- 1 - !!"!#$% & %'"%"% ()"* !!"#! $ % & ' ! " ( ( & ( & & )!*###" + ( ,- )!*## )!!"#! Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (+ )!!"#! $ % .' / ( * ( ( ' / ( / 0 #!#*#! / & # #) +) '/ ( / ( +) ###! / + )"#)"" #"# +) ( ' ( ( ( / 1 - 3 - 1 2 . ! %1 2 . ' 34 546767849 7: ;4<94 637: =96 :44>78? 634 <@@A78?94@74<:1) ' !"#! $ % %&' %() ' *&+ , ' *&- %% ) . ) /0/#121 1- 31& ( 455&4554 6(455 *& ) 3, ) 34 BC:4 < 634 546767849 7: 63C6 37: <C6349 C?48D9C AC: 3@D78? @7B48:4 78 (9E ) C8D 3CD 48?C?4D78634;=:784::<946C7@F48D78?<@7G=978634 594E7:4: ;4C978? @6 " " < CDC?C8B37 F7@@C?4@C8DCC@=>CC@C;=9C?7 7:697B6 =46B496C78 - 4 - D7<<7B=@674: 34 D7D 86 9484A 634 @7B48:4 3C6 34 5C::4D CAC8""#"#@4CF78?;4378D37:A7<4CEC;C7C8D :8:;8CE4C97:37D3C963C8D634546767849349478 3494C<649 ; ;6C7878? 634 B8:486 <9E 6349 3479: < D4B4C:4D@7B48:44634546767849C55@74D<99484AC@<634 @7B48:478649E:<=@4!<634C98C6C>CHB7:4%C@4 <8D7C8C8D(947?87G=9:'=@4:"*94CDA763=@4 " < 634 C98C6C>C HB7:4 7B48:4: %4849C@ 8D7678:' =@4: "* 78B4 63494 AC: 8 B8:7D49C678<634:CE45467678493CDC559CB34D637: =96 ; <7@78? /#"#! A37B3 AC: D7:5:4D <;9D49DC64D"#!#!D794B678?63494:58D486:6 B8:7D49634C55@7BC678<634546767849 8 <=96349C8B4 63494< 94:58D486 3C: 7::=4D C8 48D9:4E486 DC64D #!#*#! C: 549 884H=94) D4B@7878? 634 94G=4:6 < 546767849 8 634 594E7:4<5467678498659D=B78?63497?78C@<634:C7D @7B48:4 478?C??974F4D634594:4865467678 - 5 - 4C984D B=8:4@ <9 634 546767849 6C>78? 637: =96663494B9D::=;E76:63C663497?78C@@7B48:463C6 AC:7::=4D786348CE4<634<C6349<634546767849AC: <6344C9""C:549884H=94)A37B33CD;448@:6 C8DC5@7B4BE5@C78678637:94?C9DAC:@D?4D::=B3 63497?78C@B=@D86;459D=B4D:94?C9D66346349 6A DB=E486: :34 :=;E76: 63C6 :78B4 634 :C7D DB=E486: A494 86 94G=794D C: 63494 AC: 8 946C7@ F48D78? 634 5@C8 C: :=B3 AC: 86 94G=794D 6 ;4 <=987:34D 3C6 5CE486 < <44: 7: B8B4984D 634 :CE4 3C:;4485C7D=56DC64C:549884H=94) 3494<94C@@ :=B394G=794E486::6C8DBE5@74D A76348B4:44>:<9 C@@A78?6345467678 ! 34 @4C984D DD7678C@ F498E486 DFBC64 8 634 6349 3C8D :=;E76: 63C6 634 546767849 4HB456 B@C7E78? 63C6 634 @7B48:4 C: 549 884H=94) 3CD ;448 7::=4D3C:86<=987:34DC8D46C7@:C:66344H7:648B4< 97?78C@@7B48:43C66345467678493C:C@:86?7F48C8 D46C7@: 94?C9D78? 