Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92212 (KAR)
CHANDRAKANT v. GYANOBA S/O. MAHADBA MANKARE
RSA/887/2008 · 2025-12-18
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92212 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92212 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $$ %& '( $$ )
)
'
(
! "
#
$
! "
% &
'
'
(
)
! "
® Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
$)
! "
' $
! "
'
( #! (
(
! "
' (
# (
! "
*' (
! ! "
%
& *
&' &'
&*' & ' #") &'
* &'+ #,"##"# &'
** '
- 3 -
) ' )
(
#
&
'
(
! ! "
#
#'
#'
! ! "
(
)"
$
- 4 -
#'
#'
# '
(
$"
(
"
(
$)
$
! "
( ! (
! "
(
! "
)
(
( (
!)
! "
(
)
! "
- 5 -
(
)
&'
! "
(
! "
- (
! ! "
(
)
! "
(
! "
'
(
#
! "
(
,
(
&'
! "
- 6 -
! ! (
! "
,
)
(
! "
"
(
! "
(
&'
! "
#
(
&' ! "
$
$
- 7 -
(
&' ! "
(
&'
! "
$
(
&' ! " ) ( !)
(
&' ! "
& *
#
)&' )&' !) # $
*
+ # $# !!"! )
** '
*
""*
(
#"!#"
#"# . !"#"#
,,! * **
- 8 -
*
#$"#"#
*
/ *
0
*(
1
*#
2!!#""! 34 53678 9: ;<7 =6>3?;355 3? 2 ,!,2?;<7536725@3?A3=>63B36C8D7&@?' CE?>9>8 &<7@73?>5;7@ @757@@78 ;2 >4 ;<7 /@3>6 2C@;0' >DD@37B789:;<7FC8DE7?;>?887A@778>;78"##""# =>4478 ;<7@73? 9: G<3A< ;<7 @3>6 2C@; 834E34478 ;<7 >92B74C3;25;<7=6>3?;355477H3?D@763752587A6>@>;32?>?8 @7A2B7@: 25 =24474432? G<3A< 34 A2?53@E78 9: ;<7 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 8>;78 "##""! =>4478 3? 2$#""# 2? ;<7 5367 25 3B36 C8D7 &
@ ?' >4>B>H>6:>? "# 2#""#,#" 34 53678 9: 8757?8>?;4 2 >?8# 3? 2 ,,! 2? ;<7 5367 25 @3?A3=>6 3B36 C8D7 CE?>9>8 &<7@73?>5;7@ @757@@78 ;2 >4 ;<7 /@3>62C@;0'>DD@37B789:;<7FC8DE7?;>?887A@778>;78 #"!#" =>4478 ;<7@73? 87A@773?D ;<7 4C3; 25 ;<7 =6>3?;3554;<7@73?G<3A<34A2?53@E783? 2 #"#
- 9 -
"$ 6>3?;35543? 2 ,!,>@7;<78757?8>?;4 2 >?8 # 3? 2 ,,! <7 8757?8>?;4 3? 2 ,!, >@7 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 3? 2 ,,! 3?A7 ;<7 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 4C9F7A; E>;;7@ 25 ;<747 ;G2=@2A7783?D4>@797;G77?;<74>E7=>@;374>@343?D2C; 25;<7A2EE2?344C74;<747;G2>==7>64>@7;>H7?C=52@ A2EE2?834=24>6
" <7 ;7@E /=6>3?;35540 3?
;<34 FC8DE7?; 4<>66 97 @757@@78 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 3? 2 ,!, G<2 >@7 >642 8757?8>?;4 2 >?8 # 3? 2 ,,! <7 ;7@E /8757?8>?;40 3? ;<34 FC8DE7?; 4<>66 97 @757@@78 ;2 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 3? 2 ,,! G<2 >@7 ;<7 8757?8>?;4 3? 2 ,!,
" <74C9F7A;E>;;7@25>52@74>38;G24C3;434;<7 6>?8E7>4C@3?D")>A@74)DC?;>43? :2# 43;C>;78 >; <>?8>?><>663 B366>D7 CE?>9>8 >6CH> 38>@ 34;@3A; I<7@73?>5;7@@757@@78;2>4;<7/4C9F7A;6>?80J
- 10 -
'
")
C3;3? 2 ,!,34536789:;<7=6>3?;3554 477H3?D52662G3?D@763754
! !""!#$ %
&
' ( &) *+,
,
% ! !""!#$ %
&
' ( - ) *+ ,
(*
%
%
%
" .#
** '
%
/% 011% 2
.'.3
/# #010% ' %
4(
5
-
6 2?;7?83?D3?;7@>63>;<>;
- 11 -
) 3;<29> 4<G>@ >?8 2B3?8 ;<7 ;<@77 42?4 25 2?7C?8>==>>67G7@7;<72G?7@4256>?83? :2" E7>4C@3?D ") >A@74 ) DC?;>4 G3;<2C; (766 >?8 >?2;<7@ 6>?83? :2# E7>4C@3?D!>A@74>?8$,DC?;>4G3;< > (766 92;< 43;C>;78 >; B366>D7 <>?8>?><>663 B366>D7 CE?>9>8>6CH>?838>@34;@3A; )# <7 >52@74>38 ;<@77 =7@42?4 4268 6>?8 3? :2" E7>4C@3?D
") >A@74 ) DC?;>4 ;2 ;<7 8757?8>?;4 C?87@ @7D34;7@78 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 #","G3;< G@2?D874A@3=;32?4>?892C?8>@374<7 =6>3?;355 2 4C947KC7?;6: =C@A<>478 6>?8 3? :2# E7>4C@3?D ! >A@74 $, DC?;>4 >62?D G3;< > 836>=38>;78 G7663?;7@E425@7D34;7@788778254>678>;78")",!$ 52@ > B>6C>967 4>67 A2?4387@>;32? 25 4 """ <2CD< 7?;3@7 6>?8 3? :2# G>4 =C@A<>478 9: ;<7E ;<7:
A2C68 ?2; >4A7@;>3? ;<7 63E3;4 >?8 7L;7?; 25 ;<7 >@7> 42 =C@A<>478 ;366 @7A7?;6:G<7? ;<7: 29;>3?78 E7>4C@7E7?;
25 ;<7 4>38 6>?8 G3;< @757@7?A7 ;2 3==>?3 >= ;<@2CD< > =@3B>;7 4C@B7:2@ G<7@73? 3; G>4 @7B7>678 ;<>; ;<7 8757?8>?;4 >@7 3? 3667D>6 =24474432? 25 ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 G<3A<344<2G?3?;<7@78A262C@25;<74H7;A<7?A62478;2 ;<7 =6>3?;
<7@7C=2? ;<7 =6>3?;3554 @7KC74;78 ;<7 8757?8>?;4 ;2 B>A>;7 >?8 @74;2@7 ;<7 =24474432? 25 ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 ;2 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 G3;< =@253;4 >;
4#""" =7@ >??CE 5@2E ,!!! G<3A< G>4 ?2; A2?4387@789:;<78757?8>?;4
- 12 -
)$ <7?4C947KC7?;;25363?D254C3;=6>3?;355467>@?;
;<>; 8757?8>?;4 <>B7 29;>3?78 > A266C43B7 A2E=@2E347 87A@77 3? 2##,!! >D>3?4; 4<G>@ >?8 >?2;<7@ >?8 <>8 D2; 87A@77 52@ 477H3?D @76375 25 @7A;353A>;32?
25 ;<73@ 8778 25 4>67 9: >6;7@3?D
:2" 3?;2
:2# <>; ;<7 =6>3?;355 2 >5;7@ =C@A<>43?D ;<7 =@2=7@;: 3? :2# 29;>3?78 @7B7?C7 @7A2@84 3? <34 ?>E7 <>; 43?A7 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 >@7 ?2; =>@;: ;2 ;<7 87A@77 3? 2##,!! ;<7 4>E7 34 ?C66 >?8 B238 >?8 ?2;
93?83?D 2? ;<7E 7?A7 ;<7 4C3; 52@ 87A6>@>;32? >?8 =24474432? 757?8>?;4 3? ;<73@ G@3;;7? 4;>;7E7?; 87?:3?D ;<7=6>3?;>B7@E7?;4>?8>667D>;32?4A2?;7?;78;<>;
<7: <>B7 =C@A<>478 6>?8 3? ;7@E4 25 8778 25 4>678>;78#","G<3A<3492C?8782?;<7 >4;9:
C?4268 6>?8 25 ;<7 B7?82@4 (74; 9: 6>?8 9762?D3?D ;2 8757?8>?;22@;<9:6>?8252?7
<>?H>@?D67>?8 2C;<9:6>?8252?7>LE>?>@3;<<>;;<73@B7?82@4 3?4;7>825E7?;32?3?D
:2# <>B7G@2?D6:E7?;32?78 ;<7
:2" 3?;<74>38@7D34;7@788778254>67>?8;<7 4>E7 <>4 977? @7A;35378 3? ;7@E4 25 87A@77 =>4478 3? 2##,!! <7: <>B7 977? 3? =24474432? >?8 7?F2:E7?;25;<74>38=2@;32?25;<76>?8
- 13 -
# <>;;<7:<>B78CDC=>(7663?;<7=2@;32?25 ;<7=@2=7@;:=C@A<>4789:;<7E<>;;<7=6>3?;3554 A2C68 ?2;<>B7=C@A<>478;<77?;3@77L;7?;256>?8E7>4C@3?D! >A@74$,DC?;>43? :2# 44CA<;<7:<>B7?262AC4 4;>?83;25367;<74C3; $ 6;7@?>;3B76: 3; 34 A2?;7?;78 ;<>; ;<7 8757?8>?;4 <>B7 =7@57A;78 ;<73@ ;3;67 9: G>: 25 >8B7@47 =24474432? 3?A7 5@2E ;<7 8>;7 25 ;<73@ =C@A<>47 ;<7:
<>B7 977? 2=7?6: >?8 A2?;3?C2C46: 7?F2:3?D ;<73@ @3D<; ;3;67>?83?;7@74;2B7@;<74C9F7A;6>?8;2;<7H?2G678D7 25;<7=6>3?;3554<>;;<74C3;34?2;E>3?;>3?>96752@?2? F23?87@252@3D3?>6B7?82@4G<2<>B77L7AC;78@74=7A;3B7 87784 25 4>67 3? 5>B2C@ 25 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 >4 G766 >4 ;<7 8757?8>?;43?@74=7A;25;<74C3;6>?87?A742CD<;52@ 834E344>625;<74C3; ! <7 @3>6 2C@;
2? A2?4387@>;32? 25 ;<7 =67>83?D45@>E7852662G3?D344C74 7 8
'
(
' %
1
90
: 3
; 7 8
'
'
; 7 8
'
'
- 14 -
! ! & ( % -) ; 7' 8
'
"% .# ; 7' 8 </.192
=3
/010 '
; 7' 8
'
'
'
; 7' 8
'
; 7' 8
'
# > ; 7: 8 ; 7: 8
; &L3' 8
;
", <7 =6>3?;355 2 7L>E3?78 <3E4765 >4 ( >?8 ;G2 G3;?74474 >4 (# >?8 ($ >?8 7L<393;78 )# 82ACE7?;4 >4 L ;2 L)#
7B7? G3;?74474 <>B7 977? 7L>E3?78 2? 97<>65 25 ;<7 8757?8>?;4 >4 ( ;2 ( >?8 <>B7 7L<393;78 82ACE7?;4 >4 L ;2 L ? >==@7A3>;32? 25 7B387?A7 ;<7 @3>6 2C@;
>?4G7@78 344C74 2 >?8 # =>@;6: 3? ;<7 >553@E>;3B7
- 15 -
344C742)>?8!3?;<7>553@E>;3B7>?8344C742$ , >?8 "3?
