- 1 - !" #!$!! !%% &'(&)) * !" # $%% & ' ( ! ' ) !* + ! '' !" # $ ' , +& Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' $&$ & ' $& +! *!+!+ !-+! - % ' ' % . % $! $ . % & /0123342501678/49:;3520<2<82112050<=8/4:>?4> :@ 8/4 542><4? 4110:<1 %A?=4 32114? :< 2< 233509280:< @054?A<?4>4980:<++*:@8/4:?4:@>0;0<25>:94?A>4 144B0<= ?019/2>=4 @:> 8/4 :@@4<941 3A<01/2654 A<?4> 4980:<1 + ! !" :@ 8/4 <?02< 4<25 :?4 "! 2<? 4980:< $ &$C& :@ 8/4 9/4?A54? 21841 2<? 9/4?A54?>0641$>4D4<80:<:@8>:908041&98 -- + /4@2981542?0<=8:8/492142>421A<?4> - 3 - /4 2334552<89:;3520<2<8 0<1808A84? 2 3>0D284 9:;3520<80<:+! 2554=0<=8/288/4299A14?/2? 152334? /0; 2<? 26A14? /0; 0< 3A6509 D04E 8/4>467 288>2980<=8/434<253>:D010:<1A<?4>8/49/4?A54?21841 2<?9/4?A54?>0641$>4D4<80:<:@8>:908041&98 -- 3:< 3>414<8280:< :@ 8/4 9:;3520<8 A<?4>4980:< +!!:@ 8/4 > 8/4 542><4? 2=018>284 0<1842? :@ >49:>?0<= 8/4 1E:>< 18284;4<8 :@ 8/4 9:;3520<2<8 ?44;4? 08 233>:3>0284 8: >4@4> 8/4 ;2884> @:> 0<D4180=280:< A<?4> 4980:< "$& :@ 8/4 > A>1A2<8 8: 8/4 >4@4>>25 :>?4>29>0;0<259214E21>4=0184>4?2<?8/4<D4180=280<= @@094>A<?4>8::B0<D4180=280:<:E4D4>2@84>9:;35480:< :@8/40<D4180=280:<8/4<D4180=280<= @@094>1A6;0884?2 FG@0<25>43:>8:<8/4=>:A<?8/288/42554=280:<19:A5?<:8 64 1A6182<80284? 8 E21 13490@092557 <:84? 67 8/4 <D4180=280<= @@094> 8/28 8/4 8E: 34>1:<1 9084? 21 474E08<41141678/49:;3520<2<80<8/43>0D2849:;3520<8 <2;457 A<05BA;2> 2<? /2H2 ;44< /2? 9284=:>092557 18284? 0< 8/40> 18284;4<81 >49:>?4? A<?4>4980:< " :@ - 4 - 8/4>8/288/47E4>4<:83>414<8288/4194<4288/4 >454D2<83:0<8:@80;4 3:< >494038 :@ 8/4 FG >43:>8 21 >4IA0>4? A<?4> 52E <:8094 E21 011A4? 8: 8/4 9:;3520<2<8 /4 9:;3520<2<8 @054? 2 3>:8418 ;4;: 4C3>4110<= /01 ?012=>44;4<8 E08/ 8/443:>8 :@8/4<D4180=280<= @@094> 2<?1:A=/82<:33:>8A<0878:542?4D0?4<9464@:>49/2>=4 /4 542><4? 2=018>284 299:>?0<=57 =>2<84? 14D4>25 :33:>8A<080418:8/49:;3520<2<88:2??A944D0?4<94 C9438 4C2;0<0<= /0;145@ 21 8/4 9:;3520<2<8 ?0? <:8 9/::14 8: 9084 :> 4C2;0<4 2<7 2??080:<25E08<411418:1A6182<802848/42554=280:<8/28/4 E21 26A14? 