- 1 - ! "# $! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$ '#( ) ! " # $ ! %%&" ' %% Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (&)# # ## *%% + , $) & % &("()- # .$/$- %% # .$/$- %% %%# ) # # .$/$ *% + 0 %%% 0 --" % , !+, % %% % --"-/% # )/-) % % ' % % - 3 - 1 % 1 & +%1 %, 234 566758 9:;7< 7=>3?: !+, ?@ >27 ?>?< 723=874=>(//+27<73:5@>7<<7@7<<7;>?54A>27=>B@?< 42?<>, 254 C77: @387; CD >27 =853E5:>4 =25887:F3:F >27 G9;FE7:> 5:; 5H5<; ;5>7; --"-/ 65447; CD >27 ;;3>3?:587:3?<3I389;F75:;#585C9<5F33: ?)/-) 5=>4 F3I3:F <347 >? >27 @383:F ?@ >27 566758 C<37@8D 4>5>7; 5<7 >25> ?: $-$ 5> 5C?9> -- 5E >27 ;7=7547; 5<??J 3G59;;3: 5K3 5:; ?>27<4 H7<7 6<?=77;3:F 3: 5: <>3F5 =5< C75<3:F <7F34><5>3?: ?#& &!) ?: 5: E<52 %38F<3E55F7 >? 7==5 59;3 <5C35@<?E25E425C5; :>7<:5>3?:583<6?<>D;7<5C5; >?C?5<;5:3< :;35@83F2> :?<;7<>?<75=2>273<6?<> - 4 - >27DH7<7><5I783:F@<?E#585C9<5F3>?D;7<5C5;>>25> >3E7 ?: #585C9<5F3&7;5E <?5; :75< #585:??< =<?44 5 523:;<5 %3=L&96 F??;4 I723=87 C75<3:F <7F34><5>3?: ?#&&)-(! H23=2 H54 C73:F ;<3I7: 3: 5 <542 5:; :7F83F7:>E5::7<C?>2>27;<3I7<48?4>=?:><?8?I7<>273< I723=8745:;;5427;5F53:4>75=2?>27<45<7498>?@>27 5@?<7453; 5==3;7:> >27 ;7=7547; 494>53:7; F<37I?94 3:G9<3745:;49==9EC7;>?>273:G9<374 27 =853E5:>4 @387; 5 67>3>3?: 9:;7< 7=>3?: )) ?@ >27 => 477L3:F =?E67:45>3?: @?< >27 ;75>2 ?@ >27 ;7=7547;58?:FH3>23:>7<74> " 6?: 47<I3=7 ?@ :?>3=7 <746?:;7:> ?4 5:; 56675<7; >2<?9F2 =?9:478 5:; @387; H<3>>7: 4>5>7E7:> ;7:D3:F >27 5I7<E7:>4 E5;7 3: >27 =853E 67>3>3?: 27 =853E 67>3>3?: 5F53:4> <746?:;7:> ?;<3I7< ?@ >27 523:;<5%3=L 6 723=87H54;34E3447;746?:;7:>?" >2?9F256675<7;>2<?9F2=?9:478;3;:?>@3875:DH<3>>7: 4>5>7E7:> - 5 - $ : >27 C5434 ?@ >27 6875;3:F4 ?@ >27 65<>374 >27 853E4<3C9:58@<5E7;>273449745:;>27<75@>7<<7=?<;7; >27 7I3;7:=7 27 <3C9:58 CD 3E69F:7; G9;FE7:> 5:; 5H5<;25465<>8D588?H7;>27=853E67>3>3?:5:;278;>25> >27 =853E5:>4 5<7 7:>3>87; >? 5 =?E67:45>3?: ?@ 4(/(---& 58?:F H3>2 3:>7<74> 5> >27 <5>7 ?