Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92196 (KAR)

RAJU S/O PEERAPPA CHATNALLI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200075/2022 · 2025-08-20

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!! !## $% $&#'( )$'' * ! "#$ % & ' ( & ( ! #$ ' % & ' ( ")&' ( $*$"$ ( ##$"$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #"$#! ( ( + "! & + ' ,- .//-00.12 3-415 .6678-9 :# 48 4;/751415 2,- <795;-12 := 6:1>4624:1 9.2-9 $*$"$ .19 :?9-? := 8-12-16-9.2-9##$"$41-884:18.8-:#"$#! :12,-=40-:=2,-99424:1.0482?462.19-884:18795- .0.37?.54 6:1>462415 .6678-9 :# =:? 2,- :==-16-8 /7148,.30-719-?-624:18"$& .?2'.19"#:=194.1 -1.0:9-&=:?8,:?2@ A'.198-12-16415,4;2:719-?5: 84;/0- 4;/?48:1;-12 =:? B-.?8 .19 2: /.B . =41- := 8 $$$ =:? 2,- :==-16- /7148,.30- 719-? -624:1 "$& .?2':= .192:719-?5:84;/0-4;/?48:1;-12 =:?#;:12,.192:/.B.=41-:=8 $$=:?2,-:==-16- - 3 - /7148,.30- 719-? -624:1 "# := C42, 9-=.702 8-12-16-8 ?4-= =.628 := 2,- 6.8- .8 /-? 2,- /?:8-6724:1 .?-2,.2:1"$D$#).2$$/;.6678-9:8#.19 C-?- E7.??-0415 C42, 2,- 9?4>-? := 2,- .? 1 2,- ;-.124;- 2,- 9-6-.8-9 6.;- 2: 2,- 8/:2 .19 2?4-9 2: 412-?>-1-412,-;.22-?6678-9:8#.19.378-9,4; 41=402,B0.157.5-.19C?:15=700B?-82?.41-9,4;6678-9 :#.88.702-92,-9-6-.8-9C42,.C4?-#:1/.?4-2.0 ?-54:1 .8 . ?-8702 := C,46, ,- 8782.41-9 41<7?B .19 =-00 9:C1,40-,-C.83-4158,4=2-92:2,-,:8/42.0,-94-9 ,-?-=:?- 42 48 6:12-19-9 2,.2 2,- .6678-9 ,.>- 6:;;422-92,-:==-16-/7148,.30-719-?-624:1"$"# .19 $?-.9C42,-624:1":= " ,-=41.0?-/:?26.;-2:3-=40-9 ,-.6678-9 .//-.?-9 3-=:?- 2,- ?4.0 :7?2 .19 /0-.9-9 1:2 57402B ,-/?:8-6724:141:?9-?2:/?:>-2,-57402:=2,-.6678-9 -F.;41-9 # 2: 5:2 ;.?G-9 F8 # 2: D .19 - 4 - # ,-.6678-99-14-9.002,-416?4;41.2415;.2-?4.08 :1?-6:?972,.81:20-9.1B->49-16-4187//:?2:=,48 9-=-16- ,- ?4.0:7?2.=2-?2.G415412:6:1849-?.24:1.00 2,-8-;.2-?4.08:1?-6:?96.;-2:2,-6:160784:12,.22,- /?:8-6724:1 48 8766-88=70 41 /?:>415 2,- 57402 := 2,- .6678-9 .19 .66:?94150B /.88-9 2,- 4;/751-9 <795;-12 := 6:1>4624:1 .19:?9-? := 8-12-16- -415 .55?4->-9 3B 2,-8.;-2,-.6678-9483-=:?-2,48:7?2 -.?9?4B-9.82.10-.?1-96:718-0=:?2,- .//-00.12 .19 ?4 :/.0 ?48,1. .9.> 0-.?1-9 45, :7?2 :>-?1;-12 0-.9-? =:? 