;<7?7D>;3B7 >?8 A2?47KC7?;6:834E34478 ;<74C3;
" 73?D >DD@37B78 9: ;<7 4>E7 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 =@757@@78 @7DC6>@ >==7>6 3? 2$#"# 2?4387@3?D ;<7 D@2C?84 C@D78 ;<7 *3@4; ==766>;7 2C@; 5@>E78 ;<7 52662G3?D=23?;452@3;4A2?4387@>;32? &3' 8
>
'
; &33' 8 ( >
; &333' 8
' ;
&3B' 8
;
? @7>==@7A3>;32? 25 7B387?A7 ;<7 *3@4;
==766>;7 2C@; >?4G7@78 =23?;4 2 # >?8 $ 3? ;<7 ?7D>;3B7 >?8 A2?47KC7?;6: 834E34478 ;<7 >==7>6 >?8 A2?53@E78 ;<7 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 =>4478 9: ;<7 @3>6 2C@;73?D>DD@37B78;<7=6>3?;3554>@79752@7;<342C@; 3? 2!!#"
- 16 -
' # <7
2 ,,!34536789:;<78757?8>?;4 477H3?D52662G3?D@763754
3
# # . 9
1 " "9#9! %
' ( - ) * ,
."<"
! :'
. ! " "# .9
" "# %
' ( - ) %
.1 "<"
%
& %7
"<" ,
> !%'
' (
" ) %
9 9.$ #$
+$#/#0$
%
'
'
%
'
2?;7?83?D3?;7@>63>
$ <>; 8757?8>?; 2 M 4<G>@ 42 C?8>==> 3;<29> 5>;<7@ 25 8757?8>?;4 2# ;2 >?8 2B3?8@>2
- 17 -
>67 ;<7 5>;<7@ 25 8757?8>?; 24 ;2 " G7@7 ;<7 2@3D3?>62G?7@425;<76>?83? 2# G>4!>A@74 $, DC?;>4 2C; 25 G<3A< ") >A@74 ) DC?;>4 ;<7 8757?8>?;42>?8#&=6>3?;35543? 2 ,!,' >@7;<7=C@A<>47@425=2@;32?254>386>?83? :2# C9F7A;6>?8G>442689:;<72@3D3?>62G?7@43?5>B2C@25 :>?29> &=6>3?;355 2' >?8
<@>G>? &=6>3?;355 2)' C?87@ @7D34;7@78 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 #"," G3;< 4=7A353A 92C?8>@374 B7@ 43?A7 ;<7 8>;7 25 =C@A<>47 ;<7: <>B7 977? 3? =24474432? >?8 7?F2:E7?; 25 ;<7 4>E7<>;;<7@7G>4>?2@>6=>@;3;32?97;G77?:>?29> &=6>3?;3552'>?8
<@>G>?&=6>3?;3552)'3?G<3A<>? >@7> E7>4C@3?D "$ >A@74 "! DC?;>4 3? 6>?8 97>@3?D :2# # A2@@74=2?83?D ;2
:2# 34 5>667? ;2 ;<74<>@725:>?29>>?8@7E>3?3?D"$>A@74"!DC?;>4 97>@3?D
:24# >?8 # $ A2@@74=2?83?D ;2
2# <>45>667?;2;<74<>@725=6>3?;3552)M <@>G>? (<7@7>4 3? ;<7 8778 25 4>67 4C@B7: ?CE97@ <>4 977? G@2?D6: E7?;32?78 >4
:2" 3?4;7>8 25 :2# <>; =6>3?;355 2) <>8 53678 > 4C3; 3? - 18 -
2##,!! 477H3?D @76375 25 87A6>@>;32? 25 2G?7@4<3=G3;<@74=7A;;2 2# G<3A<7?8783?> A2E=@2E3478>;78"#,!,>4782?G<3A<=6>3?;355 2) >?8 <34 9@2;<7@ :>?29> <>B7 29;>3?78 @7B7?C7 7?;@374EC;>;783?;<73@?>E73?;<7 @7A2@84256>?8 3? 2# >?8;<73@?>E74<>B7A2?;3?C78;2@7567A;
3? @7A2@84 >AA2@83?D6: <>; ;<7 2@3D3?>6 2G?7@ 4<G>@3;<29>>?8:>?29><>B74268@7E>3?3?D6>?8 3? 2# E7>4C@3?D # >A@74 #$ DC?;>4 3? 5>B2C@ 25 8757?8>?;4 2 >?8 # &=6>3?;3554 3? 2 ,!,' C?87@ @7D34;7@78 8778 25 4>67 8>;78
")",!$ 4 4CA< ;<7: >@7 3? =24474432? 25 4>38 7L;7?;256>?82G7B7@8757?8>?;42>?8#<>B7 536784C3;3? 2 ,!,>D>3?4;;<7E52@=24474432? G<3A<34=7?83?DA2?4387@>;32?4;<78757?8>?;42 >?8#;<@7>;7?78;<7=6>3?;3554G<2834=2447445@2E;<7 4C9F7A;6>?8;>H3?DC?8C7>8B>?;>D725;<7874A@3=;32?
