- 1 - ! "# # $$%%$&#! # '#"%( %)%% $ %"%))" *+, %"%))" *+, # ! $ " # $# $ $ %&'" $ (( $) %"'%* +," ( %&'" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , $ # $# " $$ $$$ $ %*''*' & $ ## - & ( " . & $ ## %*''"' # (/ $(&/ *'' " / '"'+' , (( ! $( ( "+, "!($ $ ( $#$ '','' ( $ # #$ $ ", '"+ $ (( ) & $ # " $ $ ," " ! - 3 - $ " # $# $ $ %&'" $ (( $) %"'%* +," ( %&'" , $ # $# " $$ $$$ $ %*''*' & $ ## - & (" . & $## %*''"' # (/ $(&/ "0,%! $( ( "+, "!($ $ ( #$ '','' ( $ # #$ $ " '"+ $ (( ) ( & $ - 4 - $ ( #$ $ 1$# "( $ " 234435 #678495: ;<= ><==97 35 '','' ?5 $ 3" '"+ <57 $ 3", '"+ @A :B9 77?:?35<C $ <57 77C 95?3D ?E?C #6789 <57 #$<:?7<D F3D=B3D:G:B9 D?@65<CH! ?79D <57 :B9 >?CC?35 D?79D 3F :B9 43:3D2A2C9 @9<D?58 D98?=:D<:?35 3%, %."' 49: ;?:B <5 <22?795: 35 "'"'"+ 769 :3 :B9 D<=B <57 598C?895: 7D?E?58 3F :B9 D?79D 3F :B9 3FF957?58 43:3D2A2C9 @9<D?58 D98?=:D<:?35 3%&" %+. ?79D 3F :B9 43:3D2A2C9 @9<D?58 D98?=:D<:?35 3%, %."' F?C97 $ 3" '"+ ;B9D9<= >?CC?35 D?79D F?C97 $ 3", '"+2C<?4?58234>95=<:?353F=.".''' %<57 ="''''' %D9=>92:?E9CA B9 D?@65<C<F:9D235=?79D?58 :B9 95:?D9 9E?79529 35 D923D7 B<= <;<D797 < =64 3F =""+. % <C358 ;?:B ?5:9D9=: <: :B9 D<:9 3F .I >9D - 5 - <5564 FD34 :B9 7<:9 3F >9:?:?35 :?CC D9<C?J<:?35 ?5 $ 3" '"+<57<=643F=''. %<C358;?:B?5:9D9=: <::B9D<:93F.I>9D<5564FD34:B97<:93F>9:?:?35:?CC D9<C?J<:?35 ?5 $ 3", '"+ 88D?9E97 @A :B9 =<?7 234435 K678495: <57 <;<D7 :B9 D?79D <57 :B9 >?CC?35 D?79D ;B3 ;9D9 2C<?4<5:= @9F3D9 :B9 D?@65<C B<E9 >D9F9DD97:B9>D9=95:<>>9<C= , $(3'".+ '?=F?C97@A:B92C<?4<5:?5 $ 3", '"+ ;B3 ;<= :B9 >?CC?35 D?79D 3F :B9 43:3D2A2C9@9<D?58D98?=:D<:?353%, %."'<57$( 3''., ' ?= F?C97 @A :B9 2C<?4<5: ?5 $ 3" '"+;B3;<=:B9D?79D3F:B943:3D2A2C9 & - :?==:<:97:B<::B9<>>9CC<5:;<=<897,A9<D=<57 ;<= 73?58 >D?E<:9 ;3DL <57 9<D5?58 =''' % >9D 435:B B9 D?@65<C<;<D797<=643F=''. %<C358 ;?:B?5:9D9=:<::B9D<:93F.I>9D<5564FD34:B97<:93F >9:?:?35:?CC:B97<:93FD9<C?J<:?35<57F?M97:B9C?