@ )M 65 5:; ;3<7=>7; >27 746?:;7:> ?4 5:; " >? ;76?43> >27 =?E67:45>3?:5E?9:>5>>27<5>7?@$-M75=258?:FH3>2 3:>7<74> 73:F 5FF<37I7; >27 6<747:> 566758 254 C77: @387; ) 27875<:7;=?9:478@?<>27=853E5:>4254<5347;>27 @?88?H3:F=?:>7:>3?:4 5, 3<4>8D >27 =853E5:>4 5447<> >25> >27 ;7=7547; H54 5F7;5C?9>")D75<45>>27>3E7?@>275==3;7:>5:;25;5 E?:>28D 3:=?E7 ?@ "-- 59;3 3D58 H23=2 34 7J958 >? 4$!/--& CD H?<L3:F 54 5 ;<3I7< 5> 5423 5832 8 >5C3C37:?:>4>3D5;259;3<5C35?6<?I7>27 45E7>27=853E5:>425I76<?;9=7;4585<D=7<>3@3=5>7C5:L 6544C??L5:;>2765446?<>?H7I7<>27544744E7:>?@ - 6 - E?:>28D 3:=?E7 ?@ >27 ;7=7547; 5> 4!---& CD >27 <3C9:58349:G94>3@37;5:;7<<?:7?94 C, 7=?:;8D 54 67< >27 85H 853; ;?H: CD >27 ?:BC87 96<7E7 ?9<> 3: >27 =547 ?@ ! *$"!!+ ! , 3: =5474 H27<7 >27 ;7=7547; H54 478@& 7E68?D7;?<<7=73I7;5@3N7;4585<D5:5;;3>3?:?@$M?@ >27 74>5C83427; 3:=?E7 >?H5<;4 A@9>9<7 6<?467=>4B 34 H5<<5:>7;H27:>27;7=7547;H54C7>H77:>275F7?@"- >? $- D75<4 27 453; 6<3:=3687 42588 C7 566837; >? >27 6<747:>=547 c) 23<;8D =?:43;7<3:F >27 5F7 5:; 5I?=5>3?: ?@ >27 ;7=7547; >27 ?I7<588 =?E67:45>3?: 5H5<;7; CD >27 <3C9:58343:5;7J95>75:;?:>278?H7<43;7 ;, 35C383>D75<:7;=?9:478@?<>27=853E5:>4=?:>7:;4 >25> >27 <3C9:58 254 278; >25> >27 3:49<7< ?@ =5< 5:; ?H:7<?@F??;4I723=875<7835C87>?65D=?E67:45>3?:5> >27 <5>7 ?@ $-M 75=2 3:=7 >27 =853E5:>4 5<7 >23<; 65<>3743:I37H?@G9;FE7:>?@67N?9<>3:>27=547?@ - 7 - <76?<>7;3: >27 =853E5:>45<77:>3>87;>?<7=?I7<>277:>3<7=?E67:45>3?: @<?E 5:D ?:7 ?@ >?<> @7547< 7:=7 =853E5:>4 3:>7:; >? 477L=?E67:45>3?:@<?E>273:49<7<?@>27=5< 3>2 >27 5C?I7 =?:>7:>3?:4 >27 875<:7; =?9:478 4?9F2>>?588?H>27566758 ! : >27 ?>27< 25:; >27 875<:7; =?9:478 @?< >27 :49<5:=7 ?E65:D 254 <5347; >27 @?88?H3:F =?9:>7<& =?:>7:>3?:4 5, 3<4>8D 58>2?9F2 >27 =853E5:>4 =853E >25> >27 ;7=7547; H54 75<:3:F 4$!/--& 67< E?:>2 3: :;35: =9<<7:=D 5:; "-- 3: 59;3 3D58 >27D 25I7 @5387; >? 49C4>5:>35>7 >273< =853E H3>2 4966?<>3:F ;?=9E7:>4 ?:47J97:>8D >27 <3C9:58 254 =?