2,- ?-8/:19-12 -?78-9 2,-;.2-?4.084160794152,- ?4.0:7?2?-6:?98 1 >4-C := 2,- ?4>.0 6:12-124:18 7?5-9 3B 0-.?1-96:718-08=:?3:2,2,-/.?24-82,-/:4122,.2C:709 .?48-=:?;B6:1849-?.24:148 - 5 - B.18C-?2:2,-.3:>-/:41248412,- =:?2,-=:00:C415 D ,- /?:8-6724:1 -F.;41-9 # C4=- := 2,- 9-6-.8-9 C,: 0:95-9 2,- =4?82 41=:?;.24:1 .8 /-? F # .=2-? ?-6-4>415 41=:?;.24:1 ?-5.?9415 6:;;4884:1 := 2,- :==-16-3B2,-.6678-9,-48.,-.?8.BC421-88 8 .19 " .?- 2,- C421-88-8 2:2,- 41E7-82 ;.,.H.? F " 8 .19 .?- 2,- C421-88-8 2: 2,- 8/:2 ;.,.H.? F 8# .19 #" .?- 2,- C421-88-8 2: 8-4H7?- ;.,.H.? I F C,-?-41 2,- ;-2.0 C4?- 8.49 2: ,.>- 3--1 78-9 41 6:;;4884:1 := 2,- :==-16- C.8 8-4H-9 =?:; 2,- 8/:2 8# .19 # .?- 2,- 8-4H7?- ;.,.H.? C421-88-8 2: F #" 719-? C,46, 2,- =::2.5- C.8 ?-6:>-?-9 :1- := 2,-8- C421-88-8 ,.>- 87//:?2-9 2,- 6.8-:=2,-/?:8-6724:1-F6-/2.9;4224152,-4?8451.27?-8 =:719:12,-9:67;-128 ,-4?->49-16-481:2,-0/=702: - 6 - 2,-/?:8-6724:12:/?:>-2,-9?.C415:=41E7-82;.,.H.? 8/:2 ;.,.H.? 8-4H7?- ;.,.H.? .19 ?-6:>-?B := =::2.5-=?:;2,-86-1-:=:667??-16- ) 8D2:#D.?-2,-;.2-?4.0C421-88-8.82,-B .?--B-C421-88-82:2,-41649-127271=:?271.2-0B2,-8- C421-88-8 ,.>- .08: 1:2 87//:?2-9 2,- 6.8- := 2,- /?:8-6724:1 >-1 2,:75, 2,-8- C421-88-8 C-?- 2?-.2-9 ,:8240- .19 2,- 0-.?1-9 ?:8-672:? ,.8 6?:88-F.;41-9 2,-;1:2,415,.83--1-04642-997?4156?:88-F.;41.24:1 ,-?-=:?- 2,- >-?84:18 := .1B := 2,-8- -B-C421-88-8 .?- 1:2,-0/=702:2,-6.8-:=2,-/?:8-6724:12:/?:>-2,-57402 :=2,-.6678-9 ! ##482,-8:1:=2,-9-6-.8-9.19,-48.08: . ,-.?8.B C421-88 #) 48 2,- 86?43- := 6:;/0.412 F # C,: 48 B-2 .1:2,-? ,-.?8.B C421-88 ,-?-=:?- 8# 2: #) ,.>- 1:2 87//:?2-9 2,- 6.8- := 2,- /?:8-6724:12:/?:>-2,-6:;;4884:1:=2,-:==-16-:?2,- 57402:=2,-.6678-9 - 7 - * #! 48 2,- 88482.12 1541--? C,: ,.89?.C12,-8G-26,.8/-? F #* #*482,-:62:? C,: 6:19762-9 /:82 ;:?2-; -F.;41.24:1 .19 4887-9 2,- ?-/:?2.8/-? F $8/-?2,48?-/:?22,-9-.2,:=2,- 9-6-.8-9C.897-2:9-=78-87397?.0,-;:??,.5-412,- ?45,2 /.?4-2.0 .19 =?:12.0 ?-54:1 $ 48 2,- 64-124=46 ==46-?C,:4887-9(?-/:?2.8/-? F "66:?9415 2: C,46, .?2460-8 # .19 8-12 =:? -F.;41.24:1 2-82-9 /:8424>-=:?2,-/?-8-16-:=-2,.1:0.06:,:0?2460-8#.19 .?-2,-82:;.6,6:12-128.19/:?24:1:=411-?:?5.1:= 2,-9-.93:9B #482,- :046-==46-?C,:6:19762-9 41>-8245.24:1 .19 =40-9 6,.?5-8,--2 48 2,- :046- ==46-?C,:?-5482-?-92,-( #$ ,-1 42 48 2,- 6:12-124:1 := 2,- /?:8-6724:1 2,.22,-.6678-9,.>-/46G-97/E7.??-0C42,.171G1:C1 /-?8:1 .19 0.2-? .6678-9 :# .88.702-9 2,- 9-6-.8-9 C42, # 6.78415 =.2.0 41<7?4-8 C,46, ?-8702-9 41 ,48 9-.2, 42 ,.8 =.40-9 2: -82.3048, 2,- 8.;- ->-1 2,:75, 42 ,.8-F.;41-9C421-88-819-?876,64?67;82.16-842 - 8 - 482:3-,-092,.2/?:8-6724:1,.8;48-?.30B=.40-92:/?:>- 2,- 57402 := 2,- .6678-9 3-B:19 ?-.8:1.30- 9:732 ,-?-=:?-2,-.//-00.123-415.6678-9:#48-12420-92: 3-.6E7422-9 ## ,.>-5:1-2,?:75,2,-4;/751-9<795;-12:= 6:1>4624:1.19:?9-?:=8-12-16-/.88-93B2,- ?4.0:7?2 2?.15-0B 2,- ?4.0 :7?2 /?:6--9-9 2: 6:1>462 2,- .//-00.12 =:? 2,- :==-16- /7148,.30- 719-? 8-624:1 "$ & .?2' := ->-1 2,:75, 2,-?- .?- .38:072-0B 1: ;.2-?4.08 2: /?:>- 2,- 57402 := 2,- .6678-9 ,- ?4.0 :7?2 :38-?>415 2,.2 1:1- := 2,- -B-C421-88-8 ,.>- 87//:?2-9 2,- 6.8- := 2,- /?:8-6724:1 82400 /?:6--9-9 2: ,:092,.2->-12,:75,2,-C421-88-8,.>-27?1-9,:8240- 3B 8.B415 2,.22,-B ,.>-1:2 8--1 2,- 41649-12372 2,-B ,.>- .9;422-9 2,- 41649-12 .19 2,-?-=:?- /?:8-6724:1 48 8766-88=70 41 /?:>415 2,- 57402 := 2,- .6678-9 ,- 4;/751-9 <795;-12 48 1:2 :10B /-?>-?8- 372 42 48 400-5.0 .19/.88-9C42,:72.//046.24:1:=;419 ,-?-=:?-.; := 2,- :/414:1 2,.2 2,- 4;/751-9 <795;-12 := 6:1>4624:1 - 9 - .19:?9-?:=8-12-16-/.88-93B2,- ?4.0:7?24804.30-2: 3- 8-2 .849- .19 2,- .//-.0 48 04.30- 2: 3- .00:C-9 66:?94150B .18C-? 2,- /:412 =:? 6:1849-?.24:1 41 2,- A A.19/?:6--92:/.882,-=:00:C415 &4' ,-?4;41.0//-.048 &44' ,- <795;-12 := 6:1>4624:1 9.2-9 $*$"$ .19 :?9-? := -12-16- 9.2-9 ##$"$/.88-941:#"$#!:12,- =40- := 0-.?1-9 99424:1.0 482?462 .19 -884:18795-.0.37?.5448,-?-3B8-2.849- &444' :18-E7-120B .//-00.12.6678-9 :# 48 .6E7422-9 := 2,- :==-16-8 /7148,.30- 719-?-624:18"$& .?2'.19"#?-.9C42, -624:1":= &4>' .403:19:=2,-.6678-9.192,.2:= ,4887?-24-88,.0082.196.16-00-9 - 10 - &>' (41- .;:712 4= .1B 9-/:842-9 3B .6678-9:#48:?9-?-92:3-?-=719-92:,4; .=2-?.//-.0/-?4:948:>-? -5482?B2:8-193.6G2,- .0:15C42,6:/B:=2,48 <795;-12=:?41=:?;.24:1.19=:?1--9=70.624:1 +( $!!' " 482:#0:)