- 1 - !"# $"%"" " &' &()* &)) + ! " # $ " "% " " " " & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' () " * + ,! # $ + " - " " % " ", " " $% " , $% * " "".! "++" " + " , " " + " ". ", " " " ( - 3 - " ( / +"" $ ( / +"" % 012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674=2 >06 ?=4 504 :1=4@56=2 68 2 =150A1 =4@12167 7B1744=17B A5 5: >06 ?=4 47B?B4: 17 504 ;C217422 68 D?7C8?@5C=17B ?7: 2C339<17B 504 >1:4 =?7B4 68 @4 9?752 @4 9?E4=2 DD671?"67:4724=?7:"01994=?=4244E17BFC?2017B68 5043=6@44:17B2347:17B17""6.!$?=1217B6C5 68 "=1D4 6, 68 7:1 C=?9 691@4 5?5167 125=1@5 1G?<?3C=%86=50468847@423C7120?;94C7:4=4@51672. ?7:687:1?7 47?9"6:4,347:17B67504819468 504 ::15167?9 "1A19 +C:B4 ?7: +" 7:1 125=1@5 1G?<?3C= 04B12568504@6D39?1751250?5504345151674=2 ?33=6?@04: =42367:475 6@6D39?17?75 ?7: 6884=4: 56 2C339< ?7: 1725?99 ? 6H<B47 B474=?56= ?7: ;66254= 39?75 5 12 ?994B4: 50?5 504 345151674=2 =43=424754: - 4 - 504D249A42?20?A17B504=4FC1215454@071@?9@?3?@15<?7: =426C=@42564H4@C54504>6=E>150175042513C9?54:51D4 750425=47B50685012=43=42475?5167=42367:475612 25?54: 56 0?A4 39?@4: ?7 6=:4= ?7: 3?1: ?7 ?:A?7@4 ?D6C7568 250=6CB0;?7E@0?7749267504 ?22C=?7@450?550439?75>6C9:;4:491A4=4:?7:1725?994: 04 3=42475 3=1A?54 @6D39?175 12 172515C54: ?994B17B 50?5 8=6D504A4=<17@435167504345151674=20?:7617547516768 0676C=17B 5041= @6DD15D475 ?7: 50?5 504< 17:C@4: =42367:475 6 56 3?=5 >150 D674< ;< 8=?C:C9475 ?7: :12067425D4?72 ) @517B67504>=15547@6D39?175?@?24@?D456 ;4=4B1254=4:17"=1D46,?7:?854=17A4251B?5167 504 7A4251B?517B 881@4= 0?2 9?1: 504 @0?=B4 20445 17 ""6.! 86= 504 68847@42 3C7120?;94 C7:4= 4@51672.?7:68504 " 4?=74: @6C7249 86= 504 345151674=2 =4154=?517B 504 B=6C7:2 C=B4: 17 504 34515167 2C;D152 50?5 504 - 5 - 345151674=2 >4=4 ?9>?<2 =4?:< ?7: >19917B 56 1725?99 504 39?75 6>4A4=:C456:49?<4:3?<D475?7:7673?<D475 68504;?9?7@4?D6C7568 2>01@0>?26=?99< ?B=44:50439?75@6C9:765;4:491A4=4:04=486=44A4718 5044751=4@0?=B420445D?54=1?912?@@4354:?58?@4A?9C4 504 4224751?9 17B=4:14752 68 @04?517B 7?D49< :4@435167 8=?C:C94756=:1206742517:C@4D475?=4765D?:46C5512 @67547:4: 50?5 504 :123C54 12 4224751?99< @6DD4=@1?9 17 7?5C=4 ?7: 504 ?994B4: 76734=86=D?7@4 68 @675=?@5 12 ?55=1;C5?;94 56 =42367:475 6I2 8?19C=4 56 3?< 504 ;?9?7@4 @6721:4=?5167 ?7: 504=486=4 504 345151674=2 >4=4 GC251814: 17 >150069:17B :491A4=< 68 504 39?75 04 94?=74: @6C7249 >6C9: 8C=504= 2C;D15 50?5 ? 3C=49< @6DD4=@1?9 :123C54 0?2 ;447 B1A47 ? @=1D17?9 @696C= 679< 56 4H4=5 3=422C=467504345151674=2?7:56@1=@CDA475@675=?@5C?9 6;91B?51672 484==17B 56 504 94B?9 7651@4 122C4: ;< 504 345151674=2?7:5048?@550?5?@6DD4=@1?92C150?2?9=4?:< ;447172515C54:04@67547:250?5@67517C?516768@=1D17?9 - 6 - 3=6@44:17B2 C7:4= 4@51672 . ?7: 68 504 " ?D6C75256?;C24683=6@422 94?=74: @6C7249 ?334?=17B 86= =42367:47562C;D152 50?5 504@0?=B420445D?54=1?92 @94?=9< :12@9624 50?5 504 345151674=2 0?: 504 175475167 56 @04?5 8=6D 504 17@435167 ?A17B =4@41A4: ? 