<<7=>8D 5447447; >27 3:=?E7?@>27;7=7547;:?>3?:588D C, 7=?:;8D 43:=7 >27 =853E5:>4 25I7 :?> 74>5C83427; >27 3:=?E7 ?@ >27 ;7=7547; >27D 5<7 :?> 7:>3>87; @?< =?E67:45>3?:>?H5<;4A@9>9<76<?467=>4B - 8 - =, 23<;8D ?: 566<7=35>3?: ?@ ?<58 5:; ;?=9E7:>5<D 7I3;7:=7 5:; =?:43;7<3:F >27 5F7 5:; 5I?=5>3?: ?@ >27 ;7=7547; >27 ?I7<588 =?E67:45>3?: 5H5<;7; CD >27 <3C9:5834G94>5:;<754?:5C87 3>2 >27 5C?I7 =?:>7:>3?:4 >27 875<:7; =?9:478 4?9F2>>?;34E344>27566758 / 75<; >27 875<:7; =?9:478 @?< >27 65<>374 5:; 67<947;>27G9;FE7:>5:;5H5<;?@>27<3C9:58 ( >34:?>3:;3469>7>25>5<??J;37;3:>27<?5;><5@@3= 5==3;7:> ?==9<<7; ?: $-$ ;97 >? <542 5:; :7F83F7:>;<3I3:F?@>27?@@7:;3:FI723=87CD3>4;<3I7< - 27 =853E5:>4 =853E >25> ;7=7547; H54 75<:3:F 4$!/--& "-- 3: 59;3 3D58 67< E?:>2 CD H?<L3:F 545;<3I7<5>542358328>5C3C37:?:>4>3D5;2 59;3 <5C35 ? 6<?I7 >27 45E7 >27 =853E5:>4 25I7 6<?;9=7; 4585<D =7<>3@3=5>7 C5:L 6544 C??L 5:; >27 65446?<>>?42?H>25>=853E5:>?H3@7?@>27;7=7547; H54<7=73I3:FE?:7D@<?E>27294C5:; D>2747<7=?<;4 - 9 - 3> 34 I7<D =875< >25> ;7=7547; H54 F7>>3:F 4585<D ?@ 4$!/--&6E ==?<;3:F8D >27 E?:>28D 3:=?E7 ?@ >27 ;7=7547;254>?C75447447;544$!/--&67<E?:>2 ? >275@?<7453;3:=?E7$M254>?C75;;7;?:5==?9:>?@ @9>9<7 6<?467=>4 3: I37H ?@ >27 85H 853; ;?H: CD >27 ?:4>3>9>3?: 7:=2 ?@ >27 96<7E7 ?9<> 3: -$" !. +496<5, 294 >27 E?:>28D 3:=?E7 =?E74 >? 4!$-& 2767N=?9<>3:>27=547?@ ! #! ! $" $' ( ! 254278;>25>>27=?4> ?@ 83I3:F 3: @?<73F: =?9:><374 34 23F2 : >27 453; =547 ;7=7547;H5483I3:F3:?255:;>27<7@?<7>2767N=?9<> 25;;7;9=>7;"-M?@>273:=?E7?@>27;7=7547;>?H5<;4 67<4?:587N67:474 27<7@?<7 <78D3:F ?: >27 453; ;7=343?: ?@ >27 67N ?9<>3>34566<?6<35>7>?;7;9=>"-M?@>273:=?E7?@>27 ;7=7547; 67<4?:58 7N67:474 ==?<;3:F8D >27 3:=?E7 ?@ - 10 - >27 ;7=7547; =?E74 >? 4"$-& 6E 27 ;7=7547; H545F7;5C?9>")D75<45>>27>3E7?@>275==3;7:>5:; E98>36837< 56683=5C87 >? 234 5F7 F<?96 34 AB 294 >27 =853E5:>45<77:>3>87;>?=?E67:45>3?:?@/0 0 01 +4"$-OO,?:5==?9:>?@A8?44?