- 1 - ! " #!$$ %% &$' () %% * ( ) !"# $ % &$ $' ( )*" ) $ ) ') )!"# )** ) *+" ) "" ') )!"# % &$ $ , ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - -*&( +#*$ . . . " +#* $ . . ' *( ) )*" ) $ ) ') )!"# % &$ $$ ( )** ) *+" ) "" ') )!"# !"# % &$ $' , ( - 3 - -*&( $ $ $ . " $ . . +#* . ' / . ) ) 0$ . ! 1233456756 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4: " ?2@@4: AB ::7<7C523 457C> 7D73 .9:64 25:. 27E19> &FC> @1C>< G<>7A9523/( 75 5C+#* <14@4 2??423@ 2>4 F734:ABAC<1E327;25<25:75@9>4>1734 5C-#" 7@ F734: AB 75@9>4> E1233456756 2=2>: C5 H925<9; 5C-" 7@ F734: AB E327;25< FC> 45125E4;45< CF EC;?45@2<7C5 $>74F F2E<@ 2@ @<2<4: 2>4 <12< C5 + E327;25< =2@ ?7337C5 >7:4> C5 ;C<C>EBE34 5C *+" 145 7< =2@C5 27E19>$7825264>2 >C2: >7:4>>C:4 7< 75 >2@1 25: 54637645< ;2554> :94 <C =17E1 7< @I7::4: E327;25< F433 :C=525:@9@<2754:7589>74@4@?7<42:;7<<4:<C1C@?7<2325: - 4 - <2I756 <>42<;45< 14 :7: 5C< >4ECD4> F933B 25: @9@<2754: ?4>;2545< ?1B@7E23 :7@2A737<B 25: 3C@@ CF 42>5756 E2?2E7<B 14>4FC>4 14 F734: E327; ?4<7<7C5 95:4> 4E<7C5 ++ CF C<C> 417E34@E<26275@<C=54>25:75@9>4>CF;C<C>EBE34 * 5EC5<4@<=14>475E327;?4<7<7C5=2@C??C@4:C5 233 EC95<@ <>7A9523 F>2;4: 7@@94@ 25: >4EC>:4: 4D7:45E4 327;25<4J2;754:17;@43F25:>9;25 2@@25: J@ <C * =4>4 6C< ;2>I4: FF7E723 CF 75@9>4> =2@ 4J2;754:2@25:J@K6C<;2>I4: # 5 EC5@7:4>2<7C5 <>7A9523 143: 2EE7:45< CEE9>>4: :94 <C >2@1 25: 54637645< >7:756 CF 75@9>4: ;C<C>EBE34 AB 7<@ >7:4> E327;25< @9@<2754: 7589>B?4>;2545< ?1B@7E23 :7@2A737<B 25:=2@45<7<34:FC>EC;?45@2<7C5F>C;75@9>4>2@FC33C=@) C@@CFF9<9>475EC;4 #-"--+ 27525:@9FF4>756 * C@@CF75EC;4:9>756327:9??4>7C: # <<45:25<<>25@?C><2<7C525:;7@E4J?45@4@ " C@@CF2;457<74@K59<>7<7C5FCC: + 4:7E234J?45@4@ C<23 - 5 - " 7@@2<7@F74: =7<1 2@@4@@;45< AC<1 E327;25< 25: 75@9>4>=4>4752??423 + >7 C1:A:93'2BB9;342>54:EC95@43FC>75@9>4> @9A;7<<4: <12< E327;25< @9@<2754: F>2E<9>4 CF @12F< CF >761< F4;9> 2@@4@@4: AB <C 12D4 E29@4: "L :7@2A737<B >7A9523 EC5@7:4>4: F95E<7C523 :7@2A737<B 2< L 25: 2::4: F9<9>4?