2C;25?751?9 ?D6C7568 2504<8?194:56:491A4=50439?75 ?7: >4=4 8C99< ?>?=4 50?5 504< 9?@E4: 504 =426C=@42 ?7: 178=?25=C@5C=4562C339<50439?75>150175046=?99<?B=44: 51D49174 4 504=486=4 2C;D152 50?5 2C881@1475 D?54=1?9 4H1252 56 3=6@44: ?B?1725 504 345151674=2 ?7: 50?5 5012 12 765?815@?2486=4H4=@12468GC=12:1@5167C7:4=4@5167, 68"= " 4?=74: 1B0"6C=56A4=7D475 94?:4=?:6352 504?=BCD4752?:A?7@4:67;40?9868=42367:4756?7: 2C;D15250?5504345151674=2DC258?@4?8C99894:B4:5=1?9 4?@@6=:17B9<3=?<286=:12D122?96850434515167 - 7 - . 012 "6C=5 0?2 @?=48C99< @6721:4=4: 504 2C;D12216726850494?=74:@6C724986=504345151674=2?7: 0?24H?D174:504D?54=1?939?@4:67=4@6=: , 04206=53617550?5?=124286=@6721:4=?516712( J04504= 504 3=6@44:17B2 17 ""6.! 86= 504 68847@42 3C7120?;94 C7:4= 4@51672 . ?7: 68 504 " ?=4 2C25?17?;94>047504:123C544D?7?5428=6D?7 6=?9@6DD4=@1?9@675=?@5;45>447504345151674=2 ?7:=42367:4756KL ! 7@9624=2@=C517<68504D?54=1?923?=51@C9?=9< 504 94B?9 7651@4 122C4: ;< 504 345151674=2 @?9917B C367 =42367:475 6 56 3?< 504 ;?9?7@4 2?94 @6721:4=?5167 ?7: 504 8?@5 50?5 ? @6DD4=@1?9 2C15 12 76> 347:17B 5012 "6C=51268504A14>50?5504:123C54124224751?99<@1A1917 7?5C=4 D451@C96C2 =4?:17B 68 504 @6D39?175 17:1@?542 50?5 504 :123C54 ?=1242 3C=49< 6C5 68 ?7 6=:4= 39?@4: 86= 2C339< 68 ?7 6H<B47 39?75 0194 504 345151674=2 ?224=5 - 8 - 50?5 =42367:475 6 8?194: 56 3?< 504 ;?9?7@4 @6721:4=?5167=42367:4756?994B42767:491A4=<>15017 504 ?B=44: 51D49174 ?7: ?224=52 @04?517B 8=6D 17@435167 04504= 504 345151674=2 @6DD1554: ;=4?@0 ;< 765 :491A4=17B 504 39?75 >15017 51D4 6= >04504= 504< >4=4 GC251814: 17 >150069:17B :491A4=< 86= 7673?<D475 68 504 ;?9?7@4?D6C75?=4:123C54:FC4251672688?@5>01@08?99 >15017504:6D?1768504"6DD4=@1?9"6C=5 1506C54H3=42217B?7<631716767504D4=15268 504@6DD4=@1?9:123C54504122C?7@468?94B?97651@467 ;< 504 345151674=2 74B?542 504 ?994B?5167 50?5 504< 0?: ? :12067425 175475167 ?5 504 17@435167 68 504 5=?72?@5167 7 504 ?;247@4 68 ?7< D?54=1?917:1@?517B50?5504345151674=217547:4:56:4@41A4 =42367:47568=6D5046C5245504;?21@17B=4:1475268 50468847@468@04?517BC7:4=4@516768 "?=4765 2?512814: A47 ?22CD17B 504 ?994B?51672 17 504 @6D39?175 56;45=C4504:123C54>6C9:?5;425?D6C7556;=4?@068 @675=?@5 ?7: 765 ?7 68847@4 C7:4= 4@5167 68 " - 9 - 42367:475 6 12 ?5 91;4=5< 56 3C=2C4 ?33=63=1?54 =4D4:142 17 504 347:17B @6DD4=@1?9 2C15 6>4A4= 504 @67517C?5167 68 504 @=1D17?9 3=6@44:17B2 :423154 504 4H12547@468? @6DD4=@1?9:123C54=4FC1=17B8C99 894:B4: ?:GC:1@?5167 ;< ? @6D345475 "1A19 "6C=5 >6C9: ?D6C7556?;C24683=6@422043691@4D?@0174=<@?7765 ;417A6E4:56245594@1A192@6=42 6= 504 86=4B617B =4?2672 5012 "6C=5 3=6@44:2 563?2250486996>17B( $?% 04"=1D17?9 451516712?996>4: $;% 04 4751=4 3=6@44:17B2 17 ""6.! $?=1217B 6C5 68 "=1D4 6, 68 7:1 C=?9 691@4 5?5167 125=1@5 1G?<?3C=% 86= 504 68847@42 3C7120?;94 C7:4= 4@51672 . ?7: 68 504 " 347:17B ;486=4 504 "6C=5 68 504 - 10 - ::15167?9 "1A19 +C:B4 ?7: +" 7:1 125=1@51G?<?3C=?=404=4;<FC?204: ,* &"") % 1256(96(. "(