- 1 - !"#"" " $% $&'( %$'' ) ! ! " ! ! ! " # ! $ ! # !! " ! % " ! & !! ! ! ! !! ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! ! ! ! ! ! " !! ! ! !! !! ' ! ( ) * # ! ! ' + # & ! , ! + # & )! &"&#&* ( ) ! * ! ,! # , ) !* # , &&& & ) &* ! !, ', & ,! , ! ! , , , - 3 - -! ) -! * ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 0229/5: ;<=0./5: 46 3.2 1>4?228/5:0 1258/5: /5 4& )=>/0/5: 4<3 46 4&* 45 3.2 6/72 46 >/5?/1=7 /@/7 <8:2 =58 ,.4>=1<>64>3.246625?21<5/0.=A72<582>2?3/45 %46 .2:/03463.21>402?<3/45?=02/03.=3=??<028 48<>/5:3.20<A0/0325?246./0@=7/8B=>>/=:2C/3.3.2 >201458253+?4B17=/5=53 /0 =772:28 34 .=@2 ?453>=?328 = 02?458 B=>>/=:2 C/3. =??<028 4 3.2>2AD ?4BB/33/5: =546625?21<5/0.=A72<582>2?3/45%463.23/0 6<>3.2> =772:28 3.=3 3.2 1=>2530 46 =??<028 40 =58 =745: C/3. ?2>3=/5 >27=3/@20 =?3/@27D 1=>3/?/1=328 /5 =58 6=?/7/3=3283.20=/802?458B=>>/=:272=8/5:343.26/7/5:46 3.21>20253?4B17=/53 - 4 - .21>20253123/3/45/06/728AD=??<0284E 3.2.<0A=58463.2>201458253+?4B17=/5=53=??<0284 E 3.2 =772:28 02?458 C/62 =58 3.2 1=>2530 B43.2> 0/A7/5:0=58>27=3/@20 46 =??<02840=58 C.4.=@2 A225=>>=D28=0?4+=??<028/53.2?4B17=/53 ./0 4<>3 .=0 .2=>8 3.2 72=>528 ?4<5027 =112=>/5: 64> 3.2 123/3/452>0 =0 C277 =0 3.2 72=>528 ?4<5027 >21>20253/5: 3.2 >201458253 =58 .=0 ?=>26<77D 12><028 3.2 ?4532530 46 3.2 ?4B17=/53 748:28 AD 3.2 >201458253 3 /0 =5 =8B/3328 6=?3 3.=3 3.2 >201458253+ ?4B17=/5=53 8/8 543 12>045=77D C/35200 3.2 =772:28 B=>>/=:2 A23C225 =??<028 40 =58 .2 1>/@=32 ?4B17=/53.=0A2256/72804727D453.2A=0/046/564>B=3/45 1<>14>3287D >2?2/@28 AD .2> 6>4B 3./>8 1=>3/20 5 3./0 A=?9:>4<58 A264>2 2F=B/5/5: 3.2 >/@=7 ?453253/450 /3 /0 ?450/82>28 =11>41>/=32 34 2F3>=?3 3.2 >272@=53 14>3/45 46 3.21>/@=32?4B17=/53C./?.>2=80=0<582> - 5 - ! " #$ % &' ( ) ( * & +& , -& .&/( 01 .234 5 6 7 " 5=?=>26<7>2=8/5:463.22F3>=?32814>3/4546 3.2 ?4B17=/53 /3 A2?4B20 =11=>253 3.=3 3.2 >201458253+ ?4B17=/5=53 .=0 543 8/0?74028 3.2 04<>?2 46 .2> /564>B=3/45 4> 3.2 /8253/3D 46 3.2 12>045 C.4 =772:287D /564>B28 .2> =A4<3 3.2 1<>14>328 02?458 B=>>/=:2 A23C225=??<02840=58.2?4B17=/533.2>264>2/0 64<5828B2>27D45.2=>0=D/564>B=3/45C/3.4<38/0?740/5: 3.2 /564>B=53G0 /8253/3D ./72 /3 /0 3><2 3.=3 3.2 >201458253+?4B17=/5=53A2/5:3.272:=77DC28828C/6246 =??<028 4 /0 253/3728 34 /5/3/=32 ?>/B/5=7 1>4?228/5:0 =:=/503 .2> .<0A=58 3.2 =772:28 02?458 C/62 )=??<028 4* =58 3.2 1=>2530 46 =??<028 4 3.2 =A025?2 46 1=>3/?