Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92260 (KAR)
SHRI SIDDALINGAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/200882/2025 · 2025-12-18
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92260 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92260 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"% " "
& ' (
& '
)*
& '
(
! "#$
$
%%
"&
! "$"
" %
"
"
' %
! #$
"(
)"&$
! #
"
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
%* ! ""#
& '
"(
)$"
(
"! *
! #
! *
"
(($(
)
$&)
&$#$
# %
")
* ($#
"
! #
$ *
"(
! #
- 3 -
"
"(
% (($#
"! *
&
+
! #
%
"&
*
! #
&
"! ) !((
! #
(
")
*
! #
! "! )
"(
!&#
- 4 -
$# % *
")
* )
!"#
$
")
*
! #
$$
"! $"
")
% *
! #
$
"! ! #
,
' '
&###
- 5 -
$ '
'
'
'''
&##$)
" *
&###)
*
'')$(
-* % * (###)
'' +
( ##
& *
'')$(
- * % * (###)
(
''
!##$
- 6 -
! ''
! ##$
,
% ' $. ' '" . '(. & ! *
'
$$& $$('' * ' '
#$#$
&) "$#$"$
"
-
'
'
' ' / # ' '
' *
!#&$) & !$#$ * "#("#!"$#$ *'
!#$#$"
"
&")!$#" $ -
"##$#$# ' $ * '
"
"##$#$# - ' ' #$#$ - *
0 ' ' 1
' '
- 7 -
(
$
%
! #
$ %
"! "&&& &
*
! #"
"
")
"&& &
*
! #"
(
%*
! #$
")
$0
*%* ! #$
- 8 -
'
'
'
' * ###
$ ' '
&###
" ' '
'
'''
&##$)
*
&###)
2 3
*
'')$(
-* % * (###)
&
'' +
( ##
- 9 -
( *
'')$(
-* % *
(###)
! ''
!##$
)
''
! ##$
% '$ ". ' '. '! *
'
$$& $$('' * ' ' #$#$
&) "$#$"$
- ' ' ' ' #
' '
'
* !#& $)& !$#$ * "#(
"#!"$#$ *' !#$#$"
&")!$#" $ -
- 10 -
"##$#$# ' $ *'
"## $#$# -
' ' #$#$ - *
1 ' '
1 ' '
)*(
#
* $"
4 !
#"
$
")
*
! %
%*
! #$
"
$
* %* %* 4 ! #
% $ *
4 ! #$
- 11 -
%
*
! "$
4 ! #$
'
4 &###
$ ' '
'
'''
&##$)
"
*
*
'' )$(
- * % * (###)
''
+
( ##
- 12 -
& *
'' )$(
- * % * (###)
(
''
!##$
! ''
! #$
)
*
&###
% ' $. ' '" . '& (
*
'
$$& $$('' * '
' #$#$
&) "$#$"$ -
"
'
'
' '/#
' '
' *
!#&$)&!$#$ * "#("#!"$#$ $ * '
- 13 -
!#$#$" "
&")!$#" $ -
"##$#$# ' $
" * '
"
"##$#$# - '
'
#$#$ *
1 ' ' 1 ' '
'# $#$ ' ' '
*
0 %
+ 56767895:; 79 6<5;5 =:76 >5676789; ?:5 ;55@79A B8CC8=79AD8EE89:5C75B; ,
(
!"#$%#&'(#() *++,- $. (
*/ )0 1
2
3
4
! 5 2
,$# !"6 4446
2 1
4
7%&) %'7# *
(8)(7(#
- 14 -
7( 2 ( 0 2 !"#9-#:***#$)%#(&7#()
*/ );
2 1
( $ 96
<
9 0
(
42
1 1 ( */ ) 2
*/ )06 = 4 :
>4
# :
>4
6 <2
(
!"#$%#&'(#() */ )+ 1
2
3
4
!
5 2
,$# !"6 4446
21
4
7%&)%'7# *
(8)(7(#
7( 2 0 2 !"#9-#:***#$)%#(&7#()
*/ )0
2 1
( $ 96
<
9 0
42
1 1 ( */ )" 2
*/ )+6 = 4 :
>4
# :
>4
6 <2
- 15 -
,
)*(
!"#$%#&'(#()
*/ )02 ( 1
2
3
4
!5 2
,$# !"64446
21
4
7%&)%'7# * (8)(7(#
7( 2 (
!"#9-#:***#$)%#(&7#() */ )
2 1
( $ 96 <
9
( 42
1
1 ( */ ) 2
=4 :
>4
# :
>4
6 <2
$ ?;5 8B 6<5 >56767895:; 7; 6<?6 6<5F <?G5 D8E>C565H 6<57: D8I:;5 =76< ?C89A =76< 895 F5?:
>>:5967D5;<7> 5:67B7D?65 I9H5: 6<5 >>:5967D5;<7> D6 )&7;;I5HJF?:9?6?@? 8=5::?9;E7;;7898:>8:?6789 2 3 ?9H ?CC 76; B7G5 H7G7;789; 8B C5D6:7D76F I>>CF 8E>?975;23<?66<5B7:;6:5;>89H596?I6<8:76F G7H5 8:H5: H?65H $##($## <?H H5D7H5H 68 >:8G7H5
- 16 -
6:?7979A 6<:8IA< 6<5 :?7979A 5965:; 68 6:?795H >>:5967D5;<7>; ?; =5CC ?; A:?HI?65 9A7955:; 7>C8E? <8CH5:; 68 BICB7CC ;6?6I68:F :5KI7:5E596 ?; >5:
>>:5967D5;<7> D6 )& 6<5:5JF 796:8HID5H 6=8 F5?:;
D8I:;579LC5D6:7D7?91=76<5BB5D6B:8E##$## ?9H H7:5D65H ?CC 76; 68 >:8G7H5 6:?7979A ?9H ?C;8 68 >:8G7H5;>5D7B7DKI86?79:5D:I76E596>:8D5;; DD8:H79ACF 7;;I5H?9 HH59HIEH?65H$ #!$##
" <?6?;>5:6<5>:5G?7C79A?H:5?9H5D:I76E596 IC5; B8: >:8E86789 ?9H :5AIC?6789 8B 5E>C8F55; I9H5:
H?65H $ #$## B8: 6<5 >8;6 8B ;;7;6?96
795E?9 JF H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 B8CC8=79A E56<8H 8B :5D:I76E596=?;>:8G7H5H ? #M 8B 6<5 ;?9D67895H >8;6; JF H7:5D6 :5D:I76E5968BKI?C7B75HD?9H7H?65;. J
"#M 8B 6<5 ;?9D67895H >8;6; JF H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 8B D?9H7H?65; >8;;5;;79A ? >?;; D5:67B7D?65 8B 6<:55 F5?:; L 795E?9 :?H511C5D6:7D7?9:?H517E>?:65HJF9HI;6:7?C :?7979A9;676I658B . - 17 -
D $#M8B6<5;?9D67895H>8;6;JF>:8E86789B:8E 6<5 D?H:5 8B %I978:
795E?9 89 6<5 J?;7; 8B ;5978:76FDIEE5:76;
<5?B8:5;?7H9867B7D?6789?C;8>:8G7H5HE797EIE KI?C7B7D?6789 D:765:7?<5 ;?7H E56<8H 8B:5D:I76E596 =?;
E8H7B75H B:8E 67E5 68 67E5 <?6 JF ?