25 ;<7 6>?8 3? :2" ;<7: 53678 ;<7 =@747?; 4C3; 477H3?D;<7@76375>4?2;78>92B7
- 19 -
<7 8757?8>?;4 2 >?8 # &=6>3?;355 3? 2 ,!,'3?;<73@G@3;;7?4;>;7E7?;>8E3;;78;<>;
;<7 6>?8 2@3D3?>66: 9762?D78 ;2 4<G>@ 3;<29> >?8 2B3?8 >?8 >642 >8E3; ;<7: 7L7AC;78 ;<7 4>67 8778 3? ;<73@ 5>B2C@ <7: >642 >8E3;;78 5363?D 25 ;<7 4C3; 3? 2 ,!, >?8 8757?8>?;4 29;>3?3?D A2E=@2E347 87A@773? 2##,!!;34A2?;7?;78;<>;:>?29> >?8
<@>G>? >@7 ;<7 =C@A<>47@4 25 6>?8 3? 2" >?8?2;3? 2# >?843?A7;<7:=C@A<>4786>?83? 2" ;<73@ ?>E74 <>B7 977? EC;>;78 3? ;<7 @7B7?C7@7A2@84>AA2@83?D6:<>;;<78757?8>?;42 >?8 # <>B7 =C@A<>478 ;<7 7?;3@7 6>?8 97:2?8
2# 9: B3@;C7 25 @7D34;7@78 8778 25 4>67 8>;78
")",!$ >?8 ;<7: <>B7 977? 3? =24474432? 25 7?;3@7 7L;7?;25!>A@74$,DC?;>4256>?8<>;;<73@4>678778 <>4 ?2; 977? A<>667?D78 9: ;<7 =6>3?;3554 >4 G766 >4 ;<7 2@3D3?>62G?7@4<7@7G>4?2E34874A@3=;32?25;<74>67 8778>4>667D787?A742CD<;52@834E344>625;<74C3;
- 20 -
>4782?;<7=67>83?D4;<7@3>62C@;5@>E78 ;<752662G3?D344C74
8
'
. .,%
' (
'
; , 8
' #> ; *4?44*@4"<"*4"*4* ! 9 9 ( 8
"9 .# 8; * 8
; 4 8 > ; 5 8
;
3 + 8
' #> ;
0 9
) ? >==@7A3>;32? 25 ;<7 7B387?A7 678 9: ;<7 =>@;374;<7@3>62C@;87A@778;<74C3;>4C?87@
- 21 -
". "# : 9#
1#2% ?" 7 71
! ". .9 #, : 9#
1#2
> '
> * %
" *
" )
&
" 4:@/ *
9 9.$ #$%
$ /0$ %
'
*
73?D >DD@37B78 =6>3?;3554 =@757@@78 > @7DC6>@ >==7>63? 2 #"#2?4387@3?D;<7D@2C?84C@D78 ;<7@73? ;<7 *3@4; ==766>;7 2C@; 5@>E78 ;<7 52662G3?D =23?;452@A2?4387@>;32? 8
. ' >
(
'
% ( ;
, N
- 22 -
! ? @7>==@7A3>;32? 25 ;<7 7B387?A7 2? @7A2@8 ;<7 *3@4; ==766>;7 2C@; >?4G7@78 ;<7 4>E7 3? ;<7 ?7D>;3B7 >?8 A2?47KC7?;6: 834E34478 ;<7 >==7>6 >?8 A2?53@E78 ;<7 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 =>4478 9: ;<7 @3>6 2C@;73?D>DD@37B78;<7=6>3?;3554>@79752@7;<342C@; 3? 2#""#,#"
, <34 2C@; 9: >? 2@87@ 8>;78 "!"#") >8E3;;78 ;<7 >==7>6 3? 2!!#""!
;2 A2?4387@ ;<7 52662G3?D4C94;>?;3>6KC74;32?4256>G 8
(
>
>
</.011
/ 010
3
7 '
-
'
3
'
% ' - '
; <"
8 >
</.011
/ 010
>
;
8
(
> '
'
'
;
- 23 -
9 8
(
'
#>
;
#" 7>@?78 A2C?476 52@ ;<7 =>@;374 F23?;6: 4C9E3;;78 ;<>; ;<7 4C94;>?;3>6 KC74;32? 2 5@>E78 3? 2!!#""! 4<>66 97 ;@7>;78 >?8 A2?4387@78 >4 4C94;>?;3>6 KC74;32? 25 6>G 3? 2#""#,#" >4 G766<74>384C9E34432?34;>H7?2?@7A2@8AA2@83?D6:
;<7 4>E7 34 ;@7>;78 >4 4C94;>?;3>6 KC74;32? 25 6>G 3? 2#""#,#" #
@3 77=>H
>@>8 67>@?78 A2C?476 >==7>@3?D52@;<7=6>3?;3554>==766>?;44C9E3;;78+ # <>; 2?A7 ;<7 2@3D3?>6 2G?7@4 7L7AC;78 8778 25 4>673?5>B2C@25;<7=6>3?;3554A2?B7:3?D7?;3@77L;7?;25 ! >A@74 $, DC?;>4 25 6>?8 3? :2# ;<7: A2C68 ?2; <>B7A2?B7:78>?:=2@;32?25;<74>386>?83?5>B2C@25;<7 8757?8>?;4 ## <7 A2E=@2E347 87A@77 7?;7@78 3?;2 3? 2##,!!>=>@;5@2E?2;93?83?D2?;<7=6>3?;35540 34 >642 C?7?52@A7>967 3?>4ECA< >4 ;<7 4>38 A2E=@2E347 87A@77<>4977?7?;7@783?;297;G77?;<78757?8>?;4>?8 4<G>@G<2342?6:2?725;<7;<@772G?7@4<72;<7@;G2
- 24 -
