- 1 - ! " #$ " %!&'"" %!&'"$'(!!$ )"* ! " # $ %" & ' ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ) *% + ) ! %" & $ , - '( $ $ $ + %%) % . %%) $ * - 3 - * / # / # # ! '* / # ( 01230405678449:56;1649<=1:>17;?58@>91=1==5>9 1AB9>451@C540409>1@69@41=A140409;8:4596405678449: 5648D9@2;=1:=5@8?<56;168? 98:< 409 ?98:@9< <<5451@8? 1E9:@79@4 <E1>849 " 056;945451@56=5?9<>08??9@35@34091:<9:<849< %;8669<AF4098:@848D84849<75@564:845E9 :5A2@8? 8?8A2:835 5@ ;;?5>8451@ 1%%) C09:9AF 409 ;945451@9:G6 ;:8F9: 41 4:984 409 ;9:51< =:17 -!41-868>17;2?61:FC8545@3;9:51< C86 8??1C9< 5@ ;8:4 09 ;9:51< =:17 -! 41 56 4:9849< 86 8>17;2?61:F C8545@3 ;9:51< =1: ;1645@3 8@< 409 ;945451@9: 56 9@454?9< 41 8?? 71@948:F A9@9=546 - 4 - 09 A:59= =8>46 1= 409 >869 8:9 4084 409 8;;?5>8@4 C05?9 C1:D5@3 86 8 949:5@8:F @6;9>41: 84 409 949:5@8:F56;9@68:F5:655<8:8?2D8@<564:5>4C86 4:8@6=9::9<E5<91:<9:<849<%%'@@9H2:9 (41 409 8??5D09< 949:5@8:F 16;548? 27@8A8< 8?2D 1@ I2428?:8@6=9:GC5401@90:5845609<<F098;;?5>8@4 >08??9@39< 409 4:8@6=9: 1:<9: A9=1:9 409 8:@848D8 <75@564:845E9:5A2@8?5@;;?5>8451@ 1%)%5<9 1:<9:<849<"%%409:5A2@8?3:8@49<8@1:<9:1= 648426J21 @ E59C 1= 4084 409 8;;?5>8@4):96;1@<9@4 >1@45@29< 41 C1:D 84 5:65 5<8: @ 409 798@4579 E5<9 1:<9: <849< --! :5 84560 9<<F C86 ;1649< 41 409;?8>91=4098;;?5>8@4):96;1@<9@4C540124409:9A95@3 8@F 1:<9: 1= 4:8@6=9: 5@ :96;9>4 1= 409 :96;1@<9@4 09 8;;?5>8@4 62A75449< 8 :9;:969@48451@ <849< %-! 64845@3 4084 86 =8: 86 409 4:8@6=9: 1= 409 8;;?5>8@4 56 >1@>9:@9< 409 78449: 56 ;9@<5@3 A9=1:9 409 8:@848D8 <75@564:845E9 :5A2@8? '( 5@>9 409:9 C86 @1 :96;1@69 41 409 685< :9;:969@48451@ 409 8;;?5>8@4 62A75449< 8 =:960 8;;?5>8451@ ;;?5>8@4 1@>9 8385@ - 5 - 8;;:18>09< 4056 :5A2@8? 5@ ;;?5>8451@ 1!)! 409 8:@848D8 4849 <75@564:845E9 :5A2@8? AF 1:<9: <849< -! 086 3:8@49< 48426J21 @ 409 798@4579 409 8;;?5>8@4086 A99@:9?59E9<=:17 409;164 1=949:5@8:F @6;9>41:5:655@>9409>869C86;9@<5@3 A9=1:94098@<@1;1645@3C8635E9@414098;;?5>8@4 09<5<@14:9;1:4=1:<24F09685<;9:51<C864:9849<86 2@82401:5K9< 8A69@>9 8@< 8 <9;8:479@48? 9@J25:F C86 5@545849< 09:9=1:9 409 8;;?5>8@4 8;;:18>09< 409 699D5@3414:984409;9:51<=:17-!41- 86 8 >17;2?61:F C8545@3 ;9:51< :17 --! 