- 1 - !" #$%$$ $ & '&()* !'&)) + ! " # # $%$"& ' $%$& #"( ) #! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # *% # ! %&$ # # ## +*!,! # + " # "!-! .!..! ! /! # "0%0 # # ) # 1 ) 1 )! 23 435.5.6738 93.7: 523 ;6<3 =>>?;3@ .7 8.,3 6%&$6A=@:.8.6,376<.>35=5.6783:.;5383@A68 523 6AA37>3; 4?7.;2=9<3 ?7@38 3>5.67 +*!,! 6A 2=8=5.B= B=B= =72.5= & A68 ;2685 C &D! ?7@383>5.67;+=7@"6A5238653>5.676A2.<@837A86, 3E?=< AA37>3; >5 &" A68 ;2685 C >5D! =7@ ?7@383>5.67;"!-!.!..!=7@!/!6A523>23@?<3@ =;53;=7@>23@?<3@8.93;83/375.676A586>.5.3;!>5 "0%0 FA68 ;2685 C ! >5D!G 76- 437@.7: .7 43>.=< =;3 6+&$ 67 523 A.<3 6A <3=873@ .;58.>5 - 3 - =7@3;;.67;)?@:3=@:.8..;;33H.7:5637<=8:32.,67 83:?<=89=.< 3=8@8.=73;2=.H<3=873@>6?7;3<A68523 435.5.67388. 64=<H8.;27= =@=/ <3=873@ .:26?85 6/387,375 <3=@38 A68 83;467@375 6" I 5=53 =7@ 8. =J3;2 6@@=,=7. <3=873@ >6?7;3< A68 83;467@375 638?;3@523,=538.=<;6783>68@ 7 /.3- 6A 523 8./=< >675375.67; ?8:3@ 9B 523 <3=873@>6?7;3<A6896525234=85.3;52346.7552=5-6?<@ =8.;3A68,B>67;.@38=5.67.; B=7;-3856523=96/346.75.;.7C DA68 523A6<<6-.7: * 23/.>5.,2=@A.<3@523A.8;5.7A68,=5.67=:=.7;5 =>>?;3@=<<3:.7:52=5;23.;=:3@"'B3=8;=7@;5?@B.7:.7 - 4 - "&52 ;5=7@=8@ 23 =>>?;3@ @3/3<643@ .75.,=>B -.52 238 =7@.7@?>3@23856<6/32.,2?;523B-383.7<6/3-.52 673=765238;.7>35-6B3=8;23?;3@56=5537@523 <=;;3;9B58=/3<.7:.7523=?568.>H;2=-93<67:.7:56523 =>>?;3@435.5.6738 5 .; =<<3:3@ 52=5 523 435.5.6738 67 ;3/38=< 6>>=;.67; .7@?>3@ 523 /.>5., :.8< =7@ >6,,.553@ =::8=/=53@ 437358=5./3 ;3E?=< =;;=?<5 7 &"&* =5 $&&4,23=:=.7>6,,.553@523;.,.<=86AA37>3237 523/.>5.,83K?3;53@523=>>?;3@56,=88B2382383A?;3@ 523 ;=,3 67 523 :86?7@ 52=5 ;23 93<67:; 56 >23@?<3@ 8.932383A683;23A.<3@523A.8;5.7A68,=5.6783K?3;5.7: 523 46<.>3 56 83:.;538 523 >=;3 =7@ .7.5.=53 =>5.67 =:=.7;5 523=>>?;3@A538>67@?>5.7:.7/3;5.:=5.67>2=8:3;2335 -=;>=,35693A.<3@A68523=96/3;=.@6AA37>3; $ 3=873@>6?7;3<A68523435.5.67382=;486@?>3@ 523 >64B 6A 523 ;5=53,375 6A 523 /.>5., 83>68@3@ 9B 523 <3=873@=:.;58=53?7@383>5.67"%6A 2=8=5.B==:=8.H ?8=H;2==72.5=&>>68@.7:56523;5=53,375;23 /6<?75=8.