9867B7D?6789 H?65H
"#$$#"KI?C7B7D?6789:5KI7:5HB8:6<5>8;68B ;;7;6?96
795E?9=?;?E59H5HB7N79AE797EIEKI?C7B7D?6789
79D5 6<5 >56767895:; =<8 <?H D8E>C565H 6<57: ?>>:5967D5;<7><?H988>>8:6I976F8B?>>8796E596?;6<5:5 =?;98:5AIC?6789>:8G7H79A?9F;D8>5B8:?>>8796E59668 6<5>8;68B ;;7;6?96 795E?9>56767895:;<?H?>>:8?D<5H 6<7; 8I:6 JF B7C79A =:76 >5676789 79 *
8$)$#$ D8995D65H=76<86<5:E?665:;<7;8I:6?CC8=5H6<5;?7H =:76 >5676789; H5DC?:79A D5:67B7D?65 <8CH5: B:8E 6<5 :5;>89H59679;676I65=8ICHJ55C7A7JC568?>>CFB8:6<5>8;6 8B ;;7;6?96 795E?9?;>5:9867B7D?6789H?65H$$$# ?9H D89;5KI596CF H7:5D65H 6<5 :5;>89H596; 68 7;;I5
- 18 -
8::7A59HIE 79G7679A ?>>C7D?6789; B:8E J86< E?C5 ?9H B5E?C5 D?9H7H?65; >8;;5;;79A ?9H D8I:;5 68 6<5 >8;68B ;;7;6?96 795E?9=76<796=8=55@;B:8E6<5H?65 8B6<58::7A59HIE & ; ?A?79;6 6<5 ;?7H 8:H5:
>:5B5::5H =:76 ?>>5?C 79 * 8;"#("#!"$#$ 79 =<7D< ? E5E8 H?65H#!$#"D?E568J5B7C5HI9H5:6?@79A68D89;7H5: 6<5D?;58B6<5>56767895:;5D8:H79A6<5;6?65E596E?H5 79 6<5 ;?7H E5E8 H?65H #!$#" 6<5 7G7;789 59D< H7;>8;5H 8BB 6<5 =:76 ?>>5?C; ;56679A ?;7H5 6<5 7:5D6789 8;G 68 G77 7;;I5H 79 6<5 8:H5: >?;;5H 79 6<5 *
8$)$#$ ?9H D8995D65H E?665:; 8=5G5: D89B7:E5H6<57:5D67898;77687G6?C;8H7:5D65H68 >:8G7H5?A5:5C?N?6789B:8E$$#686<5>56767895:; ?;?9H=<595E>C8FE5969867B7D?6789=?;7;;I5HB8:B7CC79A I>8B6<5>8;68B ;;7;6?96 795E?9796<5C7A<68BE5E8 B7C5H JF 6<5 :5;>89H5968:>8:?6789 ?9H BI:6<5: H7:5D65H 6<5 8:>8:?6789 68 :5BI9H 6<5 ?E8I96 D8CC5D65H 68=?:H; B7CC79AI>8B6<5>8;6?;>5:9867B7D?6789H?65H$$$#
- 19 -
( <?679;>7658B6<5H7:5D67897;;I5HJF6<7;8I:6 :5;>89H596 <?; 986 D89;7H5:5H 6<5 DC?7E 8B D?9H7H?65;<?G79AD8E>C565H?>>:5967D5;<7>J?;5H89#6< ;6?9H?:H=76<6<:55F5?:;8B6:?7979AJI6<?G5?C;8B?7C5H 68 D89;7H5: 6<5 DC?7E 8B 6<5 >56767895:; =<8 <?G5 D8E>C565H >>:5967D5;<7> 8B 895 F5?: >:8A:?E ?B65:
?9H <?G5 >:8D55H5H 68 D<?9A5 6<5 98E59DC?6I:5 8B 6<5 >8;6B:8E6<5L ;;7;6?96 795E?9168L%I978: 795E?91?9H L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 >:5;D:7J79A 6<5 E797EIE KI?C7B7D?6789 B8: 6<5 >8;6 8B %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96 ?;
#6< ;6?9H?:H G7H5 9867B7D?6789 H?65H "$$# <?6 79 G75= 8B 989D89;7H5:?6789 8B 6<5 A:75G?9D5 8B 6<5 >56767895:;6<5F=5:589D5?A?79D89;6:?795H68?>>:8?D< 6<7;8I:6JFB7C79A=:76>567678979*
8"##"$# D= *
8($($# D<?CC59A79A 6<5 :5AIC?6789 H?65H
"$$#" B65: D89;7H5:?6789 8B 5?:C75: 8:H5: ?9H 6<5 9867B7D?6789 7;;I5H JF 6<5 :5;>89H596; >:8G7H79A B8: D89;7H5:?6789 8B DC?7E 8B 6<5 D?9H7H?65; <?G79A ?>>:5967D5;<7>8B6<:55F5?:;?B65:#6<;6?9H?:H6<5;?7H
- 20 -
=:76>5676789;=5:5?CC8=5HH7:5D679A6<5>56767895:;68B7C5 :5>:5;596?6789 J5B8:5 :5;>89H596 8; 68 " =76< BI:6<5: H7:5D678968:5;>89H5968;68"68D89;7H5:6<5;?E579 ?DD8:H?9D5 =76< 6<5 H5D7;789 :59H5:5H JF >5N 8I:6 79
!"#$% 4&' =76<7957A<6=55@;B:8E 6<5H?658B:5D57>68B6<5:5>:5;596?6789;
! I:;I?96 68 6<5 H7:5D6789 :5;>89H596 8" 7;;I5H 59H8:;5E596 H?65H "##$#$# ?;;I:79A 6<5 >56767895:;6<?66<57:D?9H7H?6I:5=7CCJ5D89;7H5:5HJ?;5H 89 =76< 895 F5?: >>:5967D5;<7> I9H5: #M KI86?
