- 1 - !"" #$ %!&!'!! !!'' ($) * ! " # $ % & '(!)) % !( ( && ! &('& !( " # & (* ! ! (!( $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - && +'# $ & $& '+(( & & % $ & % (!(' '+(!(( % & , (('(!! - , ))!!! (- & % . . /% & 01, 233425 1, 364746648 9: ;04 <521=2>; 2?21>,; ;04 %@8?=4>; 2>8 2A268 82;48 ! (!(' 32,,48 1> B '+(!(( 9: ;04 881;1B>25 4>1B6 1C15 %@8?4 2>8 2529@62?1 #7B6 ,0B6; D;04 ;619@>25E$ ,44F1>? 4>02><4=4>;B7;04<B=34>,2;1B> ( 04 1>G@648 <521=2>; 71548 <521= 34;1;1B> ,44F1>? <B=34>,2;1B>B7, (!!!!!!7B6;041>G@614,,@,;21>489: 01= 1> ;04 2<<184>; B> (+ ! (! + 04 ;619@>25 27;46 <B>,18461>? ;04 4>;164 4C184><4 B> 64<B68 02, 2A26848 2 ,@= B7 , (('(!! 25B>? A1;01>;464,; 2; ;04 62;4 B7 - 346 2>>@= 76B= ;04 82;4 B7 34;1;1B> ;155 64251H2;1B> 41>? - 3 - 2??614C489:;04,218%@8?=4>;2>82A268;04<521=2>;02, 364746648;04364,4>;233425 ' > ;04 364,4>; 233425 1; 1, <B>;4>848 ;02; ;04 2=B@>;, ?62>;48 9: ;04 ;619@>25 @>846 8177464>; 0428, 264 =42?46 0B@?0;04B<;B602,2,,4,,48;0481,29151;:B7;04 <521=2>; 2; ()- ;04 ;619@>25 02, <B>,184648 B>5: - 81,29151;: 4><4 64I@4,;, 7B6 4>02><4=4>; B7 ;04 <B=34>,2;1B> 4268 ;04 26?@=4>;, B7 5426>48 <B@>,45, 76B= 9B;0,184, 04 <521=2>; ,@,;21>48 3@><;@648 AB@>8 BC46 8B6,@=B761?0;7B6426=762<;@64B76281@,2>8@5>2B>61?0; ,184 ,346J 1;1,2?614CB@,1>G@6: 04<521=2>;A2, 0B,31;251H48 7B6 ;0644 82:, 2, 346 J 0B@?0 1; A2, ,;2;48;02;;04<521=2>;A2,426>1>?2,@=B7, !!!!! 346 2>>@= 76B= 2?61<@5;@64 04 02, >B; 36B8@<48 2>: 1><B=436BB7;B36BC401,1><B=4 042<<184>;02,B<<@6648 B> (+ ! (! + > C14A B7 ;04 ?@18451>4, 1,,@48 9: ;04 26>2;2F2;2;44?2546C1<4,@;0B61;:;04>B;1B>251><B=4 - 4 - B7;04<521=2>;1,;B94;2F4>2;, !(!346=B>;07B6 ;04 :426 (! + 04 ,2=4 1, <B664<; 2>8 >448, >B 1>;467464><4 04B<;B602,2,,4,,48;0481,29151;:2;()- 2,346J ) '68B7;04,2=4<B=4,;B !- ?4B7;04 <521=2>; 2, 346 J + 1 4 8026 268 1, ) :426, 04 =@5;135146 AB@58 94 D 'E 04 5B,, B7 7@;@64 1><B=4 1, 2, @>846. , !(!K (K 'K !-L, ))!! 04 ;619@>25 02, 2A26848 2 ,@= B7 , (+! 2>81;>448,>B1>;467464><4 B>,18461>?;04>2;@64B71>G@6: 2>83461B8B70B,31;251H2;1B>;01,B@6;71>8,1;642,B>2954;B 2A268 2 ,@= B7 , !!!! ;BA268, 321> 2>8 ,@77461>? , (!!!;BA268,5B,,B72=4>1;14,, (!!!!;BA268, ;62>,3B6;2;1B> 4J;62 >B@61,0=4>; 2>8 2;;4>82>; <026?4, @4 ;B ;04 1>G@614, ;04 <521=2>; =1?0; 02C4 >B; 2;;4>848 2>: AB6F 7B6 2; 542,; =B>;0, 4><4 ;01, B@6; 71>8, 1; 642,B>2954;B2A2682,@=B7, !!!#, !(!K$ @>846;0404285B,,B71><B=48@61>?5218@33461B8 4><4 ;04;B;25<B=34>,2;1B>1,2,@>846. - 5 - !+ ,-./012,3/-453 1634 B,,B77@;@641><B=4 , ))!! ( 481<254J34>,4, , (+! ' 21>2>8,@77461>? , !!!! B,,B72=4>1;14, , (!!! 62>,3B6;2;1B> 4J;62 >B@61,0=4>; 2>8 2;;4>82>; <026?4, , (!!!! B,,B71><B=48@61>?5218@3 3461B8 , !!! 4-+ /7 8 + 426>48 <B@>,45 7B6 ;04 >,@62><4 <B=32>: ,@9=1;, ;02; ;04 <B=34>,2;1B> 2=B@>; 2A26848 9: ;04 ;619@>2502,944>256428:843B,1;48947B64;04;619@>25 <<B681>?5:;047B55BA1>?. #1$ 042334251,255BA481>326;* #11$ 04 <521=2>; 1, 4>;1;548 ;B ;B;25 <B=34>,2;1B>B7, ''!25B>?A1;01>;464,; 2; ;04 62;4 B7 - 346 2>>@= 76B= ;04 82;4 B7 34;1;1B> ;155 ;04 82;4 B7 64251H2;1B> 2, 2?21>,; , (('(!!2A268489:;04;619@>25* - 6 - #111$ 04 64,3B>84>; B (>,@62><4 <B=32>: 1, 8164<;48 ;B 843B,1; ;04 4>02><48 <B=34>,2;1B>B7, !25B>?A1;01>;464,; A1;01>23461B8B7B>4=B>;076B=;0482;4B7;01, B6846* #1C$ 04 <521=2>; 1, 346=1;;48 ;B A1;0862A ;04 4>;164 2=B@>; 25B>? A1;0 1>;464,; 2<<6@48 B> 1; /.8 ('!! ) & 1,;B . 5B .) .%