- 1 - ! "#$## # % & %'() &%(( * !"#$ % # & % & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !'#$# ( ) * + + "# %! !'#$ !% !% '#, ( ) !% +- +* % + #+ + . + ! !%+ / ) + + ) %* , &* + ++ & &0#)*&$ &+ & + + + - 3 - % +% % % 1% ! %% )1% ! %%* 23435656/7389:367;<==>93?/95/&67 / /7 523 @6A3 /@ 523 />85 /@ 523 A3<873? 6B6A !>?;3<7?!%+ 67?<;6)@/892/85C86<A/>85D*<86967; />5 /@ 86E3 /, & /@ 67?<;6 /A6=3 5<56/7 <83 933F67;5/G><92523=86E67<A48/=33?67;967656<53?<;<6795 523E@/8523/@@37=394>7692<:A3>7?38 3=56/79& &0#&$83<?H652 3=56/7&/@ 7?6<37<A/?3 <A/7;H652 3=56/79<7?&/@/H8I8/26:656/7=5 3<8? 86 <;<A6 A3<873? =/>793A @/8 523 435656/7389 86!<E<?<8 2<2<:>??67A3<873?6;2/>85 /B387E375 A3<?38 @/8 8394/7?375 /' 5<53 <7? 86 2<B<7 A3<873? =/>793A @/8 8394/7?375 / ' =/E4A<67<7538>93?523E<5386<A9<B<6A<:A3/783=/8? - 4 - 7 B63H /@ 523 86B<A =/753756/79 >8;3? :I 523 A3<873?=/>793A@/85234<856395234/67552<5H/>A?<8693 @/8EI=/796?38<56/769 J235238523=86E67<A48/=33?67;967656<53? <;<6795 523 435656/7389 69 A6<:A3 5/ :3 G><923? 67B/F67; 67238375 4/H38 >7?38 93=56/7#/@2<8<56I<<;<86F >8<F92< <7265<KL & %I <79H38 5/ 523 <:/B3 4/675 69 67 523 CD@/8523@/AA/H67; 394/7?375 / 2<9 A/?;3? 523 @6895 67@/8E<56/7H652523 67?<;6/A6=3 5<56/7<;<6795<==>93? /9 5/ <AA3;67; 52<5 923 H<9 :367; 583<53? H652 =8>3A5I:I<AA523<==>93? 7B3956;<56/7H<9>7?385<F37 <7? =2<8;3'92335 =<E3 5/ :3 @6A3? /7AI <;<6795 523 435656/7389 238367 967=3 <==>93? / 67 523 + ?63? ?>867;67B3956;<56/7 - 5 - $ 5 69 523 =/753756/7 /@ 523 48/93=>56/7 52<5 <==>93? / :367; 523 2>9:<7? /@ 8394/7?375 / <==>93? / :367; 523 E/5238 <7? <==>93? / :367; 523 E<8863? 969538 /@ <==>93? / <7? <==>93? /& :367; 523 2>9:<7? /@ <==>93? / ?3E<7?3? ?/H8I <5 52356E3/@E<886<;383=36B3?9 '<7?5/A<9 /@ ;/A? /87<E3759 <7? /5238 B<A><:A3 48/4385639 5 69 95<53?52<5523E<886<;3/@<==>93?/H6528394/7?375 /H<923A?/7 , 5 69 95<53? 52<5 <==>93? / H<9 9>943=567; 523@6?3A65I/@8394/7?375/H237923:3=<E3483;7<75 @/852393=/7?56E3 569<A9/<AA3;3?52<5<==>93?H383 67969567;8394/7?375/5/?/7<53238/73F6?73I5/523 :8/5238/@<==>93?/675>875/;355H/<=839/@A<7? 569<A9/95<53?52<5<==>93?2<B3<99<>A53?238<7?;<B3 238A6@35283<5752393<AA3;<56/79523@67<A834/85=<E3 5/:3@6A3? # 3<873? =/>793A @/8 523 435656/738 2<9 ?8<H7 <553756/7/@5269/>855/523?/=>E375948/?>=3?:I26E - 6 - <==/8?67; 5/ H26=2 < 7/56=3 H<9 699>3? 5/ 8394/7?375 / :I <==>93? / <7? A<538 23 @6A3? 523 ?6B/8=3 435656/7%/$ &:3@/83523/>85/@A3<873? 376/8 6B6A!>?;3<7?!%+ 67?<;6<AA3;67;<?>A538I/7523 4<85 /@ 8394/7?375 / 5 69 <A9/ <AA3;3? 52<5 8394/7?375/H<9@/>7?83?2<7?3?AI67=/E48/E6967; 4/9656/7 H652 <7/5238 4389/7 52<5 E<?3 26E 5/ @6A3 523 435656/7933F67;?6B/8=3269435656/7@/8?6B/8=3H<9@6A3? /7$&2383<@5385234839375435656/7H<9@6A3? /7 ,& 2383@/83 65 69 523 =/753756/7 /@ 523 A3<873? =/>793A @/8 523 435656/738 52<5 699><7=3 /@ A3;<A 7/56=3 <7? @6A67; /@ E<586E/76<A =<93 :I <==>93? / 586;;383?8394/7?375/5/@6A35234839375=/E4A<675 @67? =/796?38<:A3 @/8=3 67 523 =/753756/7 5<F37 :I 523 A3<873?=/>793A@/8523435656/7389 0 ==/8?67; 5/ 8394/7?375 / ?3E<7? @/8 ?/H8I <7? <==345<7=3 /@ 523 ?/H8I H<9 ?>867; 523 E<886<;352<5H<923A?/7 5697/567?694>53 52<5 % /$ & H<9 @6A3? :I <==>93? / <AA3;67; - 7 - <?>A538I /7 523 4<85 /@ 8394/7?375 / 9 < =/>7538' :A<955/5239<6?E<586E/76<A=<935234839375=/E4A<675 <443<895/2<B3:337@6A3?:I8394/7?375/:IE<F67; :<A? <AA3;<56/79 H26=2 69 67 <:>93 /@ 48/=399 /@ A<H 37=3 <E /@ 523 /4676/7 52<5523 =86E67<A 48/=33?67;9 <83A6<:A35/:3G><923?==/8?67;AI523@/AA/H67; 6* 23=86E67<A435656/769<AA/H3? 66* 23 48/=33?67;9 67 / )<86967; />5 /@ 86E3 /, & 83;695383? :I 523 67?<;6 /A6=3 5<56/7* 437?67; /7 523 @6A3 /@ 523 86<A />85 @/8 523 /@@37=39 4>7692<:A3 >7?38 3=56/79&&0#&$83<? H652 3=56/7 & /@ 7?6<7 37<A /?3 <7? 3=56/79&<7?&/@/H8I8/26:656/7=5<83 2383:IG><923? +) %##( $ 695/ A/