- 1 - !" !" #$% & ! " #$ #%&' #('% ! &! #)!%( $ (%*(! #)!% + $, $%!$%$ ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ++ !'! + - . + + $(##$%$$ (" $%$! + + + / / 0 0 + " / 0 + 123 455647 23 89 :16 ;742<4=: 366>2=? @AB 6=14=;6<6=: A@ ;A<56=34:2A= 4B232=? AC: DCE?<6=: 4=E 4F4BE E4:6E $(%$%$$ 54336E 2= A(" $%$! 89 :166=2AB2G27CE?64=E12::45CB4@AB31AB: H:16B28C=47- $ 16 E4:6 A@ 4;;2E6=: 2=GA7G6<6=: A@ :16 G612;762=DCB93C@@6B6E89:164556774=:4=E7248272:9:A549 ;A<56=34:2A= 23 =A: 2= E235C:6, :16 A=79 E235C:6 23 F2:1 B6?4BE :A 2=4E6IC4:6 ;A<56=34:2A= 4F4BE6E 89 :16 B28C=47 F16= ;A<54B6E :A 2=DCB263 3C@@6B6E 2=;7CE2=? - 3 - 4<5C:4:2A=A@B2?1:76?48AG6:16>=6643F67743@B4;:CB6 A@:2824A@76@:76?F2:1E2348272:9:A:166J:6=:A@)!K 64BE B2 4=D66G 54:27 764B=6E ;AC=367 45564B2=?@AB:164556774=:4=E<:B66:24:2767>C=E2 764B=6E ;AC=367 45564B2=? @AB B635A=E6=: A! A:2;6 4?42=3: B635A=E6=: A! 23 E2356=36E F2:1 G2E6 ABE6B E4:6E$%!$%$ ( B2 4=D66G 4:27 :4>2=? :123 ACB: :1BAC?1 :16 DCE?<6=: 4=E4F4BE F2:1 477G616<6=;6 ;A=:6=E6E :14: :16 E4:6 A@ 4;;2E6=: F43 !!%($%$! 4=E :16 4556774=: F432=1A352:47@AB456B2AEA@!E49@AB:B64:<6=:16 B2?1:76?A@:164556774=:F434<5C:4:6E48AG6:16>=66 4=E @AB :16 @B4;:CB6 A@ 76@: 76? 26 @B4;:CB6 A@ :2824 2<574=:3 F6B6 2=36B:6E 3C8D6;:2=? :16 4556774=: @AB A56B4:2A= F12;1 B6IC2B63 B6<AG47 3 56B :16 3;16EC76 5BAG2E6E 2= :16 <57A9<6=: A<56=34:2A= ;: :16 4<5C:4:2A=A@:16B2?1:76?48AG6:16>=664=E867AF:16 3:C<5 A@ :12?1 E2348272:9 31AF= 4: '%K 4=E :1AC?1 :16 - 4 - EA;:AB 143 3:4:6E 2: 43 )%K E2348272:9 :16 B28C=47 143 :4>6= 2: 43 "%K 16 4556774=: 862=? 4 AA726 748ACB6B 31623=A:2=45A32:2A=:AEA16BA;;C54:2A=43316;AC7E EA 64B726B = :123 F49 A@ :16 <4::6B :16 6=:2B6 7A33 A@ 64B=2=?;454;2:923!%%K16A=087656JACB:2=4= 2E6=:2;47<4::6B262= ! ;A=32E6B2=? :16 @4;: :14: :16B6234"&KE2348272:93C@@6B6E89:164556774=::16B62= :4>6=:1634<643!%%K:AF4BE37A33A@64B=2=?;454;2:9 4=E4EE6E(%K:AF4BE3@C:CB65BA356;:C3:A:166J23:2=? 2=;A<63A473A;A=32E6B2=?:16;436@AB455A2=:<6=:A@4= 4::6=E4=: :A :16 B63: A@ 72@6 4=E 4F4BE6E ;A<56=34:2A= :AF4BE3@C:CB6<6E2;476J56=363164556774=:16B62=23 473A 574;6E 2= :16 34<6 32:C4:2A= 16 6=:2B6 4<AC=: 4F4BE6E C=E6B 477 :16 164E3 6J;65: <6E2;47 6J56=363 4B6 477 A= :16 7AF6B 32E6 4=E :16 34<6 B6IC2B63 :A 86 4F4BE6E 455BA5B24:679 :A 86@2: F2:12= :16 6J5B6332A= A@ 1 (2022) 15 SCC 620 - 5 - DC3:;A<56=34:2A=F16=;A<54B6E:A:162=DCB2633C@@6B6E 4=E4;;ABE2=?793AC?1::A477AF:16455647 6@C:2=?:16;A=:6=:2A=3A@:16764B=6E;AC=367 45564B2=?