67 8/4 299A14? :< 8/4 62101 :@ /01 92184 :> 8/28 /4 E21 1A6H4984? 8: 3/710925 2112A58 /4 E08<41141 :>0=0<2557 9084? 0< 8/4 9:;3520<8 /2D0<= 8A><4? /:18054 64@:>48/4<D4180=280<= @@094>8/49:;3520<2<8@2054?8: 6>0<=:<>49:>?2<70<?434<?4<8:>9:>>:6:>280D44D0?4<94 0< 1A33:>8 :@ /01 9214 8/4 542><4? 4110:<1 %A?=4 E/054 - 5 - 9:<10?4>0<=8/4;284>02535294?288/4182=4:@@>2;0<=:@ 9/2>=41 A<?4>8::B 2 ?482054? 4C2;0<280:< :@ 8/4 9:;3520<2<8G1 1E:>< 18284;4<8 /4 :A>8 2?D4>84? 4C84<10D457 8: 8/4 2554=280:<1 :@ 0<84<80:<25 0<1A58 2<? 0<80;0?280:< E08/ 8/4 B<:E54?=4 8/28 8/4 9:;3520<2<8 645:<=4? 8: 2 9/4?A54? 2184 21 >4IA0>4? 8: 288>298 4980:<$ &$C&:@8/4$&98$21 088/4<18::?& 2<? 251: 9:<10?4>4? 8/4 2554=280:< :@ 10;354 2112A58 /4 542><4? 4110:<1 %A?=4 67 >4570<= A3:< 8/4 >280: 520? ?:E<678/4:<G654A3>4;4:A>80< /45? 8/28 8/4@:A<?280:<250<=>4?04<818:9:<1808A842<:@@4<94A<?4> 4980:<$ &$C&:@8/498E4>4E/:5572614<8/4 4110:<1%A?=4251:>49:>?4?2@0<?0<=8/288/4>4E21<: ;284>025 E/281:4D4> 8: 3>:944? 2=20<18 8/4 299A14? @:> 8/4:@@4<941A<?4>4980:<1+!2<?!":@8/4 :<14IA4<8574C4>9010<=HA>01?0980:<A<?4>4980:<++*:@ > 8/4 299A14? E21 ?019/2>=4? E/09/ :>?4> 01 <:E A<?4>9/2554<=40<8/01233425 - 6 - 2D0<= /42>? 8/4 542><4? 9:A<145 @:> 8/4 2334552<82<?8/4542><4?0=/:A>8:D4><;4<8542?4> >43>414<80<= 8/4 8284 2<? A3:< 34>A125 :@ 8/4 4<80>4 5:E4> :A>8 >49:>?1 8/01 :A>8 3>:944?1 8: 4C2;0<4 8/4 1A1820<2605087:@8/40;3A=<4?:>?4> " /4 =018 :@ 8/4 2554=280:< 21 4;4>=0<= @>:; 8/4 3>0D284 9:;3520<8 01 8/28 8/4 299A14? 2554=4?57 152334?8/49:;3520<2<82<?A14?26A10D452<=A2=4<42> 8/4 92<844< =284 /4 9:;3520<2<8 /0;145@ /21 ?0195:14? 0< /01 9:;3520<8 8/28 /4 /21 644< 1A33570<= 9:;3A84>132>432>812<?>4<?4>0<=>45284?14>D09418:8/4 ?432>8;4<8E/4>48/4299A14?E21E:>B0<=@:><42>5784< 742>1801251:4D0?4<8@>:;8/49:;3520<88/288/4>4E21 2 14>D094>45284? 8>2<12980:< 34<?0<= 648E44< 8/4; 2<? ?41308429:;3520<85:?=4?678/4299A14?:< !+! 34>820<0<=8:8/414>D094011A48/49:;3520<2<82884;384? 8: 2884<? 8: 08 :<57 :< + !+! 28 26:A8 ! 3; /A1 4D4< 8/4 9:;3520<8 >4@54981 2 629B=>:A<? :@ 9:;;4>9025?013A84648E44<8/432>8041 - 7 - * 413084 8/4 >4@4>>25 :>?4> 2<? 