- 1 - !"# $% & !"# '( ! %% # ) ! # %$ * +, + Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ * +( + $ - % %"" " ( $ +( + $ $ . -' ", ) ! '# /(!# & % %+ ( ($/ %$ * +, + $ - %%"" - 3 - $ * +( + $ - % %"" " ) ! # $ +( + $ $ . -' ", '( " ) ! # , % % 0 $"!1 % % *2 % ( / ( - 4 - % + + ! !+ # 3 $ 40 54678 9: ;<7 =0>?@=A7 3BC@=:>=87?7A;43=/(!#35;<73;3?7<4A670A; !53? 0<3?; D;<7 A;E# @=8 ?393&$ 40 546789:;<7A6@4B@=;0>=87? ?87?,>6735974=F @FF?47G78 9: ;<7 H>8FB7=; @=8 @I@?8 8@;78 ( C@0078 9: ;<7 884;43=@6 7=43? 4G46 >8F7 ' @6@9>?@F4!53?0<3?;D;<7?49>=@6E#4=3($/ 4=A7 ;<7 A<@667=F7 40 ;3 ;<7 0@B7 H>8FB7=; 93;< ;<7 @CC7@6 @=8 A?300 39H7A;43= @?7 A6>9978 ;3F7;<7? <7@?8 @=8A3BB3=H>8FB7=;40974=FC@0078 @A;0F4G4=F?407;3;<75464=F35;<7@CC7@6@=8 A?300"39H7A;43= 9?4756: 0;@;78 @?7 ;<@; 3= @; @93>;@BI<7=;<787A7@078@=B@=;<@CC@I@0 - 5 - A3B4=F5?3B @94?@9@8%@84;366>?G466@F73=B3;3?A:A67 97@?4=F?7F40;?@;43=3 "(&$"(063I6:I4;<8>7A@?7 @=8A@>;43>06:@;;<@;;4B7I<7=<7I@0F34=F3=48@?" >B=@9@8?3@8@3??:97@?4=F?7F40;?@;43=3"&$." /, I<4A< I@0 A@B7 5?3B >B=@9@8 0487 I4;< <4F< 0C778 @=8 4= ?@0< @=8 =7F64F7=; B@==7? @=8 8@0<78 @F@4=0;;<7B3;3?A:A6735;<787A7@0780@?70>6;35;<7 @53?70@48 @AA487=; ;<7 87A7@078 0>0;@4=78 F?47G3>0 4=H>?470@=80>AA>B978;3;<74=H>?470@=8<7I@00<45;78 ;3 @664J<78 3G; 30C4;@6 I<7?74= ;<7 83A;3? >C3= 0774=F<4B87A6@?78;<@;<7<@88478 ( <7A6@4B@=;054678@C7;4;43=>=87?7A;43= 35 ;<7 A; 077J4=F A3BC7=0@;43= 53? ;<7 87@;< 35 ;<7 87A7@078@63=FI4;<4=;7?70; , =;<79@04035;<7C67@84=F035;<7C@?;470;<7 6@4B0?49>=@65?@B78;<7400>70@=8;<7?7@5;7??7A3?878 ;<77G487=A7<7A6@4B@=;04=3?87?;3C?3G7;<7A@07 7K@B4=78 A6@4B@=; 3 7K@B4=78 @0 %" @=8 F3; - 6 - 7K<494;7883A>B7=;0=@B76:K;3K/ =97<@6535 ?70C3=87=;0 @=J@=F3>8@ I@0 7K@B4=78 @0 %" @=8 @;;@ I@0 7K@B4=78 @0 % F3; 7K<494;78 83A>B7=; =@B76: K ;3 K <7 6@4B0 ?49>=@6 9: ;<7 4BC>F=78H>8FB7=;<768;<@;;<7@AA487=;;33J C6@A7 3= @AA3>=; 35 ?