@AB:164556774=:<:B66:24:2767>C=E2143 3C8<2::6E :14: :16 B28C=47 143 455BA5B24:679 :4>6= :16 E2348272:9 4: "%K 4=E 2=;A<6 4: :16 B4:6 A@ 3!$%%% # 56B <A=:1 2= :16 4836=;6 A@ 4=9 6G2E6=;6 4=E 89 ;A=32E6B2=?:16@4;::14::164;;2E6=:F43A@:16964B$%$! 4F4BE6E 455BA5B24:6 ;A<56=34:2A= C=E6B 477 :16 164E3 2=;7CE2=? :16164E # 5CB;1436 A@4B:2@2;247 72<8 3 3C;1 :1634<6EA63=A:;477@AB4=92=:6B@6B6=;64::1614=E3A@ :123ACB:4=E3AC?1::AE23<233:16455647 " 4G2=? 164BE :16 764B=6E ;AC=367 @AB :16 54B:263 56BC36E :16 6=:2B6 455647 5456B3 2=;7CE2=? B247 ACB: 6;ABE3 :16 A=79 5A2=: :14: FAC7E 4B236 @AB ACB ;A=32E6B4:2A=23 - 6 - 16:16B :16 ;A<56=34:2A= 4F4BE6E 89 :16 B28C=47 86@2: F2:12= :16 6J5B6332A= A@ DC3: ;A<56=34:2A= 2@ 4=3F6B 23 A:16BF236 F16:16B 4=9 2=:6B@6B6=;6 4: :1614=E3A@:123;ACB:23B6IC2B6EL ' CB4=3F6B:A:1648AG65A2=:@AB;A=32E6B4:2A= 23H54B:792=4@@2B<4:2G6-@AB:16@A77AF2=?/ 3 ;AC7E 86 366= @BA< :16 B6;ABE3 :16 4556774=: 3C@@6B6E2=DCB9F12;1143B63C7:6E2=4<5C:4:2A=A@B2?1: 76?48AG6>=664=EF2:13:C<5A@:12?16J;66E2=?!$'% ;< F12;1 43 56B :16 3;16EC76 ;A<63 :A '%K :AF4BE3 E2348272:9 16 B28C=47 143 ;A<<2::6E 4= 6BBAB 2= =A: ;A=32E6B2=? :16 34<6 4=E :4>6= :16 34<6 4: :16 B4:6 A@ "%K F12;1 B6IC2B63 B6#;A=32E6B4:2A= A @4B 43 A:16B 164E3 4B6 ;A=;6B=6E 6J;65: <6E2;47 6J56=363 F6 @667 :14::16;A<56=34:2A=4F4BE6E23A=:167AF6B32E6A @4B 7A33 A@ 64B=2=? 23 ;A=;6B=6E 2= :6B<3 A@ :16 74F 742E EAF=89:16A=-87656JACB:2= :16 2=DCB9 143 B63C7:6E 2= '%K E2348272:9 4=E :16 4556774=: - 7 - 16B62= 23 6=:2:76E @AB (%K 4EE2:2A= :AF4BE3 @C:CB6 5BA356;:C3;A=32E6B2=?:16:16964BA@4;;2E6=:23$%$! ) ;;ABE2=?79:4>2=?'%K:AF4BE37A33A@64B=2=? A@2=DCB6E4=E473A4EE2=?(%K:AF4BE3@C:CB65BA356;:3 43F67743455792=?B676G4=:<C7:25726BA@H!-2:;A<63:A 3$!'%% #:AF4BE3H7A33A@@C:CB664B=2=?;454;2:9- & AF;A<2=?:A:164356;:A@542=4=E3C@@6B2=? :16 2=DCB6E F43 4= 2=54:26=: @AB 4 56B2AE A@ ! E493 4=E :16 B2?1: 76? A@ :16 4556774=: F43 4<5C:4:6E 48AG6 :16 >=664=E4@B4;:CB6A@76@:76?26@B4;:CB6A@:2824F16B62= 2<574=:3 F6B6 2=36B:6E 3C8D6;:2=? :16 4556774=: @AB A56B4:2A= 16=;6 2: 23 455BA5B24:6 :A 4F4BE 4 ;A<56=34:2A= A@ 3$%%%%% # :AF4BE3 H542= 4=E 3C@@6B2=?- !% 356B:16;14B:5B654B6E89:166?476BG2;6 C:1AB2:9 :16 2=;A<6 @2J6E @AB :16 964B $%$! 