- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( ! " ## # $$ %&' ! #" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ ()!" $ ('''% !* " $ $ % * ''+ +$', $ $ - # !- " ./0122314/025363553789:.3;41/<1=:01>1/=0::.3 ?@7><3=: 1=7 1A157 71:37 ''' 210037 89 :.3 77/:/B=14 3=/B5/C/4@7>31=73<835B:B5;;/73=: 41/<0 5/8@=14% * 101C1=1 1>3A17/ D6B5 0.B5: E5/8@=14FG /= B+', 033H/=> 3=.1=;3<3=: B6 ;B<23=01:/B= =3 ./C1=1=71991 <3: A/:. 1= 1;;/73=: B= ,'') 1=7 7/37 /0 2153=:0 6/437 ;41/< 23:/:/B= - 3 - ;41/</=> ;B<23=01:/B= B6 0,''''% .3 5/8@=14 ;B=0/73537 :.3 3=:/53 <1:35/140 B= 53;B57 1=7 >51=:37 0,'''%A/:./=:3530: 1: :.351:3B6 (I 235 1==@< 65B< :.3 71:3 B6 23:/:/B= :/44 5314/01:/B= 89 6/J/=> I ;B=:5/8@:B59 =3>4/>3=;3 B= :.3 215: B6 :.3 73;31037 1=7 (IB=:.375/C35B6# @0>>5/3C3789:.301/7 B5735;41/<1=:06/437:./0122314 ) 3157 15>@<3=:0 B6 8B:. :.3 215:/30 1=7 235@037:.3<1:35/1401C1/41843B=53;B57 , .3 <1/= ;B=:3=:/B= B6 :.3 ;41/<1=:0 153 :.1: :.3;B<23=01:/B=1A1573789:.35/8@=14/0B=:.3430035 0/73 1=7 :.3 5/8@=14 .10 35537 /= .B47/=> I ;B=:5/8@:B59=3>4/>3=;3B=:.3215:B6:.373;31037 :/0 6@5:.35;B=:3=737:.1::.3/=;B<3B673;3103710030037 89:.35/8@=141:0'''%235<B=:./0<31>530:.3 1;;/73=: /0 B6 :.3 9315 ') :.3 5/8@=14 B@>.: :B .1C3 10030037 :.3 01<3 1: 0('''% 235 <B=:. .3536B53 :.39 2519 6B5 3=.1=;3<3=: B6 :.3 ;B<23=01:/B= A/:. /=:3530:1::.351:3B6&I2351==@< - 4 - : /0 0@8</::37 89 :.3 4315=37 ;B@=034 6B5 5302B=73=:K#:.1::.3;B<23=01:/B=1A1573789 :.3 5/8@=14 /0 ?@0: 1=7 25B235 1=7 /: =3370 =B /=:356353=;3 .3 5302B=73=:F0 ;B@=034 140B ;B=:3=737 :.1::.373;31037A10AB5H/=>101431=35/=:.3C3./;43 8@: A10 75/C/=> :.3 C3./;43 1: :.3 :/<3 B6 1;;/73=: 1=7 :.@0 :.3 5/8@=14 .10 5/>.:49 10030037 ;B=:5/8@:B59 =3>4/>3=;3 10 I B= :.3 73;31037 A./;. =3370 =B /=:356353=;3 =235@014B6:.37B;@<3=:0/:/0=B:/=7/02@:3 :.1: :.3 73;31037 A10 1>37 93150 1=7 AB5H/=> 10 431=35/=:.3C3./;431::.3:/<3B61;;/73=:.B@>.:.3 ;B@=034 6B5 :.3 5302B=73=: ;B=:3=737 :.1: :.39 .1C3 51/037:.3;B=:3=:/B=1018BC3836B53:.35/8@=14/=:.3/5 A5/::3= 0:1:3<3=: 8@: =B 3C/73=;3 /0 43: /= 89 :.3 5302B=73=::B25BC3:.3/52431B6;B=:5/8@:B59=3>4/>3=;3 : /0 6B5 :.3 =0@51=;3 B<21=9 :B 24317 1=7 25BC3 ;B=:5/8@:B59=3>4/>3=;38@::.3961/437:B7B0B00@;. :.3 ;B=:5/8@:B59 =3>4/>3=;3 6/J37 B= :.3 215: B6 :.3 - 5 - 73;31037 /0 4/1843 :B 83 03: 10/73 1=7 :.3 =0@51=;3 B<21=914B=3/04/1843:B219:.33=:/53;B<23=01:/B= ( $@5:.35:.3/=;B<31003003789:.35/8@=141: 0'''%235<B=:./0B=:.34300350/733=;310235 :.3 .15: /00@37 89 :.3 #15=1:1H1 :1:3 3>14 35C/;30 @:.B5/:9 :./0 B@5: 6/=70 /: ?@0: 1=7 5310B=1843 :B :1H3 :.3 =B:/B=14 /=;B<3 B6 :.3 73;31037 1: 0('''% 235 <B=:.6B5:.31;;/73=:B6:.39315')0235:.341A 41/7 7BA= 89 :.3 23J B@5: /= :.3 ;103 B6 ,'I :BA1570 6@:@53 25B023;:0 /0 :B 83 17737 :B 0('''% ;;B57/=>49,'IB60('''%;B<30:B0&''%:.@0 :B:14/=;B<3B6:.373;31037;B<30:B0+&''%0:.3 73;31037 A10 81;.34B5 'I B6 :.3 /=;B<3 /0 :B 83 737@;:37:BA1570./02350B=143J23=030.@0:.34B00B6 7323=73=;9 ;B<30 :B 0+&''% J J & J 'I L 0'&,''% 1 2017 ACJ 2700 SC - 6 - & $B5 4B00 B6 6/4/14 ;B=0B5:/@< :.3 ;41/<1=:0 153 3=:/:4376B50,''''%:B31;./=:B:140&''''%.3 ;41/<1=:0 153 140B 3=:/:437 6B5 1= 1<B@=: B6 0)''''% @=735 :.3 ;B=C3=:/B=14 .3170 10 235 :.3 ;/:1:/B= /= :.3 ;103 B6 /=0:317 B6 0)'''% 1A15737 89 :.3 5/8@=14 + ;;B57/=>49:.3;41/<1=:01533=:/:4376B5:B:14 ;B<23=01:/B= B6 0&,''% /=0:317 B6 0,'''% 1A1573789:.35/8@=1410@=735 3170 A15789:./0 B@5: B00B67323=73=;9 0'&,''% B00B66/4/14;B=0B5:/@< 0&''''% ) 51=02B5:1:/B= 6@=3514 1=74B00B630:1:3 0)''''% B:14 0&,''% ' $B5:.316B5301/75310B=0:.36B44BA/=> - 7 - !/" .3122314/0 !//" .3 1223441=:0 153 3=:/:437 6B5 ;B<23=01:/B=B60('),''%A/:./=:3530:1: :.3 51:3 B6 I 235 1==@< 65B< :.3 71:3 B6 23:/:/B= :/44 5314/M1:/B= /= 177/:/B= :B A.1: .10 833=1A1573789:.35/8@=14 !///" 302B=73=: B K =0@51=;3 B<21=9 /0 7/53;:37 :B 732B0/: :.3 ;B<23=01:/B=1<B@=:14B=>A/:./=:3530:A/:./= B=3<B=:.65B<:.371:3B6:./0?@7><3=: !/C" .3 ;41/<1=:0 153 235</::37 :B A/:.751A :.3 3=:/53 3=.1=;37 ;B<23=01:/B= A/:./=:3530:3N@1449 !C" B@=034 6B5 5302B=73=: B /0 235</::37:B6/431H141:A/:./=:ABA33H0 )*+ %$' # /0:B 4B #