79 6<55G5968B:5D:I76E596686<5>8;68B ;;7;6?96 795E?9 ?B65:;5DI:79AHI5?>>:8G?CB:8E6<5'79?9D55>?:6E596 <?679G75=8B 6<5 ?;;I:?9D5 A7G59 JF :5;>89H596 8" 6<5 E?665: =?; >C?D5H J5B8:5 $6< 8?:H 8B 7:5D68:;
55679A 8B <5CH 89 #)#$#$ =<5:5JF 76 =?;
:5;8CG5H 68 :5D:I76 >>:5967D5;<7> 6:?795H D?9H7H?65; 8B
:?7979A 5965:; 89CF 68 6<5 >8;6 8B %I978:
- 21 -
8=5:E?9 ?9H %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96 79 I9H5:
H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 KI86? JF 5N659H79A 6<5 ?A5 :5C?N?6789 79 65:E; 8B 8?:H 8:H5: H?65H "#"))( ?; 895 67E5 E5?;I:5?9H?I6<8:7O5H?9?A79A7:5D68: 68;55@ 95D5;;?:F ?>>:8G?C B:8E 6<5 8G5:9E596 B8: :5D:I76E596 686<5;?7H>8;6;79
) ?;5H 89 6<5 H5D7;789 6?@59 79 6<5 ;?7H 8?:H E55679A:5;>89H5968"=?;>C5?;5H68>:8>8;5D:5?679A # >8;6; ?9H ;8IA<6 B8: B79?9D7?C ?;;7;6?9D5 B8: H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 ?; 895 67E5 E5?;I:5 68 :5D:I76 !& %I978:
6?6789 6659H?96;?9H$%I978:
8=5:E?98=5G5:6<5 E?665: =?; @5>6 >59H79A ?9H >8;6>895H HI:79A "(6< 8?:H 55679A <5CH 89 $($$#$$ 5;>89H596 8" 79;65?H 8B D8E>CF79A =76< 6<5 H7:5D6789 7;;I5H JF 6<5 5?:C75:>:8D55H79A;:5B5::79A686<5?H:5?9H5D:I76E596 IC5; ?E59H5H 6<5 ;?E5 JF :5E8G79A 6<5 >8;6 8B ;;7;6?96 795E?9 6<5:5JF :5>C?D79A 6<5 >8;6 8B %I978:
6?6789 6659H?96%I978:
8=5:E?9 =76< 6<5 5C7A7J7C76F D:765:7?8B#6<;6?9H?:H=76<6<:55F5?:;8B >>:5967D5;<7>
- 22 -
896<5>:5E7;56<?679G75=8B6<5H5D7;7896?@5979"(6< 8?:HE55679A6<5:5=?;98;D8>5B8:B7CC79AI>6<5>8;68B %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96 ?9H %I978:
8=5: ?9 89CF 6<:8IA<6<5D?9H7H?65;<?G79A >>:5967D5;<7>6:?7979A # ?;5H 89 6<5 D8EEI97D?6789 :5D57G5H ?9H 6<5 8:H5:; >?;;5H 79 *
8$#()!!#$$# =<5:579 6<7; 8I:6<?HH7:5D65H:5;>89H596;68?>>87966<5>56767895:;
?; %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96; ?9H:5AIC?:7O5 6<57:;5:G7D5;
79 5N7;679A G?D?9D75; 8: D:5?65 5KI?C 9IEJ5: 8B >8;6; 68 ?DD8EE8H?65 6<5 >56767895:; 6<5:579 =76<79 B8I: E896<;
:5;>89H5968:>8:?6789 >:5B5::5H * 8$###$#$#$# D<?CC59A79A 6<5 8:H5: >?;;5H 79 *
8;$#()! !#$$# <5>8;767G5H7:5D67897;;I5H796<5=:76>5676789 =?; ;56 ?;7H5 8=5G5: 76 =?; 8J;5:G5H 7B 6<5 8:>8:?6789 <?; 6?@59 H5D7;789 68 ?>>8796 ?>>:5967D5;<7> D?9H7H?65; 6<5 8:>8:?6789 E?F A8 ?<5?H ?9H E?@5 ?>>8796E596 ?DD8:H79ACF ?9H >:8D55H 68 H7;>8;5 8B 6<5 =:76?>>5?CG7H58:H5:H?65H)$$#$
- 23 -
<?6 79;>765 8B ;>5D7B7D ?;;I:?9D5 A7G59 JF :5;>89H596 8"?I6<8:76F ? 9867B7D?6789 H?65H #$#$ <?; J559 7;;I5H D?CC79A B8: "" >8;6; B8:
%I978: 6?6789 6659H?96; ?9H $ $ >8;6; B8: %I978:
8=5:E?9 79DCIH79A !& J?D@C8A >8;6; 9D5 ?A?79 6<5 5C7A7J7C76F D:765:7? B8: ?>>CF79A 68 6<5 >8;6 7; 89CF 68 6<5 D?9H7H?65;J?;5H89#6<;6?9H?:H=76<8I6D89;7H5:79A6<5 C89A>59H79ADC?7E8B6<5>56767895:;=<8<?HD8E>C565H =76<895F5?:?>>:5967D5;<7>>:8A:?E $
56767895:; ?DD8:H79ACF E?H5 ?