2@3D3?>62G?7@4?>E76:3;<29>>?82B3?8<>B7?2;977? =>@;374;2;<74>38=@2A7783?D4 #$ <7@3>6 2C@; >?8;<7*3@4; ==766>;7 2C@; <>B7 D@2446: 7@@78 3? 834E3443?D ;<7 4C3; 25 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 >?8 87A@773?D;<74C3;25;<78757?8>?;4G3;<2C;>==@7A3>;3?D ;<75>A;;<>;;<7=@7B32C42G?7@4838?2;<>B7>?:@3D<;
;3;67 >?8 3?;7@74; 3? ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 >4 ;<7 4>E7 4;228 7L;3?DC34<78 3? B37G 25 ;<7: 7L7AC;3?D ;<7 8778 25 4>67 8>;78")",!$3?5>B2C@25;<7=6>3?;3554 # <7 @3>6 2C@; >?8 ;<7 *3@4; ==766>;7 2C@; <>B7 D@2446: 7@@78 3? ?2; >==@7A3>;3?D ;<7 5>A;4 ;<>; ;<7 8757?8>?;4<>B7?2;42CD<;>?:@76375477H3?D;247;>4387 ;<7 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 ")",!$ 7L7AC;78 9: ;<7 2@3D3?>62G?7@43?5>B2C@25;<7=6>3?;3554 # <7@3>62C@;>?8;<7*3@4;==766>;72C@;D@2446: 7@@783?>==6:3?D;<7=@3?A3=674?>E76:O ' '
'
P <7 4>38 =@3?A3=674 >@7 ?2; >==63A>967 ;2 ;<7 5>A;4 >?8 A3@ACE4;>?A74 25 ;<7 A>47 2? <>?8 3?>4ECA< >4 ;<7@7 34 ?73;<7@ >?: >E93DC3;: G3;< @7D>@8;24C@B7:?CE97@?2@;2;<77L;7?;25;<7=@2=7@;:
?2@ 7B7? ;<7 92C?8>@374 E7?;32?78 3? ;<7 8778 25 4>67 <7@3>62C@;>?8;<7*3@4;==766>;72C@;;<C47@@783? 87A@773?D ;<7 4C3; 9: >==6:3?D ;<7 >52@74>38 =@3?A3=674 G3;<2C;>8B7@;3?D;2;<75>A;C>6>4=7A;25;<7E>;;7@
- 25 -
## @
@3
>A<3? ><>F>? 67>@?78 A2C?476 >==7>@3?D 52@ ;<7 @74=2?87?;4 FC4;35:3?D ;<7 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 =>4478 9: ;<7 @3>6 2C@; >?8 A2?53@E789:;<7*3@4;==766>;72C@;4C9E3;;78;<>;+ ## <792C?8>@374>?8;<7874A@3=;32?425=@2=7@;:>4 D3B7?3?;<78778254>678>;78#",";>66374G3;<;<7 874A@3=;32? 25 ;<7 4C3; =@2=7@;: D3B7? 9: ;<7 =6>3?;355 <3E47653?;<74H7;A<7?A62478;2;<7=6>3?;
### <>;;<7=7@C4>625;<7@7A3;>6425;<78778254>67 8>;78")",!$C?87@G<3A<;<7=6>3?;3554A6>3E;2<>B7 =C@A<>478 ;<7 =@2=7@;: E>H74 3; A67>@ ;<>; ;<7 4>67 A2?4387@>;32? G>4 ?2; 2? >A@7>D7 9>434 9C; 3; G>4 3?
@74=7A; 25 ;<7 7?;3@7 7L;7?; 25 6>?8 G<3A< G>4 >B>36>967 G3;<3?;<792C?8>@374E7?;32?78;<7@73? ##$ <>; 7B7? >AA2@83?D ;2 ;<7 =6>3?; >B7@E7?;
=6>3?;3554 <>4 ?73;<7@ E7>4C@78 ?2@ 4C@B7:78 ;<7 6>?8 9752@7;<7=C@A<>47>?83;342?6::7>@46>;7@=6>3?;3554D2;
;<7 6>?8 4C@B7:78 >?8 E7>4C@78 ;<@2CD< > =@3B>;7 4C@B7:2@?6:;<7?;<7:67>@?;;<>;")>A@74)DC?;>425 6>?82C;25!>A@74$,DC?;>4256>?8973?D3?=24474432? 25;<78757?8>?;4
- 26 -
## <7 92C?8>@374 >?8 ;<7 874A@3=;32? D3B7? 3? ;<7 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 #"," >4 G766 >4 3? ;<7 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 ")",!$ 7L=63A3;6: E>H74 3; A67>@ ;<>; ;<7 6>?8G>44268;2;<7=6>3?;3554G>43?877852@E3?D=>@;25 ! >A@74 $)DC?;>425 6>?8 3? :2# >?8?2; 6>?8 3? :2" >442CD<;;297A2?;7?878 ## 7@76: ;<7@7 G>4 > G@2?D 874A@3=;32? 25 4C@B7: ?CE97@3?;<78778254>67G<7@73?3?4;7>825E7?;32?3?D :2" ;<7@7 34 E7?;32? 25
:2# ;<7 4>E7 A>??2;97A2?4;@C78;28757>;;<74C94;>?;3B7@3D<;425;<7 8757?8>?;4 7?A7 <7 4C9E3;4 ;<>;4C94;>?;3>6 KC74;32?4 256>G?7784;297>?4G7@783?5>B2C@25;<7@74=2?87?;4 7?A7477H452@834E344>625;<7>==7>6 #$ 7>@87@C478;<7@7A2@84 # >4725;<7=6>3?;355434;<>;3;<29>4<G>@>?8 2B3?8>66973?D42?425C?8>==>>67G7@7;<72G?7@4 25 6>?8 97>@3?D
