Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92229 (KAR)

RUPA AND ANR v. SANDEEP AND ANR

MFA/203020/2023 · 2025-09-15

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$$ !! %$& ' ! "!! # $!! ! ! % ! & ' ! (&(() !! !!*& Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! !! !!!! + !*&,& # $!! ' - & ! !!!% ! ' ! '! ! ) $% ' ! ! ! . '! ! ! ! ! ! ! . '! '! ! ! ! !'! ! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! ! '! ! ! ! ' !"! ! ' ! ' ' ! ! ! ! - 3 - / !! # 012 344536 12 71658 9: ;05 3445663<;2 ( =631>3<;2 255?1<@5<03<=5>5<;A7=A>45<23;1A<323B3C8581<;05 DE8@>5<; 3<8 3B3C8 83;58 432258 1< A. 9:;05C65<1AC1F16 E8@53<8 3639EC3@1 05 73=;2 65381<@ ;A 7161<@ A7 =631> 45;1;1A< 3C5 32E<85C( 03; A< , 3; 39AE; 4> ;05 3445663<;2(=631>3<;236A<@B1;0;051C>1<AC2A<(03C3; B5C503F1<@;051C6E<=0<53C;05C1=?03;;1<53C1<@361 F1663@5A<3;3C3*C3<83C34ECCA383;;03;;1>5;053;3 E>A 953C1<@ 5@A(&(() =3>5 B1;0 01@0 24558 3<8 832058 ;A ;051C >1<AC 2A< * 03C3; 5 2E2;31<58 @C15FAE2 1<DEC152 05 B32 ;3?5< ;A AF5C<>5<; A241;363<805032955<85=63C58329CAE@0;85389:;05 - 4 - 8A=;AC0585=53258*9A:B322;3;58;A95&:53C23<8 B32 3 2;E85<; 05 43C5<;2 A7 ;05 85=53258 * 9A: 03F5 71658 ;05 =631> 45;1;1A< 05 C19E<36 32252258 ;05 =A>45<23;1A<3<8432258;051>4E@<583B3C8 ) 51<@ 81223;127158 B1;0 ;05 GE3<;E> A7 =A>45<23;1A< 3B3C858 9: ;05 C19E<36 ;05 3445663<;2 * =631>3<;2 03F5 71658 ;012 344536 7AC 5<03<=5>5<; A7 =A>45<23;1A< 53C8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC ;05 3445663<;2 ( =631>3<;2 3<8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC C524A<85<; A * 1<2EC3<=5=A>43<: & 53C<58 =AE<256 7AC ;05 3445663<;2 ( =631>3<;2 BAE68=A<;5<8;03;;0585=53258B323@5839AE;&:53C2 3<8050389C1@0;7E;EC505=A>45<23;1A<3B3C85812A< 6AB5C 2185 5 463=1<@ C5613<=5 A< ;05 85=121A< A7 ;05 A<H965 E4C5>5 AEC; 1< ;05 =325 A7 1< - 5 - !"!# 85=1858 A< "$"$!"! 032 =A<;5<858 ;03;>A<;06:1<=A>5A72& (032;A95;3?5<A7;05 =0168 3<8 >E6;14615C ;A 95 3446158 3; & 93258 A< ;05 >A;05CH2 3@5 3<8 ;05 3@5 A7 ;05 >A;05C B32 :53C2 1;0;0525054C3:2;A366AB;05344536 . 53C<58 =AE<256 7AC C524A<85<; A * 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<: BAE68 =A<;5<858 ;03; 1< % & C54AC;58 1< $!"'#( ' !##;05A<H965E4C5>5AEC;032;3?5< ;05<A;1A<361<=A>5A7;0585=53258(=01683;2) ( 3<8=A<2185C1<@;05:AE<@3@5A743C5<;2<3>56:>A;05C B0AB3239AE;).:53C2A680323446158;05>E6;14615C& 032;A95;3?5<1<;A=A<2185C3;1A<57EC;05C2E9>1;2;03; ;05 =A>45<23;1A< 3B3C858 9: ;05 C19E<36 12 DE2; 3<8 4CA45C 'AC 03F1<@ 053C8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC ;05 3445663<;2 3<8 653C<58 =AE<256 7AC C524A<85<; A * 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<: ;012 AEC; 45CE258 ;05 1>4E@<58 DE8@>5<;3<8A;05C>3;5C1362463=58957AC5;05AEC; - 6 - , !; 12 <A; 1< 8124E;5 ;03; ;05 2A< A7 ;05 3445663<;2*=631>3<;23@58&:53C281581<3CA38;C3771= 3==185<; 3<8 362A ;05 6139161;: A7 C524A<85<; A * 1<2EC3<=5=A>43<: !