<7=>0 =0 34 C.4 ?45@2D28 3.2 =772:28 /564>B=3/45 =58 3.2 7=?9 46 =5D 64<58=3/45=7 B=32>/=7 =:=/503 3.2 >2B=/5/5: =??<028 B=920 /3 B=5/6203 3.=3 2@25 /6 3.2 - 6 - ?4B17=/53=583.20<114>3/5:B=32>/=70=>23=925=33.2/> 6=?2 @=7<2 54 1>/B= 6=?/2 ?=02 /0 B=82 4<3 =:=/503 123/3/452>034" $ 3 /0 = C277+0233728 1>/5?/172 46 ?>/B/5=7 H<>/01><825?2 3.=3 7/92 =77 43.2> 46625?20 3.2 46625?2 46 A/:=BD <582> 2?3/45 % 46 3.2 =704 >2;</>20 3.2 1>2025?2 46 B250 >2= = :</73D /53253 =0 =5 200253/=7 /5:>28/25364>?45@/?3/45.2>201458253+C/62B=D8<>/5: 3.2 ?4<>02 46 3>/=7 A2 /5 = 140/3/45 34 203=A7/0. 3.=3 =??<028 40 =58 .=@2 /58228 ?453>=?328 = 02?458 B=>>/=:2 8<>/5: 3.2 0<A0/0325?2 46 3.2 6/>03 4C2@2> 34 /B17/?=32 3.2 >27=3/@20 46 2/3.2> =??<028 4 4> =??<028 4 /5 3.2 46625?2 3.2>2 B<03 A2 012?/6/? =58 3=5:/A72 B=32>/=70.4C/5:3.2/>=?3/@21=>3/?/1=3/454>=A23B253/5 3.2 =772:28 A/:=B4<0 B=>>/=:2 12>045 ?=5 A2 .278 7/=A72 64> =A23B253 457D /6 3.2>2 =>2 ?72=> =58 ?4:253 =772:=3/450 3.=3 .2 4> 0.2 =?3/@27D =/828 /503/:=328 4> ?4501/>28/53.2?4BB/00/45463.246625?2 - 7 - # 5 = 17=/5 >2=8/5: 46 3.2 ?4B17=/53 /3 /0 0225 3.=3=73.4<:.3.2>201458253.=0=>>=D28123/3/452>034 "=0=??<028=58B=82=0C221/5:=772:=3/453.=33.2D .=@2I=?3/@27D1=>3/?/1=328J/53.202?458B=>>/=:23.2>2 =>254012?/6/?=@2>B2530820?>/A/5:3.2/>/58/@/8<=7>4720 4>=?303.=3?4<78?4503/3<32=A23B253<582>2?3/45&% 463.2/5?23.2/503=53?=02/0=1>/@=32?4B17=/53= :>2=32> 82:>22 46 1=>3/?<7=>/3D /0 >2;</>28 .2 ?4B17=/5=53 C=0 2F12?328 34 1>4@/82 ?45?>232 823=/70 012?/6D/5: 3.2 4@2>3 =?30 46 2=?. 46 3.2 123/3/452>0 =58 .4C0<?.=?30C4<78=33>=?33.2/5:>28/253046=A23B253 .2?4B17=/53.4C2@2>/0A2>26346=5D0<?.823=/70 % 3/06<>3.2>543/?283.=33.272=>528=:/03>=32 .=0 3=925 ?4:5/K=5?2 46 3.2 46625?2 457D <582> 2?3/45 % 46 3.2 =58 543 64> =A23B253 <582> 2?3/45 &% @25 45 3./0 :>4<58 ?453/5<=3/45 46 1>4?228/5:0 =:=/503123/3/452>034C.4=>2=772:2834A2>27=3/@20 4> 6=B/7D B2BA2>0 B2>27D 1>20253 =3 3.2 3/B2 46 3.2 =772:28B=>>/=:2C4<78543A20<03=/5=A72.27=C/0?72=> - 8 - 3.=3 B2>2 1=00/@2 1>2025?2 4> =33258=5?2 =3 = B=>>/=:2 ?2>2B45DC/3.4<3=5D=?3/@2>4724>/503/:=3/458420543 =B4<53 34 =A23B253 46 A/:=BD 5 3.2 =A025?2 46 ?72=> =58012?/6/?=772:=3/4500.4C/5:=5D8/>2?3/5@47@2B25346 3.202 123/3/452>0 /5 3.2 0472B5/K=3/45 46 3.2 02?458 B=>>/=:23.2?453/5<=3/4546?>/B/5=71>4?228/5:0=:=/503 3.2BC4<78=B4<5334=5=A<02463.21>4?200467=C & ??4>8/5:7D3./04<>3/0463.2?450/82>28@/2C 3.=3 3.2 1>4?228/5:0 8202>@2 34 A2 ;<=0.28 /5046=> =0 123/3/452>034=>2?45?2>5284C2@2>3.2;<203/45 C.23.2> =??