- 1 - ! "# $ ## #%% & &'%() & (( * ! " # # # $% & '( !" Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' )*$ "' " $') #" &' ! ' ' +" , & ' " " %-) )) ' % ' )%% % )$ " )$ " )$ ' !# ' ! ' ' &# ! . & $# . & " /012203314560748199:;0<74209713 1;0 " = =4 5/0 >730 => 5/0 301?40< <<757=413 7;5?795 14<0;;7=4;&:<8014<' "151316:?1877; 7@2:84748 5/0 A:<8@045 => 9=4B7957=4 14< =?<0? => 0450490 <150< %-) 9=4B795748 /7@ >=? 5/0 =>>0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4; )%% )$ " 77" )$ " )$ " " )$ )*% " 4" % => 5/0 4<714 0413 =<0% >=?;/=?5. ."14<0957=4;%14< => 5/0 ?=50957=4 => /73<?04 >?=@ 0C:13 >>0490; 95 >=? ;/=?5 D 95," 14< ;045049748 /7@ 5= - 3 - :4<0?8= ?78=?=:; 7@2?7;=4@045 >=? 1 20?7=< => E01?; 14< 21E 1 >740 => ; >=? 5/0 =>>0490 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4 % => 5/0 95( 5= :4<0?8= 7@2?7;=4@045 >=? 1 20?7=< => * E01?; 14< 21E 1 >740 => ;%>=?5/0=>>04902:47;/1630:4<0?0957=4)%%=> (5=:4<0?8=7@2?7;=4@045>=?120?7=<=>E01?;14< 21E1>740=>;>=?5/0=>>04902:47;/1630:4<0? 0957=4%=> (5=:4<0?8=7@2?7;=4@045>=?120?7=< => E01? 14< 21E 1 >740 => ; >=? 5/0 =>>0490 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4 )$ " => ( 5= :4<0?8= 7@2?7;=4@045 >=? 1 20?7=< => E01? 14< 21E 1 >740 => ;>=?5/0=>>04902:47;/1630:4<0?0957=4)$ " " => ( 5= :4<0?8= 7@2?7;=4@045 >=? 1 20?7=< => % @=45/; 14< 21E 1 >740 => ; >=? 5/0 =>>0490 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4 )$ => ( 5= :4<0?8= 7@2?7;=4@045 >=? 1 20?7=< => E01? 14< 21E 1 >740 => ;>=?5/0=>>04902:47;/1630:4<0?0957=4=> 5/0 95F75/<0>1:35;0450490; - 4 - '195; => 5/0 91;0 74 6?70> 1?0 5/15 #5/0 @=5/0?=>5/0B7957@87?33=<80<5/0>7?;574>=?@157=4F75/ 75E#=@04=37905157=41316:?18718174;55/0199:;0< 1;20?C*133087489=@@7;;7=4=>5/0=>>04901;;5150< 16=B0>50?74B0;578157=49/1?80;/00591@05=60>730< 5 7; 5/0 9=450457=4 => 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 5/15 B7957@ 7; 1 @74=? 180< 16=:5 % E01?; /0 199:;0< :;0< 5= 74<:90 /0? 5= /1B0 2/E;7913 ?03157=4;/72 4 * 15 -) 1@ F/04 5/0 B7957@ F1; 401? /0? ;9/==3 5/0 199:;0< G7<41220</0?=4/7;@=5=?9E93014<<0@14<0<>=?;0C:13 >1B=:?09=@@7550<;513G748;0C:13/1?1;;@045;0C:13 1;;1:35 14< 188?1B150< 20405?157B0 ;0C:13 1;;1:35 ?020150<3E /0 13;= 9=@@7550< ?