Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92293 (KAR)
SANGAMMA @ MALLESHAPPA METI v. THE STATE THROUGH THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
CP/200024/2025 · 2025-11-11
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92293 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92293 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"#$
%$& $ $ #
' ( )
! ""#$%&%
' (
)
%
"#$%&%
*
*
""#$%&
+ , *
*"
"#$%&
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
-
-
. " *$+
'
(
,%+/
"
,-)
,
- , %0& &%0 , ,
,
"
, ,"
, ,
1
"
(
1
")
23456737389:;<7=9>=<<=?@=3<39>78:6726 A3B6 8B 896 C6?6=46C * =@@=D6CC; 466E39> 726 B8@@8A39> D6@36B4*
- 3 -
!
"##$$% & '(!"#) & D3 =2=97642 =73@ @6=D96C ?8F946@ B8D 726 567373896D 4F:<374 72=7 =:8G6 4F37 39 8%0& &%0 34 B3@6C:;726567373896D:6B8D6 726 CC37389=@ 3G3@ FC>6 =9C , "=@=:FD=>3 2=7 39 726 @3>27 8B 5D8G343894 ?897=396CF9C6D6?7389(%)(?)(C)8B726,=<3@;8FD74 ?7 %0$- (26D639=B76D D6B6DD6C 78 =4 H8B 726 ?7!) A23?2 6I?@FC64 726 JFD34C3?7389 8B 726 3G3@ 8FD7 726 =B8D64=3C 4F37 34 D6KF3D6C 78 :6 A372CD=A9 =9C 7D=94B6DD6C 78 726 D39?35=@ FC>6 ,=<3@; 8FD7 "=@=:FD=>3 A23?2 2=4 726 JFD34C3?7389 F9C6D 726 ?7 6 =@48 D6B6D4 78 726 8DC6D 5=446C:;7263G3438969?28B72348FD739726?=468B 39 !C=76C$%%&- 2F4264F:<37472=77265D646974F37:6A372CD=A9=9C 7D=94B6DD6C78726,=<3@;8FD7"=@=:FD=>3=45D=;6CB8D - 4 - &+ 9 D6458946 D3 <:6E=D 726 @6=D96C ?8F946@ =556=D39> B8D 726 D64589C697 8- 4F:<374 72=7 4F:46KF697 78 B3@39> 8B 726 4F37 39 8%0& &%0 726 567373896D # <7 =9>=<<= 2=4 B3@6C =98726D 4F37 39 8+ && =>=3947 726 D64589C697 8- 26D639 =9C 8726D4466E39> D6@36B 8B 5=D737389=9C 465=D=765844644389 8B G=D38F4 @=9C6C =9C 28F46 5D856D7364 2=7 AD37769 47=76<6974397264=3C4F372=4:669B3@6CC69;39>726G6D; D6@=738942358B726567373896D26D639A37272=78BC6?6=46C* =@@=D6CC;2=77264=3C4F3734569C39>?8943C6D=738989 726 B3@6 8B 726 6938D 3G3@ FC>6 2=2=5FD A23?2 34 = 8<567697 8FD7 78 C6?3C6 726 344F64 8B ?897D8G6D4; =D3439> :67A669 726 5=D7364 6 4F:<374 72=7 6G69 726 344F6 39G8@G6C 39 726 5D64697 4F37 39 8%0& &%0 :639> 43<3@=D =4 78 726 896 39G8@G6C 39 4F37 39 8+ &&5=D73?F@=D@;A372D6>=DC78647=:@342<697 8B D6@=73894235 A372 726 5=D7364 ?89?6D96C <=; :6 7D36C =9C C345846C 8B =9=@8>8F4@; 26D6B8D6 26 4F:<374 72=7 - 5 - 39476=C8BA372CD=A39>=9C7D=94B6DD39>7265D646974F3739 8%0& &%0 78 726 ,=<3@; 8FD7 =7 "=@=:FD=>3 726 4=<6<=;:6A372CD=A9=9C7D=94B6DD6C=9C5@=?6C:6B8D6 7266938D3G3@FC>6=72=25=FD78:67D36C=@89>A372 4F37398+ && &- 9 D6458946 726 @6=D96C ?8F946@ B8D 726 567373896D28A6G6D4F:<37472=7726344F639G8@G6C39726 4F37 39 %0& &%0 :639> C6?@=D=7389 A372 D6>=DC 78 <=D37=@47=7F48B7265=D736434D6KF3D6C78:6=CJFC3?