- 1 - ! "# $ ## # % & %'() &% (( * ! "# $ % & # ' ' ( ' ) ' $ %* & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' (!'("() +& # ("( ' ' ',#! '' ' -& ' .' ' /* % /*& 01 2134345617 -1468 301 46957:+63 46 74:1 5# ("( 59 ;- 7-+6 5<4=1 3+3456 4>+7 957 301 59916=1, 2;64,0+-<1 ;6>17 1=3456, #!?%(& #?#%(& ) ( ) #%(&##!%#&+6>#?"590+7+34@+@+@++6043+("() %957,0573A("().&+6>;6>171=3456,)%#&%7&)%#&%,& +6> )%(&%B+& 59 =01>;<1> +,31, +6> =01>;<1> 74-1, % 71B163456 59 375=4341,& =3 #?!? %957 ,0573 A % & =3.& 4, ,11C468 + >471=3456 35 301 71,256>163 D 25<4=1 35 7146B1,348+31 301 :+3317 35 71=57> 301 - 3 - ,3+31:163, 59 # 35 ! +6> 35 94<1 +>>43456+< =0+781,0113 ( 6434+<<@ 301 2134345617 0+, 94<1> 301 947,3 46957:+3456 +8+46,3 +==;,1> 5,# 35 +<<18468 =5::4,,456 59 301 59916=1, ;6>17 301 275B4,456, 59 ("() +6> ;6>17 301 275B4,456, 59 % & =3 +, 7191771>35+-5B134,04,=56316345630+301-1<568,35 ,=01>;<1>=+,31+6>30171,4>16359+E+>8174B4<<+81 1 4, >5468 =55<41 E57C 46 301 ,052 -1<568468 35 561 ->;< +-4 6 "")("( E04<1 01 E+, 275=11>468 46 301 +;3574=C,0+E -1+7468 7184,37+3456 5)! ()" 01 95;6> 30+3 04, 1:2<5@17 D ->;< +-4 +346 +6> 50+::+> ->;< 50+:46 E171 F;+771<468 E430 1+=0 53017 016 +==;,1> 5,( 35 0+B1 =+;803 05<> 59 +346 +6> +-;,1> +346 46 94<30@ <+68;+81 +6> +,,+;<31> 04:30146957:+6346317B161>46301:+33176301:1+6 34:1 +==;,1> 5, +6> 0+B1 =+;803 05<> 59 301 46957:+63 01@ 0+B1 +,,+;<31> 301 46957:+63 =+;,468 -<11>46846G;741,==;,1>5#+-;,1>30146957:+63-@ - 4 - 719177468 35 04, =+,31 E430 +6 463163456 35 0;:4<4+31 04: +6>301@0+B1+<,5=74:46+<<@4634:4>+31>30146957:+63+, E1<< +, 53017 46G;71> 0171-@ +<< 301 +==;,1> 0+B1 =5::4331> 301 +-5B1:1634561> 59916=1, 01 46G;71> E171 3+C16 35 301 05,243+< +6> 0+B1 3+C16 371+3:163 01719571 46957:+63 71F;1,31> 301 25<4=1 35 7184,317 301 =+,1+6>46434+31+=3456+8+46,3301+==;,1>==57>468<@ 25<4=1 0+B1 7184,3171> 301 =+,1 6B1,348+3456 E+, ;6>173+C16 +6> 43 4, ,3+31> 30+3 946+< 712573 =+:1 35 -1 94<1>56<@+8+46,3+==;,1>5#95730159916=12;64,0+-<1 ;6>17 1=3456, ) #%(& ) ( ## %(& +6> #( %+& 59 ("()E04<1>7522468301=+,1+8+46,3+==;,1>5,(35 +6> +<,5 >7522468 301 275B4,456, ;6>17 301 % & =3 ) 3 4, 301 =563163456 59 <1+761> =5;6,1< 957 301 213434561746957:+6330+394<46859,;=0946+<71257356<@ +8+46,3 +==;,1> 5# E04<1 >7522468 301 =+,1 +8+46,3 +==;,1>5,(35+6>>7522468301275B4,456,59 % &=3E+,61B17-75;803353016534=1593012134345617 - 5 - +6> 301 21=4+< 5;73 0+, 957E+7>1> 