- 1 - !"# $%& && '"( ) ! " # $% $ # & ' '()) "% '*(* $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + $ '*(* ! " $&, $ * % & & -"% & $ & # ( $ # '+$ $ )) & & # $ . # % " . # % /012334250160547282091::/4;<78=49:2972>2?7 72:47 ( 321147 @A :/4 490B? 0C05 #<784 297 '+$/0::23<?09$ B))B6 94905 B2=41/2:/B72847(A42?1=4: >0:/ 29 2DD0749: B9 * 297 7047 B9 :/4 13B: /4?46B?4 /01 32?49:1 297 AB<984? 101:4? 60547 2 D520= - 3 - 34:0:0B9 @46B?4 :/4 ?0@<925 D520=098 DB=34912:0B9 B6 1)* ' /4 ?0@<925 DB91074?098 :/4 49:0?4 4C0749D4 B9 ?4DB?7 8?29:47 DB=34912:0B9 B6 1-( '>0:/09:4?41:2:)E326?B=:/472:4B6 34:0:0B9:055?425012:0B929770?4D:47?413B9749: B'B>94? B6:/4C4/0D54B=329A:B743B10::/412=4 88?04C47@A:/41207;<78=49:2972>2?7:/4 D520=29:1 /2C4 3?464??47 :/01 233425 7013<:098 :/4 F<29:<=21>455502@050:A297DB9:49747:/2::/47?0C4?B6 :/4 B66497098 C4/0D54 /27 9B C2507 7?0C098 50D49D4 @<: 21 34?:/4;<78=49:B6:/4 B9G@5434HB<?:09 :/4A 2?4 49:0:547 6B? 29 B?74? B6 32A 297 ?4DBC4?A 6?B= :/4 91<?29D4B=329A:016<?:/4?1:2:47:/2::/474D42147 >2142?90981 '34?=B9:/@<::/4?0@<925/21 :2I49 /01 09DB=4 B95A 2: 1* ' 34? =B9:/ 297 :/4 6<:<?4 3?B134D:1 01 :B @4 :2I49 2: *E 091:427 B6 E 1 (2018) 3 SCC 208 - 4 - &<?:/4?:/42=B<9:8?29:47<974?B:/4?/427101=428?4 /4?46B?4?4F<41:476B?49/29D4=49:B6DB=34912:0B9 42?7:/42?8<=49:1B6@B:/10741 * /4?4019B7013<:4?482?7098:/4DB=34912:0B9 2>2?747 @A :/4 ?0@<925 2: 1-( ' /4 =209 DB9:49:0B9 B6 :/4 23345529:1 01 :/2: :/4A 2?4 49:0:547 6B? 32A 297 ?4DBC4?A 21 34? :/4 D0:2:0B9 09 "<?32% /4?46B?4 :/01 B<?:609710: ?421B92@54 :B 70?4D: ?413B9749: B'91<?29D4 B=329A :B 743B10: :/4 DB=34912:0B9 2>2?747 @A :/4 ?0@<925 04 1-( '>0:/09:4?41:2:)E326?B=:/472:4B6 34:0:0B9:055?425012:0B9>0:/09B94=B9:/6?B=:/472:4B6 :/01;<78=49: ) 9 1<D/ 743B10: 23345529: B1 297 2?4 34?=0::47 :B >0:/7?2> :/4 49:0?4 2=B<9: 25B98 >0:/ 09:4?41: 2DD?<47 B9 0: 4F<255A 3345529: B 01 :/4 AB<984? 101:4? B6 :/4 74D42147 1/4 01 74349749: B9 - 5 - 23345529: B 297 1/4 01 9B: 49:0:547 6B? 29A DB=34912:0B9 - 413B9749: B'91<?29D4 B=329A 01 2: 50@4?:A:B?4DBC4?:/412072=B<9:6?B=?413B9749: B' B>94?B6:/4C4/0D54@A7<43?BD411B652> ( 9:/4?41<5::/42334250132?:5A255B>47 *+, '&( % 01: B5 B)