Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 92173 (KAR)

ANIL v. K. SANKARAN AND ANR

MFA/201494/2021 · 2025-09-11

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"## $#% &' ()( & ' ! " # $# $# $%" &'" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $$ () ' "' &' *#+ $$#$, $%'''-! $$ * ". '' "'"" #$ $ * * & * $ $ # $ * $ # '& "' / $ ,+ !!& "' & $ $ * "&"/ , '''''' ,#$ 0 "1 * $ * 2 $ * ()(& ' " - 3 - ! " # $# $# $%" &'" " $$ () ' "' &' *#+ $$#$, $%'''-! $$ * ". ' ""'" #$ $ * * & * $ $ # $ * $ # '& "' / $,+ !! "' & $ $ * "3''' , ''''' , #$ 0 "1 * $ * 2 $ * $ * $ #$ - 4 - $ 4$$ " 5*6"' &/& "'" 78957: ;6<5=7> ?69 @A7 8BB7>>85@ A8= ?C>7: 8 D7D6 =77EC5FB79DC==C656?@A76<9@@6GC@A:98G@A78BB78> 7D6978:=@A<= !"#$ %&' ( ( () * ++ , -. 5 HC7G 6? @A7 D7D6 @A7 8BB78> C5 * 6"' &/& "'" C=:C=DC==7:8=GC@A:98G5 - 5 - 5*6"' ! "'" A7 8BB78> C5 * 6"' ! "'" C= ?C>7: =77EC5F 75A85;7D75@6?;6DB75=8@C658G89:7:IJ@A79CI<58>C5 @A7 K<:FD75@ :8@7: '& "' / B8==7: C5 6 !! "' & IJ @A7 ,+ CK8J8B<98 ?69 =A69@L@A79CI<58>M " A7 ?8;@= >78:C5F @6 ?C>C5F 6? ;>8CD B7@C@C65 897 8=<5:79, A8@ 65'& "' &8@ 8I6<@ &' A6<9=GA75 @A7 ;>8CD85@ C5 6 !!& "' & 8>65F GC@A AC= =65 8= BC>>C65 9C:79 ;>8CD85@ C5 6 !! "' & G797 F6C5F 65 D6@69;J;>7 I789C5F 6$, &,,3 F6C5F @6G89:= CK8J8B<98=C:7?96D$69@C=C:785:C@G8=9C::75C58=>6G 85: ;8<@C6<= D85579 8@ @A8@ @CD7 657 85E79 699J I789C5F 6$,',,& ' ;8D7 ?96D6BB6=C@7:C97;@C65 C58ACFA=B77:85:98=A85:57F>CF75@D8557985::9CH79 I7C5F<58I>7@6;65@96>C@;8D765G965F=C:785::8=A7: @6@A7=8C:D6@69;J;>785:;8<=7:8;;C:75@ 58;;6<5@6? - 6 - @A7 =8C: 8;;C:75@ I6@A @A7 ;>8CD85@= =<=@8C57: ?98;@<97= 85:6@A79 C5K<9C7= A7 ;>8CD85@=?C>7:@A7 ;>8CD B7@C@C65= 85: @A7 9CI<58> 8==7==7: @A7 ;6DB75=8@C65 85: B8==7: @A7 8G89: A7 ;>8CD85@ C5 * 6"' ! "'" A8= =6<FA@ ?69 75A85;7D75@ 6? ;6DB75=8@C65 8= 8G89:7: IJ @A79CI<58> & $789: >78957: ;6<5=7> ?69 @A7 8BB7>>85@ 85: >78957:;6<5=7>?6997=B65:75@6",5=<985;76DB85J 78957: ;6<5=7> ?69 8BB7>>85@ G6<>: ;65@75: @A8@@A7C5K<97:C=8I6J8F7:8I6<@ J789=85:@A797C= ?98;@<976?9CFA@?7D<985::6;@69A8=8==7==7::C=8IC>C@J 8@"'@6"/1@6@A7GA6>7I6:J85:9CI<58>A8=7997:C5 @8EC5F@A7:C=8IC>C@J8@31$7=<IDC@=@A8@@A7;>8CD85@ C= 75@C@>7: @6 ;6DB75=8@C65 8= B79 @A7 :7;C=C65 6? @A7 $654I>7B7N6<9@C5@A7;8=76? ! "#$ %"& & ' 97B69@7: C5 ( ) * +, GC@A7=;8>8@C658@"'1A79CI<58>A8=56@8G89:7:85J - 7 - ;6DB75=8@C65@6G89:=>6==6?C5;6D76?@A7B8975@=:<9C5F @A7 @978@D75@ B79C6: #C@A @AC= A7 B98J7: ?69 75A85;7D75@6?;6DB75=8@C65 / 78957:;6<5=7>?6997=B65:75@6",5=<985;7 6DB85J G6<>: =<IDC@ @A8@ @A7 9CI<58> A8= 9CFA@>J 8==7==7: @A7 :C=8IC>C@J 85: 8G89:7: @A7 ;6DB75=8@C65 GAC;AC=K<=@85:B96B79#C@A@AC=A7B98J7:?69:C=DC==8> 6?8BB78> - $8HC5FA789:>78957:;6<5=7>?69@A78BB7>>85@ 85: >78957: ;6<5=7> ?69 97=B65:75@ 6",5=<985;7 6DB85J@AC=6<9@A8=B79<=7:@A7CDB<F57:K<:FD75@ 85:6@A79D8@79C8>=B>8;7:6597;69: A7;>8CD85@C5@A7B97=75@;8=7G8=8F7: J789=8=65 @A7 :8@7 6? 8;;C:75@ = B79 7HC:75;7 6? #",6;@69 G6<5: ;79@C?C;8@7,N & 85: :C=8IC>C@J ;79@C?C;8@7,N - ;>8CD85@A8==<=@8C57:?98;@<976?9CFA@?7D<985::6;@69 A8= 8==7==7: :C=8IC>C@J @6 @A7 GA6>7 I6:J 8@ "' @6 "/1 A79CI<58>A8=7997:C5@8EC5F@A7:C=8IC>C@J8@31A7 - 8 - 9CI<58>6<FA@@6A8H7@8E75:C=8IC>C@JD697@A85 '15 HC7G6?@A7:7;C=C656?@A7$654I>7B7N6<9@C5@A7;8=7 6?=<B988=:C=8IC>C@JC=D697@A85 '1@A7 ;>8CD85@ C= 75@C@>7: @6 ;6DB75=8@C65 6? =&''''' , ?69 B8C585:=<??79C5F>978:J<5:79F65785:@6I7=<??797: C5 ?<@<97 D75@8> 85: BAJ=C;8> =A6;E A89:=ACB C5;65H75C75;785::C=;6D?69@=7@;85:>6==6?8D75C@C7= C5>C?7658;;6<5@6?B79D8575@:C=8IC>C@J A78;;C:75@C5@A7;8=76?=<B98 G8=@8E75B>8;7C5@A7J789"''-85:@A78;;C:75@C5@A7 B97=75@;8=7A8=@8E75B>8;7C5@A7J789"' &85:@A797C= 8 F8B 6? J789= @A797?697 @A7 7=;8>8@C65 A8= @6 I7 ;65=C:797:8@"'1A797?697@A7;>8CD85@C=75@C@>7:@6 =&''''' ,O=-'''' ,P* +&<5:79@A7 =8C:A78: 3 A79CI<58>A8=9CFA@>J8G89:7:*& @6G89:=D7:C;8>7NB75=7= - 9 - ! =B79@A7;8=76?=<B98 @A7 ;>8CD85@ C= 75@C@>7: @6 >6== 6? C5;6D7 6? @A7 B8975@= :<9C5F@A7B79C6:6?@978@D75@?69@A977D65@A=C58=<D 6?* &=''' ,N& ' 5HC7G6?@A78I6H7@A7;>8CD85@C=75@C@>7:@6 ;6DB75=8@C658=<5:79 , -./* 0123.4.5/-/ 67389*153 8C585:=<??79C5F =&-'''' , " 7:C;8>7NB75=7= =/'''' , & 6==6?C5;6D76?B8975@= :<9C5F@978@D75@B79C6: =" ''' , 3., *( & A7;>8CD85@C=75@C@>7:@6@6@8>;6DB75=8@C656? =& ''' ,8=8F8C5=@= "3''' ,8=8G89:7:IJ@A7 9CI<58>GC@AC5@797=@ " A78BB7>>85@,;>8CD85@C5*6"' ! "'" 6 !! "' &C=56@75@C@>7:@685JC5@797=@?69@A7 B79C6: 6? :7>8J 6? &"' :8J= C5 ?C>C5F @A7 8BB78> 8= B79 69:79:8@7:' ""'" - 10 - & 5HC7G6?@A78I6H7@A7?6>>6GC5F C A7 8BB78> C5 * 6"' &/& "'" C= :C=DC==7:8=GC@A:98G5 CC A7 8BB78> C5 * 6"' ! "'" C= 8>>6G7:C5,B89@ CCC A7 8BB7>>85@,;>8CD85@ C5 * 6"' ! "'" C= 75@C@>7: @6 @6@8> ;6DB75=8@C65 6? *( & 8F8C5=@ = "3''' , 8= 8G89:7: IJ @A7 9CI<58> 8>65F GC@A C5@797=@ 8@ @A798@7 6?-1 B8 ?96D@A7:8@76?B7@C@C65@C>>978>CQ8@C65 CH A797=B65:75@6",5=<985;7;6DB85JC= :C97;@7: @6 :7B6=C@ @A7 ;6DB75=8@C65 8D6<5@ GC@AC5 8 B79C6: 6? 7CFA@ G77E= ?96D @AC= :8J ?8C>C5F GAC;A C@ =A8>> B8J C5@797=@8@@A798@76?!1B8@C>>B8JD75@ - 11 - H A7 8BB7>>85@,;>8CD85@ C5 * "' ! "'" C=56@75@C@>7:@6C5@797=@ ?69@A7B79C6:6?:7>8J6? &"':8J=8=B79 69:79:8@7:' ""'" HC 7=@ 6? @A7 69:79 6? @A7 9CI<58> C5 6 !! "' &97D8C5=<58>@797: /& $##% " &/ .