<028 4 3.2 =772:28 02?458 C/62 =58 .2> 1=>2530 .=8 954C728:2 46 3.2 0<A0/0325?2 46 3.2 6/>03 B=>>/=:2 4> C.23.2> 3.2>2 C=0 ?45?2=7B253 46 3.=36=?3 AD=??<0284=58./01=>2530/0=B=332>3.=3?=5A2 8232>B/528457D8<>/5:3.23>/=7.2>264>23.2?4B17=/53 /5046=> =0 /3 >27=320 34 =??<028 40 =58 ?=5543 A2 /532>62>28C/3.=33./003=:2 - 9 - 5046=> =0 123/3/452>0 34 " =>2 ?45?2>528 3.2 457D =772:=3/45 B=82 =:=/503 3.2B /0 3.=3 3.2D /53>48<?28 4> =>>=5:28 3.2 =772:28 B=>>/=:2 =77/=5?2 A23C225 =??<028 40 =58 3 /0 543 3.2 ?=02 46 3.2 ?4B17=/5=53 3.=3 3.202 123/3/452>0 .=8 =5D 1>/4> 954C728:2 46 3.2 0<A0/0325?2 46 3.2 2=>7/2> B=>>/=:2 4> 3.=33.2D17=D28=5D=?3/@2>472/50472B5/K/5:3.202?458 B=>>/=:2@25=00<B/5:3.2=772:=3/450/53.2?4B17=/53 34 A2 3><2 /5 3.2/> 253/>23D B2>27D /53>48<?/5: 4> =>>=5:/5: = B=>>/=:2 =77/=5?2 C/3.4<3 =5D 954C728:2 46 3.2 /772:=7/3D 4> 0<A0/03/5: 6/>03 B=>>/=:2 C4<78 543 ?4503/3<32 =5 46625?2 <582> 2?3/45 % 46 3.2 4502;<2537D 3.2 ?453/5<=3/45 46 ?>/B/5=7 1>4?228/5:0 =:=/503 123/3/452>0 34 " C4<78 =704 A2 C.477D <5C=>>=5328 .2@/2C3=925AD3./04<>36/5806<77 0<114>3 6>4B 3.2 1>/5?/1720 7=/8 84C5 AD 3.2 45GA72 <1>2B2 4<>3 /5 - 10 - C.2>2/5 /3 C=0 ?=32:4>/?=77D .278 3.=3 /5 ?4B17=/530=772:/5:A/:=BD3.2=772:=3/450=:=/5038/03=53 >27=3/@20 4> 43.2> 6=B/7D B2BA2>0 B<03 A2 012?/6/? =58 1=>3/?<7=>/K28 =:<2 4B5/A<0 =58 :252>=7/K28 03=32B2530 /B17/?=3/5: =5 253/>2 6=B/7D 4> 2F325828 >27=3/@20 ?=5543 64>B 3.2 A=0/0 46 1>402?<3/45 .2 12F 4<>36<>3.2>?7=>/6/283.=3B2>21>2025?2=34>=33258=5?2 46 = 02?458 B=>>/=:2 45 /5@/3=3/45 C/3.4<3 =5D =?3/@2 6=?/7/3=3/454>1=>3/?/1=3/458420543=B4<5334=A23B253 463.246625?246A/:=BD.22F1>200/456=?/7/3=3/45<028 /5 3./0 ?4532F3 ?=>>/20 0/:5/6/?=53 B2=5/5: 3 8254320 ?450?/4<0 =58 827/A2>=32 =/8 34 3.2 ?4BB/00/45 46 3.2 46625?253.2=A025?2460<?.=?3/@26=?/7/3=3/458/03=53 >27=3/@20 ?=5543 A2 0<AH2?328 34 ?>/B/5=7 1>402?<3/45 B2>27D 45 =??4<53 46 >27=3/450./1 4> 1>2025?2 .2 >=3/4 7=/884C5/53.20=/8H<8:B2530;<=>27D:4@2>503.26=?30 463.21>20253?=02 )%%*$ - 11 - ,4> 3.2 64>2:4/5: >2=0450 =58 /5 7/:.3 46 3.2 72:=7 1>/5?/1720 8/0?<0028 =A4@2 3./0 4<>3 1>4?2280 34 1=003.264774C/5: )/* .2123/3/45/0=774C28/51=>3 )//* .2 123/3/45 03=580 8/0B/0028 /5046=> =0 123/3/452>40=58=>2?45?2>528 )///* .2 ?>/B/5=7 1>4?228/5:0 /5 4& )=>/0/5: 4<3 46 4&* 1258/5: A264>23.24<>3463.2>/5?/1=7/@/7<8:2=58 , .4>=1<> 64> 3.2 46625?2 1<5/0.=A72 <582> 2?3/45 % 46 3.2 =>2 .2>2AD ;<=0.28 /5046=> =0 123/3/452>0 34 " =>2 ?45?2>528 *( $""' # !/03474$