Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92308 (KAR)
BALABHEEM @ BHEEMANNA S/O AMBALAPPA v. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR
MFA/201086/2023 · 2025-12-08
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92308 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92308 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$ $$
%&' () $$ *
+%&'
(
)
! "
"#$#%&'
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
') '
(
%'&*%&%'
#'!%&%&
(
*(
+
)
#
"
(
+ ,
"#$#'&%
') '
(
%'&*%&%' #'!%&%&
(
'%%'%--"
- 3 -
(
.(
# /010 2330241 250 67408 2927:1; ;/0 <=89>0:; 2:8 2?258 82;08 %'&*%&%' 321108 @A ;/0 887;7B:24 0:7B5 7C74 (=890 2:8 242@=5297 7: B#'! B6%&%& % /0 D427>2:; 2908 A0251 >0; ?7;/ 2:
2DD780:; B: ' &%%&%& 2:8 1=1;27:08 9570CB=1 7:<=501 /0506B50 /0 67408 2 D427> 30;7;7B: @06B50 ;/0 57@=:24 D427>7:9 DB>30:12;7B: B6 1'$&&&&&" /0 57@=:24 DB:178057:9 ;/0 0:;750 0C780:D0 B: 50DB58 952:;08 DB>30:12;7B: B6 1#)$) !" ?7;/ 7:;0501; 2; -E 32 65B> ;/0 82;0 B6 30;7;7B: ;744 5024712;7B: 2:8 8750D;08 ;/0 5013B:80:;"B53B52;7B:;B803B17;;/012>0
99570C08@A;/01278<=89>0:;2:82?258;/0 B53B52;7B:/2167408B%&&&*&%&%%8713=;7:9;/0
- 4 -
F=2:;=> 21 ?044 21 472@747;A 2:8 ;/0 7:<=508 D427>2:; /21 350605508B%&'&$-%&% 8713=;7:9;/0F=2:;=> ! /0D427>2:;7: /71233024DB:;0:808;/2;/0 1=1;27:08652D;=50B61/26;B6406;60>=52:8B;/059570CB=1 7:<=5701 2:8 ?21 /B137;247108 6B5 &) 82A1 /0 8BD;B5 21101108;/08712@747;A2; #E;B;/0?/B40@B8A@=;;/0 57@=:24 /21 DB:1780508 B:4A '%E 2:8 ;/0 2>B=:;1 952:;08=:805B;/05/0281250>02950=5;/057:;0501;71 ;B @0 2?25808 2; '%E 32 /0506B50 50F=01;08 6B5 0:/2:D0>0:;B6;/0DB>30:12;7B: # /0 B53B52;7B: 7: 7;1 233024 DB:;0:808 ;/2; 21305G!"57>080;27416B5>?7;/1H0;D/>23;/05071 DB:;57@=;B5A :094790:D0 B: ;/0 325; B6 ;/0 857C05 B6 ;/0 4B55A 2:8 ;/0 857C05 B6 ;/0 @=1 2:8 ;/0506B50 ;/0 B53B52;7B: 71 472@40 B:4A ;B ;/0 0G;0:; B6 #&E 2:8 2DDB587:94A 7; 71 ;B @0 >B876708 /0 7:DB>0 B6 ;/0 D427>2:; ?21 ;2H0: B: /79/05 1780 /0506B50 50F=01;08 6B5 508=D;7B: B6 ;/0 DB>30:12;7B: 2?25808 @A ;/0 57@=:24
- 5 -
- 0258;/0259=>0:;1B6@B;/17801 ) /B=9/ D427>2:; 1;2;08 ;/2; /0 ?21 025:7:9 1'#&&&"305>B:;//0/21:B;35B8=D082:A7:DB>0 35BB6 /0506B50 21 305 ;/0 9=78047:01 B6 ;/0 25:2;2H2 ;2;0 0924 05C7D01 =;/B57;A 21 ;/0 2DD780:; 71 B6 ;/0 A025 %&%& /71 :B;7B:24 7:DB>0 71 ;B @0 ;2H0: 2;
1' )#&" 305 >B:;/ 0 ?21 2908 !