H56?7C5H :5>:5;596?6789 H?65H &#$#$ :5B5::79A 68 6<5 5?:C75: 8:H5:;?9H;8IA<668:5D89;7H5:6<5E?665:?B:5;<6<5:5JF >5:E76679A 6<5E 68 B7C5 6<57: ?>>C7D?6789 I9H5: 6<5 9867B7D?6789 9 ;>765 8B 6<5 :5KI5;6; E?H5 JF 6<5 >56767895:; :5;>89H596?I6<8:7675; :5CF79A I>89 6<5 H5D7;789 79 6<5 * 8$###$#$#$# H?65H )$$#$ H5>:7G5H6<5DC?7E8B6<5>56767895:;6<8IA<6<5F=5:5986 >?:6F686<5;?7H>:8D55H79A;?9H8G5:6I:95H6<5;>5D7B7D ?;;I:?9D5 A7G59 89 "##$#$# 579A ?AA:75G5H 6<5 >56767895:;?:5J5B8:56<7;8I:6;55@79A?J8G5:5C75B;
- 24 -
" 6?65E596 8B 8JP5D6789; <?; J559 B7C5H JF 6<5 :5;>89H596 8" 68 6<5 ?J8G5 =:76 >5676789; D89659H79A
46<?6
" 5;>89H596 8" 7;;I5H :5D:I76E596 9867B7D?6789 89 #$#$ B8: B7CC79AI> 8B >8;6; 8B Q%I978: 6?6789 6659H?96;R ?9H Q%I978:
8=5:E?9R 86?C >8;6;
D?CC5H B8: =5:5 $)( 79 ?CC D?65A8:75; 68 J5 B7CC5H 79
?9H ?CC <5 >8;6 8B %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96?9H%I978:
8=5:E?968J5B7CC5H79
?:5"!#?9H( :5;>5D67G5CFI9H5:?CCD?65A8:75;?9H BI:6<5:J?D@C8A>8;68B"?9H&=5:5?C;8D?CC5HB8:
<5 C?;6 H?65 B8: B7C79A 8B 6<5 ?>>C7D?6789 =?; H?65H $#$#$I68B6<5;?7H:5D:I76E5969867B7D?6789 C?:A5 9IEJ5:8B?>>C7D?6789; <?G5 J559:5D57G5HJF :5;>89H5968"
"$ <5 >56767895:; <?G5 986 5G59 ;IJE7665H 6<57:
?>>C7D?6789; ;55@79A B8: :5D:I76E596 68 6<5 ;?7H 9867B75H >8;6 8B %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96 ?9H %I978:
8=5:E?9 ; ;ID< 6<5 >56767895:; =<8 <?G5 B7C5H 6<5>:5;596>5676789;J5C?65HCF<?G598C8DI;68;55@ ?9F:5E5HF
- 25 -
"" <?6 6<5 9867B7D?6789 >:5;D:7J5; E797EIE KI?C7B7D?6789 68 6<5 >8;6 8B %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96 B8: H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 ;7E7C?:CF E797EIE KI?C7B7D?6789 7; ?C;8 >:5;D:7J5H B8: %I978: 795E?9 <5 E797EIE KI?C7B7D?6789 B8: 6<5 >8;6 8B ;;7;6?96
795E?9<?;?C;8J559>:5;D:7J5H?;>5::5D:I76E596 :5AIC?6789; <5 :5D:I76E596 :5AIC?6789 B8: 6<5 >8;6 8B%I978:6?6789 6659H?96?9H%I978:
8=5:E?9<?;
986J559D<?CC59A5HJF6<5>56767895:; ;;ID<6<5 >5676789;?:5986E?796?79?JC5
" ; >5: 6<5 5?:C75: :5D:I76E596 :5AIC?6789 "#M >8;6 8B ;;7;6?96 795E?9 =5:5 :5;5:G5H B8: D?9H7H?65;
>8;;5;;79A >?;; D5:67B7D?65 8B " F5?:; Q 795E?9 :?H5C5D6:7D7?9 :?H5R 7E>?:65H JF 6<5 9HI;6:7?C :?7979A9;676I65;8B <5;?7H:5AIC?6789 =?; ?E59H5H JF 5NDCIH79A ;?7H :5;5:G?6789 =<7D< =?;D<?CC59A5H79=:76>567678979*
8$)$#$ <?6 JF 8:H5: H?65H $)#$$#$ ;?7H =:76 >5676789 =?; ?CC8=5H :5;68:79A 6<5 >:5G78I; 5N7;679A :5AIC?6789;
- 26 -
" <I; :5A?:H79A D?9H7H?65; 6<5:5 7; ?C:5?HF >:5B5:59D5 J579A A7G59 JF :5;5:G79A #M 8B >8;6;
?9H 76 7; DC5?: B:8E :H5: H?65H "#"))( =<5:579 >:5B5:59D5 =?; >:8G7H5H 79 H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596686<8;5?>>:5967D56:?795HD?9H7H?65;79 79 6<5 E?665: 8B Q86<5: 6<79A; J579A 5KI?C ?
6:?795H ?>>:5967D5;<8ICH J5 A7G59>:5B5:59D5R <5 ;?7H :5;5:G?6789 =?; ?>>C7D?JC5 89CF B8: 6<5 >8;6 8B Q ;;7;6?96 795E?9R ?9H 6<5 ;?E5 D?9986 J5 D8E>?:5H ?9H E?H5 ?>>C7D?JC5 68 6<5 >:5;596 9867B7D?6789=<7D<7;D?CC5HB8:6<5;5C5D67898B>8;68B Q%I978: 6?6789 6659H?96R ?9H Q%I978:
8=5:E?9R =<8;5 5HID?6789 KI?C7B7D?6789 J579A 7; 6<5 D:765:7? ; ;ID< 6<5 D896596789 :?7;5H JF 6<5 >56767895:; 79 6<5 ?J8G5 =:76 >5676789; ;55@79A >:5B5:59D568J5A7G59686<5?>>:5967D5H6:?795568 6<5 >8;6 8B Q%I978: 6?6789 6659H?96R ?9H Q%I978:
8=5:E?9R 7; 79D8::5D6 ?9H 986 ?>>C7D?JC5 68 6<5 >8;6;9867B75HG7H5 995NI:5
- 27 -
"& ; >5: 6<5 9867B7D?6789 H?65H #$#$ ?>>C7D?6789;B8:6<5>8;68BQ%I978:6?6789 6659H?96R 7; D?CC5H B8: :5D:I76E596 JF =?F 8B ;5C5D6789 ?9H ?;
>5: :5D:I76E596 ?9H>:8E86789 :5AIC?6789; 6<5 5HID?6789KI?C7B7D?67897;>:5;D:7J5H?;Q>?;;79
8: #6< ;6?9H?:H 5N?E79?6789 D89HID65H JF 6<5 8G5:9E596 8B ?:9?6?@? 9;676I6789;R <?6 6<5 ;5C5D6789 68 6<5;5 >8;6; =7CC J5 E?H5 J?;5H 89 6<5 E?:@ 8J6?795H 79 #6<
KI?C7B7D?6789 ?9H KI?C7BF79A59HI:?9D565;6=<7D<7;D89HID65H686<5 5C7A7JC5D?9H7H?65;796<5:?6788B <5>56767895:;
<?G5986>?:67D7>?65H796<5:5D:I76E596>:8D5;; ; ;ID<6<5F<?G598:7A<668D<?CC59A56<5:5D:I76E596 9867B7D?67898:>:8D5;;8B;5C5D6789?;>5: 995NI:5
"( <5 7;;I5 :5A?:H79A A7G79A >:5B5:59D5 68 ?>>:5967D5 68 6<5 >8;6 8B Q ;;7;6?96 795E?9R <?; J559 D89;7H5:5H JF 6<5 >5N 8I:6 79 6<5 D?;5 8B ;I>:? - 28 -
'8CC8=79A 6<5 ;?7H PIHAE596 6<7; 8I:6 79 *
8!$ ?9H $))! " & 68 " )))! "D"&"))!?9H"())!?6>?:? <?;<5CH 6<?6 Q 2 4
=
4
! +
46
44 4
42
4 :1
$ 4 2 4
+
2
((&&8
4 $ =44
46=242
2
1 4 44)
6
11
R
"! <?66<5'ICC59D<8B7A<8I:68B CC?<?J?H796<5 D?;5 8B & '"! - 29 -
( :5>8:65H 79 )* & <?; <5CH 6<?6 Q6<5 5N>:5;;789 L86<5: 6<79A; J579A 5KI?C1 79 >?:?A:?>< $ ?9H ?J;59D5 8B 5N5E>6789 B:8E D8E>56767G5 65;6 79 6<5 ;?7H >?:?A:?>< C5?H; 68 6<5 D89DCI;7896<?6?CC>5:;89;79DCIH79A6<5?>>:5967D5 <?G568?>>5?:796<5D8E>56767G565;6?;=5=8ICH >:5;D:7J579:5;>5D68B>?:67DIC?:;5C5D6789?9H7B?B65:
6<5 D8E>56767G5 65;6 ?9F ?>>:5967D5 6:?7955 A56;
5KI?C E?:@; 6<?9 ? 989?>>:5967D5 D?9H7H?65 6<59 89CF >:5B5:59D5 68 J5 A7G59 68 6<5 ;?7H ?>>:5967D5 6:?7955R
") <?6 6<5 ;?7H PIHAE596 8B 6<5 'ICC 59D< <?; J559 I><5CH JF 6<5 >5N 8I:6 796<5 D?;5 8B+, -,"&./&.
