- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &' ( ) ! !! " # "# $ % " # & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "# ' ( !% ) !% ! ) ( * ' & $ & &(% +!! " %!% # * $,$) ! $ - 3 - ,) !! (,, - % !! ,( + ! "!!!% - % $ # -- )"#-%! * !! - - ,(, ! !! % % $(( ! ! - - !! - % . ! $ /012/ 3/45 673389 /75 :068 1; <09 7=645540> ?43/ :0>58>3 0< @879>8= :01>58@ <09 ;793485 43 45 37A8> 1; <09 /8794>2 /45 7;;87@ 45 <4@8= 7274>53 3/8 7?79= =738= (;7558=4>%0$(( BC3/8!94>:4;7@8>409 4D4@1=287>=7>===4340>7@4=79>8/465/7 - 4 - 50>0<727;;7728=7B013C8795683?43/7>7::4=8>30> )/8?4<87>=:/4@=98>0<3/8=8:8758=<4@8=:@746 ;834340>:@7464>2:06;8>57340>0<5$)& ,?43/4>389853 /8 94B1>7@ :0>54=894>2 3/8 8D4=8>:8 0> 98:09= 297>38= :06;8>57340>0<5)&'( ,?43/4>38985373&E;897>>16 <9063/8=7380<;834340>34@@987@4F7340> 22948D8=BC3/8574=09=893/457;;87@45<4@8=BC3/8 :@7467>35 588A4>2 8>/7>:868>3 4> ?/4:/ 43 45 :0>38>=8= 3/73 3/8=8:8758=?75?09A4>2757750>7>=879>4>25 , ;8960>3//8:@7467>35<4@8= G/4B43!) G;8948>:88934<4:738 0< =8:8758= 24D8> BC 9767 !7>:/7C73/ 7@757>24 3 45 :0>38>=8= 3/73 687289 7601>3 ?75 297>38= 1>=89 3/8 /87= @0550<:0>50934167>=43>88=530B860=4<48= $879=3/8792168>350<B03/54=85 =64338=@C 3/8 :@7467>35 /7D8 >03 <4@8= 7>C 4>:068 ;900<0<3/8=8:8758=/894B1>7@/75942/3@C:0>54=898=/45 >0340>7@ 4>:068 75 Rs.$) , ;89 60>3/ 75 ;89 3/8 :/793 ;98;798=BC3/879>737A73738827@89D4:8513/0943C/8 =8:8758=?75728=C87957>=3/861@34;@4894530B837A8> - 5 - 7553/8=8:8758=683?43/7>7::4=8>34>3/8C879 E0<4>:0684530B87==8=30?79=5<13198;905;8:3575;89 3/8 H1=268>3 0< 3/8 0>.B@8 1;9868 0193 4> 3/8 :758 0< 7>= 75 3/8 =8;8>=7>35 798 6098 3/7> ' 0>8 <4<3/ 45 30 B8 =8=1:38= 30?79=5 ;8950>7@ 8G;8>585 75 ;89 3/8 214=8@4>85 0< 3/8 0>.B@8 1;9868 0193 4> 3/8 :758 0< /153/8@0550<=8;8>=8>:C :0685305)' ,"$)IE, 3/GG# '/853;834340>89,?4<80<3/8=8:8758=458>343@8=<09 5$ ,<09@0550<5;0157@:0>50934167>=;834340>8905 30 798 8>343@8= <09 5$ , 87:/ 30?79=5 ;798>37@ :0>509341675;893/8214=8@4>850<3/80>.B@81;98680193 4>3/8:7580< ! "# "$ %7>=4>3/8:758 0<& ! "# "$ %7>=4>3/8:758 0<& ! ' ( ) ' * /8 ;834340>89, 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 6 - :@7467>35 798 7@50 8>343@8= <09 5 , <09 :0>D8>340>7@ /87=575;893/8214=8@4>850<0>.B@81;986801934>3/8 :758 0< + /15 3/8 3037@ :06;8>57340> :0685 30 5$' , )>7@@3/8:@7467>357988>343@8=<093/8:06;8>57340> 0< 5$' , ?43/ 4>389853 73 'E ;89 7>>16 75 7274>53 5)'&( ,7?79=8=BC3/894B1>7@ (/87?79=0<:06;8>57340>;7558=BC3/894B1>7@45 60=4<48=751>=89 87=5 601>34>5 0550<8;8>=8>:C )' , 0550<0>5093416 $ , 0?79=5:0>D8>340>7@/87=5 , 037@ **+ &>3/89851@33/8<0@@0?4>209=8945;7558= "4# ;;87@457@@0?8=4>;793 5 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 7 - "44# /8 :@7467>35 798 8>343@8= <09 3/8 3037@ :06;8>57340>0<5$' ,?43/4>38985373'E;7<906 3/8=7380<;834340>34@@3/8=7380<987@4F7340> "444# /8 985;0>=8>3 4>5197>:8 :06;7>C /75 7@987=C =8;05438= 3/8 7?79=8= 7601>3 B8<098 3/8 94B1>7@ 7>= 3/898<0983/8C798=498:38=30=8;05433/88>/7>:8=7601>30< 5)$ ,?43/4>38985373'E;897>>16?43/4>0>860>3/ <9063/8=7380<3/4509=89 "4D# >51:/=8;054354>:8;834340>89,:@7467>30530 798 67H095 3/45 0193 <4>=5 43 98750>7B@8 30 297>3 7> 7601>30<5 ,3087:/0<3/867>=3/8C798;8964338= 30 ?43/=97? 3/849 7601>3 7@0>2 ?43/ 4>389853 7::918= 0> 43 -193/89 3/8 <4953 ;834340>89,?4<8 0< 3/8 =8:8758= 45 ;8964338= 30?43/=97?3/8B7@7>:87601>37@0>2?43/4>3898537::918=0> 43 "D# > D48? 0< 3/8 09=89 =738= $ ;7558= 0> 0 $ 3/8 :@7467>35 798 >03 8>343@8= <09 4>389853 <09 3/8=8@7C8=;8940=0<&=7C54><4@4>23/87;;87@ !,+ &%!! ( $ 4530@0'(