0<D4180=280:< 8/4<D4180=280<= @@094>E219:;34554?8:@0542FG>43:>8 :E0<= 8: 8/49284=:>0925 182<? 82B4< 678/4 8E: ;284>025 E08<41141 9084? 0< 8/4 9:;3520<8 <2;457 A<05BA;2> 2<? /2H2 ;44< E/: 9542>57 18284? 8/28 8/47 E4>4 <:8 3>414<8 E/4< 8/4 2554=4? 0<90?4<8 :99A>>4? /01 :A>8 <:8418/28E/4<8/49:;3520<2<8E2192554?A3:<8:542? 4D0?4<94 64@:>4 @>2;0<= 9/2>=41 /4 @2054? 8: 4C2;0<4 8/414 E08<41141 :> 3>:?A94 2<7 :8/4> 0<?434<?4<8 E08<41141 < 8/4 2614<94 :@ 2<7 9:>>:6:>280:< 8/4 :<57 ;284>02564@:>48/44110:<1:A>8E218/4A<9:>>:6:>284? 145@14>D0<= 84180;:<7 :@ 8 01 0< 8/01 629B=>:A<? 8/44110:<1%A?=4>0=/8579:<95A?4?8/288/4;284>025:< >49:>? @455 E:4@A557 1/:>8 :@ 8/4 >4IA0>4;4<8 8: @>2;4 9/2>=412=20<188/4299A14? 92>4@A5 >42?0<= :@ 8/4 0;3A=<4? :>?4> 0<?0928418/288/4542><4?4110:<1%A?=4/21A<?4>82B4< 2<4526:>2842<?HA?090:A1233>20125:@8/4;284>02564@:>4 /0; 64@:>4 255:E0<= 8/4 233509280:< @:> ?019/2>=4 /4 - 8 - @0<?0<=1 >49:>?4? 251: 0<?09284 8/28 8/4 4114<8025 0<=>4?04<81 :@ 4980:< $ &$C& :@ 8/4 98 E4>4 <:8 ;2?4:A88/4;4>40<D:9280:<:@92184>45284?2554=280:<1 E08/:A81A6182<80D44D0?4<94640<=0<1A@@0904<88:3>:944? /4 9:;3520<2<8 /2D0<= @2054? 8: 6>0<= :< >49:>? 2<7 9:=4<8 :> 0<?434<?4<8 ;284>025 ?413084 640<= 2@@:>?4? 2;354 :33:>8A<08041 8/4 4110:<1 :A>8 E21 HA180@04? 0< 9:<95A?0<=8/289:<80<A280:<:@9>0;0<253>:944?0<=1E:A5? 2;:A<88:2<26A14:@3>:9411 - 8012148854?3:1080:<:@52E8/288/419:34:@ 0<84>@4>4<94 67 8/01 :A>8 0< 2< 233425 9/2554<=0<= 2< :>?4> :@ ?019/2>=4 32114? A<?4> 4980:< ++* > 01 4C8>4;457 <2>>:E /01 :A>8 92<<:8 A<?4>82B4 2 >4233>490280:< :@ 8/4 4D0?4<94 :> 1A61808A84 081 :E< 9:<95A10:<1;4>4576492A142<:8/4>D04E013:110654/4 :<57IA4180:<01E/48/4>8/4:>?4>0;3A=<4?1A@@4>1@>:; 34>D4>1087 3284<8 0554=25087 :> 2 @A<?2;4<825 3>:94?A>25 4>>:>:1A9/0<@0>;08701?4;:<18>284?678/42334552<8 - 9 - ! < D04E :@ 8/4 @:>4=:0<= 90>9A;182<941 8/01 :A>8 @0<?1 <: ;4>08 0< 8/4 233425 /4 :>?4> 32114? 67 8/4 542><4? 4110:<1 %A?=4 01 E455>421:<4? 54=2557 1:A<?2<??:41<:89255@:>0<84>@4>4<9499:>?0<=578/4 233425640<=?4D:0?:@;4>08182<?1?01;0114? +' &!!) $ 018: 5: