- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! " #$ % % # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % #$ % #$ % #$ % #$ & '#($) * # & '#($# %+)$%)%# , % %, * -* %-)+%). %).$ %)* & - 3 - / # 012345012678094:;<=;79:0> <;2 4501??0>>194193 ;@902 ;< 450 A05B=>0 193 45020 B: 9; 20?20:09414B;9 <;2 =>1B8194: % 5B: 1??01> B: ?20<02203 CD 450 B9:7219=0 =;8?19D 161B9:4 450 1@123 ;< 450 2BC791> B9 ;%).$ %)* 31403 %-)+%). ?1::03 CD 450 ;4;2 ==B3094 >1B8:2BC791>BE1D?721<;2:5;24F4502BC791>G * 90 7812 145;3 1603 ( D012: 804 @B45 19 1==B3094 ;9 %#)%)* B: ?12094: <B>03 1 =>1B8 ?04B4B;9 C74 372B96 450 ?09309=D ;< 450 ?04B4B;9 :0=;93 ?04B4B;902 8;45023B031::7=5450:BC>B96:;<45030=01:03 B0C2;4502:1938122B03:B:402:@020C2;7654;920=;231: 20:?;93094;:%14;%050D<B>031=>1B8?04B4B;9=>1B8B96 =;8?09:14B;9 ;< #))))) 50 2BC791> =;9:B302B96 094B20 0AB309=0 ;9 20=;23 6219403 19 18;794 ;< :%(%)) '@B45B94020:4144502140;<$H?0219978<2;8 - 4 - 450 3140 ;< ?04B4B;9 4B>> 201>B:14B;9193 3B20=403 20:?;93094 ;%4;30?;:B4450=;8?09:14B;9 + 662B0A03 CD 450 :1B3 ;2302 450 9:7219=0 ;8?19D ?20<02203 45B: 1??01> 193 81B9>D =;9409403 4514 20:?;93094 ;* 2081B903 0I ?1240 1: :7=5 450 1??0>>194 <B>03 1 @2B4409 :41408094 0 <724502 :41403 4514 1==B3094 ;==72203;9>D3704;45021:5193906>B609432BAB96;<450J 27:5B02 E00? 193 450 =2B8B91> =1:0 @1: 1>:; 206B:40203 161B9:4 450 32BA02 ;< 450 E00? ;22D @1: ?12K03 ;9 450 0I42080>0<4:B30;<4502;13@B450I42080=120193=174B;9 C74 450 ;22D 32BA02 3B3 9;4 ?;::0:: ?028B4 193 <B490:: =024B<B=140193457:B418;794:4;AB;>14B;9;<450=;93B4B;9: ;<450?;>B=D501??0>>19451:?2;37=03I+'0I421=4;< '06B:40281B941B903CD C74B4@1:9;4=;9:B30203CD 4502BC791>50201:;9B96;<4502BC791>:7<<02:<2;89;9' 1??>B=14B;9 ;< 450 E73B=B1> 8B93 5020<;20 20L70:403 450 =;7244;8;3B<D450;2302 # 9 %#)%)* 450 32BA02 ;< 450 >;22D C012B96 978C02 '%* #+-+ @1: ?12K03 ;9 450 8B33>0 ;< 450 2;13 - 5 - @B45;74B93B=14;2;2:B691>;2>B654:5032BA02;<450=27B:02 C012B96 06B:4214B;9 ;'** ')- =180 B9 1 21:5 193 906>B6094 819902193 31:503 450 ?12K03>;22D 145;3 @1: ?2;=003B96 B9 1 =27B:02 0 :7:41B903 B9E72B0: 193 3B03 : ?02 450 =;94094B;9 ;< 450 1??0>>194 450 32BA02 ;< 450 >;22D 51: 9; <B490:: =024B<B=140 50 <B490:: =024B<B=140 @1: A1>B3 <2;8 -)%%)) 4; $)%%) 193 B4 @1: 2090@03 7?4; ()%%)%1402B4@1:9;42090@03==B3094513;==72203 ;9 %#)%)* 193 457: 1: ;9 450 3140 ;< 1==B3094 45020 @1: 9; A1>B3 <B490:: =024B<B=140 50 2BC791> 51: ;C:02A03 4514 450 =;94094B;9: ;< 20:?;93094 ;:% 4; + B: 9;4 :7<<B=B094 4; 5;>3 4514 A05B=>0 @1: 9;4 51AB96 A1>B3 <B490:: =024B<B=140 193 450 B9:7219=0 =;8?19D <1B>03 4; ?2;A0 450 :1B3 1:?0=4 50 :1B3 201:;9B96 ;< 450 2BC791> B: 9;4 ;9 ?2;?02 1??20=B14B;9 ;< <1=4: 38B4403>D 1: ;9 450 3140 ;< 1==B309445020@1:9;<B490::=024B<B=140 $ 74 450 =;79:0> <;2 450 ;@902 ;< 450 A05B=>0 =;94093034514450?;>B=DB::703CD4509:7219=0 ;8?19D @1:A1>B3<2;8%*)%%)*4;.)*%)+:;94503140;< B::7B96 450 ?;>B=D B4 B: <;2 450 B9:7219=0 =;8?19D 4; A02B<D - 6 - @504502450A05B=>0@1:51AB96A1>B3<B490::;29;45;765 450 <B490:: @1: 9;4 2090@03 1<402 %)% 450 ?;>B=D @1: B::703B9450D012%)*193450?;>B=D@1:B90IB:409=01:;9 450 3140 ;< 1==B3094 : :7=5 450 9:7219=0 =;8?19D B: >B1C>0 4; ?1D 450 =;8?09:14B;9 193 4 B: <;2 450 9:7219=0 ;8?19D 4; A02B<D @504502 450 A05B=>0 @1: 51AB96 A1>B3 <B490:: ;2 9;4 @5B>0 B::7B96 450 ?;>B=D 74 450 9:7219=0 ;8?19D<1B>034;A02B<D450:1805020<;20450B9:7219=0 =;8?19D=199;4C00I08?403<2;8?1DB96450>B1CB>B4D;9450 62;793 4514 45020 @1: 9; A1>B3 <B490:: 1: ;9 450 3140 ;< 1==B3094 - 72B96 450 ?09309=D ;< 450 1??01> <B2:4 ?04B4B;902 <14502 ;< 450 30=01:03 1>:; 3B03 09=0 B4 B: 1??2;?2B1404;3B20=44501??0>>194B:3B20=4034;30?;:B4450 18;7941@12303CD4502BC791> ( 945020:7>4450<;>>;@B96;2302B:?1::03 B 501??01>B: BB 501??0>>194B:3B20=4034;30?;:B4:%(%)) ' 1@12303CD4502BC791>@B45B94020:4144502140 - 7 - ;< $H @B45B9 ;90 8;945 <2;8 450 3140 ;< 45B: ;2302 BBB 9 :7=5 30?;:B4 450 >061> 50B2: ;< 20:?;93094 ;% :BC>B96: ;< 450 30=01:03 120 ?028B4403 4; @B45321@450:1B318;7940L71>>D BA 8;7941>2013D30?;:B403B:4;C04219:<022034; 450 )*+ %$ ' # B:4;>;(