@0< @=8 =7F64F7=; 8?4G4=F 35 ;<7 3557=84=F G7<4A67 9: 4;0 8?4G7? @0 @ ?70>6; 35 I<4A< ;<7 87A7@0780>0;@4=784=H>?470@=80>AA>B978;3;<74=H>?470 <7?49>=@65>?;<7?<768;<@;;<7A6@4B@=;0@?77=;4;678;3 @A3BC7=0@;43=350/ ($"@63=FI4;<4=;7?70;@;;<7 ?@;735 2C@@=884?7A;78;<7?70C3=87=;30@=8 ;3 87C304; ;<7 A3BC7=0@;43= @B3>=; @63=F I4;< 4=;7?70; 74=F @FF?47G78 ;<40 @CC7@6 @=8 A?300"39H7A;43= <@G7 977=54678 B;?77;4 @;46 76J>=84 67@?=78 A3>=076 53? ;<7 =0>?@=A7 3BC@=:$ ?70C3=87=; <@0 ?@4078 ;<7 53663I4=FA3=;7=;43=0+ - 7 - @# 4?0;6: ;<7 @AA487=; I@0 3AA>??78 4= @?=@;@J@ 3= 3=;<@;8@:;<73557=84=F3??:848=3;<@G7@ =@;43=@6C7?B4;<7:<@G7C7?B4;;3C6:;<7G7<4A673=6: 4=;<7;@;735@<@?@0;?@4=A74=0>?78<@0G436@;78;<7 C364A: A3=84;43=0 ;<7 4=0>?@=A7 A3BC@=: 40 =3; 64@967 ;3 C@:;<7A3BC7=0@;43=<7?49>=@6<@07??784=5@0;7=4=F ;<764@9464;:3=;<74=0>?@=A7A3BC@=: 9# 7A3=86:<7<@0A3=;7=878;<@;A3=0487?4=F;<7@F7 @=8@G3A@;43=35;<787A7@078;<73G7?@66A3BC7=0@;43= @I@?8789:;<7?49>=@640H>0;@=8?7@03=@967@=803>F<; 53?@663I4=F;<7@CC7@6546789:;<7=0>?@=A73BC@=:9: 840B4004=F;<7@CC7@6546789:;<7A6@4B@=;0 ?4@?0<@G@?8<@=@64C@;46 67@?=78 A3>=076 53?;<7A6@4B@=;0$A?30039H7A;3?0<@0?@4078;<753663I4=F A3=;7=;43=0+ @# 4?0;6: <7 <@0 A3=;7=878 ;<@; 7G7= ;<3>F< ;<7 4=0>?78 <@0 G436@;78 ;<7 C364A: A3=84;43=0 4= ?70C7A; 35 - 8 - A6@4B@=;0 @?7 A3=A7?=78 ;<7 4=0>?@=A7 A3BC@=: <@0 ;3 C@:;<7A3BC7=0@;43=@B3>=;I4;<6497?;:;3?7A3G7?;<7 0@B75?3B;<73I=7?35;<73557=84=FG7<4A67=0>CC3?; 35 <40 A3=;7=;43= <7 <@0 ?76478 3= H>8FB7=;0 35 3=E967 C7K 3>?; 4= ;<7 A@07 35 ?7C3?;78 4= !"@=8 # # # ?7C3?;784= $%%& 9# 7A3=86: <7 <@0 A3=;7=878 ;<@; 4= ?70C7A; 35 L>@=;>B 7G7= ;<3>F< A6@4B@=;0 <@G7 A6@4B78 ;<@; 87A7@078 I@0 7@?=4=F 0$" C7? B3=;< 9: 834=F @F?4A>6;>?7A36647<7?49>=@6<@0A3=0487?78<404=A3B7 350$"C7?B3=;<403=63I7?0487 A# <4?86:<7A3=;7=878;<@;;<7A6@4B@=;0@?7I457@=8 03= 35 ;<7 87A7@078 = G47I 35 ;<7 H>8FB7=; 35 ;<7 3=E967C7K3>?;4=;<7A@0735 ! ! " "# $ " ;<7 - 9 - ?49>=@6 7??78 4= 878>A;4=F M 35 ;<7 4=A3B7 35 ;<7 87A7@078;3I@?80C7?03=@6@=864G4=F7KC7=0704=0;7@835 878>A;4=F $(?8 I<4A< 40 A3=;?