=660?E => 5/0 8=3< 9/174 F078/748%8?1@;14<5/0?06E9=@@7550<5/0=>>0490;1; ;5150<16=B0 ) /0 ?713 =:?5 5==G 9=847H1490 >=? 5/0 16=B0 ;17< =>>0490; 14< ;:@@=40< 5/0 199:;0< /0 199:;0< /1; 12201?0< 60>=?0 5/0 ?713 =:?5 14< 2301<0< 4=5 8:735E /0 2?=;09:57=4 /1; 0C1@740< #; 5= 8=5 - 5 - @1?G0<C;5=-14<7<0457>70<;5=74;:22=?5 => 75; 9=450457=4 /0 199:;0< /1; <0470< 133 5/0 749?7@7415748 @150?713; 1B1731630 =4 ?09=?< 74 /7; ;5150@045 :4<0? 0957=4 )) => ? 6:5 /1; 4=5 9/=;04 5= 301< 14E 0B7<0490 74 ;:22=?5 => /7; <0>0490 =F0B0? C; 5= - F0?0 8=5 @1?G0< <:?748 9?=;; 0C1@74157=4=>2?=;09:57=4F7540;;0; $ >50?51G748745=9=4;7<0?157=41335/0@150?713; =4?09=?<5/0?713 =:?591@05=5/09=493:;7=45/155/0 2?=;09:57=4 7; ;:990;;>:3 74 2?=B748 5/0 8:735 => 5/0 199:;0< >=? 5/0 =>>0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4; )%% )$ " 77")$ ")$ " ")$)*% " 4"%=> 14< 0957=4; % 14< => 5/0 95 14< ;0450490< /7@ 1; ;5150< 16=B0 0748 188?70B0< 6E 5/0 ;1@05/0199:;0</1;122?=19/0<5/7; =:?56E>737485/0 122013 01?< ?7 14<G7;/=?0 ==6 301?40< 9=:4;03 >=? 5/0 122033145 14< ?7 &1@1<1? /1/16:<<74 301?40< 78/ =:?5 =B0?4@045 301<0? >=? ?0;2=4<045 = - 6 - 51500;2=4<045=5/=:8/;0?B0<F75/5/04=5790/1; ?0@1740< :4?02?0;0450< 0?:;0< 5/0 @150?713; 7493:<748 5/0?713 =:?5?09=?<; % 4 B70F => 5/0 ?7B13 9=450457=4; :?80< 6E 301?40<9=:4;03>=?6=5/5/021?570;5/02=7455/15F=:3< 1?7;0>=?@E9=4;7<0?157=47; E 14;F0? 5= 5/0 16=B0 2=745 7; 74 5/0 .>>7?@157B0. >=?5/0>=33=F748 * 57;5/09=450457=4=>5/02?=;09:57=45/155/0 199:;0<74<:90<5/0@74=?87?3180<%E01?;G7<41220< /0? 9=@@7550< ;0C:13 /1?1;;@045 ;513G748 188?1B150< 20405?157B0;0C:131;;1:3514<13;=9=@@7550<?=660?E=> 5/0 8=3< 9/174 # 7; 5/0 B7957@ F/= /1; <02=;0< 74 - 7 - ;:22=?5 => 5/0 91;0 => 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 5 7; 20?574045 5= 4=50 5/15 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 8=5 @1?G0< C5/0 ;5150@045 => 5/0 B7957@ 87?3 ?09=?<0< 6E 5/0 301?40< 187;5?150 :4<0? 0957=4 %$ => ? /7; ;5150@045 F1;?09=?<0<=4)7@@0<71503E1>50??087;5?157=4 => 5/0 ' =4 - /0 B7957@ /1; 87B04 /0? ;5150@04560>=?05/0301?40<187;5?1505/15;/091@05= 5/0 =:?513=48F75//0?