@;767:;7:=DB : 5;;3>3?: >27 =853E5:>4 5<7 7:>3>87; >? =?E67:45>3?: ?@ /1 ?: 5==?9:> ?@ A8?44 ?@ 74>5>7B 5:; =?E67:45>3?: ?@ /1 ?: 5==?9:> ?@ A@9:7<587N67:474B853E5:>?H3@7?@>27;7=7547;34 7:>3>87;@?<=?E67:45>3?:?@/19:;7<>27275; ?@18?44?@46?9458=?:4?<>39E1 " :I37H?@>2785H853;;?H:CD>2796<7E7?9<>3: >27 =547 ?@ - !. +496<5, =853E5:>?4>?"=238;<7:?@>27;7=7547;5<77:>3>87; @?<=?E67:45>3?:?@/175=29:;7<>27275;?@ A8?44?@65<7:>58=?:4?<>39EB5:;=853E5:>?$E?>27<?@ >27;7=7547;347:>3>87;@?<=?E67:45>3?:?@/1 9:;7<>27275;?@A8?44?@@38358=?:4?<>39EB - 11 - $ 294 >27 =853E5:>4 5<7 7:>3>87; >? >27 @?88?H3:F =?E67:45>3?: 2345/678595:4; :84;45746:/ 295785 '/( ?44?@;767:;7:=D )!))-- 9:7<587N67:474 $--- ?44?@74>5>7 $--- ?44?@46?9458=?:4?<>39E "---- ?44?@%5<7:>58=?:4?<>39E ---- ?44?@38358=?:4?<>39E "---- 76< 0 0 " ) :<7467=>?@835C383>D34=?:=7<:7;>2767N?9<>3: >27 =547 ?@ " =# ) !! $" !<76?<>7;3:' ( ! >254278;54@?88?H4 - 12 - ! " # ! # $ # # # % # & - 13 - : I37H ?@ >27 5C?I7 G9;FE7:> >27 =853E5:>4 5<7 7:>3>87;>?<7=?I7<>27=?E67:45>3?:@<?E5:D?:7?@ ==?<;3:F8D >27 :49<5:=7 ?E65:D 34 ;3<7=>7; >?;76?43>>277:>3<7=?E67:45>3?:5E?9:>H3>283C7<>D>? <7=?I7<$-M?@>275H5<;5E?9:>@<?E>27?H:7<?@>27 523:;<563=L96F??;4I723=87C75<3:F?#&&&)-(! ! :>27<7498>>27@?88?H3:F?<;7<3465447; 5, 27566758346<<?4:8536;7 C, 27G9;FE7:>?@>27853E4<3C9:5834E?;3@37; =, 27=853E5:>45<77:>3>87;>?5>?>58=?E67:45>3?:?@ /0 01 54 5F53:4> 4(/(---& 5H5<;7; CD>27<3C9:58 ;, 27 :49<5:=7 ?E65:D +3:49<7< ?@ =5< C75<3:F ?#&&&!), 34 ;3<7=>7; >? ;76?43> >27 =?E67:45>3?:5E?9:>58?:FH3>23:>7<74>5>)M65 @<?E >27 ;5>7 ?@ @383:F ?@ >27 =853E 67>3>3?: >388 >27 ;5>7?@<7583K5>3?:H3>23:567<3?;?@43NH77L4@<?E - 14 - >27 ;5>7 ?@ <7=736> ?@ 5 =?6D ?@ >234 G9;FE7:> 27 :49<5:=7 ?E65:D 34 5> 83C7<>D >? <7=?I7< $-M ?@ >27 =?E67:45>3?: 5E?9:> @<?E >27 ?H:7< ?@ >27 523:;<563=L96F??;4I723=87C75<3:F?#&&& )-(! 7, 27 566?<>3?:E7:> ;76?43> 5:; <787547 ?@ 5E?9:> 42588 C7 E5;7 3: 5==?<;5:=7 H3>2 >27 >7<E4 ?@ >27 5H5<;?@>27<3C9:58 !:1 '$!( & !:1 '"&# "( & 34>?8?(