@?: ;3 ;<7 @53?70@48 H>8FB7=; 8# 3>?;<6: @0 C7? ;<7 H>8FB7=; 35 ;<7 3=E967 >C?7B7 3>?; 4= ;<7 A@07 35 % %&& ' () & ' *+ ) ,- . /-0" 7@A< 35 ;<7 A6@4B@=;0 @?7 7=;4;678 53? A3BC7=0@;43= 35 0,$" >=87? ;<7<7@835 D6300 3563G7 @=8 @557A;43= @=8A3=03?;4>BE 7# @0;6: A3=0487?4=F ;<7 @F7 @=8 @G3A@;43= 35 ;<7 87A7@078 ;<7 3G7?@66 A3BC7=0@;43= @I@?878 9: ;<7 ?49>=@6403=;<763I7?04877=A7<7C?@:053?@663I4=F ;<7@CC7@6@=87=<@=A4=F;<7A3BC7=0@;43= / 7@?8 ;<7 67@?=78 A3>=076 53? ;<7 C@?;470 @=8 C7?>078;<7H>8FB7=;@=8@I@?835;<7?49>=@6 - 10 - ;40=3;4=840C>;7;<@;;<7@=>B@=;<@CC@8478 4=;<7?3@8;?@554A@AA487=;3AA>??783= 8>7;3 ?@0< @=8 =7F64F7=; 8?4G4=F 35 ;<7 8?4G7? 35 63??: 97@?4=F ?7F3"&$./, G7= ;<3>F< ;<7 A6@4B@=;0 <@G7 A6@4B78 ;<@; ;<7 87A7@078 I@0 7@?=4=F 0$" C7? B3=;< <7: <@G7 =3; C?38>A78 @=: 83A>B7=; ;3 70;@9640< ;<7 0@B7 = ;<7 @907=A7 35 4=A3B7 C?335 ;<7 =3;43=@64=A3B7<@0;397@0070078@0C7?;<7F>48764=70 400>78 9: ;<7 @?=@;@J@ ;@;7 7F@6 7?G4A70 >;<3?4;: 53?;<7@AA487=;;@J7=C6@A74=;<7:7@? ;<7=3;43=@6 4=A3B7 35 ;<7 87A7@078 <@0 ;3 97 ;@J7= @; 0/$" CB 3 ;<7 @53?70@48 4=A3B7 2 <@0 ;3 97 @8878 3= @AA3>=;355>;>?7C?30C7A;04=G47I35;<76@I6@4883I=9: ;<73=0;4;>;43=7=A<35;<7>C?7B73>?;4=1! (23 '!4+5+67!4 !,( / 88/0 <>0 ;<7 B3=;<6: 4=A3B7 A3B70 ;3 0& $" !0/ N 2# 4=A7 ;<7?7 @?7 ;I3 87C7=87=;04;40@CC?3C?4@;7;3878>A;$(?835;<74=A3B7 35;<787A7@078;3I@?80C7?03=@67KC7=070@=8?7B@4=4=F - 11 - @B3>=;<@0;397;@J7=@0<40A3=;?49>;43=;3;<75@B46: <787A7@078I@0@F78@93>;:7@?0@;;<7;4B735;<7 @AA487=;@=8B>6;4C647?@CC64A@967;3<40@F7F?3>C40D(E <>0 ;<7 A6@4B@=;0 @?7 7=;4;678 ;3 A3BC7=0@;43= 35 #$$!0& KK(K$(#3=@AA3>=;35 D63003587C7=87=A:E & = @884;43= ;<7 A6@4B@=;0 @?7 7=;4;678 ;3 A3BC7=0@;43=350$"3=@AA3>=;35D63003570;@;7E @=8 A3BC7=0@;43= 35 0$" 3= @AA3>=; 35 D5>=7?@6 7KC7=070E = G47I 35 ;<7 6@I 6@48 83I= 9: ;<7 >C?7B7 3>?; 4= ;<7 A@07 35 1% %&& ' () &9 !0>C?