:5>8:65H 79&0
<I; :5B5::79A 68 6<5 ?J8G5 PIHAE596; 76 7; D8965965H6<?66<5DC?7E8B6<5>56767895:;8B6<5F<?G79A D8E>C565H 895 F5?: ?>>:5967D5 79 Q5C5D6:7D7?9R =76<
- 30 -
?9H<?G79AD8E>C565H6=8F5?:;B:8E 6<5G8D?6789?C6:?7979AD5965:D?9986J55KI?65H686<:55 F5?:; Q 795E?9 6:?H5RQC5D6:7D7?9 6:?H5R 7E>?:65H JF 9HI;6:7?C:?7979A9;676I658B 59D5;8IA<6 B8:H7;E7;;?C8B>5676789;
:7?G7
?67CC5?:95HD8I9;5C?>>5?:79AB8:
>56767895:; :5765:?679A 6<5 ?G5:E596; E?H5 79 6<5 =:76 >5676789; ?9H ?C;8 6?@79A 6<7; 8I:6 6<:8IA< 6<5 :5D8:H;
;IJE7665H 6<?6 6<5 7E>IA95H 9867B7D?6789 7;;I5H JF :5;>89H5968">:5;D:7J79A5C7A7JC5D:765:7?B8:6<5>8;68B Q%I978: 6?6789 6659H?96;R ?9H Q%I978:
8=5:E?9R =76< 5HID?6789?C KI?C7B7D?6789 8B #6< ;6?9H?:H 7; =76<8I6 D89;7H5:79A 6<5 D?9H7H?6I:5 8B >56767895:; =<8 <?G5 D8E>C565H =76< 895 F5?: ?>>:5967D5;<7> 6:?7979A >:8A:?E D89HID65H JF :5;>89H5968:>8:?6789 =76< ? ;>5D7B7D D89H76789 6<?6 5ND5>6 6<5 5C7A7J7C76F D:765:7? B7N5H I9H5: 6<5 9867B7D?6789 98 86<5: 5KI7G?C596 KI?C7B7D?6789 D8ICHJ5D89;7H5:5HB8:6<5>8;6D?CC5HB8:<7;7;D896:?:F 686<5;>5D7B7D?;;I:?9D5A7G597965:E;8BD8EEI97D?6789
- 31 -
H?65H"##$#$#=<5:57976=?;?;;I:5H6<?66<5D?;58B 6<5 >56767895:; =<595G5: 6<5 :5D:I76E596 9867B7D?6789;
=5:5 D?CC5H B8: =8ICH J5 D89;7H5:5H <5 ;?7H ?;;I:?9D5 =?; A7G59 79 D8E>C7?9D5 68 6<5 8:H5: >?;;5H 79 *
8!#&$)& !$#$ ?9H 6<5 H7:5D6789 7;;I5H 79 *
8"##"$# D= *
8($($# ?9H * 8"#("#!"$#$ <?6 6<5 8:H5: >?;;5H 79 6<5 ;?7H >:8D55H79A; <?; ?66?795H B79?C76F ; ;ID< 6<5 7E>IA95H 9867B7D?6789 D?CC79A B8: 6<5 >8;6 H5>:7G79A 6<5 >56767895:;8B?98>>8:6I976F68B7C5?>>C7D?67896<8IA<6<5F ?:5 ;8IA<6 68 J5 D89;7H5:5H =<595G5: ;ID< :5D:I76E596;G?D?9D75; :5KI7:5H 68 J5 B7CC5H ?; >5: 6<5 H5D7;789 79 $6< 8?:H 55679A <?6 6<5 9867B7D?6789 7;;I5H =76<8I6 D89;7H5:79A 6<5 C89A >59H79A DC?7E 8B 6<5 >56767895:;?E8I96;68H5>:7G79A6<5E8B?98>>8:6I976F8B B7C79A ?>>C7D?6789 68 6<5 G?D?96 >8;6 D896:?:F 68 6<5 ?;;I:?9D5?9H6<58:H5:;>?;;5HJF6<7;8I:6 & <?6 6<5 :5D:I76E596 9867B7D?6789 7;;I5H G7H5 D8EEI97D?6789H?65H"##$#$#;8IA<668:5CFI>896<5
- 32 -
H5D7;789 :59H5:5H 79 * 8$###$#$#$# 68 =<7D< >56767895:;=5:5 986>?:675; ;;ID< 6<5 D8EEI97D?6789 7;;I5H JF :5;>89H596 8" :5BI;79A 68 D89;7H5: 6<5 ?>>:5967D5;<7> 8B 895 F5?: 6:?7979A ?B65: JF :5CF79A I>89 6<5 ?H:5 9H 5D:I76E596 IC5; ?>>C7D?JC5 68 6<5 %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96; ?9H %I978:
8=5:E?9 G7H5 D8EEI97D?6789H?65H!#$#$"7;7CC5A?C?9HD?9986J5 ;I;6?795H <?6 6<5 ?H:5 9H 5D:I76E596 IC5; =5:5 ?E59H5H 89 #"$$#" ?9H
"$$# ?; >5: 995NI:5;?9H79D8:>8:?679A5C7A7J7C76FD:765:7?B8:6<5 >8;6 8B Q ;;7;6?96
795E?9R JF D89;7H5:79A 6<5 D?9H7H?6I:5 8B #/" F5?:; 8B ?>>:5967D5;<7> 6:?7979A >:8G7H5HJF6<59HI;6:7?C:?7979A9;676I658B
<8=5G5: 6<5 ;?7H ?H:5 9H 5D:I76E596 IC5; =5:5 E8H7B75H JF D<?9A79A 6<5 >8;6 8B Q ;;7;6?96 795E?9R 68 Q%I978:6?6789 6659H?96%I978:
8=5:E?9R=76<5C7A7J7C76F 8B #6< ;6?9H?:H =76<8I6 >:8G7H79A ?9F ;D8>5 B8: 6<5 D?9H7H?65;<?G79AD8E>C565H6<57:895F5?:?>>:5967D5;<7> J?;5H89<5:5B8:56<55967:5>:8D5HI:5?H8>65HJF
- 33 -
6<5 :5;>89H596 8"?I6<8:76F 7; 89CF 68 H5>:7G5 6<5 C5A767E?65 5N>5D6?6789 8B 6<5 >56767895:; =<8 ?:5 89CF ?J8I6!&D?9H7H?65;H7:5D65H68J5D89;7H5:5HJF:5C?N79A 6<57: ?A5 D:765:7?