<@?C?:A3F - 6 - 'I9<2B35D9=>35795:3=<57,=>9D:B99E?79529 35D923D7:B97D?E9D3F:B93FF957?58E9B?2C9?=<C=3B<E?58 E<C?7 7D?E?58 C?29529 <57 :B6= :B9 C?<@?C?:A F?M97 35 D9=>35795:3,?=:3@9437?F?97(6D:B9D?:?=<C=3=:<:97 :B<: 53 <4365:= ;9D9 8D<5:97 6579D :B9 B9<7= G:D<5=>3D:<:?359M:D<536D?=B495:<57<::957<5:2B<D89=H <57 3:B9D ?52?795:<C 2B<D89= <57 :B6= D9N69=:= F3D 95B<529495:3F234>95=<:?35 =>9DM""%;365729D:?F?2<:9:B9<>>9CC<5: B<==6=:<?597FD<2:6D93FFD35:<C@359<57FD<2:6D93FD?8B: 3D@?:<C;<CC;B?2B<D98D?9E36=?55<:6D9 5:B9K678495: 3F:B9 D?@65<C?:;<=3@=9DE97:B<:B9=6=:<?597?5K6DA :3B?=B9<7<57:B9D9;<=<2D<5?3%F<2?<CFD<2:6D9=>9D M",%7?=2B<D89=644<DAB9;<=B3=>?:<C?J97F3D=9E95 7<A= B9 D?@65<C<;<D797<=643F="&'. %:3;<D7= 497?2<C@?CC=;B?2B5997=53?5:9DF9D9529 * 35=?79D?58 :B9 5<:6D9 3F ?5K6D?9= >9D?37 3F B3=>?:<C?J<:?35<573:B9DD9C9E<5:F<2:3D=:B?=36D:F?57= - 7 - ?: D9<=35<@C9 :3 8D<5: < =64 3F =,'''' % :3;<D7= ?5K6D?9= ='''' % :3;<D7= ><?5 <57 =6FF9D?58= =''' % :3;<D7= C3== 3F <495?:?9= <57 =,'''' % :3;<D7= :D<5=>3D:<:?35 9M:D< 536D?=B495: <57 <::957<5: 2B<D89= + B9 <>>9CC<5: 4?8B: B<E9 53: <::95797 <5A ;3DL <: C9<=: F3D < >9D?37 3F F36D 435:B= 9529 :<L?58 B?= 53:?35<C ?52349 <: ="'' % >9D 435:B B9 ?= 95:?:C97F3D<=643F=&"''' % ="''M&435:B=! :3;<D7=C3==3F?5234976D?58C<?76>>9D?37 9529:B9:3:<C234>95=<:?35?=<=6579D %. /012 345/-2067- 48-6 " (3D?5K6D?9= =,'''' % <?5<57=6FF9D?58= ='''' % , 3==3F<495?:?9= =''' % & 3== 3F ?52349 76D?58 C<?76>>9D?37 =&"''' % D<5=>3D:<:?35 9M:D< 536D?=B495: <57 <::957<5:2B<D89= =,'''' % * $97?2<C9M>95=9= ="&'. % 3:<C =".''. % - 8 - B6=:B9<>>9CC<5:?=95:?:C97F3D:3:<C234>95=<:?35 3F=".''. %<C358;?:B?5:9D9=:<::B9D<:93F*I>9D <5564FD34:B97<:93F>9:?:?35:?CC:B97<:93FD9<C?J<:?35 . 9<D597 2365=9C F3D D9=>35795: 3& 235:95797 :B<::B97D?E9D3F:B93FF957?58E9B?2C9@9<D?58D98?=:D<:?35 3%&" %+.<5:3=B;<=53:B<E?587D?E?58C?29529<= >9D:B99E?795293F@6:?5><D<3F:B9K678495:?: ;<= 3@=9DE97 @A :B9 D?@65<C :B<: ?5 B?= 9E?79529 =:<:97:B<:@3:B:B9D?79D=3F:B943:3D2A2C9=;9D9B<E?58 7D?E?58 C?29529 @6: :B9 7D?E?58 C?29529 3F :B9 2C<?4<5: ?