@=5/0?/0F1;743=B0F75/5/0 199:;0<;/0F045F75//7@=4*6=5/=>5/0@ /1B08=405=/7;/=:;05/0E/1<2/E;7913?03157=4;/7214< 3150? ?05:?40< 5= /0? /=:;0 #7540;; ;5150< 5/15 /0? @=5/0? /1< 3=<80< 5/0 >7?;5 74>=?@157=4 18174;5 5/0 199:;0< 6:5 5/0 199:;0< /1< 40B0? >=?90< /0? 5= /1B0 ?03157=4;/72 /0 13;= ;5150< 5/15 ;/0 /1; 87B04 5/0 ;5150@045 B=3:451?73E F75/=:5 14E >01? =? >=?90 >?=@ 14E6=<E /00B7<0490<02=;0<6E#60>=?05/0?713 =:?5 7; 0457?03E 9=45?1?E 5= C #7540;; /1; 8=40 5= 5/00C5045=>;1E7485/15;/0/1;87B045/0;5150@0451; - 8 - 20?C1;5/0199:;0</1<9?7@74133E 7457@7<150</0? /0 F7540;; ;2097>79133E ;5150< 74 C 5/15 ;/0 F1; 199=@21470<6E/0?@=5/0?14<5/0199:;0<F1;4=5F75/ /0? 1; /0 F1; 13?01<E 122?0/04<0< <= 4=5 >74< 14E 0B7<0490 5= 2?=B0 ;:9/ 7457@7<157=4 5/15 /1< 74>3:0490< 5/0 B7957@ 87?3 5= 87B0 ;:9/ ;5150@04560>=?0 5/0 301?40< 187;5?150 - #7;5/0<=95=?F/=0C1@740<5/0B7957@ 87?3 =4 - 70 7@@0<71503E 1>50? ?087;5?157=4 => 5/0'C%7;5/00<79= 0813C1@74157=402=?5=> ;0C:13 B7=30490 99=?<748 5= 75 5/0 /7;5=?E 87B04 6E 5/0 B7957@ /0?;03> ;515748 5/15 199:;0< 7; /0? 4078/6=:? 14< 5/0EF0?037G748=4014=5/0?/0/1<8=405=5/0/=:;0 =>5/0199:;0<B=3:451?73E=4*15-)1@14< 74<:380< 74 ;0C:13 195 F/79/ 7; 13;= 1 B=3:451?E 195 =F0B0? 3150? ;/0 0C20?70490< 2174 14< 5/0?0>=?0 ?0>:;0<5=<=;:9/195/0199:;0</1<40B0?>=?90</0? 749=@@755748;0C:13195;!7957@/1;13;=;5150<5/15;/0 F1; F75/ 5/0 199:;0< >=? =B0? =40 /=:? 14< 5/0?01>50? - 9 - ?05:?40<5=5/0/=:;0/0;1@230;F0?09=330950<6E5/0 0<7913 >>790? 14< ;045 >=? 0C1@74157=4 >50? ?090725 => 5/0' ?02=?55/0>7413?02=?51;20?C*F1;7;;:0< ; 20? 5/0 >7413 ?02=?5 4= 63==< ;5174; F0?0 <050950< 74 14E => 5/0 1?57930; 0@7413 ;5174 14< 20?@15=H=1 F0?0 13;= 4=5 <050950< ; 20? >7413 =2747=4 => 5/0 <=95=? E@04 F1; 745195 14< 5/0?0 7; 4= 0B7<0490 => ?09045 ;0C:137450?9=:?;0/00B7<0490=>#F/=0C1@740< 5/0B7957@87?314<7;;:0<C;%14<*745/0378/5=> C >13;7>70; 5/0 9=450457=4 => 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 F75/ ?081?<5=>=?97630G7<4122748;0C:13/1?1;;@045;513G748 188?1B150<20405?157B0;0C:131;;1:35?=660?E059 57;20?5740455=4=505/155/0B7957@F1;180< %E01?;155/057@0=>7497<0451;20?5/0;9/==3?09=?<; 2?