79 6<5 5?:C75: 8:H5:; >?;;5H 79 *
8;!#&$)& !$#$ ?9H * 8;"#("#!"$#$ 5G59?B65:?C?>;58B$F5?:;B:8E6<5H?658BH5D7;789 <5:5B8:5 :5;>89H596 8"?I6<8:76F :5KI7:5; 68 J5 :5AIC?65H JF ?9 8:H5: 8B6<7;8I:6JF 7;;I79A H7:5D6789; 59D5;55@;B8:?CC8=79A8B6<5>5676789; (
C5?:95H 5978: 8I9;5C ?>>5?:79A B8: 6<5 :5;>89H596; :5B5::79A 68 6<5 PIHAE596; 8B 6<5 >5N 8I:6 >:8HID5H ?C89A =76< 6<5 E5E8 8B D76?6789; ;IJE76;6<?66<5G5:F9867B7D?67897E>IA95H796<5>:5;596 >5676789; 7; D?CC79A B8: 6<5 >8;6; 8B Q%I978: 6?6789 6659H?96R?9H%I978:
8=5:E?9?9H986B8:6<5>8;68B Q ;;7;6?96 795E?9R ! <?6 >56767895:; 986 <?G79A >?:67D7>?65H 79 6<5 :5D:I76E596 >:8D5;; 79 B7C79A ?9 ?>>C7D?6789; ?:5 986 59676C5H 68 KI5;6789 6<5 ;?E5 ; :5A?:H; 6<5 :5C7?9D5
- 34 -
>C?D5H896<58:H5:>?;;5H79*
8$)$#$?9H6<5 8:H5: >?;;5H 79 * 8"#("#!"$#$ =<7D< 7; :5C75H I>89 JF 6<5 >56767895:; 76 7; ;IJE7665H 6<?6 6<5 ;?E5 >5:6?79;686<5>:5G78I;:5AIC?6789;=<5:5796<5H7BB5:59D5 =?; 68 >:8G7H5H 79 6<5 H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 68 6<8;5 ?>>:5967D56:?795HD?9H7H?65;79896<5>:79D7>C5;8B Q86<5:6<79A;J579A5KI?CR?6:?795H?>>:5967D5;<8ICHJ5 A7G59 >:5B5:59D5 <5 ;?7H >:5B5:59D5:5;5:G?6789 =?;
89CF686<5>8;68B ;;7;6?96 795E?9?9H986686<5>8;6 8B %I978: 6?6789 6659H?96 ?9H %I978:
8=5:E?9 <?G79A H7BB5:596>:5;D:7J5H5C7A7J7C76FD:765:7?<5>56767895:;D8ICH J5 59676C5H 68 DC?7E ;ID< J595B76 89CF 7B 6<5F <?G5 >?:67D7>?65H796<5:5D:I76E596>:8D5;;?9H=5:5B8I9H68 J55KI?C7986<5:?;>5D6;=76<6<5D?9H7H?65;?;>7:79AB8: 6<5;?7H>8;6;79D56<5>56767895:;<?G59865G59E?H5 ?>>C7D?6789;6<5KI5;67898B?>>C7D?6789;8B;?7H>:79D7>C5;
=8ICH 986 ?:7;5 59D5 ;55@; B8: H7;E7;;?C 8B 6<5 >5676789;
) 5?:H
5:I;5H6<5:5D8:H;
- 35 -
$#
56767895:; ?:5 5;;5967?CCF ?AA:75G5H JF 7;;I?9D5 8B :5D:I76E596 9867B7D?6789 H?65H #$#$ >:8HID5H ?6 995NI:5 7;;I5H JF :5;>89H596
D?CC79AB8:6<5>8;68BL%I978:6?6789 6659H?961?9HL%I978: 8=5:E?91<5KI?C7B7D?6789>:5;D:7J5HB8:6<5;?7H>8;6; 7;?;I9H5: % # "
"""-
7 <8ICH<?G5>?;;5H 8:#6<;6?9H?:H5N?E79?6789 B:8E6?658B?:9?6?@? 77 <8ICH <?G5 6<5 @98=C5HA5 68 :5?H ?9H =:765 79 ?99?H? 777 <8ICH<?G598:E?C5F5;7A<6 7G <8ICH <?G5 ;?67;B?D68:F ><F;7D?C B7695;; ?9H E596?C ?J7C76F
%
" ! "#
""" -
7 <8ICH<?G5>?;;5H 8:#6<;6?9H?:H5N?E79?6789 B:8E6<56?658B?:9?6?@? 77 <8ICH <?G5 >I6 79 E797EIE # F5?:; 8B ;?67;B?D68:F ;5:G7D5?;>:8J?6789?:FE?OH8: 777 <8ICH<?G5@98=C5HA58B?99?H?68:5?H?9H=:765 7G <8ICH<?G598:E?C5F5;7A<6 G <8ICH <?G5 ;?67;B?D68:F ><F;7D?C B7695;; ?9H E596?C ?J7C76F
- 36 -
G7 <8ICHJ589>:8J?6789B8:#F5?:
$ <5 >56767895:; 89 6<5 86<5: <?9H DC?7E 6<?6 6<5F?:5<8CH79A6<5KI?C7B7D?67898B=76<?C89A=76< #F5?:?>>:5967D5;<7>D5:67B7D?65I9H5:6<5 >>:5967D5;<7> D6 )& 7;;I5H JF ?9H ?CC # 7G7;789; 8B <5:57;98H7;>I658B6<5B?D66<?6686<5>8;68B L ;;7;6?96 795E?91 :5D:I76E596 :5AIC?6789; >:5;D:7J5H B8CC8=79AKI?C7B7D?6789?9HE56<8H8B:5D:I76E596
"""
#M 8B 6<5 ;?9D67895H >8;6 JF H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 8B KI?C7B75HD?9H7H?65;
797EIEKI?C7B7D?6789. <8ICH <?G5 ? >?;; D5:67B7D?65 8B !$ E896<; D8I:;5 79 LC5D6:7D7?91LC5D6:897D;1LC5D6:897D 5D<?97D :?H51 B:8E 6<5 9HI;6:7?C :?7979A 9;676I65 :5D8A97O5H JF 8G5:9E596 8B ?:9?6?@? "#M 8B ;?9D67895H >8;6 JF H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596 8B D?9H7H?65;
>8;;5;;79A ? >?;; D5:67B7D?65 8B #" F5?: L 795E?9 :?H51 LC5D6:7D7?9:?H517E>?:65HJF6<59HI;6:7?C:?H79A9;676I65
797EIEKI?C7B7D?6789 <8ICH <?G5 ? >?;; #6< ;6?9H?:H 5N?E79?6789 ?9H ;<8ICH <?G5 ?