:2" E7>4C@3?D ) >A@74 ) DC?;>4 G3;<2C;G766>?8>?2;<7@6>?83? :2# E7>4C@3?D! >A@74 >?8 $, DC?;>4 G3;< > G766 >66 43;C>;78 >;
<>?8>?><>663 <7 4>38 =7@42?4 <>8 4268 ) >A@74 ) DC?;>4256>?83? :2" ;2;<78757?8>?;43?;7@E425 L >?8<>84C947KC7?;6:4268!>A@74$,DC?;>425
- 27 -
6>?83? :2# 3?5>B2C@25=6>3?;3552C?87@>8778 254>678>;78")",!$>4=7@ L # ; 34 ;<7 5C@;<7@ 4=7A353A A>47 25 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 ;<>; ;<2CD< ;<7 7?;3@7 7L;7?; 25 6>?8 3? :2# G>4 =C@A<>478 9: ;<7E ;<7: A2C68 ?2; >4A7@;>3? ;<7 7L;7?;
>?8 63E3;4 25 ;<7 >@7> =C@A<>478 9: ;<7E ;366 3; G>4 4C@B7:78 >?8 E7>4C@78 G3;< @757@7?A7 ;2 3==>?3 E>= ;<@2CD< ;<7 =@3B>;7 4C@B7:2@ 5;7@ 4CA< 4C@B7: ;<7: 52C?88757?8>?;4973?D3?3667D>6=24474432?2B7@;<74C3; 6>?8 ;2 >? 7L;7?; 25 ) >A@74 ) DC?;>4 >4 4<2G? 3? @78 A262C@ 3? ;<7 7?A62478 4H7;A< E>= 7?A7 4C3; 52@ 87A6>@>;32?>?8=24474432? #) *@2E ;<7 @7A2@84 52662G3?D C?834=C;78 5>A;4 7E7@D7 #) <>; =6>3?;355 2 <>?8@>H>?; 3? 2 ,!, <>8 =C@A<>478 6>?8 97>@3?D
:2# 25 <>?8>?><>663 366>D7 E7>4C@3?D ! >A@74 $, DC?;>4 3? ;7@E4 25 @7D34;7@78 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 ")",!$ =@28CA78>; L<792C?8>@374D3B7?3?;<74>388778 254>67>@7>4C?87@ ?;<7 >4; (>:67>83?D;2<28G>83 ?;<7(74;
6>?8425
<@>G>?><89>>?8 :>?9><>89> ?;<72@;< 6>?825@>H>4<34<>? >2>?8 >?3H@>234<>?@>2>?8
- 28 -
?;<7
2C;< 6>?825>LE>?C?8>==>>?8 62A>63;:25
<3B>F3?>D>@3? >3@>? #)#6>3?;3554 <>B7 =@28CA78 > 4H7;A< >62?D G3;< ;<7 =6>3?;G<3A<34E>@H78>4 L$!87E>@A>;3?D;<7>@7> E7>4C@3?D)>A@74)DC?;>4256>?8G<3A<>AA2@83?D;2 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 <>4 977? 7?A@2>A<78 C=2?
9: ;<7 8757?8>?;4 <7 4>38 4H7;A< 34 4A>??78 <7@7C?87@ 52@ 3EE783>;7=7@C4>6
- 29 -
#)#757?8>?;4?>E76::>?29>>?8
<@>B>?=C@A<>478 >?7L;7?;25)>A@74)DC?;>4256>?8G<3A<344<2G?;2 97 52@E3?D =>@; 25
:2" 3? ;7@E4 25 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 #"," =@28CA78 >4 L <7 92C?8>@374 E7?;32?783?;<74>388778254>6734>4C?87@ >4;9:@7E>3?3?D6>?825;<77L7AC;>?;4 &C?4268' (74;9:6>?825:>?29> 2@;<9:;<76>?825
<>?H>@E87 2C;<9:;<76>?825>LCE>?>@3;
#)$
H7;A< 7?A62478 9: ;<7 8757?8>?;4 =6>3?; 3? 2 ,,!344A>??78<7@7C?87@52@=7@C4>6
- 30 -
# <7 @3>6 2C@; >?8 ;<7 *3@4; ==766>;7 2C@;
<>B7 87A63?78 ;2 >AA7=; ;<7 A>47 25 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 2? ;<7 =@7E347;<>;;<7B7?82@425;<7=6>3?;3554<>83?87784268 ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 973?D >? 7L;7?; 25 ) >A@74 ) DC?;>4 52@E3?D=>@;!>A@74$,DC?;>425
:2# 3?5>B2C@25 ;<78757?8>?;43?;7@E425;<78778254>672?#"," >; L <>; ;<7@7 G>4 >? 7@@2@ 3? E7?;32?3?D ;<7 4C@B7: ?CE97@ 3? G<3A< 3?4;7>8 25 E7?;32?3?D ;<7 :2# ;<74>388778<>8E7?;32?782?6:
:2" >?8 A2?47KC7?;6: <768 ;<>; ;<7 A2EE2? B7?82@4 <>8 3?8778A2?B7:784C9F7A;6>?83?5>B2C@25;<78757?8>?;4 >?82?6:;<7@7E>3?3?D7L;7?;256>?8G>4=C@A<>4789: =6>3?;3552 #! 7>@?78 A2C?476 52@ ;<7 =6>3?;3554>==766>?;4 <7@73? B7<7E7?;6: 4C9E3;;78 ;<>; ;<7@7 G>4 ?2 >E93DC3;: 25 >?: ?>;C@7 G<>;427B7@ 3? ;<7 8778 25 4>67 8>;78#",">; L G<3A<4=7A353A>66:@757@@78;2 :2" E7>4C@3?D ) >A@74 ) DC?;>4 <>B3?D 977? A2?B7:78 3? 5>B2C@ 25 ;<7 8757?8>?;4
3E36>@6: ;<7@7
- 31 -
G>4?2>E93DC3;:G3;<@7D>@8;2;<74C@B7:?CE97@>?8 7L;7?;2592C?8>@37425;<76>?8A2?B7:783?5>B2C@25;<7 =6>3?;3554 9: ;<7 B7@: 4>E7 B7?82@4 <C4 ;<7 344C7 25 A2?;@2B7@4:34G3;<@7D>@8;2G<7;<7@2@?2;;<76>?84268 3?5>B2C@25;<78757?8>?;43?;7@E4258778254>678>;78 #"," 52@E78 =>@; 25
:2# 2@ ;<7 4>E7 34 83557@7?;>?8834;3?A;5@2E6>?897>@3?D
:2" #, <7 @3>6 2C@; >?8 ;<7 *3@4; ==766>;7 2C@;
<>B7 >=>@; 5@2E FCL;>=243?D ;<7 8778 25 4>67 8>;78
")",!$ >; L >?8 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 #"," >; L >?8A2E=>@3?D;<792C?8>@374>?8874A@3=;32?4 D3B7?;<7@73?<>B7>642@757@@78;2 L G<3A<34>344> >= 25 6>?8 3? :2# G3;< 344> 24# # # # $>?8# ?4CA<A2E=>@342?;<7@3>62C@;>?8 ;<7*3@4;==766>;72C@;<>B752C?852662G3?D92C?8>@374 ;2;<76>?8
:2# ?;<77>4; 6>?83? :2# ?;<7G74;
6>?83? :2"G<3A<34@757@@78;2>4 ;<7>?A74;@>6=@2=7@;:25;<78757?8>?; ?;<7?2@;< 6>?83? :2",>?8 ?;<742C;< 6>?83? :2#)
- 32 -
$" ? 2 ,,! > ;2?A< E>= 34 =@28CA78 >; L#"G<3A<=7@;>3?4;26>?83? :2" ")" >?8# 7@C4>625;<74>38;2?A<E>=>4;>H7??2;79: <7*3@4;==766>;72C@;3? 2 #"#>;>@>2! ;2G>@84 ;<7 G74; 25 6>?8 3? :2# ;<7@7 34 6>?8 3? 2"2G>@84;<7G74;254>386>?83? :2" ;<7@7346>?83? :2")2G>@84;<7G74;254>386>?8 3? :2");<7@7346>?83? :2" $ <7 @3>6 2C@; <>4 >642 >==@7A3>;78 ;<7 5>A; ;<>;;<7874A@3=;32?25;<7=@2=7@;:3?
L>642E>@H78 >4 L G<3A< 34 > 8778 25 4>67 8>;78 #"," C?87@ G<3A< ;<78757?8>?;4 <>B7=C@A<>478;<76>?8 ;2 97 E2@7 =@29>967 >?8 =@2=7@ 3? G<3A< ;2G>@84 ;<7 G74;
;<7@7 34 > 4=7A353A E7?;32? 25 6>?8 ;2 97 9762?D3?D ;2 :>?29> G<2 34 ;<7 =C@A<>47@ C?87@ ;<7 4>38 8778 25 4>67 <>; ;<7 4>38 6>?8 2? G74; 34 ;<7 6>?8 97>@3?D :2"G<3A<>8E3;;786:9762?D78;2;<7>?A74;2@425 :>?29> >?8
<@>B>? <7 @3>6 2C@; >?8 ;<7 *3@4;
==766>;72C@;<>B752C?8;<>;35@7>66:;<74>386>?83? - 33 -
2" G>4 4268 ;2 :>?29> >?8
<@>B>? ;<7 92C?8>@374 25 ;<7 4>38 6>?8 G2C68 <>B7 977? 83557@7?;
<>;>4=7@ L#";2?A<E>=;<792C?8>@374256>?83? 2" G2C6897>4C?87@ 2G>@847>4;>?83? 24">?8") 2G>@84G74;>?83? 24,$>?8, 2G>@84?2@;<>?83? 2"!>?8 2G>@8442C;<6>?83? 2"
$# <C4A2E=>@3?D;<792C?8>@374D3B7?3?8778 254>678>;78")",!$=@28CA78>; L>?8;<78778 254>678>;78#","=@28CA78>; L >?8344> 3==>?3>; L >?8;<7;2?A<E>=>; L#";<7@3>6 2C@;>?8;<7*3@4;==766>;7<>B7A2E7;2;<7A2?A6C432? ;<>;;<76>?8G<3A<G>44C9F7A;E>;;7@25;<78778254>67 8>;78#"," L 343?8778;<76>?852@E3?D=>@; 25 :2# G<3A< 34 ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 G@2?D6: E7?;32?3?D;<74C@B7:?CE97@>4" $$
7A;32? , 25 ;<7 ?83>? B387?A7 A;!# @7>84>4C?87@
0 +# 4'
: #
% : % ' '
7
6
- 34 -
$ <7 >92B7 =@2B3432? 25 ?83>? B387?A7 A;