< ;05 =325 A7 % & ;05 A<H965E4C5>5AEC;032;3?5<<A;1A<361<=A>5A7;05 85=53258 3; 2) ( 05 2318 =325 =3>5 ;A 95 85=18581<;05:53C3<8;05=631>45;1;1A<45C;31<2;A ;05 :53C ) !< ;05 =325 A< 03<8 ;05 3==185<; 032 ;3?5<463=51<;05:53C05C5123@34A7.:53C21< 95;B55<;053==185<;1<;05=325A7% & 3<8;054C525<;=325 05 A<H965 E4C5>5 AEC; 1< ;05 =325 A7 $2E4C3%032056832E<85C( !" # $$$%& - 7 - '& ( ) !" * * * +,-. . / 0 * +,, . , 1 # $$$%& 23 + 0 -, # 4 $$$$%& # -$$$$ ) " 5 * 67$+4 +, *)) ,8$9 # :$$$$%& 3 ( ) # + $$$% 1 ( ) - 8 - 3 . ( ) # + $$$%& ( # 8$$$$3 3 # + $$$%& # 84$$$$%& ; !< ;05 2318 =325 ;05 A<H965 E4C5>5 AEC; 032 ;3?5< ;05 >A<;06: 1<=A>5 A7 ;05 =0168 3; 2& ( 3<83446158>E6;14615C&=A<2185C1<@;05>A;05CH23@5A7 ).:532!<;05=325A<03<8;053@5A7;05>A;05C12 :53C2A<2185C1<@;0523183@5>E6;14615C34461=396512, )C8A7;051<=A>5032;A95858E=;58;AB3C82 45C2A<365I45<252A7;0585=53258*9A:!<F15BA7;05 23>5;05=A>45<23;1A<7AC6A22A78545<85<=:BAE6895 2& ( I I , J 2, ( I ) J 2 ( - 9 - ) 05 3445663<;2 ( =631>3<;2 951<@ ;05 43C5<;2 3C55<;1;658;A=A<2AC;1E>1<32E>A72 (53=032 45C;0585=121A<A7;05A<H965E4C5>5AEC;1<;05=325 A7 ) * + C54AC;581<,!"'-( '. .$" 05 =631>3<;2 3C5 362A 5<;1;658 ;A 7E<5C36 3<8 ;C3<24AC;3;1A<=03C@52A72& (3<8;AB3C826A22A7 52;3;5A72& ( & !<F15BA70539AF5;05;A;36=A>45<23;1A<12 32E<85C( ( )*+, -./)0,*120 ./)0,*120 *3*4+)+56172,841 A22A78545<85<=: 2 ( A22A7=A<2AC;1E> 2, ( ) 'E<5C36 3<8 ;C3<24AC;3;1A<=03C@52 2& ( A22A752;3;5 2& ( 1*( ,9: - 10 - . !<F15BA7;0539AF5;053445663<;2*=631>3<;2 3C5 5<;1;658 ;A =A>45<23;1A< A7 2,) ( 32 3@31<2; 2 (323B3C8589:;05C19E<36 05 3445663<;2 * =631>3<;2 3C5 <A; 5<;1;658 ;A 1<;5C52; 7AC 8563:45C1A8 A7 83:2 1< 7161<@ ;05 344536 3245CAC85C83;58& , !<F15BA7;0539AF5;057A66AB1<@- ! 0534453612366AB581<43C; !! 05 3445663<;2 * =631>3<;2 3C5 5<;1;658 ;A ;A;36 =A>45<23;1A< A7 2,) ( 32 3@31<2; 2 (323B3C8589:;05C19E<3636A<@B1;0 1<;5C52; 3; ;05 C3;5 A7 .K 43 7CA> ;05 83;5 A7 45;1;1A<;1661;2C5361L3;1A< !!! 05 3445663<;2 * =631>3<;2 3C5 <A; 5<;1;658 ;A 1<;5C52; 7AC 8563: 45C1A8 A7 83:2 1< 7161<@ ;05 344536 - 11 - ! 05 C524A<85<; A * 1<2EC3<=5 =A>43<: 20366 854A21; ;05 2318 3B3C8 3>AE<; B1;0 1<;5C52; 957AC5 ;05 C19E<36 B1;01< , B55?2 7CA> ;012 83: 73161<@ B01=0 1; 12 613965 ;A 43: 1<;5C52; 3; ;05 C3;5 A7 K 43 05 AC85C A7 854A21; 32 432258 9: ;05 C19E<36 12 C5>31<58E<36;5C58 +: %$$& # 12;A6A& ; ?