>?;; D5:67B7D?65 8B 6<:55 F5?:; Q 795E?9 6:?H5RC5D6:7D7?9 :?H5R 7E>?:65H JF 6<5 9HI;6:7?C :?7979A 9;676I658B
$#M8B6<5;?9D67895H>8;6JF>:8E86789B:8E6<5D?H:5;8B %I978: 795E?9896<5J?;7;8B;5978:76FDIEE5:76
- 37 -
$$ <8IA<767;6<5D?;58B6<5>56767895:;6<?66<5 ?E59HE596 68 6<5 :5AIC?6789 5NDCIH79A :5;5:G?6789 8B
"#M>8;6;8BL ;;7;6?96 795E?91LC5D6:7D7?9:?H51=?; ;IJP5D6 E?665: 8B D<?CC59A5 79 6<5 *:76 5676789 8$)$#$ =<7D< =?; ?CC8=5H :5;68:79A 6<5 5N7;679A :5AIC?6789;6<5;?E5D?9986J55N659H5H686<5>:5;596 9867B7D?6789H?65H#$#$?;>5: 995NI:5=<7D<7;
68 6<5 >8;6; 8B L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 ?9H L%I978: 8=5:E?91 $" <5 >8;6 8B L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 ?9H L%I978:
8=5:E?91=76<6<5E797EIEKI?C7B7D?67898B
?; 9865H ?J8G5 D?9986 J5 5KI?65H 68 6<5 >8;6 8B L ;;7;6?96 795E?91:5KI7:79A>?;;D5:67B7D?658B"F5?:;79 ? L 795E?9 :?H51LC5D6:7D7?9 :?H51 7E>?:65H JF 9HI;6:7?C :?H79A 9;676I65 8B <5 >8;6 8B L ;;7;6?96 795E?91 J579A H7BB5:596 ?9H H7;679D6 B:8E 6<?6 8B 6<5 >8;6; 8B L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 ?9H L%I978: 8=5:E?91D?9986J5D8E>?:5H
- 38 -
$ 5D5;;?:F 68 9865 6<?6 6<5 >56767895:; ?:5 DC?7E79A 6<?6 6<5F 8IA<6 68 J5 A7G59 >:5B5:59D5 79 6<5 :5D:I76E596 >:8D5;; J?;5H 89 6<5 8:H5: >?;;5H 79 *
8$)$#$ H?65H $)#$$#$ ?9H 6<5 H7:5D6789 7;;I5H 79 6<5 *
!#&$)& !$#$ ?9H 79 *:76 >>5?C 8"#("#!"$#$?;=5CC?;896<5>I:>8:65H?;;I:?9D5 A7G5989"##$#$#JF6<5:5;>89H5968"79?H5D7;789 8B$6<8?:HE55679A $ 9 6<5 8:H5: H?65H $)#$$#$ >?;;5H 79 *
8$)$#$ D8995D65H =76< *
8$!" $#$ ?9H *
8$ # $#$ 6<5 88:H79?65 59D< 8B 6<7;
8I:6 KI?;<79A 6<5 ?E59HE596 68 6<5 :5AIC?6789; <?H ?CC8=5H6<5=:76>5676789;796<5B8CC8=79AE?995: ? 244
=
! 4
*/ )"87 2 ! 04
4 ! 4
44
42
* "
6*/ )9
- 39 -
@ 4 4 ! ! 4
44 42 * "
6*/ )9 @ ! 44
*/ )9
2 26 1 4
4 4
! ! *
" /
4
1 4
= =
=3
@ ! =
1 4 2 4 *"
42
@ ; 4
1
44 44 4
= 04
"= 4 4 ;
42A
$& <5?B8:5;?7H8:H5:=?;:5765:?65H796<58:H5:
H?65H #"#$#$ >?;;5H 79 *
8;!#&$)!#& !$#$ 8=5G5: HI:79A 6<5 >59H59DF 8B 6<5 * 8"#(
"#!"$#$J?;5H896<5E5E8H?65H#!$#"?;=5CC ?; E5E8 H?65H $&$#" =<7D< 7; 5N6:?D65H ?6 >?:?A:?>< 8;# ?9H 8B 6<5 ;?7H 8:H5: 6<5 7G7;789
- 40 -
59D< 8B 6<7; 8I:6 H7;>8;5H =:76 ?>>5?C JF 7;;I79A 6<5 B8CC8=79AH7:5D6789; ?B !