=<:90< 1; 20? C$ 14< 0B7<0490 => # 5 7; 13;= 20?574045 5= 4=50 5/15 199:;0< 7; 180< E01?; /0?0>=?0757;9301?5/155/0199:;0<14<5/0B7957@F0?0 5004180?; F/= 1?0 155?1950< 5=F1?<; =40 14=5/0? 14< 74<:380<74;0C:131957B75E4B70F=>5/0@0<7913?09=?<; - 10 - 5/0 /E@04 => 5/0 B7957@ F1; 745195 14< 5/0?0>=?0 5/0 9=450457=4=>5/02?=;09:57=45/155/0199:;0<9=@@7550< 188?1B150<20405?157B0;0C:131;;1:35?020150<3E5/155== >=?9763E9144=5601990250< /0>7?;5B0?;7=4=>5/0B7957@<7;93=;0;5/1575 F1;1B=3:451?E195B045/=:8/5/0B7957@F1;19/73< 180< % E01?; ;/0 12201?; 5= /1B0 ;:>>797045 @15:?75E /0 199:;0< 60748 5/0 5004180? @1E 4=5 G4=F 5/0 9=4;0I:0490; => /7; 195 14< 1; ;:9/ 6=5/ => 5/0@ /1B0 74<:380<74;:9/195;4<0?;:9/97?9:@;51490;5?015748 5/087?3 1; 1 B7957@ 14< 5/0 6=E 1; 199:;0< F733 ?0;:35 74 8?015 74A:;5790 /0?0>=?0 1@ => 5/0 =2747=4 5/15 5/0 199:;0<7;0457530<>=?19I:75513 /1B08=405/?=:8/5/07@2:840<A:<8@045=> 9=4B7957=414<=?<0?=>;045049021;;0<6E5/0?713 =:?5 5 /1; 6374<3E 1990250< 5/0 B0?;7=4 => 5/0 B7957@ F/= 7; <02=;0< 1; # 14< 2?=900<0< 5= 9=4B795 5/0 199:;0< F75/=:551G748745=9=4;7<0?157=4CJ;5150@045=>5/0 B7957@:4<0?0957=4%$=> ? 14<5/0/7;5=?E87B04 - 11 - 6E5/0B7957@/0?;03>1;20?C%155/001?370;52=745=> 57@05/1;13;=4=551G04745=9=4;7<0?157=45/0=2747=4 => 5/0 0<7913 >>790? # /0?0>=?0 1@ => 5/0 =2747=4 5/15 5/0 7@2:840< A:<8@045 => 9=4B7957=4 14< =?<0? => ;0450490 ;:>>0?; >?=@ 733081375E 784=?748 5/0 @150?713;=4?09=?<14<5/0?0>=?05/0;1@07;3716305=60 ;051;7<099=?<7483E14;F0?5/02=745>=?9=4;7<0?157=4 745/0D ,14<2?=900<5=21;;5/0>=33=F748 7" /0 ?7@7413220137; 77" /0 7@2:840< &:<8@045 => 9=4B7957=4 <150<%-)14<=?<0?=>0450490 <150< )) 21;;0< 74 209713 1;0 "==45/0>730=>301?40< <<757=413 7;5?795 14< 0;;7=4; &:<80 ' "1316:?1877;/0?06E;05 1;7<0 - 12 - 777" =4;0I:0453E199:;0<7;19I:7550<=>5/0 =>>0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4; )%% )$ " 77" )$ " " )$ )*% " 4" 14<%=> 14<0957=4;%14<=> 5/0 95 7B" 173 6=4< => 5/0 199:;0< 14< 5/15 => /7; ;:?0570;;/133;514<91490330< B" '740 1@=:45 7> 14E <02=;750< 6E 5/0 199:;0<7;=?<0?0<5=60?0>:4<0<5=/7@ 1>50?12201320?7=<7;=B0? 087;5?E5=;04<619G5/0 13=48F75/9=2E=>5/7; A:<8@045>=?74>=?@157=414<>=?400<>:31957=4 +) &##( $ 7;5=3=)