- 1 - !"# $"%"" " &'()&*+,') &++ - ! " # # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $% & ' ( ) %!" & ' * ( ) )'( ) + ) ! ) )) #'(#'(#'('('(!'(#! ) ) + , * - 3 - ' , * ( -././01-23 456- 7/8-9 .4- :5;./01-9 ;-././01 <19-2 -:./0107 4525./=5 5>52/?<25?345514/.5! 3--?/1> >251. 07 51./:/;5.02= @5/8 /1 2/A- 0 ! 2->/3.-2-9@=4025;<208/:-.5./0159>/2//3.2/:.702 .4- 077-1:-3 ;<1/345@8- <19-2 -:./013 #'( #'( #'( '( '( ! '( 519 #! 07 4525./=5 =5=5514/.5! 4- >/3. 07 .4- :0A;85/1. 809>-9 @= .4- 7/23. /1702A51. /3 .45. 01 !#! B4/8- .4- :0A;85/151. B53B5/./1>7025@<31-52.4-89 <3.5194025;<2 5::<3-9 0:5A-2/9/1>5A0.02@/?-/152534519C/>C5> A511-25352-3<8.07B4/:4.4-.=2-307.4-@/?-3;8534-9 A<9 01 .4- :0A;85/151. . /3 7<2.4-2 588->-9 .45. B4-1 .4- :0A;85/151. 596/3-9 5::<3-9 0 .0 2/9- .4- @/?- :5<./0<38= ?--;/1> /1 A/19.4-25/1= :019/./0135::<3-9 0 2-5:.-9 51>2/8= 8-59/1> .0 5 A/102 3:<778- @-.B--1 .4-A <@3-D<-1.8= B4/8- .4- :0A;85/151. 519 4/3 - 4 - =0<1>-2@20.4-2B-2-3.519/1>/17201.07.4-/240<3-588 .4-5::<3-9;-23013588->-98=:5A-.0.4-/240<3-52A-9 B/.4 3./:?3 519 3.01-3 5@<3-9 .4-A /1 7/8.4= 851><5>- 519 5335<8.-9 .4-A ::<3-9 03 519 52- 3.5.-9 .0 456- 925>>-9 .4- :0A;85/151. 519 B4-1 .4- :0A;85/151.E3 @20.4-2 /1.-26-1-9 5::<3-9 0 588->-98= 5335<8.-94/A01.4-4-59B/.45B2/3.2/1>B4/8-5::<3-9 04/.4/A01.4-@5:?B/.453./:?::<3-9 0/335/9 .0 456- 5..5:?-9 B/.4 5 3.01- 519 5::<3-9 03 .0 # 588->-98= 5335<8.-9 .4- :0A;85/151. 519 4/3 @20.4-2 B/.4 451935198->3 -521-9 :0<13-8 702 .4- ;-././01-23 2-/.-25./1> .4->20<193<2>-9/1.4-;-././01:01.-19-9.45..4-2-/3 5:53-519:0<1.-2%:53-52/3/1>720A.4-35A-/1:/9-1.53 .4-:0A;85/151.5194/35330:/5.-345958305335<8.-9.4- ;-././01-23 -7-22/1> .0 .4- A-9/:58 2-:0293 8-521-9 :0<13-8 ;0/1.-9 0<. .45. .4- :0A;85/151.E3 @20.4-2 3<3.5/1-9 018= 3/A;8- /1F<2/-3 53 :-2./7/-9 /1 .4- B0<19 :-2./7/:5.- . B53 .4-2-702- <2>-9 .45. 3/1:- .4- - 5 - ;-././01-23 5;;2-4-19 /AA/1-1. 522-3. .4-= 52- :013.25/1-9.03--?.4-/19<8>-1:-07.4/30<2.702>251. 0751./:/;5.02=@5/8 -2 :01.25 .4- 8-521-9 />4 0<2. 06-21A-1. 8-59-23.201>8=0;;03-9.4-;-././01:01.-19/1>.45..4- ;-././01-23 B/.4 5 ;2-A-9/.5.-9 /1.-1./01 B-1. .0 .4- :0A;85/151.E3 40<3- 519 5335<8.-9 .4- :0A;85/151. 519 4/3@20.4-2.4-2-@=:0AA/../1>3-2/0<3077-1:-3-1:-/. B53 3<@A/..-9 .45. .4/3 /3 10. 