>C@?4E<@<C;C5<13B75EC;44D45757589>BE2@4<=2@ @9A;7<<4: 4D45 2=2>: CF @" <C=2>:@ ?275 25: @9FF4>756 @"- <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CF 75EC;4 :9>756 327:9? ?4>7C: @"+ <C=2>:@ 75E7:45<23 4J?45@4@ @" <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CF 2;457<74@ 25: @+ <C=2>:@ F9<9>4 ;4:7E234J?45@4@=4>4C517614>@7:425:@C961<>4:9E<7C5CF EC;?45@2<7C5 - 5 C<14> 125: >7 2562526C9:2 $7>2:2> 342>54:EC95@43FC>E327;25<2??43325<C??C@4:75@9>4>/@2??423 25: @C961< 45125E4;45< < =2@ @9A;7<<4: 2@ ?4> C?757C5 CF E327;25< @9@<2754: 37;A :7@2A737<B CF "L :94 <C >4@<>7E<7C5 CF ;CD4;45< CF 17? 14>4FC>4 2@@4@@;45< CF F95E<7C523 :7@2A737<B 2< L =2@ C5 3C=4> @7:4 25: @C961< 45125E4;45< - 6 - 42>: 342>54: EC95@43 25: ?4>9@4: 7;?9654: 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: 25: E4><7F74: EC?74@ CF :4?C@7<7C5 25: 4J17A7<@ ;2:4 2D2732A34 FC> ?4>9@23 CF <17@ C9>< AB 342>54: EC95@43FC>E327;25<2??43325< >C;2ACD4@75E4AC<175@9>4>2@=4332@E327;25< 2>4H94@<7C57562@@4@@;45<CFEC;?45@2<7C5?C75<<12<=C93: 2>7@4FC>EC5@7:4>2<7C57@) 2;47@25@=4>4:?2><3B752FF7>;2<7D4FC>FC33C=756 >42@C5@) >C;2ACD4CEE9>>45E4CF2EE7:45<:94<C>2@125: 54637645< >7:756 CF 75@9>4: ;C<C>EBE34 AB 7<@ >7:4> E327;25< @9@<275756 7589>74@?4>;2545< ?1B@7E23 :7@2A737<B 25: 75@9>4> A4756372A34<C?2BEC;?45@2<7C52>45C<75:7@?9<4327;25< @<2<4: <12< 14 =2@ * B42>@ CF 264 =C>I756 2@ ?39;A4> 25: 42>5756 @* ?4> ;C5<1 @ @2;4 =2@ 5C< @9A@<25<72<4: <>7A9523 >761<3B 2@@4@@4: ;C5<13B 75EC;4 2< @#-" - 7 - 327;25< @9@<2754: F>2E<9>4 CF 3C=4> *>: CF >761< F4;9> 2@ ?4> J"=C95: E4><7F7E2<4 25: J:7@2A737<B E4><7F7E2<4 4J2;754: E327;25< 25: 2@@4@@4: 37;A :7@2A737<B 2< "L 4>9@23 CF J =C93: 75:7E2<4 <12< 12:2@@4@@4::7@2A737<B:94<C>4@<>7E<7C5CF;CD4;45<CF17? 2I7565C<4CFF2E<<12<F>2E<9>4@9@<2754:=2@<C3C=4>*>:CF >761<F4;9>7<=C93:A4:7FF7E93<<C2EE4?<@27:F>2E<9>4E29@756 >4@<>7E<7C5CF;CD4;45<CF17?4@?4E7233B=7<1C9<4J?3252<7C5AB 5 2A@45E4 CF @2;4 2@@4@@;45< CF F95E<7C523 :7@2A737<B 2<LAB<>7A9523=C93:2??42>89@<25:?>C?4> * C5/A34 9?>4;4 C9>< 75 E2@4 CF ! !"# $% & ' 12@ 143: <14>4 12@ <C A4 2::7<7C5 CF F9<9>4 ?>C@?4E<@ <C ;C5<13B 75EC;4 4D45 75 ?4>@C523 7589>B E327;@ 75DC3D756 =1734 :423756 =7<1 E2@4 CF ?2>2?34672 4E7@7C5@ >4F4>>4:<C<14>475=4>4E2@4@CF2;?9<2<7C54<E7;?3B756<12< F9<9>4 ?>C@?4E<@ 12D4 <C A4 2::4: 75 ?4>@C523 7589>B E327;@ =14>4 :7@2A737<B 2@@4@@4: 7@ 75E4 :7@2A737<B 1 &*(*#* - 8 - 2@@4@@4:7@2<LC53B2::7<7C5CFF9<9>4?>C@?4E<@=C93:5C< A489@<7F74:19@EC;?45@2<7C5<C=2>:@3C@@CFF9<9>475EC;4 =C93:A4) @#-"JLJ+JM@**# # 327;25<12:@9@<2754:F>2E<9>4CF>761<F4;9>17@ C9>< 5C>;233B 2=2>:@ @" FC> ;28C> F>2E<9>4@ 25: @" <C=2>:@ ;75C> F>2E<9>4@ 5:4> E7>E9;@<25E4@ 2=2>: CF @" <C=2>:@ ?275 25: @9FF4>756 =C93: A4 4JE4@@7D425:>4H97>4@>4:9E<7C5<C@* " C>;233BF>2E<9>4@<2I42AC9<<1>44;C5<1@<C1423 C5@7:4>756 @2;4 2@ ?4>7C: CF 32BCFF E327;25< =C93: A4 45<7<34: <C @##" 2@ 26275@< @"- 2=2>:4: AB <>7A9523 + 327;25< <CCI 75?2<745< <>42<;45< FC> + :2B@ 17342@@4@@;45<AB<>7A95232<@+?4>:2B<C=2>:@FCC: 5C9>7@1;45<4<E;2B5C<A44JE4@@7D42=2>:CF@" <C=2>:@ EC5D4B25E4 25: 2<<45:25E4 =C93: A4 4JE4@@7D4 95@9@<2752A34 25: =7<1C9< A2@7@ < 7@ FC95: 2??>C?>72<4 <C >4:9E47<<C@75<C<23 - 9 - - >7A9523 12@ 2=2>:4: @" <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CF 2;457<74@ 145 E327;25< 12@ @9@<2754: C54 F>2E<9>4 25: @9FF4>4:?1B@7E23:7@2A737<B2<L2=2>:=C93:A44JE4@@7D4 25:<14>4FC>4>4:9E4:<C@* >7A9523 2=2>:4: @+ <C=2>:@ F9<9>4 ;4:7E23 4J?45@4@ 1C961 @<2<4: 2AC9< >4H97>4;45< CF C54 ;C>4 @9>64>B FC> >4;CD23 CF 7;?325<@ 5C>;233B EC@< CF @2;4 7@ @* 19@ 2F<4> >4:9E<7C5 CF @* EC;?45@2<7C5 <C=2>:@ ;4:7E23 4J?45@4@ 25: F9<9>4 ;4:7E23 4J?45@4@ =C93: >4:9E4 <C @--## 19@ <C<23 EC;?45@2<7C5=C93:A4) C@@CFF9<9>475EC;4 **# 27525:@9FF4>756 * C@@CF75EC;4:9>756327:9??4>7C: # <<45:25<<>25@?C><2<7C525:;7@@4J?45@4@ " C@@CF2;457<74@K59<>7<7C5FCC: + 4:7E234J?45@4@ +,- - 10 - C5@4H945<3BFC33C=756) &7( 5C-#" F734: AB 5@9>4> 7@ ($ &77( 5C-" F734: AB E327;25< 7@ &777( ;?9654: 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>: :2<4: " ?2@@4: AB ::7<7C523 457C> 7D73 .9:64 25: . 27E19> 75 5C+#*7@;C:7F74:, &7D( 327;25< 7@ 143: 45<7<34: FC> >4:9E4: EC;?45@2<7C5 CF @"*+*# 2@ 26275@< @-*-=7<175<4>4@<2<+L?2F>C; :2<4CFE327;?4<7<7C5<733:4?C@7< &D( ;C95< 75 :4?C@7< 7@ C>:4>4: <C A4 <>25@;7<<4:<C<>7A9523FC>:7@A9>@4;45< .( &$$' ! 7@< C)3 C)