- 1 - !" "" #$% & !" #$$ % " "" " "&' ' #% ! "" #$$ % (( )'#% (" " " && &"" & * "( ( ( " " " $ " $"" +" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " " " " ( " $ " $( $" " "( " """, , "-$ ! ./0122314/05/436789.3:41/;1<91=1/<099.3 >?6=;3<91<61@1A661936&& &210036789.3 66/9/B<143</BA/C/4?6=31<6+/>1812?A1 D5BA 0.BA9 EA/7?<14FG /< "B & * @.3A378 9.3 :41/;239/9/B<B59.31223441<9:1;39B736/0;/0036789.3 A/7?<14B<9.3=AB?<6B593AA/9BA/14>?A/06/:9/B< & $A/3551:90B59.3:103B51223441<9 :41/;1<91A3 9.19 .3A 0B< A10.1<9. 1=36 && 831A0 ;39 @/9. 1< 1::/63<9 B< * & ' @/9./< 9.3 4/;/90 B5 /;2A/ ?<3 1.1A10.9A1 9193 1<6 6/36 5BA 9.3 /<>?A/30 0?091/<36/<9.301/61::/63<941/;1<91<6.3A.?071<6 73/<= 9.3 21A3<90 B5 9.3 63:31036 5/436 1 :41/; 239/9/B< 735BA3 9.3 A/7?<14 033H/<= :B;23<019/B< B5 - 3 - 0 5AB; 9.3 A302B<63<90 ?A/<= 9.3 23<63<:8B59.3239/9/B<9.3519.3AB59.363:310366/36 1<69.3;B9.3A:B<9309369.3;1993A.3A/7?<141593A :B<0/63A/<= 9.3 3<9/A3 3C/63<:3 B< A3:BA6 6/0;/0036 9.3 :41/; 239/9/B< B< 9.3=AB?<6 9.199.3A3 @10 <B 93AA/9BA/14 >?A/06/:9/B< 9B 9A8 9.3 239/9/B< 10 9.3 :41/;1<9 51/436 9B 2AB6?:3 2ABB5 B5 A30/63<:3 1<6 10 23A I* 319. 3A9/5/:193B5.3A.?071<6.36/3619B412?A ' ==A/3C36789.301/6>?6=;3<91<61@1A69.3 :41/;1<9.102A353AA369./0122314;1/<48:B<93<6/<=9.19 0.3 /0 A30/6/<= 19 />1812?A1 1<6 0.3 .10 5/436 16.11A 1A60.B@/<=.3AA30/63<:319/>1812?A17?99.3A/7?<14 51/4369B:B<0/63A9.301;31<69.?02A18365BA144B@/<= 9.3122314 9 /0 0?7;/9936 78 9.3 431A<36 :B?<034 5BA A302B<63<9 9.19 9.3 /;2?=<36 >?6=;3<9 1<6 1@1A6 210036789.3A/7?<14/0>?091<62AB23A1<66B30<B9:144 5BA1<8/<93A53A3<:3789./0B?A9 - 4 - 31A6 431A<36 :B?<0340 B< 7B9. 9.3 0/630 1<6 23A?0369.3;193A/1401C1/41743B<A3:BA6 .3 /00?3 B< 93AA/9BA/14 >?A/06/:9/B< @10 A1/036 735BA39.3A/7?<146;/9936489.31::/63<9B::?AA3619 ?<3/<1.1A10.9A1919341/;1<93I1;/<36.3A034510 1<60919369.190.3/0A30/63<9B5/>1812?A11<6/< 0?22BA9B5/90.3.105/436.3A16.11A1A60.B@/<=.3A A30/63<9/14166A30019/>1812?A1.36193B5/00?1<:3B5 16.11A1A6/0 *& &1<69.36193B56B@<4B16B5 9.301;3/0B< *& & ) .3 6B?79 1A/030 A3=1A6/<= 9.3 17BC3 01/6 6B:?;3<9 B< 9.3 =AB?