3A @4B 43 C=3>2776E748ACB23;A=;6B=6E233!($% #;;ABE2=?79 A= B6#E6:6B<2=4:2A= :16 4556774=: 23 6=:2:76E @AB - 8 - 3)%% #C=E6B:16164EH7A33A@2=;A<6@AB742E56B2AE @AB 32J <A=:13- :4>2=? :16 2=;A<6 A@ :16 4556774=: 4: 3!($% #2=3:64EA@3!$%%% #:4>6=89:16B28C=47 !! =3A@4B 43 4::6=E4=: ;14B?63 5CB;1436 A@ 4B:2@2;247 72<8 4=E 7A33 A@ 4<6=2:263 23 ;A=;6B=6E A= B6# E6:6B<2=4:2A= 2: ;A<63 :A 3'%(%% :AF4BE3 H4::6=E4=: ;14B?63- 3(%%%%% # :AF4BE3 H5CB;1436 A@ 4B:2@2;247 72<8-4=E3!%%%%% #:AF4BE3H7A33A@4<6=2:263- !$ =:14:G26FA@:16<4::6BA=B6#E6:6B<2=4:2A= :16;742<4=:34B66=:2:76E@AB:16;A<56=34:2A=43@A77AF3/ '()*+,-'.*(/0. ,1./ A33 A@ @C:CB6 64B=2=? M!($% #N(%K J!$J! J'%K / 3 $!'%% # 42=4=E3C@@6B2=? / 3 $%%%%%% # 6E2;476J56=36 / 3 (%%% # A33 A@ 2=;A<6 ECB2=? 742E C5 56B2AE @AB 32J <A=:13 3!($% #J" / 3 )%% # B4=35AB:4:2A= 56;247 26: 4=E::6=E4=:;14B?63 / 3 '%(%% # - 9 - CB;1436A@4B:2@2;24772<8 / 3 (%%%%% # A33A@4<6=2:263 / 3 !%%%%% # * 2 34 ! ;;ABE2=? :16 4556774=: 23 6=:2:76E @AB 4 :A:47 ;A<56=34:2A=A@3)%("%% #434?42=3:3$$)'%% 3 3C;1 :16 6=14=;6E ;A<56=34:2A= FAC7E ;A<63 :A 3!!'!%% #F12;131477;4BB92=:6B63:4::16B4:6A@"K 56B4==C<@BA<:16E4:6A@56:2:2A=:277B6472O4:2A= !( +AB :16 @AB6?A2=? B643A=3 :123 ACB: 5BA;66E3 :A5433:16@A77AF2=?/ 2 1645564723 , 22 16 DCE?<6=: 4=E 4F4BE 54336E 89 :16 B28C=47 2= 4F4BE E4:6E $(%$%$$ 2= A(" $%$!54336E89:166=2AB2G27CE?6 4=E12::45CB23<AE2@26E, 222 164556774=:236=:2:76E@AB:A:47;A<56=34:2A= A@ 3)%("%% # 4=E 6=14=;6E ;A<56=34:2A= - 10 - 4:3!!'!%% #47A=?F2:12=:6B63:4:"K56B 4==C<@BA<:16E4:6A@@272=?A@:1656:2:2A=:277 B6472O4:2A=, 2G 635A=E6=: A$ # =3CB4=;6 A<54=9 31477 E65A32: :16 6=:2B6 6=14=;6E ;A<56=34:2A= 47A=?F2:14;;BC6E2=:6B63:3:4:6E 86@AB6 :16 ;A=;6B=6E B28C=47 F2:12= 4 56B2AE A@ 32J F66>3 @BA< :16 E4:6 A@ B6;625: A@ ;A59 A@ :123 ABE6B, G @:6B E65A32: A@ ;A<56=34:2A= 'K F2:1 5BA5AB:2A=4:6 2=:6B63: 4: "K 54 23 :A 86 E65A32:6E 2= 4=9 4:2A=47 4=> 2= 4= 2=:6B63: 864B2=? +2J6E 65A32: @AB 4 56B2AE A@ :1B66 964B3 F2:1 4B6=6F4876 ;74C36 @AB 4=A:16B :FA :6B<3A@:1B66964B364;1, G2 16;A=;6B=6E84=>31477=A:56B<2:4=9 7A4= A=:16342E+2J6E65A32:F2:1AC:4=ABE6B89 :16455BA5B24:6ACB: - 11 - G22 474=;6$KF2:15BA5AB:2A=4:62=:6B63:4:"K 543147786B676436E2=@4GACBA@4556774=:A= 5BA56B2E6=:2@2;4:2A= G222 AABE6B43:A;A3: )4 # % " )4 #% " 23:A/! 7A/ /