- 1 - !"#$# %$ && '' (&) * ! " #$ % &'(&#)(( *')'#+" % , *')'"+" Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % "- % ! % % "$. "! % % "+(+ /012 '(+" %, % % % 3 $ 4566789:89 ;0<9=782 58< 5>51< <527< "+(+ ?5@@7< AB <<:2:/856 :@21:C2 58< 7@@:/8@ /012 58< <<6 :<51 @:22:89 52 5@5D5E56B58 F/1 @4/12 G21:A0856! :8 8/'(+"24:@5??756:@F:67< 1: 58;77DE0=51 52:6 675187< C/08@76 @0A=:227< 5??756 >5@ AB C65:=582 C4566789:89 F:8<:89 /F 21:A0856 /8 6:5A:6:2B 5@ >766 5@ F/1 78458C7=782 /F C/=?78@52:/82>5@@0A=:227</8+#++">478C65:=582 >5@?1/C77<:892/>51<@5@5D7@4>517=?67AB>56E/8@:<7 /F 1/5< 1:<71 /F =/2/1CBC67 8/&'(&#)(( 1/<7 :2 :8 15@4 58< 8796:9782 =58871 58< <5@47< 595:8@2 C65:=582 C50@:89 - 3 - 5CC:<7828@5:<5CC:<782C65:=582@0@25:87<91:7D/0@:8;01:7@ 7@?:27 25E:89 21752=782 52 /D718=782 /@?:256 5@5D5E56B58 58< 1585<7 /@?:256 =5195 47 <:< 8/2 17C/D71F066B58<@0@25:87<?71=58782?4B@:C56<:@5A:6:2B6/@@/F 7518:89 C5?5C:2B 4717F/17 47 F:67< C65:= ?72:2:/8 08<71 7C2:/8"((/F/2/174:C67@C2595:8@2/>87158<:8@0171/F =/2/1CBC67 . 7@?:27 @71D:C7 />871 <:< 8/2 5??751 7 >5@ ?65C7<7H&?5127 86B:8@0171/??/@7<C65:=?72:2:/8C/8278<:89 2452 C65:=7< 5=/082 >5@ 7HC7@@:D7 1:<71 /F =/2/1CBC67 >5@ 8/2 4/6<:89 D56:< 58< 7FF7C2:D7 <1:D:89 6:C78C7 58< 24717 >5@ D:/652:/8/F271=@58<C/8<:2:/8@/F?/6:CB # 5@7< /8 ?675<:89@ 21:A0856 F15=7< :@@07@ 58< 17C/1<7< 7D:<78C7 65:=582 7H5=:87< 4:=@76F 58< 15;E0=51585<75@ @"58<58<9/2=51E7<H@ " 2/ "7@?/8<782@<:<8/2675<7D:<78C7 ' 8 C/8@:<7152:/8 21:A0856 476< 2452 5CC:<782 45< /CC0117<<072/15@458<8796:97821:<:89/F=/2/1CBC67AB:2@ 1:<71C65:=58245<@0@25:87<?71=58782?4B@:C56<:@5A:6:2B6/@@ - 4 - /F 7518:89 C5?5C:2B 58< >5@ 782:267< F/1 C/=?78@52:/8 5@@7@@7<5@F/66/>@ " /@@/FF02017:8C/=7 $'#++& 7<:C567H?78@7@ "+++++& . 01:8965:<0??71:/< ")+++& # 5:858<@0FF71:89 ++++& +,- .! ./ ( 5E:89 8/27 /F F5C2 2452 C/?B /F :8@0158C7 ?/6:CB ?1/<0C7<<:<8/2C/D71<527/F5CC:<782:25A@/6D7<6:5A:6:2B/F :8@0171991:7D7<?17@7825??756:@F:67< $ 2 >5@ @0A=:227< D74:C67 >5@ <06B :8@017< 5@ /8 <527 /F 5CC:<782 58< <07 2/ :85<D71278C7 :8@0158C7 ?/6:CB F/1 ?17D:/0@B751>5@?1/<0C7<2>5@@0A=:227<:8@0158C7?/6:CB C/D71:89<527/F5CC:<782>5@?1/<0C7<5@5<<:2:/8567D:<78C7 56/89 >:24 8/"+ 5@7< /8 @5=7 :2 >5@ ?15B7< F/1 F5@278:896:5A:6:2B0?/8:8@0171 ) 8I05820=:2>5@@0A=:227<C65:=58245<@2527< 2452 47 >5@ >/1E:89 5@ 65A/0171 58< 7518:89 ")+++& ?71 =/824 21:A0856 5@@7@@7< :2 52 +++& >4:C4 >5@ /8 6/>71 @:<7 2 >5@ F012471 @0A=:227< 21:A0856 7117< :8 8/2 5>51<:89 58BC/=?78@52:/82/>51<@6/@@/F5=78:2:7@2>5@@0A=:227< - 5 - 24/094 C65:=58245< 2//E 21752=782 5@ :8?52:782 F/1 ". <5B@ 21:A0856<:<8/25>51<58BC/=?78@52:/82/>51<@@5=72>5@ @0A=:227< C65:=582 >5@ @0@25:87< F15C2017 /F 1:942 2:A:5 58< F:A065 4717F/17 5>51< /F ++++& 2/>51<@ ?5:8 58< @0FF71:89 >5@ /8 6/>71 @:<7 2 >5@ @0A=:227< C/8@7I07826B 7D785>51</F")+++&2/>51<@6/@@/F:8C/=7<01:8965:<&0? ?71:/<56@/17I0:17<2/A778458C7< 8@5:<91/08<@/0942F/1 78458C7=782 =2 1772: 52:6 76E08<: 675187< C/08@76 F/1 17@?