Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 92157 (KAR)
SHRI ASHOK PATIL v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
WP/203166/2025 · 2025-11-13
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92157 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 92157 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"!#$%
& %'"%"%
(%")
!! "# $ %%
&
# " %%$
! ' %
%"" !!''
%"" !!''
%
"" !!''
!!''
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! !!''
& %
# ( $
"% % ) "
" % *$ " % %
%
%
% # $ '+ ! " ((
% ((
%
,
%% %
%% ''! , % **$ % % % " %
"%% (
% ***$
" - % '+
!)
% %% ''! , %
%
" % % -
%%% '+'! #%$
" ((
% % ((
%
" % % %%%
- 3 -
. (
! # . ( $
/012 34/ 5/016/2 /6*71 7869/5 1* 186 4:0;
0576< =*34 34/ 5/016/2 >7869/5 1* 025771 03:06010:060>401:0?7134/@/3*3*76/1*6@/19760621* 409*A*106 4/33: 34/ 5/016/2 2B7>03/ /6/105 34178<4 B*2/7 >76?/1/6>/ 0576< =*34 5/016/2 22*3*7605 7B/16;/632B7>03/*6@/1976
8198063 37 34/ 712/1 203/2 ''! 5/016/222*3*76057B/16;/632B7>03/@50>/2761/>712 34/ 712/1 203/2 '''! @099/2 C: 34/ 1/9@762/63 7 049*5201 062 D/>83*B/ 0<*93103/ 4*330@81 0>>712*6< @/1;*99*76 37 34/ @/3*3*76/1 37 >7628>3 1783/ ;01>4=4*>41/02909862/1
- 4 -
!" !"
#"$% &'(
) *+ ,-
./
0
12+/34 5/6+(/
7/%8)9 4:;4<;=<=> = ?829@0'A B%, CD
9 <E 44 =<=> F
+/"G.0/H 99 44;44;=<=>
I/J+B K+ /%* *+",9L+
(
!" !" )
+"%
./M+/+ 12+/3 N4O 5/ 6+(/
7/% 8)
P
"L + &'( ?1$Q ? % %, CI/R =<F4SST=<=> 3L + ? ?% .+/)6 + 9 =U;4<;=<=> 6 "MV+ +"2C + &'(9 F<;4<;=<=> ?1$Q ? % %, CI/R ./W .+/)6 + 9 <>;44;=<=> ? X+/Y Z 2 ,+'A(
[+/0
+(/+ \ 6 "MV+
P 8)
]/% ^+(+ +"2_
? ? % .+/)6 +&'(6"MV+ $)L+"0 )
0
`"M+/C+
12+/3 N=O ? 829@0'A B %, C D
+
+/" G .0/H D0 9 +(/2CB 12+/3 NFO X +/" G .0/H
)
0 a@ +(9'+9
P"L +
8)0'+ ) +"% +/"G.0/H
(9 PV0L
./
0 K+A+/6
+/6
"TTT4E:T=<=>;=S
9 4=;44;=<=>
I/J+ 0L+12+/3N4O X 8)5/6+(/
7/%
( ) +"% +(/0 &'(12+/3NFO +/"G .0/H (9 PV0L9 4S 44 =<=>
V?&PF;<<'Y+_
"^+>;F<+'+
#"$% &'( ) *+K+A 'b'+cA
./W+/5L+
4O #"$% &'( ) MV'`"% '0F<<Z 0'+L '+(b"2C+ &'( K ) MV'`"
"X
"+/ (
%(] CM+/
=O #"$% &'( ) => Z 0'+ M?
+(9'+ &Z'%
6+
FO #"$% &'( ) MV'`" +(,d &+" B A"
(e "3?+ 'A P ) +" c 9 +(% +/" D2f+'+""M+/
gO #"$% &'( )
P=<=> +/ +,4S +/9
V?&P F;<< 'Y+_
"^+ >;F< + +L
)'+(b"M+/
"
P
.YC
"M+/
- 5 -
>O +/"D2f+_ .'9
WL ')'A,^Z2? B,".2-B M+/* G ")0 '#% B ," "h+B i+/ f bB 5 '
'j+/6 9+ M?B%(
$
)% B")0
) 2+/Z B,"+/6X")%9 b,^Z2? K')+ /
#
"$% +k'+(A lm M+/+m+/')'A P,A" %
SO K
#"$% &'( )
P,^^2? + /
.YC +"M+/
') +H ) &+( WL m+/
")Z. "nA'A T,/9'A m+/ MV'A # ) 'A P +(/8"M
EO
) +(/Z B MV'`"
B &X. m+/ Z]/
MV'A P M
m+/
$+(/ 0 MV+ # i+(/+'A P ,A"M
UO K )
"
) ZM-0
P +'+ +(A l
m+/ ` i +'A P "MV"+ +(/W+(A l & Z ?]'A T
T"i 7
P &+" B A"
(e "3?++(9'+
+/" D2f+'+ ./M+/
:O VXZ'A BM? 'A B,7''A PAW"%
"H 9@0'b
P o C
+ M+/ &'(M? ,7''Am+/
$+(/ \ i+(/+'A P
9"M
4<O
"MV +(/Z &'( MV'`"
) *+ "MV9L !2
'A"nb/ b+(9'+"&0"M+/
"
P c M0
C ./2C+ 'p.X 1$Q ? % %, CI/R32 =<F4SST=<=>9 =g;4<;=<=>