= 4?=>C<297 ?5 B?= F?C9 <57 B9 <FF?D497 :B<: @3:B :B9 D?79D= ;9D9B<E?587D?E?58C?29529<::B9:?493F<22?795:9<D597 2365=9C F6D:B9D 235:95797 :B<: :B9A ?==697 =64435= :3 D9=>35795: 3, @6: B9 7?7 53: :6D5 6> <57 :B6= :B9A 235:95797 :B<: D9=>35795: 3, B<= E?3C<:97 :B9 :9D4= 3F :B9?5=6D<529>3C?2A=>9D:B99E?795293F35D923D7 :B9 D?79D 3F :B9 3:B9D 43:3D2A2C9 ?= <C=3 B<E?58 7D?E?58 C?29529 B9D9F3D9 :B?= 36D: F?57= ?: D9<=35<@C9 :3 7?D92: @3:BD9=>35795:3=<57&:3><A:B9234>95=<:?35<::B9 - 9 - D<:9 3F 'I 9<2B 223D7?58CA :B9 <>>9<C 79=9DE9= :3 @9 <CC3;97?5><D: "' - = >9D M%;3657 29D:?F?2<:9 :B9 <>>9CC<5: B<= =6=:<?597 :B9 FD<2:6D9 3F :?@?< <57 F?@6C< ;B?2B <D9 8D?9E36=?55<:6D9 "" B368B :B9 <>>9CC<5: =:<:97 :B<: B9 ;<= ;<= ;3DL?58 ?5 < >D?E<:9 =92:3D <57 9<D5?58 =''' % >9D 435:BB9B<=53:>D376297<5A?52349>D33F9529<= B9 49: ;?:B <5 <22?795: ?5 :B9 A9<D '"+ <= >9D :B9 86?79C?59=3F:B9<D5<:<L<:<:998<C9DE?29=6:B3D?:A B?= 53:?35<C ?52349 ?= :3 @9 :<L95 <: ="'' % >9D 435:BM?=:B97?=<@?C?:A29D:?F?2<:9?5;B?2B7?=<@?C?:A 3F:B9><D:?26C<DC?4@?=<==9==97<:&'I B9D<7?3C38?2<C F?57?58==B3;=:B93C7><D:?<CCA65?:97FD<2:6D93F>D3M?4<C :?@?<;?:B?4>C<5:?5=?:6<577?=<@?C?:A?=<==9==97<:&'I " ,D7 3F :B9 =<49 2349= :3 ",I B9D9F3D9 :B?= 36D: F?57=?:D9<=35<@C9:3235=?79D:B97?=<@?C?:A<=",I B9 - 10 - 46C:?>C?9D3F"+<73>:97@A:B9 D?@65<C?=K6=:<57>D3>9D B6=:B9C3==3FF6:6D99<D5?58=?=<=6579D ="''M"M"+M",IO=+",' % " B9 D?@65<C B<= 8D<5:97 =& % :3;<D7= 497?2<C9M>95=9=<57?:5997=53?5:9DF9D9529 ", B9 <>>9CC<5: ;<= <74?::97 ?5 :B9 B3=>?:<C F3D =?M 7<A= 35=?79D?58 :B9 5<:6D9 3F ?5K6D?9= >9D?37 3F B3=>?:<C?=<:?35 <57 3:B9D F<2:3D= :B?= 36D: F?57= ?: D9<=35<@C9:38D<5:<5<4365:3F='''' %F3D><?5<57 =6FF9D?58 =''' % F3D C3== 3F <495?:?9= <57 =,'''' % F3D :D<5=>3D:<:?35 9M:D< 536D?=B495: <57 <::957<5:2B<D89= "& B9 <>>9CC<5: 4?8B: 53: B<E9 <::95797 <5A ;3DL <: C9<=: F3D < >9D?37 3F F36D 435:B= 769 :3 :B9 ?5K6D?9==6=:<?597 B9D9F3D9:B?