Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92239 (KAR)
MOHAMMAD ALLAUDDIN v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200241/2025 · 2025-08-20
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92239 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92239 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#""
"$$
%&
%'% '' (
! " #
#
$%%"&
'
(
)%%&"
#"* )
! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
"+) ! # ! &+&,&%
-
.&%
)%
! ("&% #
# ##
".! "."! "."(! "&("! /"! ( ".& #
! &(
(!! # ! ".. #
# -
.&%
#
0
#"
0
! 12 344255367 $ 3889:2; <% =: >2?<@2 71=: <9@7 :22A=6BB@367<?>3=596;2@287=<6"+)<?712812;952; 3:72:36;812;952;@=>2:@2C267=<6<?7@<8=7=2:!87
"..12@2=63?72@@2?2@@2;7<3:D71236;!87- ?<@:1<@7!=6@=E2 <("&%<?1=E3@3F363B9;=<5=82 737=<6 @2B=:72@2; ?<@ 712 <??2682: 496=:13>52 96;2@ 287=<6:".!"."!"."(!"&("!/"!(G 287=<6 ".& <? 13@37=F3 F3F3 361=73 &( ?<@ :1<@7
- 3 -
D -! 36; 287=<6 (!C! <? 712 36; ! 87 6<G 426;=6B <6 712 ?=52 523@62; =:7@=87 36; 2::=<6: 9;B23;B=@==6453:2 <.&%<6712>3:=:<?712 ?=@:7=6?<@E37=<65<;B2;>F=6?<@E367)3HE=
12?387:<?71283:2=6>@=2?3@27137712G=?2 <? 712 ;2823:2; ?=52; ?=@:7 =6?<@E37=<6 G=71 1=E3@3F363B9;= <5=82 737=<6 3B3=6:7 :2C26 42@:<6:
6C2:7=B37=<6 G3: 96;2@73A26 36; 813@B2 :1227 83E2 7< >2?=52;3B3=6:73889:2;
<:"7</ 7=::7372;7137?=C2 42@:<6: 63E2; =6 712 # G2@2 ;@<442; 36; ?<9@ <712@ 42@:<6:G2@23@@3F2;3:3889:2;=6712813@B2:1227 ( : 42@ 712 813@B2 :1227 , 13; =55=8=7 @2537=<6:1=4G=713889:2; <9>:2I92675F712@2G3:
E=:96;2@:736;=6B >27G226 712 7G< 12 ;2823:2; 13; =672@C262;36;125;3436813F378<E4255=6B3889:2; < 7< 43@7 G=71 &" 38@2 <? 536; =6 ?3C<9@ <? , 19: 3889:2;
< 13; E<7=C2 7< 839:2 712 ;2371 <? 712 ;2823:2;36;12B3C2:943@=7<3889:2; <"7<839:21=:
;2371 7=::7372;7137=6?9@712@3682<?:9818<6:4=@38F
- 4 -
3889:2; <"13;7@=2;7<?=@237712;2823:2;<G2C2@ 12 2:8342; 712 3772E47 @=E2
<"&&"+ <? 1=E3@3F363B9;= <5=82 737=<6 83E2 7< >2 @2B=:72@2; 3B3=6:73889:2; <:"36; + 7 =: 712 ?9@712@ 8<67267=<6 <? 712 4@<:2897=<6 7137<6(&/&".712;2823:2;13;3::39572;3889:2;
<" 36; @=E2 <"&". <? 1=E3@3F363B9;= <5=82 737=<6 83E2 7< >2 @2B=:72@2; 3B3=6:7 712 ;2823:2; 36; <712@:19:3889:2; <:"36;G2@213C=6BE<7=C27< 839:2712;2371<?712;2823:2;36;712F8<6:4=@2;G=71 3889:2; <( =6 1=: ;13>3 889:2; <( =6)79@6 8<6:4=@2;G=713889:2; <:+7</:343@7<?8<6:4=@38F 3889:2;
<:% 36; / G2@2 13C=6B 712 G3781 <C2@ 712 E<C2E267 <? 712 ;2823:2; 36; 3889:2;
<% =6?<@E2; 3889:2;
<:" 36; 7137 712 ;2823:2; G<95; 8<E2 7< 131349@ C2B273>52 E3@A27 88<@;=6B5F <6 "/&(&% 3889:2; <:"7</83E27<131349@3889:2; <"7<<A 3889:2;
<+ =6 1=: 83@ 36; 355 712 3889:2; G2@2 13C=6B 8<67387 G=71 <62 36<712@ <C2@ 41<62 7< A6<G 712 2H387
- 5 -
5<837=<6 <? 712 ;2823:2; 889:2;
<:% 36; / G2@2 ?<55<G=6B 712 ;2823:2; =6 712 E<7<@8F852 7< =6?<@E 1=:
E<C2E267 7<3889:2; <" 36; <712@ 3889:2; 7 =:712 8<67267=<6 <? 712 4@<:2897=<6 7137 G126 712 ;2823:2; 83E2623@712:8262<?<889@@26823889:2; <:"36;+ 83E2 =6 712=@ 83@ 36; ;3:12; =7 7< 712 @=B17 :=;2 <? 712 E<7<@8F852 @=;;26 >F 712 ;2823:2; 3: 3 @2:957 <?
G1=81 12 ?255 ;<G6 <G2C2@ 12 =EE2;=3725F :73@72; @966=6B 3G3F 889:2;
<:" 36; + B<7 ;<G6 ?@<E 712 83@ 36;
71@2G 712 81=55= 4<G;2@ <6 1=: ?382 889:2; <" 3::39572;1=EG=713735G3@36;5372@7<<A<973E381272 36; 3::39572; 712 ;2823:2; 6 712 E2367=E2 3889:2;
<+ 3::39572; G=71 3A6=?2G1=81G3: :798A =6 1=:><;F :3@2:957<?712?3735=6J9@=2::9:73=62;>F712;2823:2; 12;=2;12@2>F7123889:2;13C28<EE=772;712<??2682 3::7372;3><C2 <G712344255367>2=6B3889:2; <%=: :22A=6BB@367<?>3=5 % 23@; @= 3J2:1 <;;3E36= 523@62; <96:25 ?<@71234425536736;E7@37=37=5523@62;=B1<9@7
- 6 -
<C2@6E267 523;2@ ?<@ 712 @2:4<6;267 <")7372 2:4<6;267 < 71<9B1 :2@C2; G=71 712 6<7=82 13:
@2E3=62; 96@24@2:2672; 2@9:2; 712 E372@=35: =6859;=6B 712@=35<9@7@28<@;: / 6 C=2G <? 712 @=C35 8<67267=<6: 9@B2; >F 712 523@62;8<96:25?<@><7171243@7=2:7124<=677137G<95; 3@=:2?<@EF8<6:=;2@37=<6=:
!"#"$% F36:G2@7<7123><C24<=67=:=6712D?<@ 712?<55<G=6B
, 6 42@9:35 <? 712 E372@=35: <6 @28<@;
2:428=355F 712 813@B2 :1227 ?=52; >F 712 6C2:7=B37=6B ??=82@ =7 ;=:85<:2: 7137 712@2 3@2 :7@<6B E372@=35: 7< 8<66287 712 344255367 7< 712 <??2682 =6 I92:7=<6
C26 71<9B1=7G3:3889:2; <:"36;+G1<3@27123::3=5367:
G1< =6?5=872; ?3735 =6J9@=2: 7< 712 ;2823:2; 712
- 7 -
4@<;982;>F712 6C2:7=B37=6B??=82@ &;=:85<:2:
7137 712 344255367 G3: =6 8<6:7367 7<981 G=71 3889:2;
<:"+36;<712@8<)3889:2;12E<>=52136;:279:2; >F712344255367377127=E2<?=68=;267G3:@28<C2@2;>F 712 6C2:7=B37=6B ??=82@ :"% 36; "/ 3@2 8=72; 3: 2F2G=762::2:G1<13C2:7372;71373889:2; <:"36;+ 3::39572; 712 ;2823:2; 36; 839:2; 1=: ;2371 7 =: 42@7=62677<6<727137"%13::428=?=8355F@2?2@:7<712 63E2 <? 3889:2;
<%)712 344255367 12@2=6 3: 12 G3: ?<55<G=6B 712 ;2823:2; 36; G3: ?<96; 37 712 :8262 <? <889@@2682 126 :981 :7@<6B & E372@=35: 3@2 4@<;982; 7< 8<66287 712 344255367 7< 712 <??2682 =6 I92:7=<6 G12@2 712 ;2823:2; G3: ;<62 7< ;2371 =6 3 B@92:<E2E3662@ 3E<?712<4=6=<67137712344255367 =:6<7267=752;?<@B@367<?>3=5
23@62; 8<96:25 ?<@ 712 344255367 8<6726;2; 7137 3889:2;
</ 3B3=6:7 G1<E :=E=53@ <C2@7387:13C2 >2263552B2;=:35@23;F2653@B2;<6>3=5>F712@=35<9@7 C26 71<9B1 3889:2;
</ =: 2653@B2; <6 >3=5 =7 G3:
- 8 -
;9@=6B 8@=E2 :73B2 G126 1=: 63E2 G3: 6<7 34423@=6B =6 712# 36;712=6C2:7=B37=<6G3: 6<78<E45272;36;712 813@B2 :1227 G3: 6<7 F27 ?=52; 97 6<G :9??=8=267 E372@=35: 3@2 45382; >2?<@2 712 <9@7 7< 8<66287 712 344255367 7< 712 <??2682 =6 I92:7=<6 G1=81 =: 496=:13>52 2=712@G=71;2371<@=E4@=:<6E267?<@5=?2 . 3A=6B =67< 8<6:=;2@37=<6 712 6379@2 36; :2@=<9:62::<?712<??268236;712<C2@73878<EE=772;>F 712 4@2:267 344255367 3E <? 712 <4=6=<6 7137 712 344255367 =: 6<7 267=752; ?<@ B@367 <? >3=5 88<@;=6B5F 36:G2@ 712 3><C2 4<=67 =6 712 62B37=C2 36; 4@<822; 7< 43::712?<55<G=6B
12344235=:
)& %""' #
=:7 <"5 <"%