Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92171 (KAR)
SUMITRABAI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/202759/2025 · 2025-10-13
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92171 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92171 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #
$%&!%!%
'(
! "
#
$%&&&"
'
#! #
$%&&&"
(
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$"&"
)
$"&"
* + $"&'
% *
$("(
,
$("(
#
"
)- ,! ''% '',
! )() '&') &&,'&' '
*$ ! . #
- 3 -
. # ! /010123/4 562 578 73 /9/:0/; </<=/4 78 5/99 78 4/81;/302>4/8?23;/302,@47<773:67A70B41C207 D1997E/ 18 =/>24/ 0618 2B40 7EE41/D/; =A 06/ 24;/4 ;70/;
&&,'&' ?42;B:/; 70 33/FB4/$ 561:6 18 ?788/; =A 4/8?23;/30 2' 4/<2D13E 06/ ?/010123/4 >42< 06/ </<=/4861? 2> 06/ 871; 47<7 73:67A70 78 5/99 78 ;18GB791>A13E6/4>42<:230/8013E/9/:01238>247?/412;2> 81FA/748130/4<82>/:0123)($ "!)($ '!73;/:0123 ))!2>06/743707C747<75747H73;73:67A707H </3;</30! :0 "II( J6/4/137>0/4 4/>/44/; 02 78 06/ K :0"II(LM
' 6/ =41/> >7:08 2> 06/ :78/ 74/ 0670 ?/010123/4 :971<8 02 67D/ =//3 /9/:0/; 78 7 </<=/4 2> 4/8?23;/30 2, $ 47<7 73:67A70 23 (&"''&'& 73; 86/ 578 /9/:0/; 78 7 4/81;/30 2> 06/ 871; 47<7 73:67A70 23 &(&'&'(>2406/8/:23;0/4<67086/578;18:674E13E 6/4;B01/873;>B3:0123851062B073A=9/<18625/D/47
- 4 -
>798/ 73; >41D292B8 :2<?97130 67; =//3 >19/; =A 41 <=747A7 7<=9/ 799/E13E 0670 823 2> 06/ ?/010123/4 23/ <4B06 7E74 67; 4/:/1D/; 7 8B< 2> 8"&&&&$ 13 0/4<82>:6/GB/=/7413E2,%)I>42<4/8?23;/302, $ 47<7 73:67A70 13 618 ?/482379 37</ 670 =78/; 23 06/ 871; :2<?97130 4/8?23;/30 2 $ 61/> F/:B01D/ >>1:/4 67; :799/; >24 06/ 4/?240 >42< 4/8?23;/30 2% $ 79BC7 F/:B01D/
>>1:/4 670 51062B0 D/41>A13E 06/ 799/E70123 <7;/ =A 871; <=747A7 7<=9/ 78 02 56/06/406/871;:6/GB/7<2B305784/:/1D/;>24?/482379 E713 24 206/4518/ 73; 51062B0 /D/3 ?42D1;13E 73 2??240B310A /37=913E 06/ ?/010123/4 02 E1D/ 73A :9741>1:701234/8?23;/30267;8B=<100/;06/4/?24002 4/8?23;/30 2( @ /E12379 2<<188123/4 02 07C/ 7:0123 7E7138006/?/010123/4130/4<82>/:0123)($ 2>06/ :0
"II( B48B730 02 561:6 4/8?23;/30 2( $ /E12379 2<<188123/4 188B/; 7 8625$:7B8/ 3201:/ 02 06/ ?/010123/4 /010123/4 188B/; 4/?9A 5106 799 3/:/8874A ;2:B</308 02 06/ 871; 3201:/ 670 4/8?23;/30 2( @
- 5 -
/E123792<<188123/451062B0?42D1;13E73A2??240B310A 02 06/ ?/010123/4 67; 8B=<100/; 06/ 4/?240 02 06/ 61/> F/:B01D/ >>1:/4 +1997 73:67A706 797=B47E1 4/:2<</3;13E 06/ 2D/43</30 02 4/<2D/ 06/ ?/010123/4 >42< 6/4 ?280 3 06/ </735619/ 4/8?23;/30 2( 23 4/:/1?0 2> 06/ 4/?9A >42< 06/ ?/010123/4 67; ?788/; 06/ 24;/4 ;70/; "'&,'&') ;14/:013E 06/ 61/> F/:B01D/ >>1:/4 797=B47E1 02 ;42?
06/ :78/ 70 0618 807E/ =A 4/:2D/413E78B<2>8"&&&&$73;02;/?281006/87</ =/>24/ 06/ 2D/43</30 670 7>0/4 4/:/1?0 2> 06/ 871; 4/?240 >42< 4/8?23;/30 2( @ /E12379 2<<188123/4 4/8?23;/30 2' 51062B0 /D/3 188B13E 73A 3201:/ 73; 51062B0 ?42D1;13E 73A 2??240B310A 02 06/ ?/010123/4 2> =/13E 6/74; ?788/; 06/ 1<?BE3/; 24;/4 7EE41/D/; =A 561:606/?/010123/418=/>24/06182B40 ( /743/; :2B38/9 >24 06/ ?/010123/4 4/10/47013E 06/ E42B3;8 B4E/; 13 06/ </<2473;B< 2> ?/010123 8B=<108067006/24;/41<?BE3/;1306/?4/8/30?/01012318 :230474A 02 ?413:1?9/ 2> 370B479 HB801:/ / 8B=<108 0670 - 6 - 8/412B8799/E701232><187??42?41701232>>B3;8=A06/823 2> 06/ ?/010123/4 18 <7;/ 73; 56/3 06/ ?/010123/4 18 ;14/:0/;02=/4/<2D/;>42<06/?28073;;18GB791>1/;>42< :230/8013E 06/ /9/:0123 4/8?23;/30 2' :2B9; 320 67D/ ?788/; 8B:6 73 24;/4 51062B0 ?42D1;13E 8B>>1:1/30 2??240B310A 02 06/ ?/010123/4 2> =/13E 6/74; 670 7?740 >42< =4/7:6 2> ?413:1?9/ 2> 370B479 HB801:/ 06/ >B3;7</3079 41E60 2> 06/ ?/010123/4 EB74730//; =A 06/ 238010B0123 2>3;1767D/7982 =//3 D12970/; /3:/ 06/ ?/010123 ) 34/8?238/06/9/743/; ;;10123792D/43</30 ;D2:70/7??/7413E>2406/4/8?23;/308@070/>B43186/8 7 :2?A 2> 06/ 3201:/ ;70/; &"&'&') 188B/; >42< 06/ 2>>1:/ 2> 4/8?23;/30 2' 7;;4/88/; 02 06/ ?/010123/4 6/4/13 1301<7013E 06/ ;70/ 2> 6/7413E 78 (&"&'&') 70 ""&& 7< 7923E 5106 7 9/00/4 ?B4?240/;9A 188B/; =A 06/ ?/010123/4 7;;4/88/; 02 4/8?23;/30 2' 561:6 18 ;70/; &'"''&') 4/GB/8013E 320 02 ?788 73A 24;/4 51062B0 6/7413E 6/4 />/4413E 02 06/8/ 052 ;2:B</308 9/743/; - 7 - 8B=<108 0670 06/ 239A :230/30123 B4E/; =A 06/ ?/010123/4 2> 86/ 320 67D13E =//3 188B/; 5106 7 3201:/ 18 B30/37=9/ / 8B=<108 0670 06/ ?/010123/4 6/48/9> 23 4/:/1?0 2> 06/ 3201:/ 2> 6/7413E 67; 82BE60 >24 7;H2B43</30 2> 06/ <700/4 561:6 13;1:70/8 0670 06/ ?/010123/4578E1D/38B>>1:1/302??240B310A2>=/13E6/74; 6/4/>24/ 6/ 8B=<108 0670 06/ ?/010123 18 <18:23:/1D/; 73;8//C8>24;18<188792>06/?/010123 /74;/4B8/;06/4/:24;8 % 6/ >7:08 374470/; 7=2D/ ;2 320 4/GB14/ 4/10/470123 62BE6 06/ ?