<B =>>6,4=7.3@ 523 435.5.6738 =7@ 523B 2=@ - 5 - 42B;.>=< 83<=5.67;2.4 3=873@ >6?7;3< A68 523 435.5.6738 ;?9,.5; 52=5 523 3/.@37>3 6A 523 -.573;;3; 2=; 9337 83>68@3@ 9B 523 8.=< 6?85 =7@ 523 /.>5., 2=; 5?873@ 26;5.<3 23 2=; 765 ;?446853@ 523 >=;3 6A 523 486;3>?5.67 2.; A=>5 .; A=.8<B >67>3@3@ 9B 523 <3=873@ >6?7;3<A6883;467@3756 + 5 .; 765.>3@ 52=5 523 435.5.6738 .; =:3@ B3=8;.;@35375.67.7>?;56@B,=B98.7:2.,.7>675=>5 -.52 2=8@ >683 >8.,.7=<; 2383A683 @35375.67 6A 523 435.5.6738.7>?;56@B-6?<@=,6?7556.7A8.7:3,375562.; 8.:25 56 <.A3 =7@ <.9385B 7@38 ;?>2 >.8>?,;5=7>3; @6 765 A.7@ =7B 83=;67 56 @35=.7 523 435.5.6738 .7 >?;56@B 37>3=,6A52364.7.6752=5523435.5.6738.;375.5<3@56 93 37<=8:3@679=.< ;?9J3>5 56 >67@.5.67;-2.>2-.<<5=H3 >=836A523.75383;56A523486;3>?5.67 ' >>68@.7:<B =7;-38 523 =96/3 46.75 .7 523 =7@486>33@564=;;523A6<<6-.7: - 6 - 23435.5.67.; 23 435.5.6738 .; 68@383@ 56 93 37<=8:3@ 67 9=.< .7 8.,3 6%&$ 6A =@:.8. 6,37 6<.>3 5=5.67 76- 437@.7:.743>.=<=;36+&$67523A.<36A<3=873@ .;58.>5=7@3;;.67;)?@:3=@:.8.67695=.7.7:523967@ .7 = ;?, 6A ;&&&&& ?433;-6 =H2; 67<B! -.52 5-6 ;?835.3; A68 523 <.H3;?, 56 523 ;=5.;A=>5.67 6A 523 J?8.;@.>5.67=<6?85;?9J3>556523A6<<6-.7:>67@.5.67; =! 23 435.5.6738 ;2=<< 765 >6,,.5 ;.,.<=8 6AA37>3; 9! 23 435.5.6738 ;2=<< 765 5283=537 68 5=,438-.52523486;3>?5.67-.573;;3; >! 23 435.5.6738 ;2=<< =443=8 93A683 523 6?85=;=7@-23783K?.83@ A .7 >=;3 523 435.5.6738 /.6<=53; =7B 6A 523 >67@.5.67; =; ;5=53@ =96/3 523 486;3>?5.67 -.<< 93 =5 <.9385B56,6/35238.=<6?85;33H.7:>=7>3<<=5.676A9=.< - 7 - 7A?87.;2.7:523;?835.3;9B523435.5.67385238.=< 6?85 .; =5 <.9385B 56 @.83>5 523 7/3;5.:=5.7: AA.>38 56 /38.AB 523 >6883>573;; 6A 523 =@@83;; =7@ =?52375.>.5B 6A 523@6>?,375;A?87.;23@9B523435.5.6738=7@523;?835.3; =7@=834685,=B93>=<<3@A68.752=583:=8@-2.>2.;56 93 ;?9,.553@ 9B 523 7/3;5.:=5.7: AA.>38 -.52.7 $ @=B; 238.=<6?8567;=5.;A=>5.67,=B486>33@56=>>345523 ;?835.3;A685234?846;36A83<3=;.7:523435.5.6738679=.< ,* &$$) % .;56"<6"'