@#A6@4B@=;3I45735;<787A7@078407=;4;67853? A3BC7=0@;43= 35 0,$" >=87? ;<7 <7@8 35 6300 35 0C3>0@6 A3=03?;4>B A6@4B@=; 3 40 7=;4;678 53? A3BC7=0@;43= 35 0,$" >=87? ;<7 <7@8 35 D6300 35 C@?7=;@6A3=03?;4>BE - 12 - <>0;<7A6@4B@=;0@?77=;4;678;3;<753663I4=F A3BC7=0@;43=+ %&'(#)*+(,(-'.-+'.'(* ')-# %,(*+("#/ 3003587C7=87=A: 0 >=7?@67KC7=070 0 3003570;@;7 0 300350C3>0@6A3=03?;4>B 0, 30035@?7=;@6A3=03?;4>B 0, *)0 0$$ = ?70C7A; 35 64@9464;: 40 A3=A7?=78 4; 40 =3; 4= 840C>;7 ;<7 @AA487=; <@0 3AA>??78 3= 8>7 ;3 ?@0< @=8 =7F64F7=; 8?4G4=F 35 ;<7 8?4G7? 35 63??: 97@?4=F ?7F3"&$."/,4= @?=@;@J@;@;7@03=;<@;8@: ;<7 3557=84=F 3??: 848 =3; <@G7 @ =@;43=@6 C7?B4; <7: <@G7 C7?B4; ;3 C6: ;<7 G7<4A67 3=6: 4= ;<7 ;@;7 35 @<@?@0;?@ 7=A7 ;<7 4=0>?78 <@0 G436@;78 ;<7 C364A: A3=84;43=0 <7?753?7 =0>?@=A7 A3BC@=: I@0 =3; 64@967 ;3C@:;<7A3BC7=0@;43=4=A7;<7?49>=@6<@05@0;7=78 ;<7 64@9464;: 3= ;<7 4=0>?@=A7 A3BC@=: ;<7 4=0>?@=A7 A3BC@=:<@054678@=@CC7@6<@0;@J7=@0C7A454AA3=84;43= ;<@;;<73I=7?35;<73557=84=FG7<4A674064@967;3C@:;<7 - 13 - A3BC7=0@;43==0C4;73507?G4A735=3;4A79:;<403>?; <7<@007?G78@=8>=?7C?707=;78=G47I35H>8FB7=;35 3=E967C7K3>?;4=A@0735 '() * # '()#;<74=0>?@=A7 A3BC@=:<@0;3C@:;<7A3BC7=0@;43=@B3>=;I4;<6497?;: ;3 ?7A3G7? 5?3B 3I=7? 35 ;<7 3557=84=F G7<4A67 AA3?84=F6:I7C?3A778;3C@00;<753663I4=F+ @ <7@CC7@6@=8?300 9H7A;43=@?7)001'- +(&).* 9 <7 H>8FB7=; 35 ;<7 6@4B0 ?49>=@6 40 B3845478 A <7 A6@4B@=;0 @?7 7=;4;678 ;3 @ ;3;@6 A3BC7=0@;43=35#$$@0@F@4=0; 0/ ($"@I@?8789:;<7?49>=@6 8 <7 =0>?@=A7 3BC@=: 40 84?7A;78 ;3 87C304; ;<7 7=;4?7 A3BC7=0@;43= @B3>=; @63=FI4;<4=;7?70;@; 2C@5?3B;<78@;7 35 5464=F 35 ;<7 A6@4B C7;4;43= ;466 ;<7 8@;7 35 ?7@64O@;43=I4;<4=@C7?4383504KI77J05?3B - 14 - ;<78@;735?7A74C;35A3C:35;<40H>8FB7=; I4;< 6497?;: ;3 ?7A3G7? ;<7 0@B7 5?3B ;<7 3I=7?35;<73557=84=FG7<4A67 7 B3>=; 4= 87C304; 40 84?7A;78 ;3 97 ;?@=057??78;3;<7?49>=@6 2- "32/ ! 2- "4!54/ ! 40;3+63+, +