/010123/4 :230/3;/; 32 3201:/ 2> 6/7413E 5/4/ 188B/; =A 06/ 4/8?23;/30 2' ?/4B879 2> 06/:2?A2>06/3201:/325>B43186/;=A06/9/743/; 13;1:70/067006/?/010123/457813;//;188B/;510673201:/ ;70/;&"&'&')1301<7013E06/;70/73;01</2>6/7413E 78 (&"&'&') 70 ""&& 7< 62BE6 73206/4 ;2:B</30 >B43186/; =A 9/743/; 13;1:70/ ?/010123/4 6/4/13 ?B4?240/;9A 188B13E 7 9/00/4 ;70/; &'"''&') ?/4B879 2> - 8 - 561:6 52B9; 13;1:70/ 0670 06/ ?/010123/4 67; 82BE60 >24 7;H2B43</302>06/<700/42306/?4/<18/2>86/4/:/1D13E 06/ 3201:/ ;70/; &"&'&') >42< 4/8?23;/30 2' 23 (&"&'&') 1380730 06/ D/4A ;70/ 23 561:6 06/ 6/7413E ;70/578>1F/;6/678?9/7;/;86/=/13E19910/470/:2B9; 320 7??/74 23 06/ 6/7413E ;70/ 78 86/ 67; 4/:/1D/; 06/ 3201:/ 23 06/ D/4A 6/7413E ;70/ 8 8B:6 86/ 67; 4/GB/80/;32002?42://;51062B06/7413E6/4 , 6/7>24/871;:230/3082>06/8/:23;;2:B</30 ?42;B:/; =A 9/743/; 74/ 8/9> /F?9737024A4/GB14/ 32 HB801>1:70123 3 0670 062BE6 4/8?23;/30 2' 8//</; 02 67D/ 188B/; 06/ 3201:/ 23 &"&'&') 06/ 87</ 18 4/:/1D/; =A 06/ ?/010123/4 23 06/ ;7A 56/3 06/ 6/7413E 578 >1F/; 2381;/413E
06/ :238/GB/3:/8 2> 06/ 24;/4 ?788/;70 33/FB4/$ 561:61878320/;7=2D/06/3201:/ ;70/;&"&'&');2/83207??/7402=/78B>>1:1/303201:/ 78:230/<?970/;B3;/4975 3201:/561:6184/:/1D/;23 06/6/7413E;7A:73320=/:2381;/4/;7878B>>1:1/303201:/ - 9 - 7806/?/010123/47;<100/;9A:2B9;3207??/74>24?7B:10A2> 01</ 30670D1/52>06/<700/406/>2992513E 7! 6/?/01012318 =! 4;/4 1<?BE3/; 70 33/FB4/$ ;70/;
&&,'&' ?788/; =A 4/8?23;/30 2' 18 8/0 781;/ :! 700/4 18 4/<100/; 02 4/8?23;/30 2' /010123/4 18 ?/4<100/; 02 >19/ 8070/</30 2> 2=H/:012351062B0/F?/:013E73A>B406/43201:/ >42< 4/8?23;/30 2' B:6 2=H/:01238 86799 =/>19/;=/>24/4/8?23;/302'510613(&;7A8 >42<06/;70/2>4/:/1?02>06/:/401>1/;:2?A2> 061824;/4 ;! /8?23;/302'234/:/1?02>8B:62=H/:01238 >1F 06/ ;70/ 2> 6/7413E 1301<70/ 06/ 87</ 02 06/?/010123/4
- 10 -
/! >0/4 7>>24;13E 8B>>1:1/30 2??240B310A 86799 ?7887??42?4170/24;/4137::24;73:/5106975 >! /010123/4 18 /30109/; 02 8//C 8B:6 206/4 4/91/> 78<7A=/7D7197=9/=/>24/4/8?23;/302'
!)* '%!%( &
1802"92)"