Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92326 (KAR)
ISMAIL SAB v. THE ASSISTANT REGISTAR
WP/203950/2025 · 2025-12-12
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92326 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92326 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%#& # #
' (#)
! "# $$$
" $"
" $" %
&$"
'
(
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" $ %
$ $ %
! ) $$"
""
"" $$"
""
&$""
' *"
"(
# $" "
"+"""
$"( # " " $""
" $"" % " ,% "") " " $ $" " " " ""
" " % " $
""" ! $"" ( " # "
" ""
$"
"
"
$"
"
#""
"- *
- 3 -
./ 0/121234/56 7892:24; 13 </ 1./ :/:</56 3= 5/6034>/41 "3!330/5912?/ 372/1@ 95/ </=35/ 1.26 3A516//B24;=3883C24;5/82/=D6 E(C5213=:94>9:A6>25/7124;1./5/6034>/416 13 73462>/5 1./ 5/05/6/41912346 >91/> % 94>,%2>/44/FA5/94>94>0/5:21 1./0/121234/5613?31/94>7341/61241.//46A24;1./ /8/71234613</./8>34%94>98630/5:21 1./: 13 =28/ 43:24912346 13 1./ !5> 5/6034>/41 6372/1@ (66A/94@C5213535>/535>25/71234961.2634D<8/ 3A51>//:6=21247257A:61947/63=1./796/G
1261./796/1.911.//8/712346131./ 395>3= 25/71356 3= 5/6034>/41 "3!372/1@ 26 67./>A8/> 13 </ ./8> 34 % 94> 1./ 798/4>95 3= /?/416 .9?/ 985/9>@ <//4 266A/> /==/712?/ =53: %% .91 1./ 0/121234/5695/ 1./ <3553C/56 94>C21.3A1 >A/0537/663= 89C 1./25 49:/6 .9?/ 431 <//4 2478A>/> 24 1./ 8261 3= /82;2<8/ ?31/56 ./5/=35/
1./@ .9?/ <//4 >/42/> 3= 94 300351A421@3=095127209124;241.//46A24;/8/71234/47/ 1./0/121234
- 4 -
! /954/>73A46/8=351./0/121234/566A<:2161.91 43300351A421@C96053?2>/>131./0/121234/563=./9524; </=35/.38>24;1./:24/82;2<8/13</2478A>/>241./82613= /82;2<8/ ?31/56 / 9863 6A<:216 1.91 1./ 0/121234/56 .9?/ 985/9>@ 5926/> 1./ 3<H/712346 </=35/ 1./ 66261941 F1/46234 ==27/5 96 0/5 1./ >25/712346 3= 66261941 /;261595
330/5912?/372/1@5/6034>/41"3
/954/>73A46/8=351./0/121234/566A<:2161.91 1./ 0/121234/56 .9?/ 985/9>@ 6A<:211/> 5/05/6/4191234 >91/> % 94> ,% 91 44/FA5/6 94> 5/60/712?/8@0A56A94113C.27.1./66261941/;261595
3 30/5912?/ 372/1@ .96 985/9>@ 266A/> >25/712346 13 1./ 66261941 F1/46234 ==27/5
/3>A59;9
13 /4IA25/ 94> 6A<:21 1./ 5/0351 ?2>/ 73::A42791234 >91/> % 053>A7/> 91 44/FA5/ / 6A<:216 1./5/=35/ 1./ 0/121234/56 </ 0/5:211/> 13 0951272091/ 24 1./ /8/71234 6A<H/71131./3A173:/3=05/6/410/121234
- 5 -
4 5/60346/
8/954/> 19B24; 43127/ =35 5/6034>/41"3694> 6A<:216 1.91 1./ 266A/ 5926/> <@ 1./ 0/121234/56 26 C21.
5/;95> 13 05/09591234 3= /8/713598 8261.911.263A51.967346261/418@./8>241./82;.13=1./ 89C892>>3C4<@1./0/F3A511.91241/5?/41234>A524;
1./ 0537/66 3= /8/71234 9=1/5 1./ 266A947/ 3= 798/4>95 3= /?/416
IA/6123424; 1./ 05/09591234 3= /8/713598 53886
C288 .9?/ 13 </ 5/615271/> 94> 09512/6 </ 5/8/;91/> 13 .9?/ 5/>5/6698 A4>/5 1./ 053?26234 3= /71234 +% 3= 1./ 954919B9 330/5912?/ 372/12/6 71
,, /47/
./ 6A<:216 1.91 0/121234/56 24 1.26 796/ 96 C/88 C288 </ 5/8/;91/>13.9?/1./69:/5/:/>@
./692>6A<:2662342619B/4345/735> + 1266/118/>036212343=89C1.911./>260A1/13 1./ 05/09591234 3= /8/713598 53886 /?/4 24 5/60/71 3= 1./ /8/712346 13 1./ 330/5912?/ 372/1@
09519B/ 1./ 7.95971/5 3= >260A1/ 13 1./ /4125/ /8/71234 0537/66 "3 HA>27298 241/5?/41234 26 0/5:2662<8/ 9=1/5 266A947/ 3=
- 6 -
798/4>95 3= /?/416
2= 6A7. 241/5?/41234 26 431 =35 1./ 0A5036/3==A51./524;<@79A6/3=/8/71234
.26 3A51 24 1./ 796/ 3=
24 #$"3,+ %! 94> 7344/71/> :911/56 >91/> %! 94> 24 1./ 796/ 3=
24 >91/> !"! .96 5/8/;91/> 1./ 0/121234/56 13 9?928 1./ 5/:/>@ A4>/5 /71234 +% 3= 1./ 954919B9330/5912?/372/12/671247/1./0/121234/56 ./5/2495/9863621A91/>62:2895131./0/121234/56241.36/ 0/1212346
1./=3883C24;J
'9( ./0/12123426#$ '<( 247/ 0A56A941 13 1./ 5/05/6/41912346 >91/> % 94> ,% 053>A7/> 91 44/FA5/6 94>
1./ 66261941 /;261595 3= 330/5912?/ 372/1@ <@ .26 73::A42791234 >91/> % 91 44/FA5/ .96 985/9>@ 7988/>=355/0351
1./66261941F1/46234==27/5
- 7 -
6.988/4IA25/94>6A<:21.265/0351967988/>=35 C21.24>9@6 '7( ./ 66261941 /;261595 6.988 1./5/9=1/5 0966 9005305291/35>/56 34 1./ 692> 5/05/6/41912346 9144/FA5/694>C21.24>9@6=53:1./ >91/ 3= 5/7/201 3= 6A7. 5/0351 =53: 1./ 66261941F1/46234==27/5 '>( ./ 0/121234/56 95/ 91 82</51@ 13 2421291/ >260A1/ 0537//>24;6 A4>/5 /71234 +% 3= 1./ 954919B9 330/5912?/ 372/12/6 71 </=35/ 1./5/6034>/41"3
2=5/IA25/>94>9>?26/>
*( '# #) &
261"38"3 $