34 3CF78? ?7F48 @:6 BE5@C786 4 3C: - 6 - C@: 86 <=987:34D C86378? C;=6 9484AC@ < 634 :C7D DB=E486 4 :=;E76: 63C6 634 CE=86 5C7D ; 634 5467678497:F@=86C9::=B3634:CE4A=@D86?7F4 C8 97?36 78 <CF=9 < 634 546767849 48B4 59C4D <9 D7:E7::C@<6345467678 * 4C9D49=:4D63494B9D: 46767849 B@C7E: 63C6 634 @7B48:4 C: 549 884H=94) AC: ?9C864D 78 <CF=9 < 37: <C6349 8 #"#C8D345C::4DCAC8""#"# =@4!<634C98C6C>CHB7:4%C@4<8D7C8 C8D(947?87G=9:'=@4:"*94CD:C:=8D491) 7&8.. &94,:/* 3 - 3 ) . . . ) 8. 6 . .;* ... <31& 4<31&4 9, 4 =. 9, /> . .. ) . ) * . . ? @> /* 3 - 3 ) . . A . - 7 - 9%, : . =. 4555 ) /* 3 - 3 ) B 9 , )8.6 . . ? @> . . )&. - 3 /* 3 ).. . ) . * * 8.4 A . C 8 6349 A9D: 549=:C@ < 634 :C7D 59F7:78 EC>4:76B@4C963C69484AC@3C:6;4ECD4A7637863467E4 :54B7<74D 6349478 6378? 7: ;9=?36 8 94B9D C:6 C8 :=B3C664E563CF78?;448ECD4C867E4C<6497::=C8B4 <634:C7D@7B48:4C8DD=978?634@7<467E4<<C6349<634 546767849 "# =@4 " < 634 C98C6C>C HB7:4 7B48:4: %4849C@ 8D7678:'=@4:"*94CD:C:=8D491) 74(& : > > . .=*****. - 3 . ) .. > /* 3 . . ) >C - 8 - "" 34 :C7D 9=@4 8@ B864E5@C64: 69C8:<49 < @7B48:4786348CE4<634@4?C@3479:86349A9D:634 :C7D59F7:78B864E5@C64:4H7:648B4<CFC@7D@7B48:46 ;469C8:<4994D59F7:78<@CA;9=?366634867B4< 637: =96C:6@4?C@3479;478?48676@4D6:44>69C8:<49< 88)4H7:64864H5794D@7B48:4 " 9D78C64 48B3 < 637: =96 78 634 BC:4 < F: 945964D 78 + ,, A37@4 D4C@78? A763 634 D4EC8D 867B4 7::=4D ; 634 C=6397674: 6 D45:76 634 486794 C994C9: < @7B48:4 <44 <9 634 5=95:4 < 9484AC@ < @7B48:4 =8D49 =;)=@4 %' < =@4 !) < =@4: "* C6 5C9C?9C53 3C:34@DC:=8D491) 7( : . 8. & 8. . . ) ) ) 8. 6 8. > . ) . ) &* . A . . . ) * . 8. & 8. > . . . . > .: 8. > . ) & . . 8.& . > - 9 - " * .>) 2> .). * . ! > . . ) ) ) . .. . (& 6 . > ) .. . ) ) ...) . " 3=:4F48<9:44>78?9484AC@<@7B48B4=8D49 :=;)=@4%'<=@4!)<=@4:"*6345467678493C: 64:6C;@7:363C6634@7B48B4AC:D=@9484A4D<9594F7=: 4C9:A37B37:86634BC:483C8D " 78B4 634 94:58D486 ) C=6397674: 3CF4 D4B@784D 6 B8:7D49 634 94G=4:6 C: 634 546767849 3C: 8476349 59D=B4D 634 97?78C@ @7B48:4 89 3C: ?7F48 C8 I=:67<7BC678 94?C9D78? :CE4 3CF78? ;448 @:6 78 634 C;:48B4 < C8 DB=E486 78 637: 94?C9D 7@@4?C@76 9 7994?=@C976BC8;4<=8DAC99C8678?C878649<4948B4 "! 84634@4:: 4F48 7< :=B3 C @7B48:4 4H7:64D :CE4 86 3CF78? ;448 9484A4D 78 634 EC8849 >8A8 6 @CA C: C;F4 C 5467678 C<649 @C5:4 < 4H5@C78C;@4 789D78C64D4@C<4C9:BC886;4B8:7D494D - 10 - BB9D78?@63454676787: "-. (%"%* '! .. 7:61"@1 1