=@2B3874 52@ >8E34439363;: 25 7L;@3?43A 7B387?A7 G<7? ;<7 6>?DC>D72582ACE7?;>==63743?=>@;A2@@7A;6:>?83?=>@;
3?A2@@7A;6: ;2 >? 7L34;3?D 5>A; ;2 4<2G G<7;<7@ 3; G>4 3?;7?878;2>==6:;23;>L3EO M5>647874A@3=;32? 8274?2;B3;3>;7<>;>?3?4;@CE7?;8274?2;?7A744>@36: 5>36 2@ 97A2E7 3?2=7@>;3B7 97A>C47 3; A2?;>3? >? 3?>AAC@>;7 2@ 5>647 874A@3=;32? 5 >5;7@ @7F7A;32? 25 3?>AAC@>;7 874A@3=;32? ;<7@7 34 4C553A37?; 7B387?A7 ;2 387?;35: =7@42? 2@ =@2=7@;: >557A; G366 97 D3B7? ;2 3; & 757@ !" 25 B387?A7 ,;< 83;32? >D7 ,),,$' $ <C45@2E;<7>52@74>385>A;4>?8=@2B3432?25 6>G3;34A67>@;<>;E7@7G@2?DE7?;32?3?D25;<74C@B7:
2" 3?4;7>8 25 E7?;32?3?D 4C@B7: 2# G2C68 ?2; ;>H7>G>:;<7@3D<;;3;67>?83?;7@74;A@7>;783?5>B2C@25 ;<78757?8>?;43?@74=7A;254C9F7A;6>?83?;7@E4258778 25 4>67 8>;78 #"," =@28CA78 >; L >?8 L
- 35 -
$) 763>?A7 =6>A78 2? 9: ;<7 67>@?78 A2C?476 52@ ;<78757?8>?;4 ;2;<7FC8DE7?;25;<73B3432? 7?A< 25 ;<34 2C@; 3? ;<7 A>47 25 # $%& ' &( $)# * &@7=2@;783? +!,-.3425>4434;>?A7;2;<7A>4725;<7 8757?8>?;4 G<7@73? >; >@> 2# >?8 # ;<7 3B3432? 7?A<25;<342C@;<>4<768>4C?87@ /3
''
(
(
'A * '
B
'A * '
%01$ (( <? C
$1+3?" 011 C
/D
>
) (
C '
= 'E
@ @ ' B'
= 'E
@@ '%010(( <?
C
$1+7010 C?E $ 0D
-
' '
'
8
4: @#9 @#/
0! '
'
- 36 -
0$/ 4: @#$ ' & %
(9!%9$%90 99 4: @#$ 7
' & '
-
'
'
0$/ $8
'
% '
''
' & .0
( 9$
.0 :
8 4: @#
4:@#$#
' & ' (
' & .0
4:@#1%
6
$ ;34>==@2=@3>;7;2@757@FC8DE7?;>?887A@77 8>;78"#,!,=>44783? 2##,!!9>4782?> A2E=@2E347 G<3A< ;<7 =6>3?;3554 >@7 834=C;3?D >4 ?2; 7?52@A7>9672?;<7=@7E347254>E7<>B3?D977?7?;7@78 3?;29:
@34<G>@<7<>B3?D4268;<7=@2=7@;:3?5>B2C@ 25 ;<7 =6>3?;3554 >?8 <7 ?2; <>B3?D @3D<; ;2 7?;7@ 3?;2 A2E=@2E347
- 37 -
$! 7@C4>625;<7A2E=@2E34787A@77=@28CA78>;
L 3?83A>;7 ;<>; > A2?53@E>;32? 34 E>87 9: 4<G>@ 2?7 25 ;<7 2G?7@4 25 ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 3? 5>B2C@ 25 8757?8>?;4A2?53@E3?D;<>;=6>3?;35543?8778=C@A<>47>?8 >@7;<72G?7@4256>?83? :2# G@2?D6:E7?;32?3?D :2" $, 4 >6@7>8: ?2;78 >92B7 G@2?D 874A@3=;32? 25 ;<7=@2=7@;:G2C68?2;B3;3>;7>;@>?4>A;32?<C47B7?3? ;<7 >947?A7 25 4CA< > A2E=@2E347 87A@77 8757?8>?;4 G2C68 4;366 97 ;<7 2G?7@4 25 ;<7 4C9F7A; 6>?8 <7@752@7 ;<7@3>62C@;>?8;<7*3@4;==766>;72C@;G7@7FC4;35378 3? =>443?D ;<7 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 3E=CD?78 3? ;<34 >==7>6
" <7 4C94;>?;3>6 KC74;32? 25 6>G 2 <>B3?D >?4G7@78 >4 >92B7 ;<34 2C@; 82 ?2; 53?8 >?: ?778 2@ ?7A7443;: ;2 876B7 3?;2 2;<7@ 4C94;>?;3>6 KC74;32? 25 6>G @7D>@83?D>8B7@47=24474432?>?84C3;973?D9>852@?2? F23?87@25?7A744>@:=>@;:AA2@83?D6:;<752662G3?D
- 38 -
&3' 2;<;<7>==7>64>@7 &33' <7FC8DE7?;>?887A@778>;78"##""# =>4478 3? 2 ,!, 9: ;<7 @6 3B36 C8D7 &@?' CE?>9>8 >?8 FC8DE7?;
>?8 87A@77 8>;78 "##""! =>4478 3? 2$#""#9:;<73B36C8D7&
@?' >4>B>H>6:>?>@7A2?53@E78 &333' <7FC8DE7?;>?887A@778>;78#"!#" =>44783? 2 ,,!9:;<7@63B36 C8D7 &@?' CE?>9>8 >?8 FC8DE7?; >?8 87A@77 8>;78 #"!#" =>4478 3? 2 #"# 9: ;<7
7?32@ 3B36 C8D7 CE?>9>8>@7A2?53@E78
+' % & #
( 34;2
62