<6 9.19 9.3 1223441<9 .10 51/436 9B 0?7091<9/193 .3A A30/63<9/14 166A300 6;/993648 9.3 :41/;1<9 .10 :.B/:3 B5 /<09/9?9/<= 1 :41/; 239/9/B< @.3A3 9.3 1::/63<9 B::?AA36 BA @.3A3 0.3 A30/630 BA :1AA/30 B< .3A7?0/<300 B 7?99A300 9.3 1A=?;3<9 9.3 :B?<034 5BA 9.3 A302B<63<9 .10 A34/36 ?2B< 1 :/919/B< A32BA936 /< ( - 5 - "B ' & ) 61936 & /< @./:. /9 @10 B703AC36 9.19 /< 9.3 7BA63A 6/09A/:90 B5 ?471A=1 $34=1?; />1812?A1 1<6 $/61A 1 0?7091<9/14 <?;73A B5 :10301A35/436/<9.3::/63<941/;0A/7?<14/<A3023:9B5 9.3 1::/63<9 1A/0/<= B?9 B5 9.3 9193 B5 1.1A10.9A1 10 0?:. 9.3 5B?A 6/09A/:90 0.144 0:A?9/</J3 9.3 A30/63<9/14 166A300 2AB23A48 19 9.3 9/;3 B5 <?;73A/<= 3<:3 9./0 B?A9/0B59.3B2/</B<9.199.3:41/;1<9:1<122AB1:.9.3 A/7?<14@.3A39.31::/63<99BBH241:3BA@.3A39.381A3 A30/6/<=BA@.3A39.3:BA2BA19/B<.10/90A3=/093A36B55/:3 9B@BAHB?99.3/AA3;368 * 31A<36 :B?<034 5BA 9.3 A302B<63<9 140B A34/36 ?2B< B9.3A :/919/B< /< ( "B' * & 61936 ) & & /< @./:. /9 @10 .346 9.19 517A/:1936 6B:?;3<9 <1;348 343:9/B< :1A6 @10 2AB6?:36 5BA 9.3 2?A2B03B5:A319/<=93AA/9BA/14>?A/06/:9/B< < 9./0 :103 9.3 1223441<9 :41/;1<9 /0 1< /44/93A193 4168 6B/<= :BB4/3 @BAH .3 4B09 .3A 0B< /< 9.3 1::/63<9 1<6 140B .?071<6 6?A/<= 9.3 23<63<:8 B5 9.3 - 6 - 2AB:336/<=0 1<6 0.3 5/436 .3A 16.11A 1A6 @/9. 9.3 A30/63<9/14 166A300 B5 />1812?A1 1A<191H1 1<6 /9 @10 /00?36B< & &.3A/7?<14B703AC369.196193B5 /00?1<:3 B5 16.11A :1A6 /0 B< *& & 1<6 /9 @10 6B@<4B1636 B< *& &$?9 9.301/6 16.11A :1A6/0 <B9 5/436 735BA3 9.3 122344193 :B?A9 1<6 1<B9.3A 16.1A :1A6 /0 5/436 @./:. @10 /00?36 B< & & 1<6 6B@<4B1636B<& & .3 1::/63<9 B::?AA36 B< * & ' 1<6 16.11A:1A605/436789.31223441<9.3A3/<1A323A91/</<= 9B & & 1<6 & & 3<:3 <B 6B?79 9.3 B9BA 3./:430 :9/0173<35/:/1443=/0419/B<7?9/9/05BA9.3:41/;1<99B 2ABC39.3/AA30/63<9/14166A300@./435/4/<=1<1224/:19/B</< 1241:3B9.3A9.1<9.3241:3B51::/63<9.B?=.0.3.10 0919369.190.3@/445/431A19/B<:1A60.3.10<B95/4369.3 01;31<69.3343:9/B</63<9/98:1A63<:39.3A/7?<14 A/=.948 :B<0/63A36 144 9.3 1023:90 1<6 6/0;/0036 9.3 239/9/B< B< 9.3 =AB?<6 9.19 9.3A3 @10 <B 93AA/9BA/14 - 7 - >?A/06/:9/B<1<69./0B?A95/<60<BA310B<9B/<93A53A3@/9. 9.301/6BA63A & < 9.3 A30?49 9.3 122314 /0 :B<5/A;/<=9.3BA63AB59.3A/7?<14 '() #"% ! $,21A19B ,21A1)9B3<6 /09"B,4"B,* ,