301 2+217, 35 301 5;73 59 <1+761> 746=42+< 4B4< *;>81 +6> *' 4>+7 35 37@ 301 :+3317 01719571 301 2134345617 4, -19571 304, 5;73 ,11C468 61=1,,+7@ >471=3456 35 7146B1,348+31 301 :+3317 1+7> 74 +6>C4,0571 55- <1+761> =5;6,1< 957 301 2134345617 +6> 74 *+:+>+7 0+0+-;>>46 <1+761> 480 5;73 5B176:163 <1+>17 957 301 71,256>163, 17;,1>301:+3174+<,5671=57> 6 B41E 59 301 74B+< =563163456, ;781> -@ 301 <1+761>=5;6,1<9573012+7341,3012546330+3E5;<>+74,1 957:@=56,4>17+34564, !"# - 6 - @+6,E1735301+-5B1254634,46301 95730195<<5E468 3 4, 301 ,21=494= =563163456 59 301 2134345617 30+3 01 0+> :+>1 ,21=494= +<<18+3456, +8+46,3 +==;,1> 5,#359570+B468=5::4331>30159916=1,-530;6>17 301 275B4,456, 59 ("() +6> ;6>17 301 275B4,456, 59 % & =3 01 12;3@ ;21746316>163 59 5<4=1 0+,94<1>301946+<71257356<@+8+46,3+==;,1>5#;6>17 301 275B4,456, 59 ("() 5 :+3174+<, +71 2<+=1> -195713015;7335 ,05E 30+3301,+:1 E+, 46957:1>35 30146957:+63+6>+6522573;643@E+,84B163504:3594<1 04,5-G1=3456, H 3 4, 301 ,21=494= =563163456 59 301 2134345617 30+3 # 35 ! +71 301 1@1E4361,,1, 35 301 46=4>163+6>3016B1,348+3468994=170+>61B1716F;471> 301:65771=57>1>30147,3+31:163,01,11@1E4361,,1, 41 # +6> 35 ! 0+B1 ,E576 46>4B4>;+< - 7 - +994>+B43, 719177468 35 301 46=4>163 30+3 0+, 5==;771> +, ,3+31>-@30146957:+6346301947,346957:+345634,+<,5 ,3+31> 30+3 301 6B1,348+3468 994=17 0+, 71=57>1> 30147 ,3+31:163,E0171301@6+77+31>+-5;330146=4>163-;301 0+, =56=5=31> 9+<,1 ,3+31:163, 35 =56316> 30+3 65 ,;=0 46=4>163 0+> 5==;771> +6> +==;,1> 5,( 35 E171 653 271,163 +3 301 34:1 59 301 46=4>163 6 B41E 59 301 +994>+B43, 94<1> -@ # 35 ! 714317+3468 301 46=4>16330+3E+,=5::4331>-@+==;,1>5,#35946> =56,4>17+-<1 957=1 46 301 =563163456 3+C16 -@ 301 2134345617 16=1+:59301524645630+3301213434564, 35 -1 +<<5E1> -@ >471=3468 301 ;21746316>163 59 5<4=1 4>+7 351637;,3 301 :+3317 35 + =5:213163 5994=1759 301 7+6C 59 12;3@ ;21746316>163 59 5<4=1 35 7146B1,348+31 301:+3317+6>94<1301946+<712573+93171I+:46468# +6>35!E430718+7>3530146=4>163 ! 6B41E59301+-5B1+6,E17301+-5B125463 46301 +6>275=11>352+,,30195<<5E468 - 8 - 01=74:46+<213434564, 01 ;21746316>163 59 5<4=1 4>+7 4, >471=31> 35 71917301:+33179577146B1,348+34563530125<4=15994=1759 3017+6C5912;3@;21746316>16359 5<4=1-@71=57>468 301,3+31:163,59#+6>35!+971,0+6>35 ,;-:43301+>>43456+<712573 184,37@4,>471=31>35=5::;64=+31304,57>1735301 ;21746316>16359 5<4=14>+795746957:+3456+6>611>9;< +=3456 +) %##( $ 4,35#<5)