/8<782 8/:8@0171 @/0942 2/ /??/@7 5??756 />7D71 @47F5:16BC/8C7<7<2452:8@0158C7?/6:CB?1/<0C7<5@5<<:2:/856 7D:<78C7>5@8/2<:@?027<AB:8@017158<:8@0171>/06<5@@0=7 6:5A:6:2B 8I05820=4/>7D71:2>5@@0A=:227<C/=?78@52:/8 5>51<7< AB 21:A0856 >5@ ;0@2 58< ?1/?71 58< <:< 8/2 C566 F/1 78458C7=782 "+ 751< 675187< C/08@76 ?710@7< :=?0987< ;0<9=78258<5>51<58<17C/1<@ "" %1/=5A/D7@:8C7C65:=582:@:85??756C4566789:89 F:8<:89 /F 21:A0856 /8 6:5A:6:2B 5@ >766 5@ F/1 78458C7=782 /F C/=?78@52:/8?/:82@2452>/06<51:@7F/1C/8@:<7152:/8517 - 6 - '01+1! " 8@/F51 5@ 6:5A:6:2B :8 D:7> /F ?1/<0C2:/8 /F :8@0158C7?/6:CBF/1?71:/<C/D71:89<527/F5CC:<78258<@5=7 A7:89 8/2<:@?027<AB :8@0171 ?/:82 8/" >/06<17I0:17 2/A7 58@>717<87952:D78@0171:@476<6:5A672/?5BC/=?78@52:/8 '01+ ". 4/094 C65:=582 @2527< 2452 47 >5@ >/1E:89 5@ 591:C06201:@2 58< 7518:89 ")+++& ?71 =/824 @5=7 >5@ 8/2 @0A@2582:527< >:24 58B =5271:56 :8 5A@78C7 21:A0856 >5@ ;0@2:F:7< :8 5@@7@@:89 :2 8/2:/8566B 02 8/2:/856 :8C/=7 F/1 ?71:/</F5CC:<782:7+"A7:89".'+&21:A0856>5@8/2 ;0@2:F:7< :8 25E:89 :2 52 +++& ".'+& 45@ 2/ A7 C/8@:<717< 40@ F02017 6/@@ /F :8C/=7 :@ 17C/=?027< 5@ F/66/>@& ".'+H"H"$H"'JK#+'#'+& 5=7:@5>51<7<2/C65:=582 - 7 - "# 1:A0856 5>51<7< "++ 65E4 2/>51<@ =7<:C56 7H?78@7@ 675D:89 8/ @C/?7 F/1 78458C7=782 65:=582 @0@25:87< C/==:8027< F15C2017 /F 1:942 2:A:5 58< F:A065 >4:C4 >/06<A7=5;/1F15C2017@/8@:<71:89@5=75>51</F++++& 2/>51<@ ?5:8 58< @0FF71:89 >/06< A7 :85<7I0527 5=7 :@ 78458C7<2/.++++& "' /1=566B F15C2017@ 25E7 24177 =/824@ 2/ 4756 5E:89 @5:< ?71:/< 5@ ?71:/< /F 65B/FF C65:=582 >/06< A7 782:267<2/.$'+&/8@:<71:89:8?52:782?71:/</F21752=782 /F".<5B@:2>/06<A75??1/?1:5272/5>51<"'+++&2/>51<@ F//< 52278<58C7 58< /2471 :8C:<78256 7H?78@7@ 1:A0856 45@ 56@/8/25>51<7<58BC/=?78@52:/82/>51<@6/@@/F5=78:2:7@ 25E:89 8/27 /F <:@5A:6:2B C50@7< :2 >/06< A7 5??1/?1:527 2/ 5>51< .++++& 2/>51<@ 6/@@ /F 5=78:2:7@ 40@ C65:=582 :@ 782:267<F/12/256C/=?78@52:/85@F/66/>@& " /@@/FF02017:8C/=7 #+'#'+& 7<:C567H?78@7@ "+++++& . 01:8965:<0??71:/< .$'+& # 5:858<@0FF71:89 .++++& ' %//< 52278<582 58< /2471 :8C:<782567H?78@7@ ( />51<@6/@@/F5=78:2:7@ +,- " / - 8 - /:82 8/ :@ 58@>717< ?5126B :8 5FF:1=52:D7 /8@7I07826B F/66/>:89 : ??756 :@ 566/>7< :8 ?512 ;0<9=782 58< 5>51< <527<"+(+?5@@7<:88/'(+"AB /012/F<<:2:/856 :@21:C258<7@@:/8@/012 58<<<6:<51@:22:89525@5D5E56B58:@ =/<:F:7<C65:=582:@476<782:267<F/1175@@7@@7< C/=?78@52:/8 /F " / 5@ 595:8@2 #.+#++& 5>51<7< AB 21:A0856 >:24 :82717@2 52 (J ?71 5880= F1/= <527 /F C65:= ?72:2:/8 2:66 <7?/@:2F1/=:8@0171 :: 8@0171:@<:17C27<2/<7?/@:2782:17C/=?78@52:/8 A7F/1721:A0856>:24:8@:H>77E@F1/=2/<5B ::: 8 <7?/@:2 '+J /F C/=?78@52:/8 :@ /1<717< 2/ A7E7?2:8F:H7<<7?/@:2:85852:/856:L7<A58E/1 :8 5 ?/@2 /FF:C7 F/1 5 ?71:/< /F 24177 B751@ 7=5:8:89 '+J :@ /1<717< 2/ A7 17675@7< 2/ C65:=582 2/ (&& ) $ :@2/"6/.)