5 7/. :53- .0 -G-2:/3- 9/3:2-./01/17560<207.4-;-././01-23 4-;-././01-23456-5830;209<:-95801>B/.45 A-A05:0;=07.4-:0A;85/1.809>-9@=.4-A2-3<8./1> /12->/3.25./01072/A- 0 !;01;-2<35807.4- 2-:0293 .4/3 0<2. 7/193 .45. @0.4 ;52./-3 70880B/1> .4- 58.-2:5./01 .45. 0::<22-9 1-52 .4- @<3 3.519 456- /19<8>-9 /1 5:.3 07 6/08-1:- 519 .45. .4- ;08/:- 456- 2->/3.-2-9:53-35..4-/13.51:-07@0.43/9-3 - 6 - 56/1> -G5A/1-9 .4- B0<19 :-2./7/:5.- /. /3 -6/9-1..45..4-:0A;85/151.E3@20.4-24533<3.5/1-9018= 3/A;8- /1F<2/-3 . /3 5830 10.-9 .45. .4- 16-3./>5./1> 77/:-2 453 10. 30<>4. .0 522-3. .4- ;-././01-23 9-3;/.- 2->/3.25./01 07 .4- :2/A- 01 !#! 1 3<:4 :/2:<A3.51:-3 .4/3 0<2. /3 07 .4- 0;/1/01 .45. .4- ;-././01-23 A5= @- 9/2-:.-9 .0 3<22-19-2 @-702- .4- 16-3./>5./1> 77/:-2 702 .4- ;<2;03- 07 /1.-220>5./01 519 .0:00;-25.-702.4-/16-3./>5./01::029/1>8=.4/30<2. 7/193 /. 5;;20;2/5.- .0 >251. 51./:/;5.02= @5/8 .0 .4- ;-././01-23 3<@F-:. .0 3.2/1>-1. :019/./013 .0 -13<2-.45. .4-= 90 10. :0AA/. 51= 7<2.4-2 5:.3 07 6/08-1:- 02 /1.-27-2-B/.4.4-/16-3./>5./01 " )02 .4- 702->0/1> 2-53013 .4- 70880B/1> 029-2 /3 ;533-9 4-;-././01/35880B-9 - 7 - 4- 2-3;019-1.H08/:- 52- 9/2-:.-9 .0 2-8-53- .4- ;-././01-2301@5/8/1.4--6-1.07.4-/2522-3./1:011-:./01 B/.4 2/A- 0 ! 2->/3.-2-9 @= 4025;<2 08/:- .5./0159>/2//3.2/:.702.4-077-1:-3;<1/345@8-<19-2 -:./013 #'( #'( #'( '( '( ! '( 519 #! 07 .4- 4525./=5 =5=5 514/.5 !3<@F-:..0.4-70880B/1>:019/./013 /( 4- ;-././01-23 34588 5;;-52 @-702- .4- 16-3./>5./1> 77/:-2 B/.4/1 7/7.--1 '( 95=3720A.4-95.-072-:-/;.075:-2./7/-9 :0;= 07 .4/3 029-2 519 34588 -G-:<.- ;-230158@019370253<A073!!!!! % '<;--3 1- 5?4 018=( -5:4 B/.4 .B0 3<2-./-3 702 .4- 8/?- 3<A .0 .4- 35./375:./0107.4-16-3./>5./1>77/:-2 //( 4-;-././01-2334588:0%0;-25.-7<88=B/.4 .4- /16-3./>5./01 519 34588 5;;-52 @-702- .4- 16-3./>5./1> 77/:-2 53 519 B4-1 2-D</2-9 ///( 4- ;-././01-23 34588 A52? .4-/2 5..-1951:- @-702- .4- 16-3./>5./1> - 8 - 77/:-201:-5B--?013<:495=519./A- 53A5=@-10./7/-9@=4/A<1./8.4-7/8/1> 07.4-:452>-%34--. /6( 4- ;-././01-23 34588 10. .5A;-2 B/.4 .4- ;203-:<./01 B/.1-33-3 02 -6/9-1:- -/.4-2 9/2-:.8=02/19/2-:.8= 6( 4- ;-././01-23 34588 5;;-52 @-702- .4- 2/58 0<2. 2-><8528= 9<2/1> .4- :0<23- 07 ;20:--9/1>3 <18-33 -G-A;.-9 702 658/9 2-53013@=.4-35/90<2. 6/( 4- ;-././01-23 34588 10. /16086- .4-A3-86-3/151=3/A/852020.4-2:2/A/158 5:./6/./-3/17<.<2- ., &""+ % /3. 08 0