F<;4<;=<=> Z C $+ 9 'A ./W .+/)6
B )
+(/Z
82b + +6"MV+ $$+)
"./2' + K
P M+/+
'b'+
) .6) + 0'e"2' m9%
"0 +/6 P ",
H' m+/ ( & *'A # & *'A + / / ) ! 0'e"2' m9%+ bL+
"`T;N4= 44 =<=>O
&L/2- &'( %(9@0'A ( '+B 5/6+(/+]6
7/% 82"i$% !"!"%, C
P
4O ?829@0'A %, C
`'C"L+ =O ?"&
"+/
`'C"L+ FO
+/"1
9@/H 6&M1
;MV'`'C"L+ gO
+/"G.0/H
"( *C"L+ >O[+/0*+
- 6 -
7@: 7? 34/ 0?71/90*2 712/1 0576< =*34 *39 /6>57981/9 *9 9/1B/2 76 5/016/2 /6*71 7869/5 ?71 34/ @/3*3*76/1 /016/2/6*717869/5?7134/@/3*3*76/1=4*5/ 0@@1/>*03*6< 062 0>A67=5/2<*6< 34/ /??7139 ;02/ C: 34/ 1/9@762/63E83471*3*/95/2C:5/016/22B7>03//6/105 *6 0>>712*6< 34/ @/1;*99*76 47=/B/1 @50>/9 0 1/F8/93 3403 *693/02 7? 1/931*>3*6< ;0D*;8; 68;C/1 7? @013*>*@0639 *6 34/ 1783/ ;01>4 03 90;/ ;0: C/ *6>1/09/2 37 ) 062 3403 *693/02 7? 1/931*>3*6< 34/ 68;C/17?@/19769*634/C062<178@03!90;/;0:C/ *6>1/09/237! !
/ ?8134/1 98C;*39 3403 34/ 0?71/90*2 1/F8/93 C/ >769*2/1/2 09 76/ 3*;/ ;/0981// 09981/9 340334/ @/3*3*76/1 062 4*9 71<06*G03*76 =7852 /6981/ 024/1/6>/ 062 >7;@5*06>/ 37 055 734/1 >762*3*769 *;@79/2 *6 34/ 0?71/90*2 712/1 062 =7852 0597 >77@/103/ *6 ;0*630*6*6< 50=062712/1
- 7 -
) 6 1/9@769/ 34/ 5/016/2 2B7>03/ /6/105 98C;*39340334/68;C/17?@013*>*@063*91/931*>3/203 30A*6< *637 >769*2/103*76 34/ 9*;*501 1783/ ;01>4 >7628>3/2 C: 34/ 71<06*G03*76 7? 34/ @/3*3*76/1 *6 34/ 98117862*6< 01/09 =4*>4 =09 *6 34/ 106</ 7?@013*>*@0639 68;C/1*6<'!37!48934/1/931*>3*767?68;C/197? @013*>*@0639 03 *9 ?*D/2 C09/2 76 34/ 2030 >755/>3/2 ?17;34/98117862*6<01/09
/016/2 /6*71 >7869/5 ?71 34/ @/3*3*76/1 *6 1/@5:98C;*393403035/09334/1/9@762/63083471*3*/9C/ 2*1/>3/237@/1;*334/C062<178@7?!;/;C/19*693/02 7? ! ;/;C/19 =4*>4 *9 ?0*15: 0>>/@3/2 C: 5/016/2 2B7>03/ /6/105 37 *6>1/09/ 34/ 68;C/1 7? C062 <178@ ;/;C/19?17;!37! 8C;*99*76@50>/2761/>712
+ 489/D>/@334/0C7B/>406</*634/>762*3*76 77?34/712/1/D310>3/20C7B/1/937?34/>762*3*7697? 34/ 712/1 1/;0*6 *630>3 403 *9 34/ @/3*3*76/1 062 4*9
- 8 -
71<06*G03*76 *9 @/1;*33/2 37 30A/783 34/ 1783/ ;01>4 76 ')''! C/3=//6 @; 37 ! @; =*34 ;0D*;8;@013*>*@063909@/1>762*3*767'062C062 <178@ >769*93*6< 7? ! @013*>*@0639 *693/02 7? ! 09 @/1 >762*3*767
' 4/@/3*3*76/10624*971<06*G03*7694055/6981/ 055734/1>762*3*7697?34/712/1203/2'''!@099/2 C:1/9@762/637E0409*520109/D310>34/1/*60C7B/ 01/ >7;@5*/2 =*34 062 024/1/ 37 =*34783 06: B*7503*76 34/1/7? '' 6 34/ 5*<43 7? 34/ 0C7B/ 34/ @/3*3*76 *9
6 B*/= 7? 34/ 2*9@7905 7? 34/ ;0*6 @/3*3*76 34/ @/62*6< 9 27 673 981B*B/ ?71 >769*2/103*76 34/ 90;/ 01/2*9@79/27?0>>712*6<5:
- 9 -
4*9 7813 @50>/9 76 1/>712 *39 0@@1/>*03*76 37 34/ /??71397?5/016/21*409*A*1064/33:2B7>03//6/105 062 4*9 3/0; %*931*>3 2;*6*93103*76 062 34/ 303/ 83471*3*/9 062 34/ >77@/103*76 /F8055: 1/62/1/2 C: 1* 186 4:0; 5/016/2 /6*71 7869/5 062 1* 025771 03:06010:060>401:0 5/016/2 >7869/5 76 1/>712 062 34/ @/3*3*76/1*60;*>0C5/1/97583*767?34/;033/1
"*+ (%"%) '! (( *937'57+'