:9A@1 90,1 A>@9 5,<61 ,9 @-21A<274- 9A :A<1,6-@ 90- 6,127,4,98 29 G-<:-90-4A11A55>9>@--2@<,<=:232:,98,121><6-@. 1&( LLL GM 1'( ' 0- 9@,7><24 2?2@6-6 2 1>; A5 1&(' 9A?2@61;-6,:24-I3-<1-12<6,9<--61<A,<9-@5-@-<:-0- :42,;2<9?210A13,924,H-65A@62810-@-5A@-:A<1,6-@,<= 90-<29>@-A5,<C>@,-12<63-@,A6A50A13,924,H29,A<90,1A>@9 5,<61 ,9 @-21A<274- 9A 2?2@6 2 1>; A5 1 9A?2@61 32,< 2<6 1>55-@,<=1 1& 9A?2@61 4A11 A5 2;-<,9,-1 1& 9A?2@61 9@2<13A@929,A< -I9@2 <A>@,10;-<9 2<6 299-<62<9 :02@=-1 0- :42,;2<9 ;,=09 02B- <A9 299-<6-6 2<8 A90-@ ?A@F 5A@ 29 4-219 5A>@ ;A<901 -<:- 2 1>; A5 1 ,12?2@6-69A?2@614A11A5,<:A;-6>@,<=42,6>3 - 6 - 3-@,A6 0- :42,;2<9 ,1 -<9,94-6 9A 9A924 :A;3-<129,A< 21 ><6-@. * +,-./01+2.,342 0523 A11A55>9>@--2@<,<=:232:,98 1'( $-6,:24-I3-<1-1 1(' & 2,<2<61>55-@,<=1 1 % A11A52;-<,9,-1 1& @2<13A@929,A< -I9@2 <A>@,10;-<9 2<6 299-<62<9 :02@=-1 1& A11 A5 ,<:A;- 6>@,<= 42,6 >3 3-@,A6 1 3,* .6! 6 7 ,<:-90-6@,B-@A590-A55-<6,<=B-0,:4-?21<A9 02B,<= B24,6 2<6 -55-:9,B- 6@,B,<= 4,:-<:- 23348,<= 90- 3@,<:,34-1 42,6 6A?< ,< 90- :21- A5 @-3A@9-6,< 90- <1>@2<:- :A;32<8 ,1 6,@-:9-6 9A 328 90- :A;3-<129,A< 2<6 429-@ @-:AB-@ ,9 5@A; 90- A?<-@ A5 90- B-0,:4- ::A@6,<=4890-5A44A?,<=. ",# 0-233-24,1244A?-6,<32@9+ - 7 - ",,# 0- :42,;2<9 ,1 -<9,94-6 9A 9A924 :A;3-<129,A<A5 1%'(' 24A<=?,90,<9-@-19 29 90- @29- A5 G 3-@ 2<<>; 5@A; 90- 629- A5 3-9,9,A< 9,44 90- 629- A5 @-24,H29,A< 21 2=2,<19 1% 2?2@6-67890-9@,7><24+ ",,,# 0- <1>@2<:- :A;32<8 ,1 6,@-:9-6 9A 6-3A1,990--<9,@-:A;3-<129,A<2;A><924A<=?,90 ,<9-@-19 ?,90,< A<- ;A<90 5@A; 90- 629- A5 90,1 A@6-@ 2<6 429-@ @-:AB-@ 90- 12;- 5@A; 90- A?<-@ A590-B-0,:4-786>-3@A:-11A542?+ ",B# < 1>:0 6-3A1,9 90- :42,;2<9 ,1 3-@;,99-6 9A ?,906@2? 90- -<9,@- 2;A><9 24A<= ?,90,<9-@-192::@>-6A<,9+ "B# ,6-A@6-@629-6 3211-6A< A % 90- :42,;2<9 ,1 <A9 -<9,94-6 5A@ ,<9-@-195A@90-6-428-63-@,A6A5&'6281 .-7 &% ( $ ,19A.4A. .