=76C 89@; :; 726 ,=<3@; 8FD74 ?894737F76C F9C6D 726 5D8G343894 8B 726 ,=<3@; 8FD74 ?7 9 726 @3>27 8B 5D8G343894 F9C6D 6?7389 8B 726 4=3C ?7 37 34 89@; 726 ,=<3@; 8FD7 =7"=@=:FD=>3 A8F@C2=G6 726 JFD34C3?7389 78 C6=@ A372 726 <=776D 6 =@48 4F:<374 72=7 =@76D9=73G6@; 726 4F37 39 8+ && <=; :6 A372CD=A9 =9C 7D=94B6DD6C 78 726 ,=<3@; 8FD7 =7 "=@=:FD=>3 78 :6 7D36C =@89>A3727265D646974F37398%0& &%0 - 6 - & 6=D96C ?8F946@ B8D D64589C697 8- 89 726 8726D 2=9C 4F:<374 72=7 4F?2 = ?8FD46 8B =?7389 34 F9A=DD=976C ,3D47@; =4 726 4F:46KF697 4F37 39 8+ &&B3@6C:;726G6D;567373896D34B8D726D6@36B 8B 5=D737389 =9C 465=D=76 5844644389 =9C =@@ 726 @=9C6C 5D856D7364=D6437F=76CA37239726JFD34C3?73898B7266938D 3G3@FC>6392=2=5FDA23?2347268<5676978FD778 C6=@ A372 726 4=3C <=776D 6?89C@; 26 D6B6D4 78 726 5D8G3438948B6?7389+=9C@=F46*(=)8BF:6?7389(%) 8B 6?7389 8B 726 ?7 78 4F:<37 72=7 439?6 726D6 34 98 ,=<3@;8FD7?894737F76C392=2=5FD373489@;7266938D 3G3@FC>62=2=5FDA23?234?8<56769778C6=@6G69726 344F64 56D7=3939> 78 726 <=7D3<893=@ 344F64 2F4 26 4F:<37489:872726?8F9748B76DD378D3=@JFD34C3?7389=4A6@@ =4 726 ?8<56769?; 37 34 726 6938D 3G3@ FC>6
=7 2=2=5FDA23?22=4726JFD34C3?7389 & 6=DC6DF46C726D6?8DC4 - 7 - & 26 4F37 39 8%0& &%0 B3@6C :; 726 567373896D=>=3947D64589C697*7=76=F728D37364=4A6@@=4 <7=2=C6G334B8D726B8@@8A39>D6@36B4* #* %($$ ( % + ! ,*+ -* * * . ( .* &#* %*%! "#!!/ * '( 0* # * %/%*'(
% %( #%
% ( $ $(1%
+
!,*+-** * . ( .* &#* %*%!
"# %%#$ ( # $ $*
% %
**'%*%*%
&$ D3776947=76<697397264=3C4F372=4:669B3@6C C69;39> 726?@=3< 8B 726 567373896D26D6398B 426 :639> = @6>=@@; A6CC6C A3B6 8B C6?6=46C * =@@=D6CC; 26 B8@@8A39>344F642=G6:669BD=<6C397264=3C4F37* 2
% % % ( $ %$*%(3 2%%%#0
%3 /2
%%% 3 42*3
- 8 -
&0 264F37398+ &&34B3@6C:;726G6D; 567373896D#<7=9>=<<=B8D726B8@@8A39>D6@36B4* *
%
%%%% '( # %%
% % %* 5*
% %* ' % % *6
%1% '( 4 *% *% 4 *% % 2 768 $ # 5*%(&% #7%$!7%
'(#
% *''%%%#('%# 7 * *''%% #
% %'%%*
% 7 ( $*
* #
%%#$
%
%& D37769 47=76<697 2=4 :669 B3@6C C69;39> 726 ?@=3< 8B 726 5@=3973BB 78 :6 726 @6>=@@; A6CC6C A3B6 8B C6?6=46C * =@@=D6CC; 6G69 39 726 4=3C 4F37 =9C 26D 69737@6<697 78 726 5D856D7364 9=DD=76C 726D639 26 B8@@8A39>344F642=G6:669BD=<6C397264=3C4F37* 2
%
% ( $ $ ( 1 % 3 2
%
% %
( 1%
3
- 9 -
/2 % /
% % ( $ $ (1%
3
42 % /
% %9*:% (1%
3
92
%
%'%/; %*
%* % < = *% '(&
('%%>3
>2
%
%'% %*
% % *6 ((1%
3
?2%/
%' %*
(%%*6
( 4@"A3
;2%/
%' %*
( % % *6 (3
2/
%' %*
( % % *6 (3
2/
%' %*
( % % *6 (/@A3
2 % /
% =(;/(> ''#
%3
2 %
% ' % '#3
/2%
%'#3
4 2 %
% #
* 3 9 2 /
% 9#%$%
%%%% '%!/;
%*
(3
>2
%%'% !/;
%*
%3
?2
%% 3
;2*3
- 10 -
%% 7 34 F9C6D 72646 ?3D?F<47=9?64 726 KF647389 72=7D6KF3D6478:6=CCD6446C34* 2 % % 6 # $$
* # ! ! $* % (%/ #( (
%' # '( $$
*# '(
"#%%#(
3)
% 5584376 78 D6B6D 78 @=F46*(C) 8B 6?7389 8B 726 ?7 C6B3939> 726 76D< ,=<3@; 8FD7 A23?2 D6=C4 =4 F9C6D* @A '( ) '% '( %#% */
%+ 6?7389+8B726?7D6=C4=4F9C6D* ! "# $ # % &B @A % 5*% 0%*
$% * '( #( % *! C'!*%$<! #(*!B
@A!%%%'(#*''*' % *! %#% ( *'