A0251 21 305 G'&"28/25258/0506B50;/0>=4;734705?21579/;4A ;2H0:21I'-J/02330442:;0G2>7:08;/08BD;B521% 2:8/021101108;/08712@747;A2; #E;B;/0?/B40@B8A =:805G)/057@=:24/21;2H0:' 58B6 #E21'%E ?/7D/ :0081 :B 7:;056050:D0 /=1 ;/0 4B11 B6 6=;=50 025:7:91?B=48@0 1' )#&G'%G'-G'%EK1 '-$&&" $ /0 57@=:24 /21 2?25808 2: 2>B=:; B6 1'''*#!" ;B?2581 >087D24 0G30:101 21 305 G'%" >087D24@74412:87;:0081:B7:;056050:D0
- 6 -
* /0 D427>2:; ?21 28>7;;08 7: ;/0 /B137;24 6B5 &) 82A1 2:8 ;/0 57@=:24 /21 2?25808 2: 2>B=:; B6 1#&&&&"6B5327:2:81=66057:91 &&&&"6B54B11B6 2>0:7;701 2:8 1 #&&&" 6B5 6=;=50 >087D24 0G30:101 ?/7D/ :0081 :B 7:;056050:D0 =5;/05 ;/0 57@=:24 /21 2?258082:2>B=:;B61%&&&&"6B52;;0:82:;6BB82:8 DB:C0A2:D0 D/25901 B?0C05 DB:178057:9 ;/0 3057B8 B6 /B137;24712;7B: ;/71 B=5; 67:81 7; 5021B:2@40 ;B 952:; 2: 2>B=:; B6 1 &&&&" 6B5 ;52:13B5;2;7B: 0G;52 :B=571/>0:;2:82;;0:82:;D/25901 '& /0D427>2:;>79/;:B;/2C02;;0:8082:A?B5H 2; 4021; 6B5 2 3057B8 B6 6B=5 >B:;/1 8=0 ;B ;/0 7:<=5701 1=1;27:08 /0506B50 ;/71 B=5; 67:81 7; 5021B:2@40 ;B 952:;2:2>B=:;B61##&&&"1' )#&G!6B54B11B6 7:DB>08=57:94278=33057B8 '' 0:D0;/0D427>2:;710:;7;4086B5;/0>B876708 DB>30:12;7B:=:8058766050:;/028121@04B? - 7 -
27:2:81=66057:9 1#&&&&" 087D240G30:101 1'''*#!" =;=50>087D240G30:101 1 #&&&" B11B66=;=50025:7:91 1 '-$&&" B11B67:DB>08=57:94278=33057B8 1##&&&" 52:13B5;2;7B: 0G;52 :B=571/>0:; 2:82;;0:82:;D/25901 1 &&&&" B11B62>0:7;701 1 &&&&" ,-. /* 0(
/=1;/0D427>2:;710:;7;4086B5;B;24DB>30:12;7B: B61-%$)#!"?7;/7:;0501;2;-E3052::=>65B>;/0 82;0B630;7;7B:;7445024712;7B:
'% 025:08DB=:104 6B5;/0B53B52;7B: DB:;0:808 ;/2; ;/050 71 DB:;57@=;B5A :094790:D0 B: ;/0 325; B6 ;/0 857C05B6;/04B55A2;#&E2:87;71;B@05021101108=;
;/0 305=124 B6 ;/0 50DB581 1/B?1 ;/2; ;/0 D427>2:;
@B25808;/0@=1@0257:909B" "&!$&2:8?/0: ;/0@=1502D/08:0252:7H2:;/B;;B:744;/0857C05B6 ;/0 @=1 857C0: 7; 7: 2 521/ 2:8 :094790:D0 >2::05 0:82:9057:9 ;B /=>2: 4760 2:8 ;5708 ;B BC05;2H0 ;/0 C0/7D40?/7D/?2135BD0087:92/028B6;/0@=12:8821/08 ;B;/04B55A?/7D/?21DB>7:965B>;/0B33B17;08750D;7B:
- 8 -
2:8D2=108;/02DD780:;/0D/25901/00;71674082927:1; ;/0857C05B6;/0@=16B5/71:094790:D0/05071:B@2171 ;B 211011 ;/0 DB:;57@=;B5A :094790:D0 B: ;/0 325; B6 ;/0 857C05 B6 ;/0 4B55A /0506B50 ;/0 57@=:24 /21 579/;4A 621;0:08;/00:;750472@747;AB:;/0B53B52;7B:2:87;:0081 :B 7:;056050:D0 0:D0 ;/0 B53B52;7B: 24B:0 71 472@40 ;B 32A ;/0 DB>30:12;7B: B6 1-%$)#!" ?7;/ 7:;0501; 2; -E32 ' :;/0501=4;;/06B44B?7:9B580571321108 7 B%&'&$-%&% 67408 @A ;/0 D427>2:; 71 244B?087:325; 77 B%&&&*&%&%%67408@A;/0B53B52;7B:71 871>71108 777 /0 D427>2:; 71 0:;7;408 6B5 ;B;24 DB>30:12;7B: B61-%$)#!"?7;/7:;0501;2;-E3052::=>65B>;/0 82;0B630;7;7B:;744;/082;0B65024712;7B:B?0C0521305 B5805 82;08 '-'&%&%# ;/0 D427>2:; 71 :B; 0:;7;408 6B5
- 9 -
7:;0501; 6B5 ;/0 8042A08 3057B8 B6 '#) 82A1 7: 6747:9 ;/0 233024 7C /0 B53B52;7B: 71 8750D;08 ;B 803B17; ;/0 26B501278 DB>30:12;7B: 2>B=:; ?7;/ 7:;0501; ?7;/7: B:0 >B:;/65B>;/082;0B6;/71<=89>0:; C : 1=D/ 803B17; ;/0 D427>2:; 71 305>7;;08 ;B ?7;/852? ;/0 0:;750 2?258 2>B=:; 24B:9 ?7;/ 7:;0501; 2DD5=08B:7;
C7 /02>B=:;7:803B17;@06B50;/71B=5;7:
B%&&&*&%&%% 71 B580508 ;B @0 ;52:1>7;;08 ;B ;/0 57@=:246B5871@=510>0:;2:8;/05724B=5;50DB5871;B @010:;@2DH
/1( %$' #
71;B'4B!'