2 4 +4 C & D
2 6 &##=
7()'# ')''#+)0,+ 2 42
4
@
@E B - @ 2 4
+4C
2 E B
6
44#
1 4/ ))
= 4
2
44 *"64
4 2*44#
E @B D
6 44#
44
= 44
)) 6/
426 1
E @B 4
4 44
A
$( 9 BI:6<5:?9D5 68 6<5 ?B8:5;?7H 8:H5:; >?;;5H JF 6<7; 8I:6 6<5 :5;>89H596 <?H 7;;I5H ?9 59H8:;5E596 H?65H
"##$#$# ?; >5: 995NI:5
- 41 -
=<5:579 ?6 >?A5 8B 6<5 59H8:;5E596 6<5 B8CC8=79A I9H5:6?@79A?;;I:?9D5=?;A7G59
!" # $%&
' ( ) !* *! +*'! , !' - . !#/ 0
12(
*
345 6
7 89! ,: -;( - <= <88 >? 8,! @A 9( !" )
BC* ? DEFEDE <* >1! * ) )@AG H = ;,I *!@ >1 J% )* B * $*! =!*'?KL ,EMN ! O9 * 8> 0P >? @A 8#
: Q%7 J R 6 ?%BES
$! <I; 6<5 >56767895:; ?:5 DC?7E79A 6<57: :7A<6 J?;5H 89 6<5 ?J8G5 8:H5:; ?9H >I:>8:65H ?;;I:?9D5; 5?H79A8B6<5?B8:5;?7H8:H5:;>?;;5HJF6<7;8I:6?9H 6<5 59H8:;5E596 ?;;I:?9D5 H?65H "##$#$# =8ICH 79H7D?65 6<?6 >:5B5:59D5 =?; 68 J5 >:8G7H5H 79 H7:5D6 :5D:I76E596686<8;5?>>:5967D56:?795HD?9H7H?65;79 =<7C5 :5D:I7679A 68 6<5 >8;6 8B L ;;7;6?96 795E?91 89 6<5 >:79D7>C5;8BL86<5:6<79A;J579A5KI?C1
- 42 -
$) ; ?C:5?HF 9865H ?J8G5 ;79D5 6<5 :5D:I76E596 9867B7D?6789?;>5: 995NI:57E>IA95H796<5;5>5676789;
7; 68 6<5 >8;6; 8B L%I978:
8=5:E?91 ?9H L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 =76< ? H7BB5:596 KI?C7B7D?6789 >:5;D:7J5H 6<5 >56767895:; =<8 >8;;5;; D8E>C565CF H7BB5:596 KI?C7B7D?6789 B8: 6<5 >8;6 8B L ;;7;6?96 795E?91 D?9986 J5D89;7H5:5H I9H5:6<5>:79D7>C5;8BL86<5:6<79A;J579A5KI?C1
"# ;:7A<6CF>87965H8I6JFC5?:95HD8I9;5CB8:6<5 :5;>89H596 6<5 5N>:5;;789 8B 6<5 65:E L86<5: 6<79A;
J579A5KI?C1I;5H796<5PIHAE5968B6<5 >5N8I:6796<5 D?;5 8B
1=<7D<B79H;E5967895H796<559H8:;5E596H?65H
"##$#$# ?6 995NI:5 68 6<5 =:76 >5676789 <?; J559 5N>C?795H?9HDC?:7B75HJF6<5'ICC59D<8B6<5 CC?<?J?H 7A< 8I:6 79 6<5 D?;5 8B & '"! 1 =<5:579 ?6 >?:?A:?>< 8; ?9H & 76 <?; J559 <5CH ?; I9H5: ?'*
/
1
( !
4 /
- 43 -
(
<4 42
1
(= 4 3 F F
+ 1 1
* 4 1
C 3 4 42
4
4
/
24
2/ 4/
/
% 1=6 / F
4F
/
1
64
4 44 4 1
162
4 4
6 1 6 2
4 3
)
6
42
1
A
" <5 ;?7H 'ICC 59D< PIHAE596 8B & '"!1; D?;5 1 <?; J559 I><5CH JF 6<5 >5N 8I:6 79 6<5 D?;5 8B +, -," &./&. "$ 9 86<5: =8:H; 7B 6<5 >56767895:; <5:579 ?:5 79659H79A68?G?7C6<5J595B768B6<5D89D5;;789?;;I:?9D5 7B?9F6<5F?:5:5KI7:5H68D8E>CF=76<?9H>?:67D7>?6579 6<5;5C5D6789>:8D5;;<5>56767895:;<?G59865G59B7C5H
- 44 -
6<57: ?>>C7D?6789; ;55@79A :5D:I76E596 68 6<5 >8;6; 8B L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 ?9H L%I978:
8=5:E?91 9867B75H 796<57E>IA95H9867B7D?6789
"" >5N 8I:6 79 76; PIHAE596 79 6<5 D?;5 8B !232//45 $ :5>8:65H 79 )
* ?6 >?:?A:?><8(<?;<5CH?;I9H5: ?8! 1
=
=
42
=* *1
4
2 =
4 2 4
2 ! 44
4 23
1
42+
* ) 42
= 44 4 2 4
2
2 4
2
2 =
4
+)
=1
1
= 2 ) =
446
4 4
6 1 4
2 6 4
2
446
4
6 4 4
2 6 44
14
2 2
2
! 1
*04
=
2 =
=4
2
=
= * *1
44 1 4
2 6
4 2 4
2
- 45 -
4
4
0
= 2 4 =
4 1 4
2 6 4
2 42 44
2 4
2
2 44
=
0 =
4
44 1
=4 A
" G59 79 6<5 79;6?96 D?;5 6<5:5 7; 98 D896:?D6D89H76789 J56=559 6<5 >56767895:; ?9H :5;>89H5968:>8:?6789 8=5G5: 6<5 DC?7E 8B 6<5 >56767895:;?;9865H?J8G57;J?;5H896<58:H5:;8B6<7; 8I:6 ?9H 6<5 >I:>8:65H ?;;I:?9D5 A7G59 I9H5:
995NI:5 66<5D8;68B:5>5676789767;68J59865H6<?6 79?9F5G596>56767895:;D?9986DC?7E?9F>:5B5:59D589 6<5 A:8I9H 8B 6<5 8:H5:; >?;;5H 79 6<5 ?B8:5;?7H =:76 >5676789; ?9H =:76 ?>>5?C; ?9H 6<5 ?;;I:?9D5 A7G59 79 995NI:579?;EID<?;6<8;58:H5:;?9H6<5?;;I:?9D5 =5:5>5:6?7979A686<5>8;6;8BL ;;7;6?96 795E?91=76<?
H7BB5:596KI?C7B7D?6789>:5;D:7J5H6<5:5I9H5:?9H986686<5 >8;6 8B L%I978: 6?6789 6659H?961 ?9H L%I978: 795E?91 =<7D< <?G5 H7BB5:596 ?9H H7;679D6 KI?C7B7D?6789; ?9H :5;>89;7J7C7675;
- 46 -
" 96<?6G75=8B6<5E?665:6<7;8I:67;8B6<5 D89;7H5:5H G75= 6<?6 6<5 >56767895:; <?G5 986 E?H5 8I6 ?9FA:8I9H;B8:A:?9679A>:?F5:;?;;8IA<6B8:
DD8:H79ACF6<5=:76>5676789;?:5! .( &" "' %
%%
7;68C8$