=36D:F?57=?:D9<=35<@C9 :38D<5:<5<4365:3F=&"''' % ="''M&!F3DC3== 3F?5234976D?58C<?76>>9D?37 - 11 - " 9529 :B9 :3:<C 234>95=<:?35 ;36C7 @9 <= 6579D <?5<57=6FF9D?58 ='''' % $97?2<C9M>95=9= =& % D<5=>3D:<:?35 9M:D< 536D?=B495: <57<::957<5:2B<D89= =,'''' % 3==3F?5234976D?58C<?76>>9D?37 =&"''' % 3==3FF6:6D99<D5?58= =+",' % 3==3F<495?:?9= =''' % 60. 2! ! 2! ! "* B9 D?@65<C B9C7 :B<: :B9 D?79D 3F :B9 43:3D2A2C9 B<= 53 E<C?7 7D?E?58 C?29529 <57 B9529 :B9 598C?8952935B?=><D:;<=B9C7<:'I<57'I;<=B9C7 35 :B9 ><D: 3F D9=>35795: 3,%3;59D 3F :B9 E9B?2C9 3;9E9D?5><D<33F:B9K678495:?:;<=3@=9DE97 @A:B9 D?@65<C:B<:=:<:97:B<:@3:B:B9D?79D=3F 43:3D2A2C9=;9D9B<E?587D?E?58C?29529<::B9:?493F:B9 <22?795: B9D9F3D9D9=>35795:3&@9?58:B9?5=6D9D3F :B9 3FF957?58 E9B?2C9 ?= 7?D92:97 ><A 'I 3F :B9 234>95=<:?35 - 12 - "+ B6= :B9 <>>9CC<5: ?= 95:?:C97 F3D 35CA 'I 3F :B9:3:<C234>95=<:?353F=&*,, %?9=,"*.& % <C358;?:B?5:9D9=:<:*I><FD34:B97<:93F>9:?:?35:?CC D9<C?J<:?35<57D9=>35795:3&?=7?D92:97:379>3=?::B9 =<49<C358;?:B?5:9D9=: " 5:B9D9=6C::B9F3CC3;?583D79D?=><==97 ?! $(3'".+ '?=<CC3;97?5><D: ??! B9 <>>9CC<5: 2C<?4<5: ?5 $ 3", '"+ ?= 95:?:C97 F3D :3:<C 234>95=<:?35 3F =".''. % ;?:B ?5:9D9=:<:*I>9D<5564FD34:B97<:93F>9:?:?35:?CC:B9 7<:93FD9<C?=<:?35 ???! 9=>35795:3=<57&% 5=6D<52934><5?9= <D97?D92:97:379>3=?::B9<F3D9=<?7234>95=<:?35<4365: ?5 :B9 D<:?3 3F '' ;?:B?5 359 435:B FD34 :B9 7<:9 3F :B?=K678495: ?E! 5 =62B 79>3=?: :B9 <>>9CC<5: ?= >9D4?::97 :3 ;?:B7D<; :B9 95:?D9 <4365: <C358 ;?:B ?5:9D9=: <22D697 35?: - 13 - E! $(3''., '?=<CC3;97?5><D: E?! B9 <>>9CC<5: 2C<?4<5: ?5 $ 3" '"+ ?= 95:?:C97 F3D :B9 234>95=<:?35 3F =,"*.& % ;?:B ?5:9D9=:<:*I>9D<5564FD34:B97<:93F>9:?:?35:?CC:B9 7<:93FD9<C?J<:?35 E??! 9=>35795: 3&% 5=6D<529 34><5A ?= 7?D92:97 :3 79>3=?: :B9 <F3D9=<?7 234>95=<:?35 <4365: ;?:B?5359435:BFD34:B97<:93F:B?=K678495: E???!5 =62B 79>3=?: :B9 <>>9CC<5: ?= >9D4?::97 :3 ;?:B7D<; :B9 95:?D9 <4365: <C358 ;?:B ?5:9D9=: <22D697 35?: 21 *)%% $, ( $ ?=:3"C3* %#