41 409:9C868648426J211:<9:8@<409;1645@3 C86 @14 35E9@ 41 409 8;;?5>8@4 09:9=1:9 409 :5A2@8? :5304?F4:9849<409;9:51<=:17-!41 86 8 ;9:51< 1= >17;2?61:F C8545@3 =1: ;1645@3 1: 409 ;9:51< =:17 41 - :5A2@8? 086 :9B9>49< 409 ;9:51< 4:9845@3 86 8 >17;2?61:F C8545@3 ;9:51<09:956@19::1:1:5??938?54F5@4091:<9:;8669< AF409:5A2@8?09:5A2@8?08635E9@8>?98:=5@<5@3C540 :96;9>4 41 4:9845@3 409 ;9:51< =:17 -! 41 - 6 - 86 8>17;2?61:F C8545@3 ;9:51< 09:9?9E8@4 ;8:83:8;068@<:98<862@<9:* L 09 8;;?5>8@4 C86 8>>1:<9< 8 ;1645@3 84 8??8 E5<9 1:<9: <849< C05>0 409 8;;?5>8@4 <5< @14 B15@ 8??935@3 5?? 098?40 2A69J29@4?F09086A99@35E9@8;1645@3E5<9 1:<9: <849< - 84 057D1< C09:9 09 :9;1:49< 1@ "- @ 4056 :938:< 409 8;;?5>8@4 56 =8>5@3 <56>5;?5@8:F ;:1>99<5@36 E5<9 601C>8269@145>956629<41057<849< 8??935@3 4084 09 086 :9785@9< 8A69@4 2@82401:569<?F5@409;9:51<=:1741 -4098;;?5>8@4086:9;1:49<?F:9;?59< 41409>08:396<849<%8@<409:956@1 1:<9:1=409>17;949@482401:54F5@ 4056:938:< 5@>9 409 :932?8:568451@ 1= 409 ;9:51< =:17 41 - 56 62AB9>4 78449: 1= <56>5;?5@8:F;:1>99<5@36C05>08:9@1457;23@9< 5@ 4056 8;;?5>8451@ C9 <9>?5@9 41 409 ;:8F9: =1: >1@65<9:8451@1=409:932?8:568451@1=4056;9:51< 2@45? 8=49: 409 <56>5;?5@8:F 82401:54F 086 >1@65<9:9< 409 6879 1C9E9: 65@>9 409 8;;?5>8@4086@1469:E9<84409;?8>91=;1645@3 41C05>009C86;1649<=1::9861@6C05>08:9409 62AB9>4 78449: 1= <56>5;?5@8:F ;:1>99<5@36 8385@64 057 409 J296451@ 1= 4:9845@3 409 ;9:51< =:1741-86;9:51<6;9@4 1@ >17;2?61:F C8545@3 56 2@49@8A?9 65@>9 409 8;;?5>8@4 08< A99@ 8>>1:<9< 8 ;1645@3 8@< 54 56 409 8;;?5>8@4 C01 086 =1: :9861@6 C05>0 8:9 41 - 7 - A9 >1@65<9:9< 5@ 409 <56>5;?5@8:F ;:1>99<5@36 5@545849<8385@64057@1469:E9<84409;?8>91= ;1645@3098;;?5>8@4>8@@1448D98<E8@48391= 056<9=82?48@<409>?857=1:409685<;9:51<41A9 4:9849< 86 ;9:51< 6;9@4 1@ >17;2?61:F C8545@3 =1:;1645@3562@49@8A?91@=8>46 @ E59C 1= 409 <56>26651@6 8A1E9 409 8;;?5>8451@56;8:4?F8??1C9<8@<409;9:51<=:17 -! 41 608?? A9 4:9849< 86 ;9:51< 6;9@4 1@ >17;2?61:F C8545@3 =1: ;1645@3 8@<4098;;?5>8@4608??A99@454?9<41056;8F8@< 971?279@46 =1: 4056 ;9:51< 09 ;:8F9: 41 :932?8:569409;9:51<=:1741- 86>17;2?61:FC8545@3562@49@8A?91@=8>46 8@<56:9B9>49<M @ E59C 1= 409 8A1E9 409 ;945451@9: 086 @14 78<9 1248@F3:12@<=1:5@49:=9:9@>9AF405612:4>>1:<5@3?FC9 <9>?5@9415@49:=9:9C5404091:<9:;8669<AF40909C:54 ;945451@56409:9=1:9<5675669< "+, )"* ' "+, )$'(!!$* ' 564 1*? 1* *