% *( $ $%
5*% '! '(D
@#A(%#% '(%%*% %'('*%%(
7 C' %!
*% $ <!%
*(!#( *!*'% $* 0%* '( %5'(!('!*%!* %*'%)
- 11 -
%- ,D8< 726 D6=C39> 8B 726 =B8D64=3C 5D8G34389 F9C6D6?7389+8B726?73734?@6=D72=7=,=<3@;8FD7 :6 647=:@3426C 39 = 6G6D; =D6= ?8<5D3439> 37; 8D 8A9 A2846585F@=73896I?66C%<3@@389
% 734=@48D6@6G=9778D6B6D78@=F46*(=)=9C(:) 8BF:6?7389(%)8B6?7389A23?2D6=C4=4F9C6D* ?@AEEEE
@A5*%0%*5*%##( ( %* ( %# * ( $ ' # * %
* %% *% 5
! @#A # '! % 5*% %* 0%*%*$!#%*!% *% '( #! %* %# * $* 0%* '( 5%)
% 26?89J8397D6=C39>8B726=B8D64=3C5D8G343894 A8F@C39C3?=7672=7B8D7265FD58468B726647=:@342<6978B ,=<3@;8FD7726D6KF3D6<69734585F@=73896I?66C39>896 <3@@389396G6D;=D6=397267=76?8<5D3439>8B37;8D726 8A9 =9C A26D6 4F?2 647=:@342<697 34 987 D6KF3D6C B8D A=978B726585F@=73896I?66C39>896<3@@3896?73898B 726 ?7 3746@B 5D8G3C64 72=7 4=3C JFD34C3?73894 42=@@ :6
- 12 -
6I6D?34=:@6 :;726 347D3?7 8FD7 8D =9; F:8DC39=76 3G3@ 8FD7F9C6D=9;@=AB8D72673<6:639>39B8D?639D6456?7 8B 4F374 =9C 726 5D8?66C39>4 8B 726 9=7FD6 D6B6DD6C 78 39 7266I5@=9=7389
% 266I5@=9=73898B6?738939C3?=76472=7726 7;5648BC345F76478:6C6=@7A372:;726347D3?78FD78D 726F:*DC39=763G3@8FD7D6B6DD6C78F9C6D@=F46*=8B F:6?7389(%)8B6?73898B726?7
%$ C<3776C@; 4F37 39 8+ && 34 B3@6C :6B8D6 726 6938D 3G3@ FC>6 2=2=5FD A23?2 34 ?8<567697 =9C 2=4 JFD34C3?7389 78 C6=@ A372 726 5D8?66C39>4 8B 726 9=7FD6 D6B6DD6C 78 39 726 6I5@=9=7389 =498,=<3@;8FD7=4?8976<5@=76CF9C6D6?7389+8B726 ?72=4:669647=:@3426C397264=3C=D6=
%0 643C64 =4 D3>27@; 583976C 8F7 :; 726 @6=D96C ?8F946@B8D726D64589C69747264F:46KF6974F3734896B8D 5=D737389 A26D6 =@@ 726 3<<8G=:@6 5D856D7364 =D6 437F=76C A37239726JFD34C3?73898B7266938D3G3@FC>62=2=5FD =9C7265=D7364=D6=@48D643C39>726D639
- 13 -
& 972=7G36A8B726<=776D7265D6469756737389 34 ' $ C3D6?739> A372CD=A=@ 8B 726 4F37 39 8%0& &%0B3@6C:;726567373896D78:67D=94B6DD6C
5D646976C:6B8D67266938D3G3@FC>6=72=2=5FD78:6 7D36C=9=@8>8F4@;A3728+ &&
% 39?6 726 5=D7364 =D6 D65D646976C :; 7263D ?8F946@726;42=@@=556=D:6B8D67266938D3G3@FC>6=7 2=2=5FD89%%&
8943C6D39> 726 569C69?; 39 726 <=776D 439?6 726 ;6=D &%0 726 6938D 3G3@ FC>6 =7 2=2=5FD 42=@@ 69C6=G8D78C3458468B726<=776D6I56C3738F4@;A37239=9 8F76D@3<378B896;6=DBD8<726C=768BD6?63578B?6D73B36C ?85;8B72348DC6D
*+ '$ $( &
" 3478%@8+%
"